Resources

In a physics laboratory verification of Newton's second law using an Atwood-style modified dynamics cart system, a cart of mass M=0.850 kgM = 0.850\text{ kg} on a low-friction horizontal track is connected via a lightweight string over an ideal pulley to a hanging mass m=0.150 kgm = 0.150\text{ kg}. High-precision motion sensors record that the system accelerates from rest at aexp=1.28 m/s2a_{\text{exp}} = 1.28\text{ m/s}^2. Taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2: (a) Calculate the theoretical net external driving force F⃗net,sys\vec{F}_{\text{net,sys}} of the ideal frictionless system. (b) Determine the actual net horizontal force F⃗net,cart\vec{F}_{\text{net,cart}} acting on the cart during the run. (c) Using the combined system dynamic equations, determine the unaccounted resistive friction force ftrackf_{\text{track}} present on the cart track.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Fnet,sys=1.47 NF_{\text{net,sys}} = 1.47\text{ N}; (b) Fnet,cart=1.09 NF_{\text{net,cart}} = 1.09\text{ N}; (c) ftrack=0.190 Nf_{\text{track}} = 0.190\text{ N}

Steps

Part (a): Theoretical Net External Driving Force of the Ideal System

In a modified Atwood machine with a frictionless horizontal track and an ideal string and pulley:

  1. The vertical forces on the cart (gravity MgM g downward and normal force FNF_N upward) balance each other: FN=MgF_N = M g
  2. The internal tension forces between the cart and the hanging mass cancel out when considering the cart and hanging mass as a single composite system.
  3. Therefore, the only unbalanced external force acting in the direction of motion is the weight of the hanging mass: Fnet,sys=mgF_{\text{net,sys}} = m g

Substitute the given numerical values: Fnet,sys=0.150 kg⋅9.80 m/s2=1.47 NF_{\text{net,sys}} = 0.150\text{ kg} \cdot 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 = 1.47\text{ N}


Part (b): Actual Net Horizontal Force on the Cart

By Newton's second law, the net force acting on any single object is the product of its mass and its actual acceleration: Fnet,cart=MaexpF_{\text{net,cart}} = M a_{\text{exp}}

Using the measured experimental acceleration aexp=1.28 m/s2a_{\text{exp}} = 1.28\text{ m/s}^2: Fnet,cart=0.850 kg⋅1.28 m/s2=1.088 N≈1.09 NF_{\text{net,cart}} = 0.850\text{ kg} \cdot 1.28\text{ m/s}^2 = 1.088\text{ N} \approx 1.09\text{ N}

Common Pitfall: Do not confuse the net force on the cart (Fnet,cart=MaexpF_{\text{net,cart}} = M a_{\text{exp}}) with the tension in the string (TT). The net horizontal force is the vector sum of tension pulling forward and friction resisting motion (Fnet,cart=T−ftrackF_{\text{net,cart}} = T - f_{\text{track}}).


Part (c): Resistive Friction Force on the Track

Consider the entire system of mass Mtotal=M+mM_{\text{total}} = M + m: Mtotal=0.850 kg+0.150 kg=1.000 kgM_{\text{total}} = 0.850\text{ kg} + 0.150\text{ kg} = 1.000\text{ kg}

The actual net force accelerating the combined system along its trajectory is: Fnet,actual=Mtotalaexp=1.000 kg⋅1.28 m/s2=1.28 NF_{\text{net,actual}} = M_{\text{total}} a_{\text{exp}} = 1.000\text{ kg} \cdot 1.28\text{ m/s}^2 = 1.28\text{ N}

In the presence of track friction ftrackf_{\text{track}}, the equation of motion for the entire system along the line of motion is: mg−ftrack=(M+m)aexpm g - f_{\text{track}} = (M + m) a_{\text{exp}}

Rearranging to solve for the friction force ftrackf_{\text{track}}: ftrack=mg−(M+m)aexpf_{\text{track}} = m g - (M + m) a_{\text{exp}} ftrack=1.47 N−1.28 N=0.190 Nf_{\text{track}} = 1.47\text{ N} - 1.28\text{ N} = 0.190\text{ N}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student includes the total mass of the cart and hanging mass when calculating the driving gravitational force instead of using only the hanging mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    F_{net,sys\text{net,sys}} = (M + m) * g   ⟹  \implies F_{net,sys\text{net,sys}} = (0.850 + 0.150) * 9.80 = 9.80 N\text{ N}

    Correct

    F_{net,sys\text{net,sys}} = m g = 0.150 kg\text{ kg} ⋅\cdot 9.80 m/s\text{ m/s}^2 = 1.47 N\text{ N}_

    The cart rests on a horizontal track, so its weight MgM g is balanced by the upward normal force FNF_N. The only unbalanced external driving force acting along the line of motion is the weight of the hanging mass, mgm g.

