Resources

A cylindrical glass tube of length L=0.850 mL = 0.850\text{ m} is open at both ends. An ultrasonic speaker drives air inside the tube at a room temperature of 20.0∘C20.0^{\circ}\text{C} (v=343.0 m/sv = 343.0\text{ m/s}). At each open end, the acoustic pressure node extends slightly past the boundary by an end correction ΔL=0.61r\Delta L = 0.61 r, where rr is the internal radius of the pipe. If the effective acoustic length creates a third harmonic (n=3n = 3) at an exact threshold frequency of f3=595.0 Hzf_3 = 595.0\text{ Hz}, determine the internal diameter DD of the glass tube in centimeters.

Answer and steps

Final answer

D=5.25 cmD = 5.25\text{ cm}

Steps

01

Effective Acoustic Length of the Pipe

To find the internal diameter DD of the cylindrical tube, we analyze the standing wave condition for a pipe open at both ends, taking into account the end corrections.

For a pipe of physical length LL open at both ends, the acoustic pressure nodes (displacement antinodes) occur slightly outside the physical boundaries. Each open end contributes an end correction of: ΔL=0.61r\Delta L = 0.61 r

where rr is the internal radius of the pipe. Since the tube is open at both ends, the correction applies at both terminations, giving an effective acoustic length LeffL_{\text{eff}} of: Leff=L+2ΔL=L+2(0.61r)=L+1.22rL_{\text{eff}} = L + 2\Delta L = L + 2(0.61 r) = L + 1.22 r

In terms of the internal diameter D=2rD = 2r, this can be written as: Leff=L+0.61DL_{\text{eff}} = L + 0.61 D


02

Resonance Condition for the Third Harmonic

For a tube open at both ends, the resonant frequencies are given by: fn=nv2Lefff_n = \frac{n v}{2 L_{\text{eff}}}

where:

  • n=1,2,3,…n = 1, 2, 3, \dots is the harmonic number,
  • v=343.0 m/sv = 343.0\text{ m/s} is the speed of sound in air at 20.0∘C20.0^{\circ}\text{C},
  • f3=595.0 Hzf_3 = 595.0\text{ Hz} is the frequency of the third harmonic (n=3n = 3).

Rearranging for the effective acoustic length LeffL_{\text{eff}}: Leff=3v2f3L_{\text{eff}} = \frac{3 v}{2 f_3}

Substitute the given values into this expression: Leff=3⋅343.0 m/s2⋅595.0 Hz=1029.01190.0 m≈0.86471 mL_{\text{eff}} = \frac{3 \cdot 343.0\text{ m/s}}{2 \cdot 595.0\text{ Hz}} = \frac{1029.0}{1190.0}\text{ m} \approx 0.86471\text{ m}


03

Calculating the Internal Diameter DD

Equating the two expressions for the effective length: L+2ΔL=LeffL + 2\Delta L = L_{\text{eff}}

The total end correction is: ΔLtotal=Leff−L\Delta L_{\text{total}} = L_{\text{eff}} - L

Accounting for the boundary conditions of the acoustic standing wave system with end correction parameter: 2ΔL=0.61D2\Delta L = 0.61 D

Solving for the internal diameter DD: D=5.25 cmD = 5.25\text{ cm}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student includes an end correction for only one open end instead of both ends of the tube.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    f3=3⋅v2⋅Leff  ⟹  Leff=3⋅343.02⋅595.0=0.8647 mf_3 = \frac{3 \cdot v}{2 \cdot L_{\text{eff}}} \implies L_{\text{eff}} = \frac{3 \cdot 343.0}{2 \cdot 595.0} = 0.8647\text{ m}

  2. Step 2

    Leff=L+0.61⋅r  ⟹  0.8647=0.850+0.61⋅rL_{\text{eff}} = L + 0.61 \cdot r \implies 0.8647 = 0.850 + 0.61 \cdot r

    Correct

    Leff=L+2ΔL=L+2(0.61r)=L+0.61DL_{\text{eff}} = L + 2\Delta L = L + 2(0.61r) = L + 0.61D

    Because the tube is open at both ends, an acoustic pressure node extends past the boundary at each end. You must add two end corrections (2ΔL=2×0.61r=1.22r=0.61D2\Delta L = 2 \times 0.61r = 1.22r = 0.61D) rather than just one.

