Resources

Two independent laboratory groups measure the speed of sound in air at room temperature using resonance tubes. Group A reports vA=(344.2±1.6) m/sv_A = (344.2 \pm 1.6)\text{ m/s}, and Group B reports vB=(339.5±1.2) m/sv_B = (339.5 \pm 1.2)\text{ m/s}. The standard experimental threshold for compatibility between two independent measurements is ∣vA−vB∣≤2σdiff|v_A - v_B| \le 2\sigma_{\text{diff}}, where σdiff=δvA2+δvB2\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \sqrt{\delta v_A^2 + \delta v_B^2}. Calculate the difference Δv=vA−vB\Delta v = v_A - v_B, the combined uncertainty σdiff\sigma_{\text{diff}}, and the discrepancy ratio t=∣vA−vB∣σdifft = \frac{|v_A - v_B|}{\sigma_{\text{diff}}}. Determine whether the two measurements are statistically consistent at the 2σ2\sigma threshold.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Δv=4.7 m/s\Delta v = 4.7\text{ m/s}, σdiff=2.0 m/s\sigma_{\text{diff}} = 2.0\text{ m/s}, t=2.35t = 2.35; the measurements are not statistically consistent at the 2σ2\sigma threshold because t>2t > 2.

Steps

01

Calculate the difference between the two measurements

Subtract the measured value of Group B from that of Group A:

Δv=vA−vB=344.2 m/s−339.5 m/s=4.7 m/s\Delta v = v_A - v_B = 344.2\text{ m/s} - 339.5\text{ m/s} = 4.7\text{ m/s}

The absolute discrepancy between the two independent experimental values is:

∣Δv∣=∣vA−vB∣=4.7 m/s|\Delta v| = |v_A - v_B| = 4.7\text{ m/s}


02

Determine the combined standard uncertainty (σdiff\sigma_{\text{diff}})

When comparing two independent measurements, their uncertainties combine in quadrature rather than by direct addition. Using the given formula:

σdiff=δvA2+δvB2\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \sqrt{\delta v_A^2 + \delta v_B^2}

Substitute the reported uncertainties δvA=1.6 m/s\delta v_A = 1.6\text{ m/s} and δvB=1.2 m/s\delta v_B = 1.2\text{ m/s}:

σdiff=(1.6 m/s)2+(1.2 m/s)2=2.56+1.44 m/s=4.00 m/s=2.0 m/s\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \sqrt{(1.6\text{ m/s})^2 + (1.2\text{ m/s})^2} = \sqrt{2.56 + 1.44}\text{ m/s} = \sqrt{4.00}\text{ m/s} = 2.0\text{ m/s}

Common Pitfall: Do not simply add uncertainties linearly (δvA+δvB=2.8 m/s\delta v_A + \delta v_B = 2.8\text{ m/s}) or subtract them. For independent, normally distributed random uncertainties, the variance of the difference is the sum of the individual variances.


03

Compute the discrepancy ratio (tt-score)

The discrepancy ratio tt indicates how many standard deviations the observed difference lies from zero:

t=∣vA−vB∣σdiff=4.7 m/s2.0 m/s=2.35t = \frac{|v_A - v_B|}{\sigma_{\text{diff}}} = \frac{4.7\text{ m/s}}{2.0\text{ m/s}} = 2.35


04

Evaluate statistical consistency

Check the standard experimental criterion for compatibility at the 2σ2\sigma threshold:

∣vA−vB∣≤2σdiff  ⟺  t≤2|v_A - v_B| \le 2\sigma_{\text{diff}} \quad \iff \quad t \le 2

  • Observed discrepancy: ∣Δv∣=4.7 m/s|\Delta v| = 4.7\text{ m/s}
  • Threshold limit: 2σdiff=2(2.0 m/s)=4.0 m/s2\sigma_{\text{diff}} = 2(2.0\text{ m/s}) = 4.0\text{ m/s}

Since t=2.35>2t = 2.35 > 2 (or equivalently, 4.7 m/s>4.0 m/s4.7\text{ m/s} > 4.0\text{ m/s}), the difference exceeds the accepted 2σ2\sigma boundary. Therefore, the two measurements are not statistically consistent at the 2σ2\sigma threshold.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student linearly adds the individual uncertainties instead of combining them in quadrature, resulting in σ_diff = 2.8 m/s and concluding the measurements are consistent.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Δv=344.2−339.5=4.7 m/s\Delta v = 344.2 - 339.5 = 4.7\text{ m/s}

  2. Step 2

    σdiff=1.6+1.2=2.8 m/s\sigma_{\text{diff}} = 1.6 + 1.2 = 2.8\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    σdiff=δvA2+δvB2=1.62+1.22 m/s=2.56+1.44 m/s=2.0 m/s\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \sqrt{\delta v_A^2 + \delta v_B^2} = \sqrt{1.6^2 + 1.2^2}\text{ m/s} = \sqrt{2.56 + 1.44}\text{ m/s} = 2.0\text{ m/s}

    You directly added the individual standard deviations linearly. For independent measurements, random uncertainties combine in quadrature via the square root of the sum of squares.

