Resources

A bat flies horizontally at 18.0 km/h18.0\text{ km/h} directly toward an insect flying in the opposite direction (toward the bat) at 450 cm/s450\text{ cm/s}. The bat emits an ultrasonic chirp at 42.0 kHz42.0\text{ kHz}. Using a speed of sound in air of 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}, calculate the frequency of the echo heard by the bat after reflection from the approaching insect.

Answer and steps

Final answer

44.4 kHz44.4\text{ kHz}

Steps

01

Convert all given velocities into SI units (m/s\text{m/s})

  • Speed of the bat (vBv_B): vB=18.0 km/h=18.0×1000 m3600 s=5.0 m/sv_B = 18.0\text{ km/h} = 18.0 \times \frac{1000\text{ m}}{3600\text{ s}} = 5.0\text{ m/s}
  • Speed of the insect (vIv_I): vI=450 cm/s=450100 m/s=4.5 m/sv_I = 450\text{ cm/s} = \frac{450}{100}\text{ m/s} = 4.5\text{ m/s}
  • Speed of sound in air (vv): v=340 m/sv = 340\text{ m/s}
  • Emitted frequency (f0f_0): f0=42.0 kHzf_0 = 42.0\text{ kHz}

02

Determine the frequency received by the insect (Stage 1)

In the first stage, the bat acts as a source moving toward the insect, and the insect acts as an observer moving toward the bat.

Using the standard Doppler effect formula for approaching bodies: f′=f0(v+vIv−vB)f' = f_0 \left(\frac{v + v_I}{v - v_B}\right)

  • The numerator has a plus sign (+vI+ v_I) because the observer (insect) is moving toward the source, encountering wave crests more frequently.
  • The denominator has a minus sign (−vB- v_B) because the source (bat) is moving toward the observer, compressing the emitted wavelength.

Substitute the values: f′=42.0 kHz×(340+4.5340−5.0)=42.0 kHz×344.5335.0f' = 42.0\text{ kHz} \times \left(\frac{340 + 4.5}{340 - 5.0}\right) = 42.0\text{ kHz} \times \frac{344.5}{335.0}


03

Determine the echo frequency heard by the bat (Stage 2)

The insect reflects this sound wave at frequency f′f', acting as a moving source flying toward the bat. The bat is now an observer moving toward the source.

Applying the Doppler formula again: f′′=f′(v+vBv−vI)f'' = f' \left(\frac{v + v_B}{v - v_I}\right)

  • The observer (bat) moves toward the source, giving (v+vB)(v + v_B) in the numerator.
  • The source (insect) moves toward the observer, giving (v−vI)(v - v_I) in the denominator.

Substitute f′f' into the equation: f′′=f0(v+vIv−vB)(v+vBv−vI)f'' = f_0 \left(\frac{v + v_I}{v - v_B}\right) \left(\frac{v + v_B}{v - v_I}\right)


04

Calculate the final frequency

Substitute the numerical values: f′′=42.0×(344.5×345.0335.0×335.5)f'' = 42.0 \times \left(\frac{344.5 \times 345.0}{335.0 \times 335.5}\right)

f′′=42.0×118852.5112392.5≈42.0×1.05748≈44.414 kHzf'' = 42.0 \times \frac{118852.5}{112392.5} \approx 42.0 \times 1.05748 \approx 44.414\text{ kHz}

Rounding to three significant figures gives 44.4 kHz44.4\text{ kHz}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates only the single Doppler-shifted frequency received by the insect, neglecting the second Doppler shift when the sound is reflected back to the moving bat.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    vb=18.0 km/h=5.0 m/s  ⟹  vi=450 cm/s=4.5 m/sv_b = 18.0\text{ km/h} = 5.0\text{ m/s} \implies v_i = 450\text{ cm/s} = 4.5\text{ m/s}

  2. Step 2

    fecho=42.0×340+4.5340−5.0  ⟹  fecho=42.0×344.5335.0=43.2 kHzf_{echo} = 42.0 \times \frac{340 + 4.5}{340 - 5.0} \implies f_{echo} = 42.0 \times \frac{344.5}{335.0} = 43.2\text{ kHz}

    Correct

    f′′=f′(v+vBv−vI)=42.0×(344.5335.0)(345.0335.5)≈44.4 kHzf'' = f' \left(\frac{v + v_B}{v - v_I}\right) = 42.0 \times \left(\frac{344.5}{335.0}\right)\left(\frac{345.0}{335.5}\right) \approx 44.4\text{ kHz}

    This expression only calculates the frequency f′f' detected by the insect. When the sound reflects off the insect, the insect acts as a moving source emitting f′f', and the approaching bat acts as a moving observer detecting a second Doppler-shifted frequency f′′f''.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You converted both speeds correctly to standard SI units of m/s\text{m/s}.