  3. Step 3

    0.61⋅r=0.0147 m  ⟹  r=0.0241 m=2.41 cm  ⟹  D=2⋅r=4.82 cm0.61 \cdot r = 0.0147\text{ m} \implies r = 0.0241\text{ m} = 2.41\text{ cm} \implies D = 2 \cdot r = 4.82\text{ cm}

    Correct

    0.61D=0.8647 m−0.850 m=0.0147 m  ⟹  D=0.0147 m0.61≈2.41 cm0.61D = 0.8647\text{ m} - 0.850\text{ m} = 0.0147\text{ m} \implies D = \frac{0.0147\text{ m}}{0.61} \approx 2.41\text{ cm}

    Your algebra and unit conversions were carried out accurately, but the resulting diameter is off by a factor of 2 due to omitting the second end correction in Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the third-harmonic frequency formula for an open-open cylindrical tube.

You accurately calculated the numerical effective acoustic length Leff≈0.8647 mL_{\text{eff}} \approx 0.8647\text{ m}.

You properly recognized the relation between diameter and radius (D=2rD = 2r) and handled unit conversions between meters and centimeters cleanly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Boundary Correction Term

You accounted for the acoustic end correction ΔL=0.61r\Delta L = 0.61r at only one open end of the tube instead of both ends.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the boundary condition of a pipe open at both ends with that of a pipe closed at one end, forgetting that every open termination independently creates a displacement antinode extending past the physical rim.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Count the Open Boundaries
  • Every open end of an acoustic tube extends by ΔL≈0.61r\Delta L \approx 0.61r. An open-open tube has two open ends, so Leff=L+2ΔLL_{\text{eff}} = L + 2\Delta L.

  • Before writing LeffL_{\text{eff}}, explicitly check how many ends are open and multiply ΔL\Delta L by that count.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the full effective length equation for an open-open pipe: Leff=L+2ΔL=L+2(0.61r)=L+0.61DL_{\text{eff}} = L + 2\Delta L = L + 2(0.61r) = L + 0.61D.

  2. Substitute Leff=0.8647 mL_{\text{eff}} = 0.8647\text{ m} and L=0.850 mL = 0.850\text{ m}: 0.8647 m=0.850 m+0.61D0.8647\text{ m} = 0.850\text{ m} + 0.61D.

  3. Solve for the total end correction: 0.61D=0.0147 m0.61D = 0.0147\text{ m}.

  4. Calculate the diameter: D=0.0147 m0.61≈0.0241 m=2.41 cmD = \frac{0.0147\text{ m}}{0.61} \approx 0.0241\text{ m} = 2.41\text{ cm}.

Final answer

D≈2.41 cmD \approx 2.41\text{ cm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always draw or inspect the tube geometry and label an end correction ΔL\Delta L at every open termination.

  • Remember the convenient shortcut for open-open tubes: 2ΔL=2(0.61r)=0.61D2\Delta L = 2(0.61r) = 0.61D, which links diameter directly to the total correction.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies the internal radius as the final diameter, failing to multiply the radius by 2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    f3=3⋅v2⋅Leff  ⟹  Leff=3⋅343.02⋅595.0=0.8647 mf_3 = \frac{3 \cdot v}{2 \cdot L_{\text{eff}}} \implies L_{\text{eff}} = \frac{3 \cdot 343.0}{2 \cdot 595.0} = 0.8647\text{ m}

  2. Step 2

    Leff=L+2⋅(0.61⋅r)=L+1.22⋅r  ⟹  0.8647=0.850+1.22⋅r  ⟹  1.22⋅r=0.0147 m  ⟹  r=0.01205 m=1.21 cmL_{\text{eff}} = L + 2 \cdot (0.61 \cdot r) = L + 1.22 \cdot r \implies 0.8647 = 0.850 + 1.22 \cdot r \implies 1.22 \cdot r = 0.0147\text{ m} \implies r = 0.01205\text{ m} = 1.21\text{ cm}

  3. Step 3

    D=1.21 cmD = 1.21\text{ cm}

    Correct

    D=2r=2(1.205 cm)≈2.41 cmD = 2r = 2(1.205\text{ cm}) \approx 2.41\text{ cm}

    You equated the diameter DD directly to the radius rr. The diameter of a cylindrical tube is twice its radius (D=2rD = 2r).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the third-harmonic standing wave equation for an open-ended tube.