  2. Step 2

    F_{net,cart\text{net,cart}} = M * a_{exp\text{exp}}   ⟹  \implies F_{net,cart\text{net,cart}} = 0.850 * 1.28 = 1.088 N\text{ N}_

  3. Step 3

    F_{net,sys\text{net,sys}} - f_{track\text{track}} = (M + m) * a_{exp\text{exp}}   ⟹  \implies 9.80 - f_{track\text{track}} = 1.000 * 1.28   ⟹  \implies f_{track\text{track}} = 9.80 - 1.28 = 8.52 N\text{ N}_

    Correct

    f_{track\text{track}} = m g - (M + m) a_{exp\text{exp}} = 1.47 N\text{ N} - 1.28 N\text{ N} = 0.190 N\text{ N}

    Your dynamic equation Fnet,sys−ftrack=(M+m)aexpF_{\text{net,sys}} - f_{\text{track}} = (M + m) a_{\text{exp}} is conceptually correct, but substituting your incorrect value of 9.80 N9.80\text{ N} from part (a) carried over into an incorrect final friction value.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the net force on an individual object equals its own mass multiplied by its acceleration.

You accurately formulated the system equation of motion relating driving force, resistive friction, and total inertia.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Driving force vs. total mass confusion

You used the total system mass (M+m)(M + m) instead of only the hanging mass mm when calculating the driving gravitational force.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In a modified Atwood machine, gravity acts on both masses, but the cart's weight is perpendicular to the track and fully supported by the normal force. Therefore, only the unsupported hanging mass provides the external driving force along the direction of motion.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Unbalanced External Forces
  • Only gravitational forces acting parallel to the motion (or hanging freely) contribute to the net driving force.

  • Always draw a free-body diagram for each object and check whether gravity is balanced by a normal force before including it in the driving force.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the ideal driving force: Fnet,sys=mg=0.150 kg⋅9.80 m/s2=1.47 NF_{\text{net,sys}} = m g = 0.150\text{ kg} \cdot 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 = 1.47\text{ N}.

  2. Substitute into your system equation: 1.47 N−ftrack=(0.850 kg+0.150 kg)⋅1.28 m/s2=1.28 N1.47\text{ N} - f_{\text{track}} = (0.850\text{ kg} + 0.150\text{ kg}) \cdot 1.28\text{ m/s}^2 = 1.28\text{ N}.

  3. Solve for track friction: ftrack=1.47 N−1.28 N=0.190 Nf_{\text{track}} = 1.47\text{ N} - 1.28\text{ N} = 0.190\text{ N}.

Final answer

(a) 1.47 N1.47\text{ N}; (b) 1.09 N1.09\text{ N}; (c) 0.190 N0.190\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review free-body diagrams for modified Atwood machines to distinguish accelerating mass from driving mass.

  • Practice separating the total inertial mass (M+m)(M + m) in ΣF=mtotala\Sigma F = m_{\text{total}} a from the specific external force providing ΣF\Sigma F.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes the net driving force of the combined system accelerates only the cart mass M rather than the total system mass (M + m).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Fnet,sys=m⋅g  ⟹  Fnet,sys=0.150⋅9.80=1.47 NF_{\text{net,sys}} = m \cdot g \implies F_{\text{net,sys}} = 0.150 \cdot 9.80 = 1.47\text{ N}

  2. Step 2

    Fnet,cart=M⋅aexp  ⟹  Fnet,cart=0.850⋅1.28=1.088 NF_{\text{net,cart}} = M \cdot a_{\text{exp}} \implies F_{\text{net,cart}} = 0.850 \cdot 1.28 = 1.088\text{ N}

  3. Step 3

    m⋅g−ftrack=M⋅aexp  ⟹  1.47−ftrack=0.850⋅1.28  ⟹  ftrack=1.47−1.088=0.382 Nm \cdot g - f_{\text{track}} = M \cdot a_{\text{exp}} \implies 1.47 - f_{\text{track}} = 0.850 \cdot 1.28 \implies f_{\text{track}} = 1.47 - 1.088 = 0.382\text{ N}

    Correct

    mg−ftrack=(M+m)aexp  ⟹  ftrack=1.47 N−(0.850 kg+0.150 kg)(1.28 m/s2)=0.190 Nm g - f_{\text{track}} = (M + m)a_{\text{exp}} \implies f_{\text{track}} = 1.47\text{ N} - (0.850\text{ kg} + 0.150\text{ kg})(1.28\text{ m/s}^2) = 0.190\text{ N}

    You set the net force of the combined system equal to MaexpM a_{\text{exp}} instead of (M+m)aexp(M + m)a_{\text{exp}}. Because the string connects both objects, the hanging mass accelerates downward at the same rate, so its inertia must be included in the total accelerating mass.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the weight of the hanging mass is the external driving force of the system.

