Resources

A student inspecting a step-up transformer connected to an AC line observes that the secondary voltage is five times greater than the primary voltage (Vs=5VpV_s = 5 V_p). The student concludes: 'Because voltage is stepped up by a factor of 5, the electric power delivered to the secondary must also increase by a factor of 5, providing free extra energy to the circuit.' (a) Refute this misconception using the Law of Conservation of Energy and state the exact quantitative relationship between primary current IpI_p and secondary current IsI_s for an ideal transformer. (b) If the secondary delivers Vs=600 V (rms)V_s = 600\text{ V (rms)} to a resistive load of RL=150  ΩR_L = 150\;\Omega, calculate the primary current IpI_p drawn from a 120 V (rms)120\text{ V (rms)} input source.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Refutation: In an ideal transformer, energy is strictly conserved (Pin=PoutP_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{out}}); stepping up voltage by a factor of 55 reduces the secondary current to one-fifth of the primary current, so Ip=5IsI_p = 5 I_s (or IsIp=VpVs=15\frac{I_s}{I_p} = \frac{V_p}{V_s} = \frac{1}{5}); (b) Ip=20.0 AI_p = 20.0\text{ A}

Steps

Part (a): Refuting the Misconception and Current Relationship

  1. Law of Conservation of Energy: A transformer is a passive device; it cannot generate or amplify energy. According to the Law of Conservation of Energy, energy input per unit time must equal energy output per unit time. For an ideal transformer (operating with no power losses): Pin=PoutP_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{out}}

    Expressing electric power in terms of root-mean-square (rms) voltage and current: VpIp=VsIsV_p I_p = V_s I_s

  2. Refutation: The student's claim that a 5-fold increase in voltage provides "free extra energy" violates the first law of thermodynamics. Since electric power is the product of voltage and current (P=V⋅IP = V \cdot I), an increase in secondary voltage must be accompanied by an inverse decrease in secondary current. Power remains constant—it is never multiplied.
  3. Quantitative Relationship: Rearranging VpIp=VsIsV_p I_p = V_s I_s gives the inverse proportionality between voltage and current: IsIp=VpVs\frac{I_s}{I_p} = \frac{V_p}{V_s}

    Given that Vs=5VpV_s = 5 V_p: IsIp=15  ⟹  Ip=5Is(or Is=15Ip)\frac{I_s}{I_p} = \frac{1}{5} \implies I_p = 5 I_s \quad \left(\text{or } I_s = \frac{1}{5}I_p\right)


Part (b): Calculating the Primary Current

  1. Find the Secondary Current (IsI_s): Using Ohm's law for the secondary circuit with load resistance RL=150 ΩR_L = 150\ \Omega and Vs=600 VV_s = 600\text{ V}: Is=VsRL=600 V150 Ω=4.0 AI_s = \frac{V_s}{R_L} = \frac{600\text{ V}}{150\ \Omega} = 4.0\text{ A}
  2. Determine the Primary Current (IpI_p): Using the current ratio derived in Part (a): Ip=5Is=5⋅4.0 A=20.0 AI_p = 5 I_s = 5 \cdot 4.0\text{ A} = 20.0\text{ A}

    (Alternative verification via power conservation): Pout=VsIs=(600 V)(4.0 A)=2400 WP_{\text{out}} = V_s I_s = (600\text{ V})(4.0\text{ A}) = 2400\text{ W} Pin=Pout  ⟹  Ip=PinVp=2400 W120 V=20.0 AP_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{out}} \implies I_p = \frac{P_{\text{in}}}{V_p} = \frac{2400\text{ W}}{120\text{ V}} = 20.0\text{ A}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes current scales directly with voltage rather than inversely, concluding the primary current is smaller than the secondary current.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    By energy conservation, power in equals power out: Pp=Ps  ⟹  Vp×Ip=Vs×IsP_p = P_s \implies V_p \times I_p = V_s \times I_s