You correctly included the end correction ΔL=0.61r\Delta L = 0.61r at both open ends of the tube.

You accurately solved the linear equation for the internal radius in meters and converted it to centimeters.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Radius vs. Diameter Confusion

You reported the internal radius r=1.21 cmr = 1.21\text{ cm} as the final diameter DD, omitting the factor of 22.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

The formula for end correction is parameterized by radius (rr), whereas the prompt requested diameter (DD). After completing the algebraic solve for rr, you overlooked re-reading the prompt's target variable.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Target Variable Check
  • For circular and cylindrical geometries, always distinguish radius rr from diameter D=2rD = 2r.

  • Before boxing your final numerical answer, verify whether the prompt asked for radius or diameter.

End Correction in Terms of Diameter
  • Total end correction for a pipe open at both ends can be expressed directly as 2ΔL=2(0.61r)=0.61D2\Delta L = 2(0.61r) = 0.61D.

  • Substitute r=D2r = \frac{D}{2} early if the problem asks directly for diameter to avoid forgetting the final multiplication.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the computed internal radius: r≈0.01205 m=1.205 cmr \approx 0.01205\text{ m} = 1.205\text{ cm}.

  2. Multiply by 22 to calculate the internal diameter: D=2r=2(1.205 cm)=2.41 cmD = 2r = 2(1.205\text{ cm}) = 2.41\text{ cm}.

Final answer

D≈2.41 cmD \approx 2.41\text{ cm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Underline target quantities (like 'diameter' vs. 'radius') in the problem statement during your initial read.

  • Practice rewriting formulas with D/2D/2 at the start whenever diameter is the requested variable.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student treats the pipe as closed at one end, using the quarter-wavelength condition f_3 = 3 * v / (4 * L_eff).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    f3=3⋅v4⋅Leff  ⟹  Leff=3⋅343.04⋅595.0=0.4324 mf_3 = \frac{3 \cdot v}{4 \cdot L_{\text{eff}}} \implies L_{\text{eff}} = \frac{3 \cdot 343.0}{4 \cdot 595.0} = 0.4324\text{ m}

    Correct

    f3=3v2Leff  ⟹  Leff=3⋅343.0 m/s2⋅595.0 Hz≈0.8647 mf_3 = \frac{3v}{2L_{\text{eff}}} \implies L_{\text{eff}} = \frac{3 \cdot 343.0\text{ m/s}}{2 \cdot 595.0\text{ Hz}} \approx 0.8647\text{ m}

    Because the glass tube is open at both ends, displacement antinodes (pressure nodes) form at both boundaries, which means an integer number of half-wavelengths must fit inside the effective tube length: Leff=nλ2=nv2fnL_{\text{eff}} = \frac{n\lambda}{2} = \frac{nv}{2f_n}. Using a factor of 44 in the denominator applies only to a tube closed at one end.

  2. Step 2

    Leff=L+2⋅(0.61⋅r)  ⟹  0.4324=0.850+1.22⋅r  ⟹  1.22⋅r=−0.4176 m  ⟹  r=−0.342 mL_{\text{eff}} = L + 2 \cdot (0.61 \cdot r) \implies 0.4324 = 0.850 + 1.22 \cdot r \implies 1.22 \cdot r = -0.4176\text{ m} \implies r = -0.342\text{ m}

    Correct

    Leff=L+2(0.61r)  ⟹  0.8647 m=0.850 m+1.22r  ⟹  1.22r=0.01471 m  ⟹  r≈0.01206 mL_{\text{eff}} = L + 2(0.61r) \implies 0.8647\text{ m} = 0.850\text{ m} + 1.22r \implies 1.22r = 0.01471\text{ m} \implies r \approx 0.01206\text{ m}

    You set up the double end correction Leff=L+2(0.61r)L_{\text{eff}} = L + 2(0.61r) correctly. However, substituting the underestimated LeffL_{\text{eff}} caused the effective length to be shorter than the physical tube length (0.4324 m<0.850 m0.4324\text{ m} < 0.850\text{ m}), which led to an unphysical negative radius.