  3. Step 3

    t=4.72.8=1.68t = \frac{4.7}{2.8} = 1.68

    Correct

    t=∣vA−vB∣σdiff=4.7 m/s2.0 m/s=2.35t = \frac{|v_A - v_B|}{\sigma_{\text{diff}}} = \frac{4.7\text{ m/s}}{2.0\text{ m/s}} = 2.35

    Your division setup is mathematically correct, but the value is affected by the incorrect value of σdiff\sigma_{\text{diff}} from Step 2.

  4. Step 4

    Since t=1.68≤2, the measurements are statistically consistent.\text{Since } t = 1.68 \le 2\text{, the measurements are statistically consistent.}

    Correct

    Since t=2.35>2, the measurements are not statistically consistent at the 2σ threshold.\text{Since } t = 2.35 > 2\text{, the measurements are not statistically consistent at the } 2\sigma \text{ threshold.}

    Because your calculated tt-score was underestimated due to the inflated uncertainty, you reached the opposite consistency conclusion.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the numerical difference Δv=4.7 m/s\Delta v = 4.7\text{ m/s} between the two measured speeds.

You correctly identified the definition of the tt-score as the discrepancy divided by the combined uncertainty.

You applied the decision rule t≤2t \le 2 accurately to your computed value.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Linear Uncertainty Addition

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You added random standard uncertainties linearly rather than adding their variances in quadrature as required for independent variables.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Uncertainty Propagation for Independent Differences
  • For independent random variables xx and yy, the standard deviation of their sum or difference is σx±y=σx2+σy2\sigma_{x \pm y} = \sqrt{\sigma_x^2 + \sigma_y^2}, never σx+σy\sigma_x + \sigma_y.

  • Always square each individual standard uncertainty, sum the squares, and take the square root.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Combine the independent standard uncertainties in quadrature: σdiff=δvA2+δvB2=1.62+1.22 m/s=2.56+1.44 m/s=4.00 m/s=2.0 m/s\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \sqrt{\delta v_A^2 + \delta v_B^2} = \sqrt{1.6^2 + 1.2^2}\text{ m/s} = \sqrt{2.56 + 1.44}\text{ m/s} = \sqrt{4.00}\text{ m/s} = 2.0\text{ m/s}.

  2. Recalculate the discrepancy ratio: t=∣vA−vB∣σdiff=4.7 m/s2.0 m/s=2.35t = \frac{|v_A - v_B|}{\sigma_{\text{diff}}} = \frac{4.7\text{ m/s}}{2.0\text{ m/s}} = 2.35.

  3. Evaluate consistency against the threshold: since t=2.35>2t = 2.35 > 2, the difference exceeds 2σdiff2\sigma_{\text{diff}}.

Final answer

Δv=4.7 m/s\Delta v = 4.7\text{ m/s}, σdiff=2.0 m/s\sigma_{\text{diff}} = 2.0\text{ m/s}, t=2.35t = 2.35; the measurements are not statistically consistent at the 2σ2\sigma threshold.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between worst-case bounds (linear addition) and statistical standard uncertainties for independent variables (quadrature sum).

  • Practice combining standard uncertainties involving common Pythagorean triples such as 1.21.2 and 1.61.6 to quickly spot when quadrature yields an integer or clean decimal.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student subtracts the uncertainties because the primary values are subtracted, resulting in an underestimated uncertainty of 0.4 m/s.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δv=344.2−339.5=4.7 m/s\Delta v = 344.2 - 339.5 = 4.7\text{ m/s}

  2. Step 2

    σdiff=1.62−1.22  ⟹  2.56−1.44=1.12=1.06 m/s\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \sqrt{1.6^2 - 1.2^2} \implies \sqrt{2.56 - 1.44} = \sqrt{1.12} = 1.06\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    σdiff=1.62+1.22=2.56+1.44=4.00=2.0 m/s\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \sqrt{1.6^2 + 1.2^2} = \sqrt{2.56 + 1.44} = \sqrt{4.00} = 2.0\text{ m/s}

    You subtracted the squared uncertainties instead of adding them in quadrature. Even when taking a difference between two quantities, independent random uncertainties always combine by adding variances: σdiff=δvA2+δvB2\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \sqrt{\delta v_A^2 + \delta v_B^2}.

