Resources

In an engineering physics laboratory experiment, a student calibrates a dual-pan equal-arm balance with a total beam length of 2L0=50.00 cm2L_0 = 50.00\text{ cm} supported at its center. Due to manufacturing asymmetry, the actual pivot knife-edge is slightly offset from the geometric center such that the left arm has length L1=25.15 cmL_1 = 25.15\text{ cm} and the right arm has length L2=24.85 cmL_2 = 24.85\text{ cm}. When an unknown standard brass cylinder of true mass mxm_x is placed on the left pan, standard calibrated masses totaling m1=148.20 gm_1 = 148.20\text{ g} must be placed on the right pan to achieve static rotational equilibrium (zero net torque). Neglecting pan masses, calculate the true mass mxm_x of the cylinder in grams.

Answer and steps

Final answer

mx=146.4 gm_x = 146.4\text{ g}

Steps

01

Set Up the Torque Balance Equation

Principle of Rotational Equilibrium

For a rigid body supported at a fixed pivot to remain in static rotational equilibrium, the sum of all external torques about the pivot must be zero: ∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0 Taking torques about the knife-edge pivot eliminates any unknown normal force exerted by the support.

Each suspended mass exerts a downward gravitational force:

  • Downward force on the left arm: F1=mxgF_1 = m_x g
  • Downward force on the right arm: F2=m1gF_2 = m_1 g

Since both arms are horizontal at balance, the lever arms are the perpendicular distances from the pivot to the lines of action of the weights:

  • Counterclockwise torque from the left mass: τleft=mxgL1\tau_{\text{left}} = m_x g L_1
  • Clockwise torque from the right mass: τright=m1gL2\tau_{\text{right}} = m_1 g L_2

Equating the magnitudes of the counterclockwise and clockwise torques:

mxgL1=m1gL2m_x g L_1 = m_1 g L_2

Canceling the acceleration due to gravity gg from both sides gives the lever law:

mxL1=m1L2m_x L_1 = m_1 L_2


02

Calculate the True Mass mxm_x

Solve the equation for the unknown mass mxm_x:

mx=m1(L2L1)m_x = m_1 \left( \frac{L_2}{L_1} \right)

Substitute the given values (m1=148.20 gm_1 = 148.20\text{ g}, L1=25.15 cmL_1 = 25.15\text{ cm}, and L2=24.85 cmL_2 = 24.85\text{ cm}):

mx=148.20 g⋅24.85 cm25.15 cmm_x = 148.20\text{ g} \cdot \frac{24.85\text{ cm}}{25.15\text{ cm}}

mx≈148.20 g⋅0.98807=146.43 gm_x \approx 148.20\text{ g} \cdot 0.98807 = 146.43\text{ g}

Rounding to four significant figures yields:

mx=146.4 gm_x = 146.4\text{ g}


Common Pitfall

A common mistake is assuming that an equal-arm balance always yields the true mass directly (mx=m1m_x = m_1). Because manufacturing asymmetry caused the left lever arm to be slightly longer than the right arm (L1>L2L_1 > L_2), a smaller mass on the left produces the same torque as a larger mass on the right; hence, mxm_x must be less than m1m_1.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the lever arms in the torque balance equation, multiplying the unknown mass by the right arm length and the counterweight by the left arm length.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    τleft=τright\tau_{\text{left}} = \tau_{\text{right}}

  2. Step 2

    mx∗L2=m1∗L1m_x * L_2 = m_1 * L_1

    Correct

    mxL1=m1L2m_x L_1 = m_1 L_2

    You paired each mass with the opposite arm length. Since mass mxm_x sits on the left pan at distance L1L_1 from the pivot, its torque is mxgL1m_x g L_1. Similarly, m1m_1 sits on the right pan at distance L2L_2, so its torque is m1gL2m_1 g L_2.

