Resources

A rigid horizontal beam of length LL and negligible mass is pinned at its left end (x=0x = 0) and supported by a vertical spring of force constant kk attached at its right end (x=Lx = L). A point mass mm is placed on the beam at an arbitrary position x=αLx = \alpha L, where 0<α<10 < \alpha < 1. As the load approaches the hinge boundary (α→0+\alpha \to 0^+), determine the vertical deflection δ\delta of the spring at the right end and the reaction force RyR_y at the hinge in terms of mm, gg, kk, and α\alpha, and evaluate both quantities in the asymptotic limit α→0\alpha \to 0.

Answer and steps

Final answer

δ(α)=αmgk\delta(\alpha) = \frac{\alpha m g}{k}, with lim⁡α→0δ=0 m\lim_{\alpha \to 0} \delta = 0\text{ m}; Ry(α)=(1−α)mgR_y(\alpha) = (1 - \alpha)mg, with lim⁡α→0Ry=mg\lim_{\alpha \to 0} R_y = mg

Steps

01

Identify the Forces and Equilibrium Conditions

Consider the rigid beam of length LL lying along the xx-axis from x=0x = 0 to x=Lx = L:

  • At the hinge (x=0x = 0): A vertical support reaction force RyR_y acts upward. (Any horizontal force is zero because there are no external horizontal loads.)
  • At the load location (x=αLx = \alpha L): The point mass exerts a downward gravitational force of magnitude W=mgW = mg.
  • At the right end (x=Lx = L): The spring exerts an upward restoring force Fs=kδF_s = k\delta, where δ\delta is the vertical displacement (compression or downward deflection at x=Lx = L) and kk is the spring constant.

For the beam to remain in static equilibrium, two conditions must be satisfied:

  1. Rotational equilibrium: The net torque about any pivot point is zero (∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0).
  2. Translational equilibrium: The net vertical force is zero (∑Fy=0\sum F_y = 0).

02

Determine the Spring Deflection δ\delta via Rotational Equilibrium

Taking the hinge at x=0x = 0 as the reference pivot eliminates the reaction force RyR_y from the torque equation:

∑τhinge=0\sum \tau_{\text{hinge}} = 0

Choosing counterclockwise torques as positive:

Fs⋅L−(mg)⋅(αL)=0F_s \cdot L - (mg) \cdot (\alpha L) = 0

Dividing both sides by the beam length LL:

Fs=αmgF_s = \alpha mg

Using Hooke's law, Fs=kδF_s = k\delta:

kδ=αmg  ⟹  δ(α)=αmgkk\delta = \alpha mg \implies \delta(\alpha) = \frac{\alpha mg}{k}


03

Determine the Hinge Reaction Force RyR_y via Translational Equilibrium

Applying the vertical force balance:

∑Fy=Ry+Fs−mg=0\sum F_y = R_y + F_s - mg = 0

Substitute Fs=αmgF_s = \alpha mg:

Ry=mg−Fs=mg−αmg=(1−α)mgR_y = mg - F_s = mg - \alpha mg = (1 - \alpha)mg


04

Evaluate the Asymptotic Limit as α→0\alpha \to 0

As the load approaches the hinge boundary (α→0+\alpha \to 0^+):

  • Spring deflection: lim⁡α→0δ(α)=lim⁡α→0αmgk=0 m\lim_{\alpha \to 0} \delta(\alpha) = \lim_{\alpha \to 0} \frac{\alpha mg}{k} = 0\text{ m}
  • Hinge reaction force: lim⁡α→0Ry(α)=lim⁡α→0(1−α)mg=mg\lim_{\alpha \to 0} R_y(\alpha) = \lim_{\alpha \to 0} (1 - \alpha)mg = mg

Physical Interpretation & Common Pitfall: A common mistake is assuming the spring always carries half the weight of the load. Because the torque exerted by the load is proportional to its lever arm αL\alpha L, moving the load toward the pivot (α→0\alpha \to 0) reduces its torque to zero. In this limit, the entire weight of the mass is supported directly by the hinge, and the spring experiences zero load and zero deflection.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies the lever arm of the mass from the hinge as (1 - α)L instead of αL, inverting the dependence on α.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Στhinge=Fs⋅L−m⋅g⋅(1−α)⋅L=0  ⟹  Fs=(1−α)⋅m⋅g\Sigma \tau_{\text{hinge}} = F_s \cdot L - m \cdot g \cdot (1 - \alpha) \cdot L = 0 \implies F_s = (1 - \alpha) \cdot m \cdot g