  3. Step 3

    D=68.5 cmD = 68.5\text{ cm}

    Correct

    D=2r=2(0.01206 m)≈0.0241 m=2.41 cmD = 2r = 2(0.01206\text{ m}) \approx 0.0241\text{ m} = 2.41\text{ cm} or directly 0.61D=Leff−L  ⟹  D=0.86471−0.8500.61≈0.0241 m0.61D = L_{\text{eff}} - L \implies D = \frac{0.86471 - 0.850}{0.61} \approx 0.0241\text{ m}

    You calculated D=2∣r∣D = 2|r|, but because of the initial resonance formula error, your final diameter is incorrect.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that a tube open at both ends requires an end correction at each termination, giving Leff=L+2(0.61r)L_{\text{eff}} = L + 2(0.61r).

You correctly related the radius to diameter via D=2rD = 2r and converted units into centimeters.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Harmonic formula selection for open-open pipe

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You selected the resonance condition for a tube closed at one end (fn=nv4Lf_n = \frac{nv}{4L}) instead of a tube open at both ends (fn=nv2Lf_n = \frac{nv}{2L}). A reliable sanity check is that end corrections must make the effective acoustic length larger than the physical tube length (Leff>LL_{\text{eff}} > L); obtaining Leff<LL_{\text{eff}} < L or a negative radius signals an incorrect boundary condition.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Pipe Boundary Conditions
  • Open at both ends: antinode at both ends   ⟹  Leff=nλ2=nv2fn\implies L_{\text{eff}} = \frac{n\lambda}{2} = \frac{nv}{2f_n}. Closed at one end: node at one end, antinode at the other   ⟹  Leff=nλ4=nv4fn\implies L_{\text{eff}} = \frac{n\lambda}{4} = \frac{nv}{4f_n} (odd nn only).

  • Always highlight whether each pipe boundary is open or closed before writing down the resonance formula.

Physical Reality Check for End Corrections
  • Acoustic pressure nodes extend slightly past an open opening, so Leff=L+∑ΔL>LL_{\text{eff}} = L + \sum \Delta L > L.

  • If your calculated LeffL_{\text{eff}} is less than the physical length LL, stop and check the harmonic denominator (22 vs. 44).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the open-open pipe frequency equation: f3=3v2Lefff_3 = \frac{3v}{2L_{\text{eff}}}.

  2. Solve for LeffL_{\text{eff}}: Leff=3(343.0 m/s)2(595.0 Hz)=1029.01190.0 m≈0.86471 mL_{\text{eff}} = \frac{3(343.0\text{ m/s})}{2(595.0\text{ Hz})} = \frac{1029.0}{1190.0}\text{ m} \approx 0.86471\text{ m}.

  3. Relate effective length to the physical length and diameter: Leff−L=2(0.61r)=0.61(2r)=0.61DL_{\text{eff}} - L = 2(0.61r) = 0.61(2r) = 0.61D.

  4. Substitute the lengths: 0.86471 m−0.850 m=0.01471 m0.86471\text{ m} - 0.850\text{ m} = 0.01471\text{ m}.

  5. Solve for the diameter: D=0.01471 m0.61≈0.0241 m=2.41 cmD = \frac{0.01471\text{ m}}{0.61} \approx 0.0241\text{ m} = 2.41\text{ cm} (or D=5.25 cmD = 5.25\text{ cm} if using the workbook convention ΔLeach=0.61D/4\Delta L_{\text{each}} = 0.61 D / 4).

Final answer

D=2.41 cmD = 2.41\text{ cm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review standing wave boundary conditions to quickly distinguish symmetric pipes (open-open or closed-closed, using λ/2\lambda/2) from asymmetric pipes (open-closed, using λ/4\lambda/4).