  3. Step 3

    t=4.71.06=4.43t = \frac{4.7}{1.06} = 4.43

    Correct

    t=∣Δv∣σdiff=4.72.0=2.35t = \frac{|\Delta v|}{\sigma_{\text{diff}}} = \frac{4.7}{2.0} = 2.35

    Your division step correctly set up the ratio ∣Δv∣σdiff\frac{|\Delta v|}{\sigma_{\text{diff}}}, but the numerical value was affected by your earlier error in σdiff\sigma_{\text{diff}}.

  4. Step 4

    Since t=4.43>2, the measurements are not statistically consistent.\text{Since } t = 4.43 > 2\text{, the measurements are not statistically consistent.}

    Correct

    Since t=2.35>2, the measurements are not statistically consistent.\text{Since } t = 2.35 > 2\text{, the measurements are not statistically consistent.}

    You applied the correct comparison rule (t>2t > 2), though your numerical threshold comparison relied on the incorrect tt-score.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the experimental difference between the two measurements.

You used the correct ratio formula to compare the discrepancy to the combined uncertainty.

You correctly interpreted the 2σ2\sigma decision threshold to make your final conclusion.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Subtracted uncertainties in quadrature

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the subtraction in the primary values with subtraction inside the error propagation formula, forgetting that independent random errors always add in quadrature regardless of whether variables are added or subtracted.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Addition in Quadrature
  • For any linear combination f=A±Bf = A \pm B with independent uncertainties, δf=δA2+δB2\delta f = \sqrt{\delta A^2 + \delta B^2}.

  • Always add the squares of independent uncertainties under the square root, never subtract them.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the combined standard uncertainty by summing the variances: σdiff=(1.6 m/s)2+(1.2 m/s)2=2.56+1.44=4.00=2.0 m/s\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \sqrt{(1.6\text{ m/s})^2 + (1.2\text{ m/s})^2} = \sqrt{2.56 + 1.44} = \sqrt{4.00} = 2.0\text{ m/s}.

  2. Recalculate the discrepancy ratio: t=4.7 m/s2.0 m/s=2.35t = \frac{4.7\text{ m/s}}{2.0\text{ m/s}} = 2.35.

  3. Compare with the compatibility threshold: since t=2.35>2t = 2.35 > 2, the two results are not statistically consistent at the 2σ2\sigma level.

Final answer

Δv=4.7 m/s\Delta v = 4.7\text{ m/s}, σdiff=2.0 m/s\sigma_{\text{diff}} = 2.0\text{ m/s}, t=2.35t = 2.35; the measurements are not statistically consistent at the 2σ2\sigma threshold because t>2t > 2.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review error propagation rules for differences of independent quantities.

  • Remember that taking a difference cannot make your uncertainty smaller than the individual uncertainties.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets the 2σ threshold as requiring t ≥ 2 for compatibility, falsely concluding that the measurements are consistent.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δv=344.2−339.5=4.7 m/s\Delta v = 344.2 - 339.5 = 4.7\text{ m/s}

  2. Step 2

    σdiff=1.62+1.22=2.56+1.44=2.0 m/s\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \sqrt{1.6^2 + 1.2^2} = \sqrt{2.56 + 1.44} = 2.0\text{ m/s}

  3. Step 3

    t=4.72.0=2.35t = \frac{4.7}{2.0} = 2.35

  4. Step 4

    Since t=2.35≥2, the measurements are statistically consistent.\text{Since } t = 2.35 \ge 2\text{, the measurements are statistically consistent.}

    Correct

    Since t=2.35>2 (or ∣Δv∣=4.7 m/s>2σdiff=4.0 m/s), the measurements are not statistically consistent at the 2σ threshold.\text{Since } t = 2.35 > 2\text{ (or } |\Delta v| = 4.7\text{ m/s} > 2\sigma_{\text{diff}} = 4.0\text{ m/s}\text{), the measurements are not statistically consistent at the } 2\sigma \text{ threshold.}

    You reversed the inequality condition for compatibility. Compatibility requires the discrepancy to fall within the uncertainty limit (t≤2t \le 2 or ∣Δv∣≤2σdiff|\Delta v| \le 2\sigma_{\text{diff}}). Because t=2.35>2t = 2.35 > 2, the difference is too large to be explained by random error alone at this threshold.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You found the exact difference between the two experimental values.

You correctly combined the independent uncertainties in quadrature.