    Correct

    Στhinge=Fs⋅L−mg(αL)=0  ⟹  Fs=αmg\Sigma \tau_{\text{hinge}} = F_s \cdot L - mg(\alpha L) = 0 \implies F_s = \alpha mg

    You chose the hinge at x=0x = 0 as your pivot, but you used (1−α)L(1 - \alpha)L as the lever arm for the weight. The position of the mass is x=αLx = \alpha L, so its perpendicular distance from the hinge is αL\alpha L. The quantity (1−α)L(1 - \alpha)L is the distance from the right end to the mass.

  2. Step 2

    δ=(1−α)⋅m⋅g/k  ⟹  As α→0, δ→m⋅g/k\delta = (1 - \alpha) \cdot m \cdot g / k \implies \text{As } \alpha \to 0,\, \delta \to m \cdot g / k

    Correct

    δ=Fsk=αmgk  ⟹  lim⁡α→0δ=0 m\delta = \frac{F_s}{k} = \frac{\alpha mg}{k} \implies \lim_{\alpha \to 0} \delta = 0\text{ m}

    You correctly applied Hooke's law δ=Fsk\delta = \frac{F_s}{k} and evaluated the limit as α→0\alpha \to 0, but the result was affected by the inverted expression for FsF_s from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    ΣFy=Ry+Fs−m⋅g=0  ⟹  Ry=m⋅g−(1−α)⋅m⋅g=α⋅m⋅g  ⟹  As α→0, Ry→0\Sigma F_y = R_y + F_s - m \cdot g = 0 \implies R_y = m \cdot g - (1 - \alpha) \cdot m \cdot g = \alpha \cdot m \cdot g \implies \text{As } \alpha \to 0,\, R_y \to 0

    Correct

    ΣFy=Ry+Fs−mg=0  ⟹  Ry=mg−αmg=(1−α)mg  ⟹  lim⁡α→0Ry=mg\Sigma F_y = R_y + F_s - mg = 0 \implies R_y = mg - \alpha mg = (1 - \alpha)mg \implies \lim_{\alpha \to 0} R_y = mg

    You correctly stated the translational equilibrium condition ΣFy=0\Sigma F_y = 0 and solved for RyR_y, but substituting the incorrect FsF_s caused RyR_y to vanish as α→0\alpha \to 0 instead of carrying the full load.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that taking torques about the hinge eliminates the hinge reaction force RyR_y.

You applied Hooke's law correctly to relate spring force and deflection.

You used vertical translational equilibrium correctly to relate RyR_y, FsF_s, and the load mgmg.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect Lever Arm Reference

You used the distance to the other end of the beam, (1−α)L(1 - \alpha)L, instead of the distance to the chosen pivot at x=0x = 0, which is αL\alpha L.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the coordinate of a point with its distance from the opposite boundary when computing torque lever arms.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Verify Lever Arm from Pivot
  • The lever arm for torque τ=r⊥F\tau = r_{\perp} F is the direct distance from the chosen pivot point to the line of action of the force.

  • Always explicitly write r=∣xforce−xpivot∣r = |x_{\text{force}} - x_{\text{pivot}}| before writing the torque equation.

Sanity-Check Asymptotic Limits
  • When a load sits directly on a support (here α→0\alpha \to 0, right on the hinge), that support must carry 100%100\% of the load, leaving zero force on remote supports.

  • Check whether your limit matches physical intuition: as α→0\alpha \to 0, the mass is on the hinge, so Ry→mgR_y \to mg and δ→0\delta \to 0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Στhinge=Fs⋅L−(mg)(αL)=0  ⟹  Fs=αmg\Sigma \tau_{\text{hinge}} = F_s \cdot L - (mg)(\alpha L) = 0 \implies F_s = \alpha mg

  2. δ=Fsk=αmgk\delta = \frac{F_s}{k} = \frac{\alpha mg}{k}

  3. lim⁡α→0δ=0 m\lim_{\alpha \to 0} \delta = 0\text{ m}

  4. Ry=mg−Fs=mg−αmg=(1−α)mgR_y = mg - F_s = mg - \alpha mg = (1 - \alpha)mg

  5. lim⁡α→0Ry=mg\lim_{\alpha \to 0} R_y = mg

Final answer

δ(α)=αmgk\delta(\alpha) = \frac{\alpha mg}{k} with lim⁡α→0δ=0 m\lim_{\alpha \to 0} \delta = 0\text{ m}; Ry(α)=(1−α)mgR_y(\alpha) = (1 - \alpha)mg with lim⁡α→0Ry=mg\lim_{\alpha \to 0} R_y = mg

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how to measure lever arms from a chosen origin x0x_0 using r=∣x−x0∣r = |x - x_0|.