  3. Step 3

    mx∗24.85=148.20∗25.15  ⟹  mx=148.20∗(25.1524.85)m_x * 24.85 = 148.20 * 25.15 \implies m_x = 148.20 * \left(\frac{25.15}{24.85}\right)

    Correct

    mx∗25.15=148.20∗24.85  ⟹  mx=148.20∗(24.8525.15)m_x * 25.15 = 148.20 * 24.85 \implies m_x = 148.20 * \left(\frac{24.85}{25.15}\right)

    Your algebraic isolation and numerical substitution followed logically from your equation in Step 2, but the ratio was inverted due to the swapped arm lengths.

  4. Step 4

    mx=149.99 gm_x = 149.99\text{ g}

    Correct

    mx≈146.4 gm_x \approx 146.4\text{ g}

    Your final numerical value is greater than m1m_1 because of the inverted lever arm ratio. With the longer arm on the left (L1>L2L_1 > L_2), the left mass must be smaller than the right mass to achieve balance.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that static equilibrium requires the clockwise and counterclockwise torques about the pivot to balance.

You correctly eliminated the acceleration due to gravity gg from both sides of the torque balance equation.

You accurately carried out the arithmetic and solved for the unknown variable using your formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted lever arm pairing

You accidentally cross-paired the left-hand mass with the right-hand lever arm length.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing which lever arm corresponds to which pan when setting up the torque formula τ=F⋅r\tau = F \cdot r. Torque on each side is the product of the force on that side and its own distance to the pivot knife-edge.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match force to its own lever arm
  • τi=Fi⋅ri\tau_i = F_i \cdot r_i

  • Always label and multiply the force on a specific side by the distance from the pivot to that same side: τleft=(mleftg)⋅Lleft\tau_{\text{left}} = (m_{\text{left}} g) \cdot L_{\text{left}}.

Perform a physical plausibility check
  • Longer lever arm   ⟹  \implies smaller required mass to produce the same torque

  • Check whether Lleft>LrightL_{\text{left}} > L_{\text{right}}. If the left arm is longer, mxm_x must be strictly less than m1m_1 to balance.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the torque on each side using its corresponding lever arm: τleft=mxgL1\tau_{\text{left}} = m_x g L_1 and τright=m1gL2\tau_{\text{right}} = m_1 g L_2.

  2. Equate the two torques and cancel gg: mxL1=m1L2m_x L_1 = m_1 L_2.

  3. Solve for mxm_x: mx=m1(L2L1)m_x = m_1 \left(\frac{L_2}{L_1}\right).

  4. Substitute the given values: mx=148.20 g×24.85 cm25.15 cm≈146.43 gm_x = 148.20\text{ g} \times \frac{24.85\text{ cm}}{25.15\text{ cm}} \approx 146.43\text{ g}.

Final answer

mx=146.4 gm_x = 146.4\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Draw a quick free-body or lever diagram before writing equations, marking each distance directly under its corresponding mass.

  • Verify your final answer with a quick qualitative check: the side with the longer arm must hold the smaller mass.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes an equal-arm balance condition and uses the nominal half-length rather than accounting for the unequal lever arm lengths.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    L0=50.002=25.00 cmL_0 = \frac{50.00}{2} = 25.00\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    mx⋅L0=m1⋅L0  ⟹  mx=m1m_x \cdot L_0 = m_1 \cdot L_0 \implies m_x = m_1

    Correct

    mxgL1=m1gL2  ⟹  mxL1=m1L2m_x g L_1 = m_1 g L_2 \implies m_x L_1 = m_1 L_2

    Because the knife-edge pivot is offset from the center, the lever arms are unequal (L1=25.15 cmL_1 = 25.15\text{ cm} on the left and L2=24.85 cmL_2 = 24.85\text{ cm} on the right). Setting both arms equal to L0L_0 ignores the rotational effect of this asymmetry.

  3. Step 3

    mx=148.20 gm_x = 148.20\text{ g}

    Correct

    mx=m1(L2L1)=148.20 g⋅24.85 cm25.15 cm≈146.4 gm_x = m_1 \left(\frac{L_2}{L_1}\right) = 148.20\text{ g} \cdot \frac{24.85\text{ cm}}{25.15\text{ cm}} \approx 146.4\text{ g}

    This numerical answer follows directly from equating mxm_x to m1m_1, which was derived from the equal-arm assumption.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that rotational equilibrium requires balancing the torques on opposite sides of the pivot.