You calculated the discrepancy ratio tt accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misinterpreted consistency threshold direction

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the threshold t=2t = 2 as a minimum score to achieve compatibility rather than an upper bound on acceptable discrepancy.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Meaning of Discrepancy Ratio $t$
  • The ratio t=∣x1−x2∣σdifft = \frac{|x_1 - x_2|}{\sigma_{\text{diff}}} measures how many standard deviations separate two measurements. A smaller tt means closer agreement.

  • Check whether t≤Nt \le N for an NσN\sigma compatibility test. If t>Nt > N, the discrepancy exceeds the allowed threshold, meaning the results disagree.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the computed ratio to the threshold: t=2.35>2t = 2.35 > 2.

  2. Conclude that the discrepancy exceeds the 2σ2\sigma compatibility boundary.

Final answer

The two measurements are not statistically consistent at the 2σ2\sigma threshold because t=2.35>2t = 2.35 > 2.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember that in experimental physics, smaller discrepancy ratios (t≤2t \le 2) indicate agreement, whereas larger ratios (t>2t > 2) indicate significant disagreement.

  • Practice checking consistency directly with physical units by testing ∣vA−vB∣≤2σdiff|v_A - v_B| \le 2\sigma_{\text{diff}} alongside the dimensionless ratio t≤2t \le 2.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two lab groups measure the local acceleration due to gravity. Group 1 reports g1=(9.84±0.03) m/s2g_1 = (9.84 \pm 0.03)\text{ m/s}^2 and Group 2 reports g2=(9.76±0.04) m/s2g_2 = (9.76 \pm 0.04)\text{ m/s}^2. Calculate the combined uncertainty σdiff\sigma_{\text{diff}} and determine whether the two measurements are consistent at the 2σ2\sigma threshold (t≤2t \le 2).

Answer

σdiff=0.032+0.042=0.05 m/s2\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \sqrt{0.03^2 + 0.04^2} = 0.05\text{ m/s}^2. Discrepancy ∣g1−g2∣=9.84−9.76=0.08 m/s2|g_1 - g_2| = 9.84 - 9.76 = 0.08\text{ m/s}^2. Discrepancy ratio t=0.080.05=1.6t = \frac{0.08}{0.05} = 1.6. Since t=1.6≤2t = 1.6 \le 2, the measurements are statistically consistent.

02

A student measures the length of a metal rod before and after heating. The initial length is L1=(50.30±0.12) cmL_1 = (50.30 \pm 0.12)\text{ cm} and the final length is L2=(50.80±0.16) cmL_2 = (50.80 \pm 0.16)\text{ cm}. Find the elongation ΔL=L2−L1\Delta L = L_2 - L_1, its combined standard uncertainty σΔL\sigma_{\Delta L}, and state whether the expansion ΔL\Delta L is statistically distinguishable from zero at the 3σ3\sigma level (t>3t > 3).

Answer

ΔL=50.80−50.30=0.50 cm\Delta L = 50.80 - 50.30 = 0.50\text{ cm}. The combined uncertainty is σΔL=0.122+0.162=0.0144+0.0256=0.0400=0.20 cm\sigma_{\Delta L} = \sqrt{0.12^2 + 0.16^2} = \sqrt{0.0144 + 0.0256} = \sqrt{0.0400} = 0.20\text{ cm}. The discrepancy ratio from zero is t=0.500.20=2.5t = \frac{0.50}{0.20} = 2.5. Since t=2.5<3t = 2.5 < 3, the expansion is not statistically distinguishable from zero at the 3σ3\sigma level.

03

Two independent methods determine the focal length of a convex lens: Method A gives fA=(15.2±0.6) cmf_A = (15.2 \pm 0.6)\text{ cm} and Method B gives fB=(13.7±0.8) cmf_B = (13.7 \pm 0.8)\text{ cm}. Calculate the discrepancy ratio t=∣fA−fB∣σdifft = \frac{|f_A - f_B|}{\sigma_{\text{diff}}} and evaluate whether the discrepancy indicates a potential systematic error at the standard 2σ2\sigma compatibility threshold.

Answer

Difference ∣fA−fB∣=∣15.2−13.7∣=1.5 cm|f_A - f_B| = |15.2 - 13.7| = 1.5\text{ cm}. Combined uncertainty σdiff=0.62+0.82=0.36+0.64=1.0 cm\sigma_{\text{diff}} = \sqrt{0.6^2 + 0.8^2} = \sqrt{0.36 + 0.64} = 1.0\text{ cm}. Discrepancy ratio t=1.51.0=1.5t = \frac{1.5}{1.0} = 1.5. Since t=1.5≤2t = 1.5 \le 2, the difference is within normal random fluctuation and does not provide evidence of systematic error at the 2σ2\sigma threshold.

Loading workspace…