  2. Step 2

    Since Vs=5VpV_s = 5V_p, Is=5IpI_s = 5I_p

    Correct

    IsIp=VpVs=15  ⟹  Ip=5Is(or Is=15Ip)\frac{I_s}{I_p} = \frac{V_p}{V_s} = \frac{1}{5} \implies I_p = 5I_s \quad \left(\text{or } I_s = \frac{1}{5}I_p\right)

    When substituting Vs=5VpV_s = 5V_p into VpIp=VsIsV_p I_p = V_s I_s, the VpV_p terms cancel to give Ip=5IsI_p = 5I_s (or Is=15IpI_s = \frac{1}{5}I_p). Because power is constant, stepping up voltage reduces the current by the same factor.

  3. Step 3

    Is=VsRL=600150=4 AI_s = \frac{V_s}{R_L} = \frac{600}{150} = 4\text{ A}

  4. Step 4

    Ip=Is5=45=0.8 AI_p = \frac{I_s}{5} = \frac{4}{5} = 0.8\text{ A}

    Correct

    Ip=5Is=5(4 A)=20.0 AI_p = 5I_s = 5(4\text{ A}) = 20.0\text{ A}

    Your arithmetic followed directly from your Step 2 equation, but the inverted ratio propagated here to yield 0.8 A0.8\text{ A} instead of 20.0 A20.0\text{ A}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that an ideal transformer conserves power so that Pp=PsP_p = P_s.

You accurately calculated the secondary current using Ohm's law as Is=4 AI_s = 4\text{ A}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse proportionality algebraic inversion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated current as scaling directly with voltage rather than inversely when rearranging VpIp=VsIsV_p I_p = V_s I_s.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check power balance
  • For an ideal transformer, Pin=Pout  ⟹  VpIp=VsIsP_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{out}} \implies V_p I_p = V_s I_s.

  • If voltage goes up by a factor of kk, current must go down by that same factor kk (Is=1kIpI_s = \frac{1}{k}I_p, so Ip=kIsI_p = k I_s).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute Vs=5VpV_s = 5V_p into the power balance: VpIp=(5Vp)IsV_p I_p = (5V_p) I_s.

  2. Divide both sides by VpV_p: Ip=5IsI_p = 5I_s.

  3. Substitute Is=4.0 AI_s = 4.0\text{ A}: Ip=5×4.0 A=20.0 AI_p = 5 \times 4.0\text{ A} = 20.0\text{ A}.

Final answer

(a) Ip=5IsI_p = 5I_s (or Is=15IpI_s = \frac{1}{5}I_p); (b) Ip=20.0 AI_p = 20.0\text{ A}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice solving VpIp=VsIsV_p I_p = V_s I_s algebraically by dividing out common variables rather than matching scaling factors by intuition.

  • Perform a quick sanity check: in a step-up transformer (Vs>VpV_s > V_p), the primary current must always be larger than the secondary current (Ip>IsI_p > I_s).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates secondary power assuming power increases by a factor of 5 and misapplies power conservation to find primary current.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Energy conservation requires \text{Energy conservation requires } P_p = P_s , so a transformer cannot output free energy\text{, so a transformer cannot output free energy}   ⟹  \implies V_p ×\times I_p = V_s ×\times I_s   ⟹  \implies I_p = 5I_s

  2. Step 2

    I_s = 600150\frac{600}{150} = 4 A\text{ A}

  3. Step 3

    P_s = V_s ×\times I_s = 600 ×\times 4 = 2400 W\text{ W}   ⟹  \implies P_p = Ps5\frac{P_s}{5} = 24005\frac{2400}{5} = 480 W\text{ W}

    Correct

    P_p = P_s = 2400 W\text{ W}

    In an ideal transformer, total power is conserved without scaling factors (Pp=PsP_p = P_s). Dividing PsP_s by 55 violates the very conservation principle you correctly stated in part (a).