You correctly calculated the geometric half-length of the balance beam.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equal-arm assumption on an asymmetric balance

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You used the nominal symmetric arm length L0L_0 for both pans instead of accounting for the knife-edge offset that creates distinct lever arms L1L_1 and L2L_2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify actual lever arms about the pivot
  • In static torque equilibrium ∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0, the lever arm for each force is measured strictly from the actual axis of rotation (the pivot), not from the geometric midpoint.

  • Always check whether the pivot is at the exact center; if an offset is stated, use the distinct lengths L1L_1 and L2L_2 for the opposing torques.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the torque balance condition about the actual knife-edge pivot: ∑τ=0  ⟹  mxgL1=m1gL2\sum \tau = 0 \implies m_x g L_1 = m_1 g L_2.

  2. Cancel the acceleration due to gravity gg: mxL1=m1L2m_x L_1 = m_1 L_2.

  3. Solve for the unknown mass: mx=m1(L2L1)m_x = m_1 \left(\frac{L_2}{L_1}\right).

  4. Substitute the given values: mx=148.20 g⋅24.85 cm25.15 cm≈146.43 gm_x = 148.20\text{ g} \cdot \frac{24.85\text{ cm}}{25.15\text{ cm}} \approx 146.43\text{ g}.

Final answer

mx=146.4 gm_x = 146.4\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Draw a free-body diagram showing the actual pivot location and label each lever arm distance separately before writing the torque equation.

  • Practice checking whether the longer lever arm holds the smaller or larger mass to sanity-check your answer.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student subtracts the offset difference between the two arm lengths directly from the measured mass instead of applying torque equilibrium.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔL=L1−L2=25.15−24.85=0.30 cm\Delta L = L_1 - L_2 = 25.15 - 24.85 = 0.30\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    mx=m1−ΔL  ⟹  mx=148.20−0.30m_x = m_1 - \Delta L \implies m_x = 148.20 - 0.30

    Correct

    mx=m1(L2L1)=148.20 g⋅24.85 cm25.15 cmm_x = m_1 \left(\frac{L_2}{L_1}\right) = 148.20\text{ g} \cdot \frac{24.85\text{ cm}}{25.15\text{ cm}}

    You subtracted a length in centimeters directly from a mass in grams. Because physical quantities must obey dimensional homogeneity and static rotational balance depends on torque, you need to apply the law of the lever: mxL1=m1L2m_x L_1 = m_1 L_2.

  3. Step 3

    mx=147.90 gm_x = 147.90\text{ g}

    Correct

    mx=146.4 gm_x = 146.4\text{ g}

    This result follows from subtracting the length offset rather than multiplying by the ratio of the lever arms.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the longer left arm means the true mass mxm_x must be smaller than the counterbalancing mass m1m_1.

You performed accurate decimal subtraction to find ΔL=0.30 cm\Delta L = 0.30\text{ cm}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Dimensional Inconsistency in Lever Equilibrium

You treated the lever arm asymmetry as a direct additive offset instead of a multiplicative ratio.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You applied an intuitive additive correction rather than setting the sum of torques to zero (∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0). Static rotational equilibrium requires equating clockwise and counterclockwise moments (mxgL1=m1gL2m_x g L_1 = m_1 g L_2), which leads to an inverse proportionality between mass and arm length (mx=m1L2L1m_x = m_1 \frac{L_2}{L_1}). Furthermore, subtracting centimeters from grams violates dimensional homogeneity.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Dimensional Consistency
  • You cannot add or subtract quantities with different physical dimensions (such as grams and centimeters).

  • Ensure every term in an addition or subtraction shares the exact same physical units before calculating.

Apply Rotational Equilibrium
  • For a balanced lever or beam, net torque about the pivot must be zero: τleft=τright\tau_{\text{left}} = \tau_{\text{right}}.