You correctly applied Newton's second law to find the net force acting on the cart alone using its measured acceleration.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted hanging mass inertia in system equation of motion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When setting up Newton's second law for a multi-body connected system, you applied the net external driving forces (mg−ftrackm g - f_{\text{track}}) to only the cart's mass MM rather than the total inertia of the coupled system (M+m)(M + m). Alternatively, if analyzing the cart alone, the pulling force is the string tension TT, which is strictly less than mgm g because the hanging mass is accelerating downward (T=m(g−a)T = m(g - a)).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
System Boundary Rule
  • For coupled objects moving with identical acceleration magnitude aa, ΣFext=mtotala=(m1+m2+… )a\Sigma F_{\text{ext}} = m_{\text{total}} a = (m_1 + m_2 + \dots) a.

  • Always list every moving mass inside the system boundary before writing the right-hand side of ΣF=ma\Sigma F = m a.

Tension vs. Weight Distinction
  • A hanging mass accelerating downward has mg−T=mam g - T = m a, which means T=m(g−a)<mgT = m(g - a) < m g.

  • Never substitute the hanging weight mgm g directly as the forward tension force on the cart when the system is accelerating.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write Newton's second law for the entire connected system: ΣFext=(M+m)aexp\Sigma F_{\text{ext}} = (M + m)a_{\text{exp}}.

  2. Identify the external forces along the direction of motion: the driving gravity force mgm g pulling forward and the track friction ftrackf_{\text{track}} resisting motion, giving mg−ftrack=(M+m)aexpm g - f_{\text{track}} = (M + m)a_{\text{exp}}.

  3. Substitute the known values: 1.47 N−ftrack=(0.850 kg+0.150 kg)(1.28 m/s2)=1.28 N1.47\text{ N} - f_{\text{track}} = (0.850\text{ kg} + 0.150\text{ kg})(1.28\text{ m/s}^2) = 1.28\text{ N}.

  4. Solve for the friction force: ftrack=1.47 N−1.28 N=0.190 Nf_{\text{track}} = 1.47\text{ N} - 1.28\text{ N} = 0.190\text{ N}.

Final answer

(a) Fnet,sys=1.47 NF_{\text{net,sys}} = 1.47\text{ N}; (b) Fnet,cart=1.09 NF_{\text{net,cart}} = 1.09\text{ N}; (c) ftrack=0.190 Nf_{\text{track}} = 0.190\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the two valid approaches for connected systems: the whole-system approach using total mass (M+m)(M+m), and the isolated-body approach using individual free-body diagrams linked by string tension TT.

  • Solve the follow-up exercises to ensure you consistently include all accelerated masses when formulating Newton's second law for coupled bodies.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses the actual net force on the cart with the tension in the string and directly equates the net force on the cart to the hanging mass weight minus friction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Fnet,sys=m⋅g  ⟹  Fnet,sys=0.150⋅9.80=1.47 NF_{\text{net,sys}} = m \cdot g \implies F_{\text{net,sys}} = 0.150 \cdot 9.80 = 1.47\text{ N}

  2. Step 2

    Fnet,cart=(M+m)⋅aexp  ⟹  Fnet,cart=(0.850+0.150)⋅1.28=1.28 NF_{\text{net,cart}} = (M + m) \cdot a_{\text{exp}} \implies F_{\text{net,cart}} = (0.850 + 0.150) \cdot 1.28 = 1.28\text{ N}

    Correct

    Fnet,cart=Maexp=0.850 kg⋅1.28 m/s2≈1.09 NF_{\text{net,cart}} = M a_{\text{exp}} = 0.850\text{ kg} \cdot 1.28\text{ m/s}^2 \approx 1.09\text{ N}

    When applying Newton's second law to an individual object, you must multiply that specific object's mass by its acceleration. By using (M+m)(M + m), you calculated the actual net force on the entire two-body system rather than the net horizontal force on the cart alone.