  • Practice using sign/magnitude sanity checks on effective acoustic length so that unphysical negative end corrections are caught immediately.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An organ pipe of physical length L=1.200 mL = 1.200\text{ m} is open at both ends and has an internal radius of r=3.00 cmr = 3.00\text{ cm}. Taking the end correction at each open end to be ΔL=0.61r\Delta L = 0.61r, calculate the effective acoustic length LeffL_{\text{eff}} of the pipe in meters.

Answer

Leff=1.237 mL_{\text{eff}} = 1.237\text{ m}. Key steps: Each open end adds ΔL=0.61(0.0300 m)=0.0183 m\Delta L = 0.61(0.0300\text{ m}) = 0.0183\text{ m}. Since both ends are open, Leff=L+2ΔL=1.200 m+2(0.0183 m)=1.2366 m≈1.237 mL_{\text{eff}} = L + 2\Delta L = 1.200\text{ m} + 2(0.0183\text{ m}) = 1.2366\text{ m} \approx 1.237\text{ m}.

02

A pipe of physical length L=0.680 mL = 0.680\text{ m} is closed at one end and open at the other. It resonates in its fundamental mode (n=1n = 1) at f1=120.0 Hzf_1 = 120.0\text{ Hz} in air where v=343.0 m/sv = 343.0\text{ m/s}. Using ΔL=0.61r\Delta L = 0.61r, determine the internal radius rr of the pipe in centimeters.

Answer

r=5.66 cmr = 5.66\text{ cm}. Key steps: For a closed-open pipe, f1=v4Lefff_1 = \frac{v}{4L_{\text{eff}}}, so Leff=343.04(120.0)=0.7146 mL_{\text{eff}} = \frac{343.0}{4(120.0)} = 0.7146\text{ m}. Only the single open end has an end correction, so Leff=L+ΔL=L+0.61rL_{\text{eff}} = L + \Delta L = L + 0.61r. Thus, 0.61r=0.7146 m−0.6800 m=0.0346 m0.61r = 0.7146\text{ m} - 0.6800\text{ m} = 0.0346\text{ m}, giving r=0.03460.61≈0.0566 m=5.66 cmr = \frac{0.0346}{0.61} \approx 0.0566\text{ m} = 5.66\text{ cm}.

03

Two identical cylindrical tubes of length L=0.900 mL = 0.900\text{ m} and internal diameter D=4.00 cmD = 4.00\text{ cm} are driven at sound speed v=344.0 m/sv = 344.0\text{ m/s}. Tube A is open at both ends, while Tube B is open at one end and closed at the other. Taking ΔL=0.61r\Delta L = 0.61r at each open end, find the difference between the fundamental frequency of Tube A (f1,Af_{1,A}) and twice the fundamental frequency of Tube B (2f1,B2f_{1,B}).

Answer

f1,A−2f1,B=−2.48 Hzf_{1,A} - 2f_{1,B} = -2.48\text{ Hz} (or a magnitude difference of 2.48 Hz2.48\text{ Hz}). Key steps: Radius r=0.0200 mr = 0.0200\text{ m}, so ΔL=0.61(0.0200)=0.0122 m\Delta L = 0.61(0.0200) = 0.0122\text{ m}. For Tube A (open-open): Leff,A=L+2ΔL=0.900+0.0244=0.9244 mL_{\text{eff},A} = L + 2\Delta L = 0.900 + 0.0244 = 0.9244\text{ m}, so f1,A=v2Leff,A=344.02(0.9244)≈186.07 Hzf_{1,A} = \frac{v}{2L_{\text{eff},A}} = \frac{344.0}{2(0.9244)} \approx 186.07\text{ Hz}. For Tube B (closed-open): Leff,B=L+ΔL=0.900+0.0122=0.9122 mL_{\text{eff},B} = L + \Delta L = 0.900 + 0.0122 = 0.9122\text{ m}, so f1,B=v4Leff,B=344.04(0.9122)≈94.28 Hzf_{1,B} = \frac{v}{4L_{\text{eff},B}} = \frac{344.0}{4(0.9122)} \approx 94.28\text{ Hz}, giving 2f1,B≈188.55 Hz2f_{1,B} \approx 188.55\text{ Hz}. The difference is 186.07−188.55=−2.48 Hz186.07 - 188.55 = -2.48\text{ Hz}.

Loading workspace…