You correctly used the Doppler equation signs for an approaching source and approaching observer in the forward wave.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Single Doppler Shift Instead of Double Shift

You stopped calculating after finding the frequency received by the insect instead of carrying out the return wave calculation.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated an echo reflection problem as a one-way transmission, overlooking that reflection from a moving target involves two distinct Doppler shifts: emission to target, then reflection back to the detector.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Two-Stage Doppler Reflection
  • An echo from a moving target undergoes two shifts: Stage 1 has the target as the observer; Stage 2 has the target as the moving source reflecting the wave toward the original emitter.

  • Multiply the original frequency by both shift factors: f′′=f0(v±vtargetv∓vemitter)(v±vemitterv∓vtarget)f'' = f_0 \left(\frac{v \pm v_{\text{target}}}{v \mp v_{\text{emitter}}}\right) \left(\frac{v \pm v_{\text{emitter}}}{v \mp v_{\text{target}}}\right).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the insect as a source moving toward the bat at vI=4.5 m/sv_I = 4.5\text{ m/s} emitting frequency f′=42.0×344.5335.0 kHzf' = 42.0 \times \frac{344.5}{335.0}\text{ kHz}.

  2. Set the bat as an observer moving toward the source at vB=5.0 m/sv_B = 5.0\text{ m/s}.

  3. Apply the Doppler formula for the echo: f′′=f′(v+vBv−vI)=42.0×(344.5335.0)(340+5.0340−4.5)f'' = f' \left(\frac{v + v_B}{v - v_I}\right) = 42.0 \times \left(\frac{344.5}{335.0}\right) \left(\frac{340 + 5.0}{340 - 4.5}\right).

  4. Compute the product: f′′=42.0×(344.5×345.0335.0×335.5)≈44.414 kHzf'' = 42.0 \times \left(\frac{344.5 \times 345.0}{335.0 \times 335.5}\right) \approx 44.414\text{ kHz}.

Final answer

44.4 kHz44.4\text{ kHz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember that any radar, sonar, or echolocation problem involving reflection off a moving object always requires two Doppler shift factors.

  • Practice tracking the role of each body (source vs. observer) explicitly in two separate stages: outbound wave and inbound echo.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the sign conventions for moving toward and moving away, using minus signs in the numerator and plus signs in the denominator.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    vb=18.03.6=5.0 m/s  ⟹  vi=450100=4.5 m/sv_b = \frac{18.0}{3.6} = 5.0\text{ m/s} \implies v_i = \frac{450}{100} = 4.5\text{ m/s}

  2. Step 2

    fecho=42.0×(340−4.5)(340−5.0)(340+5.0)(340+4.5)f_{\text{echo}} = 42.0 \times \frac{(340 - 4.5)(340 - 5.0)}{(340 + 5.0)(340 + 4.5)}

    Correct

    fecho=42.0×(340+4.5)(340+5.0)(340−5.0)(340−4.5)f_{\text{echo}} = 42.0 \times \frac{(340 + 4.5)(340 + 5.0)}{(340 - 5.0)(340 - 4.5)}

    Because the bat and the insect are flying toward each other, both the motion of the observer and the motion of the source must shift the frequency upward. An approaching observer requires a plus sign in the numerator (v+vobs)(v + v_{\text{obs}}), and an approaching source requires a minus sign in the denominator (v−vsrc)(v - v_{\text{src}}).

  3. Step 3

    fecho=42.0×(335.5×335.0)(345.0×344.5)=39.7 kHzf_{\text{echo}} = 42.0 \times \frac{(335.5 \times 335.0)}{(345.0 \times 344.5)} = 39.7\text{ kHz}

    Correct

    fecho=42.0×(344.5×345.0)(335.0×335.5)≈44.4 kHzf_{\text{echo}} = 42.0 \times \frac{(344.5 \times 345.0)}{(335.0 \times 335.5)} \approx 44.4\text{ kHz}

    Your arithmetic was correctly executed from your previous formula, but the final numerical value was affected by the inverted signs in Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You converted both given velocities accurately into standard SI units.

You correctly structured the echo problem as a compound two-stage Doppler shift.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Doppler Effect Sign Convention Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the sign conventions for relative motion in the general Doppler formula, associating approaching motion with minus in the numerator and plus in the denominator rather than ensuring that approach causes a frequency increase (f>f0f > f_0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Physical Intuition Check
  • Approaching motion always increases the received frequency (f′>ff' > f).

  • Before evaluating formulas, verify that the numerator is larger than the denominator so the Doppler factor exceeds 1.

Doppler Sign Convention
  • For observer motion toward source: v+vOv + v_O. For source motion toward observer: v−vSv - v_S.

  • Use f′=f(v±vOv∓vS)f' = f \left(\frac{v \pm v_O}{v \mp v_S}\right) where top signs (+,−)(+, -) correspond to approaching motion.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the compound Doppler ratio for mutual approach: f′′=f0(v+vIv−vB)(v+vBv−vI)f'' = f_0 \left(\frac{v + v_I}{v - v_B}\right)\left(\frac{v + v_B}{v - v_I}\right).