  3. Step 3

    ftrack=m⋅g−(M+m)⋅aexp  ⟹  ftrack=1.47−1.000⋅1.28=0.190 Nf_{\text{track}} = m \cdot g - (M + m) \cdot a_{\text{exp}} \implies f_{\text{track}} = 1.47 - 1.000 \cdot 1.28 = 0.190\text{ N}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the hanging mass's weight is the external driving force for the ideal modified Atwood system.

You properly formulated the combined two-body equation of motion to calculate track friction in part (c).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
System boundary confusion in Newton's second law

You substituted the total system mass (M+m)(M + m) into the formula for the net force acting on the single cart MM.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the net force accelerating an isolated component of a system with the net force accelerating the combined multi-body system.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define the System Boundary
  • For any isolated body ii, Newton's second law states ΣF⃗i=mia⃗i\Sigma \vec{F}_i = m_i \vec{a}_i.

  • Always check whether the question asks for the net force on an individual object (Fnet=mobjectaF_{\text{net}} = m_{\text{object}} a) or the net force on the entire system (Fnet,sys=mtotalaF_{\text{net,sys}} = m_{\text{total}} a).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply Newton's second law directly to the cart of mass MM: Fnet,cart=MaexpF_{\text{net,cart}} = M a_{\text{exp}}.

  2. Substitute the cart's mass M=0.850 kgM = 0.850\text{ kg} and acceleration aexp=1.28 m/s2a_{\text{exp}} = 1.28\text{ m/s}^2: Fnet,cart=0.850 kg×1.28 m/s2=1.088 NF_{\text{net,cart}} = 0.850\text{ kg} \times 1.28\text{ m/s}^2 = 1.088\text{ N}.

  3. Round to three significant figures to obtain 1.09 N1.09\text{ N}.

Final answer

(a) Fnet,sys=1.47 NF_{\text{net,sys}} = 1.47\text{ N}; (b) Fnet,cart=1.09 NF_{\text{net,cart}} = 1.09\text{ N}; (c) ftrack=0.190 Nf_{\text{track}} = 0.190\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before writing down Fnet=maF_{\text{net}} = m a, clearly circle or name the specific body you are applying the equation to.

  • Remember that internal forces (like tension) cancel out for the composite system (M+m)(M+m), but external forces on the isolated cart include tension and friction: Fnet,cart=T−ftrack=MaF_{\text{net,cart}} = T - f_{\text{track}} = M a.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A cart with mass M=1.20 kgM = 1.20\text{ kg} on a frictionless horizontal table is connected by a light string over a frictionless pulley to a hanging mass m=0.30 kgm = 0.30\text{ kg}. Taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2, find: (a) the net driving force on the system, and (b) the theoretical acceleration of the system.

Answer

(a) Fnet=mg=(0.30)(9.80)=2.94 NF_{\text{net}} = m g = (0.30)(9.80) = 2.94\text{ N}. (b) a=FnetM+m=2.941.20+0.30=1.96 m/s2a = \frac{F_{\text{net}}}{M + m} = \frac{2.94}{1.20 + 0.30} = 1.96\text{ m/s}^2.

02

In the same system (M=1.20 kgM = 1.20\text{ kg}, m=0.30 kgm = 0.30\text{ kg}), sensors measure an actual acceleration of a=1.60 m/s2a = 1.60\text{ m/s}^2. What constant resistive friction force ff opposes the cart on the track?

Answer

System equation: mg−f=(M+m)a  ⟹  2.94−f=(1.50)(1.60)=2.40 Nm g - f = (M + m) a \implies 2.94 - f = (1.50)(1.60) = 2.40\text{ N}, so f=2.94−2.40=0.540 Nf = 2.94 - 2.40 = 0.540\text{ N}.

03

A student sets up a modified Atwood machine where a cart of mass MM accelerates along a track inclined at an angle θ=30∘\theta = 30^\circ above the horizontal, connected to a hanging mass mm. In terms of MM, mm, gg, and θ\theta, what is the net theoretical driving force pulling the cart up the incline (assuming frictionless surfaces and that mm descends)?

Answer

The hanging mass pulls with force mgm g, while gravity pulls the cart down the incline with component Mgsin⁡θM g \sin\theta. Thus, Fnet,sys=mg−Mgsin⁡(30∘)=mg−0.5MgF_{\text{net,sys}} = m g - M g \sin(30^\circ) = m g - 0.5 M g.

Loading workspace…