  • Practice using extreme-case checks (such as placing the weight at α=0\alpha = 0 or α=1\alpha = 1) to catch inverted formulas immediately.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes the beam acts symmetrically like a simply supported beam with equal load sharing of half the weight to each support.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Fs=m⋅g2  ⟹  δ=m⋅g2⋅kF_s = \frac{m \cdot g}{2} \implies \delta = \frac{m \cdot g}{2 \cdot k}

    Correct

    ∑τhinge=FsL−mg(αL)=0  ⟹  Fs=αmg  ⟹  δ=αmgk\sum \tau_{\text{hinge}} = F_s L - mg(\alpha L) = 0 \implies F_s = \alpha mg \implies \delta = \frac{\alpha mg}{k}

    You assumed equal 50/50 load sharing between the supports. Because the load is positioned at x=αLx = \alpha L, its lever arm about the hinge is αL\alpha L, so the rotational equilibrium condition determines Fs=αmgF_s = \alpha mg.

  2. Step 2

    As α→0, δ→m⋅g2⋅k\text{As } \alpha \to 0,\ \delta \to \frac{m \cdot g}{2 \cdot k}

    Correct

    lim⁡α→0δ=lim⁡α→0αmgk=0 m\lim_{\alpha \to 0} \delta = \lim_{\alpha \to 0} \frac{\alpha mg}{k} = 0\text{ m}

    Because your expression for δ\delta omitted the parameter α\alpha, your evaluation of the asymptotic limit did not reflect that the spring deflection approaches zero as the load reaches the hinge.

  3. Step 3

    Ry=m⋅g2R_y = \frac{m \cdot g}{2}

    Correct

    ∑Fy=Ry+Fs−mg=0  ⟹  Ry=(1−α)mg\sum F_y = R_y + F_s - mg = 0 \implies R_y = (1 - \alpha)mg

    Vertical force equilibrium requires Ry=mg−FsR_y = mg - F_s. Since Fs=αmgF_s = \alpha mg, the hinge reaction must be Ry=(1−α)mgR_y = (1 - \alpha)mg, which depends on the position α\alpha.

  4. Step 4

    As α→0, Ry→m⋅g2\text{As } \alpha \to 0,\ R_y \to \frac{m \cdot g}{2}

    Correct

    lim⁡α→0Ry=lim⁡α→0(1−α)mg=mg\lim_{\alpha \to 0} R_y = \lim_{\alpha \to 0} (1 - \alpha)mg = mg

    As α→0\alpha \to 0, the load sits directly over the hinge, so the hinge must support the entire weight mgmg.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly related the vertical deflection of the spring to its restoring force using Hooke's law, δ=Fsk\delta = \frac{F_s}{k}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equal-sharing assumption ignoring torque lever arm

You treated the beam as symmetrically loaded with each support carrying mg2\frac{mg}{2} instead of writing a torque balance equation involving the position parameter α\alpha.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overgeneralizing the special case of a centrally placed load (α=0.5\alpha = 0.5) to an arbitrary load position, overlooking that the fraction of weight borne by each support is determined by rotational equilibrium.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Pivot Selection and Torque Balance
  • For a rigid body in static equilibrium, ∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0 about any pivot point.

  • Place the pivot at the hinge (x=0x = 0) to eliminate RyR_y and solve directly for the spring force: Fs⋅L−mg(αL)=0F_s \cdot L - mg(\alpha L) = 0.

Asymptotic Consistency Check
  • When a point mass moves directly onto a rigid support, that support carries 100% of the load.