  4. Step 4

    I_p = PpVp\frac{P_p}{V_p} = 480120\frac{480}{120} = 4 A\text{ A}

    Correct

    I_p = 5I_s = 5(4.0 A\text{ A}) = 20.0 A\text{ A} \quad (or Ip=PpVp=2400 W120 V=20.0 A)\left(\text{or } I_p = \frac{P_p}{V_p} = \frac{2400\text{ W}}{120\text{ V}} = 20.0\text{ A}\right)

    Your formula Ip=PpVpI_p = \frac{P_p}{V_p} is correct, but your final value was affected by the incorrect value of PpP_p from the previous step. Alternatively, using your relation from part (a), Ip=5Is=20.0 AI_p = 5I_s = 20.0\text{ A}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You clearly explained that energy conservation requires Pp=PsP_p = P_s so a transformer cannot produce free energy.

You correctly derived the relationship Ip=5IsI_p = 5I_s from VpIp=VsIsV_p I_p = V_s I_s.

You correctly calculated the secondary load current as Is=4 AI_s = 4\text{ A}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misapplying power equality in ideal transformers

You accidentally divided the power by the turns ratio factor of 55, even though you had already established that power must remain equal between primary and secondary.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the voltage-current transformation ratio with power transfer. While voltage and current change by inverse factors of NN, the electric power in an ideal transformer does not scale at all (Pin=PoutP_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{out}}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Power is Invariant
  • For an ideal transformer, Pin=PoutP_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{out}} (or VpIp=VsIsV_p I_p = V_s I_s). Never multiply or divide power by the turns ratio.

  • Set Pp=PsP_p = P_s directly, or skip the power calculation entirely and use Ip=(VsVp)IsI_p = \left(\frac{V_s}{V_p}\right) I_s.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. By conservation of energy in an ideal transformer, Pp=Ps=2400 WP_p = P_s = 2400\text{ W}.

  2. Calculate the primary current using Ip=PpVp=2400 W120 V=20.0 AI_p = \frac{P_p}{V_p} = \frac{2400\text{ W}}{120\text{ V}} = 20.0\text{ A} (or directly via Ip=5Is=5×4.0 A=20.0 AI_p = 5 I_s = 5 \times 4.0\text{ A} = 20.0\text{ A}).

Final answer

I_p = 20.0 A\text{ A}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the ideal transformer relationship: voltage changes by Ns/NpN_s/N_p, current changes by Np/NsN_p/N_s, and power does not change.

  • When finding IpI_p, use the direct current ratio Ip=VsVpIsI_p = \frac{V_s}{V_p} I_s to avoid unnecessary intermediate power equations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student assumes primary and secondary currents are identical, neglecting the transformer turns ratio when determining primary current.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Energy cannot be created, so an ideal transformer conserves power: Vp×Ip=Vs×Is  ⟹  V_p \times I_p = V_s \times I_s \implies Since Vs=5VpV_s = 5V_p, Ip=5IsI_p = 5I_s

  2. Step 2

    Is=600150=4 AI_s = \frac{600}{150} = 4\text{ A}

  3. Step 3

    Current across the transformer remains unchanged: Ip=Is=4 AI_p = I_s = 4\text{ A}

    Correct

    Ip=5Is=5(4.0 A)=20.0 AI_p = 5I_s = 5(4.0\text{ A}) = 20.0\text{ A}

    A transformer changes both voltage and current inversely. Because voltage is stepped up by a factor of 5, the primary must supply 5 times as much current (Ip=5IsI_p = 5I_s) to conserve total power.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly stated that an ideal transformer conserves power according to the Law of Conservation of Energy.

You derived the correct inverse relation between voltage and current (Ip=5IsI_p = 5I_s) in part (a).

You correctly applied Ohm's law to find the secondary load current of 4 A4\text{ A}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ignoring transformer current transformation ratio

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the transformer as a single continuous series circuit where current cannot change, disconnecting your correct algebraic derivation in part (a) from the calculation in part (b).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dual Transformation Rule
  • Transformers operate via mutual induction across isolated coils, so current is never conserved directly across the gap.

