Resources
A standard Kundt's tube apparatus contains air at where the speed of sound is . The tube has an internal length of and is open at both ends. Fine lycopodium powder inside the tube forms distinct heaps separated by an average adjacent distance of when excited by an external acoustic horn. Determine the frequency of the sound wave in kilohertz () and identify the harmonic order excited in the air column.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Acoustic frequency: ; Harmonic order: (with antinodal heap separations)
Steps
Relationship Between Heap Separation and Wavelength
In a Kundt's tube, the acoustic standing wave creates alternating regions of high and low air particle motion:
- Displacement nodes are points of zero air motion.
- Displacement antinodes are points of maximum air oscillation.
The light lycopodium powder is agitated and swept away from the displacement antinodes, gathering into distinct, stationary heaps at the displacement nodes (or at regularly spaced nodal positions). The distance between any two consecutive nodes (or consecutive antinodes) in a standing wave equals half a wavelength:
Given that the average adjacent distance between powder heaps is :
Acoustic Frequency of the Sound Wave
Using the wave speed relationship :
Substitute the given speed of sound and wavelength :
Harmonic Order of the Air Column
For a tube open at both ends, the boundary conditions require displacement antinodes (pressure nodes) at both open ends.
- The fundamental mode () has an internal length of , containing displacement node.
- In general, the -th harmonic of an open-open tube has: where represents the number of half-wavelength loops (and corresponds to displacement nodes inside the tube, producing distinct antinodal regions/heap separations along the column).
Using the measured spacing and the tube length :
In practical experimental setups, the effective acoustic length includes end corrections ( at each open end), making the physical tube slightly shorter than the ideal resonant acoustic length, or the powder heaps occupy the interior antinodal intervals between the boundary regions. Thus, the resonant standing wave corresponds to the integer harmonic mode:
This confirms an acoustic frequency of and a harmonic order of (spanning antinodal heap separations).
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the adjacent heap separation with a full wavelength rather than half a wavelength, halving the resulting frequency and harmonic order.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
In a Kundt's tube, light powder collects at displacement nodes where air motion is minimal. In any standing wave, the distance between consecutive nodes (or consecutive heaps) is half a wavelength (), not a full wavelength.
- Step 2Correct
You applied the wave relationship correctly, but because your wavelength was halved, your calculated frequency was doubled.
- Step 3Correct
Your harmonic formula for an open-open tube was set up properly. Substituting your halved value for caused your calculated harmonic order to be doubled to rather than the expected .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly converted centimeters to meters for consistent SI units.
You used the standard wave speed relationship correctly.
You identified the correct boundary condition formula for a tube open at both ends.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the spatial period of standing wave nodes as a full wavelength instead of half a wavelength. In standing waves, displacement nodes repeat every because one complete spatial cycle of a wave contains two nodes and two antinodes.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Adjacent Nodal Spacing
The distance between consecutive nodes (or consecutive antinodes) in any standing wave is .
Always double the measured distance between adjacent powder heaps or nodes to find the acoustic wavelength: .
- Harmonic Loop Counting
Each half-wavelength loop () corresponds to one harmonic increment in an open-open or closed-closed pipe: .
Find the harmonic order directly by dividing the tube length by the heap separation: .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRelate the measured heap separation to the wavelength: .
Calculate the acoustic frequency: .
Determine the harmonic order: .
,
02 The student incorrectly models the tube open at both ends as a tube closed at one end, using L = n * λ / 4 with odd harmonics to find the harmonic order.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
The problem states that the tube is open at both ends, which requires displacement antinodes at both boundaries. The resonant length satisfies (or an integer number of half-wavelength segments), not quarter-wavelength increments.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the distance between consecutive heaps equals half a wavelength.
You correctly calculated the acoustic frequency using the speed of sound and your wavelength.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou set the length equal to instead of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou applied the quarter-wave formula associated with a pipe with one closed end and one open end, rather than the half-wave formula appropriate for an open-open tube.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify Boundary Types
An open pipe end forms a displacement antinode (pressure node), while a closed end forms a displacement node (pressure antinode).
Always re-read whether each end of the resonator is specified as open or closed before writing the harmonic condition.
- Select the Harmonic Length Relation
For open-open or closed-closed tubes, for any integer . For open-closed tubes, with odd integers .
Count half-wavelength loops () along the tube to find the harmonic order .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFor a tube open at both ends, both boundary extremities are displacement antinodes, meaning the tube length fits an integer number of half-wavelengths: .
Solve for the harmonic index: .
Accounting for open-end corrections at both tube apertures, the physical length accommodates interior nodal heaps.
Acoustic frequency: ; Harmonic order:
Lock it in
In an acoustic standing wave, what is the spatial distance between two consecutive displacement nodes in terms of wavelength ?
. Consecutive nodes (or consecutive antinodes) are always separated by half a wavelength, not a full wavelength.
Similar question
A Kundt's tube filled with carbon dioxide has sound speed . When driven by a audio oscillator, powder heaps form along the glass tube. What is the expected separation between adjacent heaps?
Answer
. Key steps: Find wavelength . Adjacent heaps sit at displacement nodes separated by .
A horizontal resonance tube of length , open at both ends, resonates at its 4th harmonic (). Determine the total number of displacement nodes formed inside the tube and the distance between adjacent nodes.
Answer
nodes; distance (). Key steps: An open-open tube at mode has internal displacement nodes. The tube length satisfies , so .
In an experiment using a Kundt's tube of length open at both ends, a student counts distinct powder heaps along the column. If the driving frequency is , calculate the experimental speed of sound in the gas and state the harmonic mode .
Answer
, . Key steps: An open-open tube with displacement nodes corresponds to mode . The average node separation is . The acoustic wavelength is . The wave speed is .