Resources
A passenger train travels due east along a straight, level track at a constant speed of relative to the ground. Inside a passenger car, a commuter walks toward the front of the train (due east) at a steady speed of relative to the train floor, while tossing a small ball vertically upward. Simultaneously, an automobile on an adjacent highway travels due west at relative to the ground. Determine: (a) the velocity vector of the commuter relative to the ground, and (b) the velocity vector of the commuter as observed from the reference frame of the driver in the westbound automobile.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) due east; (b) due east
Steps
Setting Up the Coordinate System
To analyze one-dimensional relative motion, define a standard coordinate system along the east-west axis:
- Let the positive -direction point due east ().
- Let the negative -direction point due west ().
Identify each given velocity relative to the ground ():
- Velocity of the train () relative to the ground:
- Velocity of the commuter () relative to the train floor:
- Velocity of the automobile () relative to the ground:
(Note: The vertical motion of the tossed ball does not affect horizontal velocities because perpendicular velocity components are independent.)
Part (a): Velocity of the Commuter Relative to the Ground
According to the Galilean velocity addition rule, the velocity of an object relative to reference frame is the vector sum of its velocity relative to frame and the velocity of frame relative to :
Substitute the known values:
The positive sign indicates the direction is east. Therefore, the commuter's velocity relative to the ground is due east.
Part (b): Velocity of the Commuter Relative to the Automobile
To find the velocity of the commuter () as observed from the reference frame of the automobile driver (), use the relative velocity formula:
Substitute the velocity vectors:
Subtracting a negative value corresponds to adding speeds of objects moving in opposite directions:
A common pitfall is subtracting the magnitudes directly without accounting for the automobile's westward direction, which leads to an incorrect difference rather than the correct sum.
Thus, relative to the westbound driver, the commuter moves at due east.
Typical errors
01 The student subtracts the relative speeds in the first task under the mistaken assumption that walking relative to a moving frame always opposes the frame's motion.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
v_{CG} = v_{TG} - v_{CT} v_{CG} = 28.0 - 1.5 = 26.5 = 26.5
Correct{C/G} = {T/G} + {C/T} = 28.0\ + 1.5\ = +29.5\ 29.5
Because the commuter is walking toward the front of the train (due east) in the same direction that the train is moving (due east), the two velocities reinforce each other relative to the ground. You should add to rather than subtracting it.
- Step 2
v_{CA} = v_{CG} - v_{AG} v_{AG} = -22.0 v_{CA} = 26.5 - (-22.0) = 48.5 = 48.5_
Correct{C/A} = {C/G} - {A/G} = 29.5 - (-22.0) = +51.5\ 51.5
Your algebraic formula and your evaluation of are completely correct. However, your final value of is affected by the incorrect value of carried over from part (a).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that relative velocity between two observers moving in opposite directions requires subtracting a negative velocity vector in part (b).
You maintained consistent directional units throughout your work.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeIn part (a), you wrote and subtracted instead of adding it.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that motion inside an already-moving reference frame always subtracts from the frame's velocity, overlooking that velocities pointing in the same direction add together under Galilean transformation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Galilean Velocity Addition Rule
with aligned coordinate directions.
When combining motion within a moving carrier frame, add the velocity vectors: if both point east, their scalar magnitudes sum.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration(due east)
(due east)
(a) ; (b) $51.5
02 The student ignores the opposite direction of the westbound automobile and subtracts its positive speed when finding the relative velocity.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
Because the automobile travels due west, its velocity vector along the east-west axis is negative: . Substituting this gives , not .
- Step 3Correct
This result follows directly from the sign error in substituting the car's velocity in the previous step.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used Galilean velocity addition to find the commuter's velocity relative to the ground in part (a).
You selected the correct vector relation to find the relative velocity in part (b).
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou substituted the scalar speed instead of the directed velocity component for the westbound car.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing vector components with scalar magnitudes in one-dimensional relative velocity problems. When defining east as positive, any motion westward must carry an explicit negative sign before applying vector formulas.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define an explicit sign convention
Before substituting into , choose a positive direction (e.g., East = , West = ).
Label each given velocity with its proper sign: , .
- Apply physical intuition check
Two objects traveling toward each other or passing in opposite directions must have a relative speed equal to the sum of their individual speeds.
Since the train passenger is heading east and the car is heading west, the car driver sees the commuter rushing past faster than either vehicle's ground speed ().
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationAssign coordinate direction: Let east be and west be .
Express the car's velocity as a vector: .
Substitute into the relative velocity formula: .
(a) due east; (b) due east
03 The student reverses the reference frame subtraction order and calculates the automobile relative to the commuter instead of the commuter relative to the automobile.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You calculated the velocity of the automobile relative to the commuter () instead of the commuter relative to the automobile (). Because the commuter is moving east and the car is moving west, the driver sees the commuter rushing toward the east at .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly combined the train and walker velocities along the east-west axis to find the ground velocity.
You assigned the correct negative sign to the westbound velocity of the automobile.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou reversed the order of terms in the relative velocity formula: to find the velocity of object A relative to observer B (), you must subtract the observer's velocity from the object's velocity (), rather than subtracting the object's velocity from the observer's.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Subscript Order Rule
Always identify the target object first and the observer's reference frame second before setting up your subtraction.
- Physical Direction Sanity Check
An observer moving toward a target sees the target approaching, not moving backward.
When driving west toward an eastbound object, you will see the object moving east toward you at an increased relative speed.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the target as the commuter () and the reference observer as the automobile ().
Set up the relative velocity formula: .
Substitute the 1D vector components: .
(a) due east; (b) due east
Lock it in
How do you find the velocity of an object relative to the ground if you know its velocity relative to frame and 's velocity relative to ?
Use vector addition: . Adjacent inner indices () must match.
Similar question
A ferry travels north across still water at . A passenger walks toward the stern (south) at . What is the velocity of the passenger relative to the water?
Answer
. Using .
A flatbed truck travels east at relative to the ground. A cyclist on the bed rides east at relative to the truck. Simultaneously, a drone flies west at relative to the ground. What is the velocity of the cyclist as observed by the drone?
Answer
. Cyclist relative to ground: . Cyclist relative to drone: .
Two parallel tracks carry trains and . Train travels north at . Train travels south at . Inside Train , a passenger walks north at . Inside Train , a passenger walks north at . What is the velocity of the passenger on Train as seen by the passenger on Train ?
Answer
. Velocity of passenger relative to ground: . Velocity of passenger relative to ground: . Relative velocity: .