  • Check the physical limits: when α→0\alpha \to 0, the mass sits on the hinge, so Ry→mgR_y \to mg and the spring force must drop to 00.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write rotational equilibrium about the hinge at x=0x = 0: ∑τ=FsL−mg(αL)=0\sum \tau = F_s L - mg(\alpha L) = 0.

  2. Solve for the spring force: Fs=αmgF_s = \alpha mg.

  3. Apply Hooke's law to find the deflection: δ(α)=Fsk=αmgk\delta(\alpha) = \frac{F_s}{k} = \frac{\alpha mg}{k}.

  4. Apply vertical translational equilibrium: Ry=mg−Fs=(1−α)mgR_y = mg - F_s = (1 - \alpha)mg.

  5. Take the limit as α→0\alpha \to 0: lim⁡α→0δ=0 m\lim_{\alpha \to 0} \delta = 0\text{ m} and lim⁡α→0Ry=mg\lim_{\alpha \to 0} R_y = mg.

Final answer

δ(α)=αmgk,lim⁡α→0δ=0 m;Ry(α)=(1−α)mg,lim⁡α→0Ry=mg\delta(\alpha) = \frac{\alpha mg}{k},\quad \lim_{\alpha \to 0} \delta = 0\text{ m};\quad R_y(\alpha) = (1 - \alpha)mg,\quad \lim_{\alpha \to 0} R_y = mg

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out ∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0 about a chosen pivot before distributing loads among supports.

  • Test your algebraic results by checking extreme endpoints (here, α=0\alpha = 0 and α=1\alpha = 1) to verify physical intuition.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A light horizontal beam of length L=2.0 mL = 2.0\text{ m} is hinged at its left end (x=0x = 0) and held horizontal by a vertical cable at its right end (x=Lx = L). A mass of 10 kg10\text{ kg} is placed at x=0.6 mx = 0.6\text{ m}. Taking g=10 m/s2g = 10\text{ m/s}^2, find the tension TT in the cable and the vertical reaction force RyR_y at the hinge.

Answer

Torque about hinge: T⋅(2.0 m)−(10 kg)(10 m/s2)(0.6 m)=0  ⟹  T=30 NT \cdot (2.0\text{ m}) - (10\text{ kg})(10\text{ m/s}^2)(0.6\text{ m}) = 0 \implies T = 30\text{ N}. Vertical force balance: Ry=mg−T=100 N−30 N=70 NR_y = mg - T = 100\text{ N} - 30\text{ N} = 70\text{ N}.

02

A uniform horizontal plank of length LL and weight WplankW_{\text{plank}} is supported by two vertical scales at its ends x=0x = 0 and x=Lx = L. A person of weight WW stands at position x=βLx = \beta L (where 0≤β≤10 \le \beta \le 1). Find the reading FRF_R on the right scale as a function of β\beta.

Answer

Take torques about x=0x = 0: FR⋅L−Wplank⋅L2−W⋅(βL)=0  ⟹  FR=12Wplank+βWF_R \cdot L - W_{\text{plank}} \cdot \frac{L}{2} - W \cdot (\beta L) = 0 \implies F_R = \frac{1}{2}W_{\text{plank}} + \beta W.

03

A horizontal massless beam of length LL is pinned at x=0x = 0 and supported by two identical springs of constant kk, one at x=L/2x = L/2 and one at x=Lx = L. A downward force FF is applied at x=αLx = \alpha L. Assuming small deflections so the beam rotates rigidly by angle θ\theta about the hinge, find the downward displacement δ(L)\delta(L) of the beam's right tip in terms of FF, kk, and α\alpha.

Answer

For small rotation θ\theta, spring deflections are δ1=θ(L/2)\delta_1 = \theta(L/2) and δ2=θL\delta_2 = \theta L, with upward forces F1=kθL/2F_1 = k\theta L/2 and F2=kθLF_2 = k\theta L. Torque about hinge: F(αL)−F1(L/2)−F2(L)=0  ⟹  FαL=kθL2(14+1)=54kθL2F(\alpha L) - F_1(L/2) - F_2(L) = 0 \implies F\alpha L = k\theta L^2\left(\frac{1}{4} + 1\right) = \frac{5}{4}k\theta L^2. Thus θ=4Fα5kL\theta = \frac{4F\alpha}{5kL}, and the tip deflection is δ(L)=θL=4αF5k\delta(L) = \theta L = \frac{4\alpha F}{5k}.

Loading workspace…