  • Whenever voltage changes by a ratio of Ns/NpN_s/N_p, current must change by the reciprocal ratio Np/NsN_p/N_s.

Power Balance Check
  • Pin=VpIpP_{\text{in}} = V_p I_p must equal Pout=VsIsP_{\text{out}} = V_s I_s.

  • Multiply your candidate primary values: (120 V)(4 A)=480 W(120\text{ V})(4\text{ A}) = 480\text{ W}, while the load receives (600 V)(4 A)=2400 W(600\text{ V})(4\text{ A}) = 2400\text{ W}. A non-match immediately flags an unscaled current.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use the secondary current Is=4.0 AI_s = 4.0\text{ A} and the current ratio from part (a): Ip=5IsI_p = 5I_s.

  2. Substitute IsI_s: Ip=5×4.0 A=20.0 AI_p = 5 \times 4.0\text{ A} = 20.0\text{ A}.

  3. Alternatively, equate input power to output power: Pin=Pout=2400 W  ⟹  Ip=2400 W120 V=20.0 AP_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{out}} = 2400\text{ W} \implies I_p = \frac{2400\text{ W}}{120\text{ V}} = 20.0\text{ A}.

Final answer

Ip=20.0 AI_p = 20.0\text{ A}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how galvanic isolation between the primary and secondary coils prevents current continuity between circuits.

  • Practice checking transformer solutions by calculating Pin=VpIpP_{\text{in}} = V_p I_p and Pout=VsIsP_{\text{out}} = V_s I_s to verify that energy is conserved.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A step-down transformer converts 240 V (rms)240\text{ V (rms)} to 24 V (rms)24\text{ V (rms)}. If the secondary delivers 3.0 A3.0\text{ A} to a device, find the primary current IpI_p assuming ideal operation.

Answer

Ip=0.30 AI_p = 0.30\text{ A}. Steps: Voltage is reduced by a factor of 1010 (Vs/Vp=24/240=1/10V_s/V_p = 24/240 = 1/10), so current on the primary is one-tenth of the secondary: Ip=Is×VsVp=3.0 A×110=0.30 AI_p = I_s \times \frac{V_s}{V_p} = 3.0\text{ A} \times \frac{1}{10} = 0.30\text{ A}.

02

An ideal step-up transformer has a turns ratio of Ns/Np=8N_s / N_p = 8. It is connected to a 120 V (rms)120\text{ V (rms)} line and powers a 960  Ω960\;\Omega resistive load. Calculate the secondary voltage VsV_s, the load current IsI_s, and the primary current IpI_p.

Answer

Vs=960 VV_s = 960\text{ V}, Is=1.0 AI_s = 1.0\text{ A}, Ip=8.0 AI_p = 8.0\text{ A}. Steps: Vs=8×120 V=960 VV_s = 8 \times 120\text{ V} = 960\text{ V}. Secondary current Is=Vs/R=960 V/960  Ω=1.0 AI_s = V_s / R = 960\text{ V} / 960\;\Omega = 1.0\text{ A}. By power conservation, Ip=8×Is=8.0 AI_p = 8 \times I_s = 8.0\text{ A}.

03

A power plant generator provides 10 kV10\text{ kV} at 500 A500\text{ A} to a transmission step-up transformer with secondary voltage 250 kV250\text{ kV}. (a) Assuming ideal transmission, find the transmission line current IsI_s. (b) By what factor are resistive transmission power losses (I2RI^2 R) reduced compared to transmitting at the generator voltage?

Answer

(a) Is=20 AI_s = 20\text{ A}; (b) Losses are reduced by a factor of 625625 (25225^2). Steps: (a) Vs/Vp=250 kV/10 kV=25V_s/V_p = 250\text{ kV}/10\text{ kV} = 25, so Is=Ip/25=500 A/25=20 AI_s = I_p / 25 = 500\text{ A}/25 = 20\text{ A}. (b) Power loss scales as I2I^2; since current drops by 2525, loss drops by 252=62525^2 = 625.

Loading workspace…