  • Set mxgL1=m1gL2m_x g L_1 = m_1 g L_2, cancel gg, and solve for the unknown mass as a ratio: mx=m1L2L1m_x = m_1 \frac{L_2}{L_1}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the condition for rotational equilibrium about the knife-edge pivot: ∑τ=mxgL1−m1gL2=0\sum \tau = m_x g L_1 - m_1 g L_2 = 0.

  2. Divide both sides by gg to relate the masses and arm lengths: mxL1=m1L2m_x L_1 = m_1 L_2.

  3. Solve for mxm_x: mx=m1(L2L1)m_x = m_1 \left(\frac{L_2}{L_1}\right).

  4. Substitute the given measurements: mx=148.20 g×24.85 cm25.15 cm≈146.43 gm_x = 148.20\text{ g} \times \frac{24.85\text{ cm}}{25.15\text{ cm}} \approx 146.43\text{ g}.

Final answer

mx=146.4 gm_x = 146.4\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the principle of moments and practice writing ∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0 about the pivot point.

  • Perform a quick unit check on every formula you write to confirm that both sides and all added terms have matching dimensions.

  • Remember that a lever is a multiplicative system (m∝1Lm \propto \frac{1}{L}), so length differences adjust masses through ratios, not addition or subtraction.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A dual-pan balance has a left arm of length L1=20.0 cmL_1 = 20.0\text{ cm} and a right arm of length L2=25.0 cmL_2 = 25.0\text{ cm}. An unknown object on the right pan is balanced by a calibrated mass of 160.0 g160.0\text{ g} on the left pan. Find the true mass of the object.

Answer

mright=128.0 gm_{\text{right}} = 128.0\text{ g}. By torque equilibrium, mleftL1=mrightL2  ⟹  160.0×20.0=mright×25.0  ⟹  mright=128.0 gm_{\text{left}} L_1 = m_{\text{right}} L_2 \implies 160.0 \times 20.0 = m_{\text{right}} \times 25.0 \implies m_{\text{right}} = 128.0\text{ g}.

02

An asymmetric balance beam has unequal arms of lengths L1L_1 and L2L_2. A stone weighs W1=18.0 NW_1 = 18.0\text{ N} when placed on the left pan (balanced by weights on the right pan) and weighs W2=20.0 NW_2 = 20.0\text{ N} when placed on the right pan (balanced by weights on the left pan). Determine the true weight WW of the stone.

Answer

W=610 N≈18.97 NW = 6\sqrt{10}\text{ N} \approx 18.97\text{ N}. Using Borda's method: WL1=W1L2W L_1 = W_1 L_2 and W2L1=WL2W_2 L_1 = W L_2. Dividing the two equations gives WW2=W1W  ⟹  W=W1W2=18.0×20.0=360≈18.97 N\frac{W}{W_2} = \frac{W_1}{W} \implies W = \sqrt{W_1 W_2} = \sqrt{18.0 \times 20.0} = \sqrt{360} \approx 18.97\text{ N}.

03

A non-uniform meter stick of total length 100.0 cm100.0\text{ cm} and mass M=120.0 gM = 120.0\text{ g} has its center of mass located at the 48.0 cm48.0\text{ cm} mark. The stick is pivoted at the 45.0 cm45.0\text{ cm} mark. What mass mm must be hung at the 75.0 cm75.0\text{ cm} mark to keep the meter stick horizontally balanced?

Answer

m=12.0 gm = 12.0\text{ g}. Clockwise torque from the stick's own weight about the pivot at 45.0 cm45.0\text{ cm}: τstick=Mg(48.0−45.0)=120.0×3.0=360 g⋅cm\tau_{\text{stick}} = M g (48.0 - 45.0) = 120.0 \times 3.0 = 360\text{ g}\cdot\text{cm}. The hanging mass at 75.0 cm75.0\text{ cm} is at distance 75.0−45.0=30.0 cm75.0 - 45.0 = 30.0\text{ cm} on the right. For equilibrium, m×30.0=360  ⟹  m=12.0 gm \times 30.0 = 360 \implies m = 12.0\text{ g}.

Loading workspace…