  2. Substitute the values: f′′=42.0 kHz×(340+4.5)(340+5.0)(340−5.0)(340−4.5)=42.0×344.5×345.0335.0×335.5f'' = 42.0\text{ kHz} \times \frac{(340 + 4.5)(340 + 5.0)}{(340 - 5.0)(340 - 4.5)} = 42.0 \times \frac{344.5 \times 345.0}{335.0 \times 335.5}.

  3. Calculate the product: f′′=42.0×118852.5112392.5≈44.414 kHzf'' = 42.0 \times \frac{118852.5}{112392.5} \approx 44.414\text{ kHz}.

Final answer

44.4 kHz44.4\text{ kHz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always do a quick physical sanity check: whenever source and observer get closer, the perceived frequency must rise.

  • Memorize the standard mnemonic: top signs (+,−)(+, -) are for approach, bottom signs (−,+)(-, +) are for recession.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student treats the relative approach speed between the bat and insect as a single source velocity relative to a stationary medium and observer.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    vb=5.0 m/s  ⟹  vi=4.5 m/sv_b = 5.0\text{ m/s} \implies v_i = 4.5\text{ m/s}

  2. Step 2

    vrel=5.0+4.5=9.5 m/s  ⟹  fecho=42.0×340340−2×9.5v_{\text{rel}} = 5.0 + 4.5 = 9.5\text{ m/s} \implies f_{\text{echo}} = 42.0 \times \frac{340}{340 - 2 \times 9.5}

    Correct

    f′′=f0(v+vIv−vB)(v+vBv−vI)f'' = f_0 \left(\frac{v + v_I}{v - v_B}\right)\left(\frac{v + v_B}{v - v_I}\right)

    In classical wave propagation, velocities must be measured relative to the medium (air), not merely relative to each other. Combining both motions into vrelv_{\text{rel}} in the denominator incorrectly assumes a stationary observer and stationary medium with an effective source speed of 2vrel2v_{\text{rel}}.

  3. Step 3

    fecho=42.0×340321.0=44.5 kHzf_{\text{echo}} = 42.0 \times \frac{340}{321.0} = 44.5\text{ kHz}

    Correct

    f′′=42.0×(344.5×345.0335.0×335.5)≈44.4 kHzf'' = 42.0 \times \left(\frac{344.5 \times 345.0}{335.0 \times 335.5}\right) \approx 44.4\text{ kHz}

    Your final numerical calculation correctly followed from your setup, but it carries forward the error from using an incorrect relative-velocity formula.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly converted all given velocities into consistent SI units (m/s\text{m/s}).

You recognized that mutual approach leads to an upward frequency shift in the echo.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Relative velocity used instead of medium-based Doppler shifts

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Acoustic Doppler shifts depend independently on the source's motion through the air (which alters the physical wavelength) and the observer's motion through the air (which alters the rate of intercepting wave crests). You cannot treat the approach as a single relative velocity relative to a stationary medium.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Reference frame for sound waves
  • Sound waves propagate through a physical medium (air) at speed vv, so the source and observer speeds must always be defined relative to the still air.

  • Avoid using vrel=vS+vOv_{\text{rel}} = v_S + v_O inside Doppler formulas for sound.

Two-stage echo analysis
  • An echo involves two distinct Doppler events: (1) Outbound wave from source to reflector, and (2) Inbound reflected wave from reflector (acting as a new source) back to the original source (acting as the observer).

  • Write f′=f0(v±vOv∓vS)f' = f_0 \left(\frac{v \pm v_O}{v \mp v_S}\right) for the incident wave, then use f′f' as the emitted frequency for the return wave.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up Stage 1 (bat as source moving at vB=5.0 m/sv_B = 5.0\text{ m/s}, insect as observer moving at vI=4.5 m/sv_I = 4.5\text{ m/s}): f′=f0(v+vIv−vB)=42.0×(340+4.5340−5.0)=42.0×344.5335.0f' = f_0 \left(\frac{v + v_I}{v - v_B}\right) = 42.0 \times \left(\frac{340 + 4.5}{340 - 5.0}\right) = 42.0 \times \frac{344.5}{335.0}

  2. Set up Stage 2 (insect reflects f′f' as a source moving at vI=4.5 m/sv_I = 4.5\text{ m/s}, bat receives as observer moving at vB=5.0 m/sv_B = 5.0\text{ m/s}): f′′=f′(v+vBv−vI)f'' = f' \left(\frac{v + v_B}{v - v_I}\right)

  3. Combine both stages: f′′=42.0×(344.5335.0)×(345.0335.5)f'' = 42.0 \times \left(\frac{344.5}{335.0}\right) \times \left(\frac{345.0}{335.5}\right)

Final answer

44.4 kHz44.4\text{ kHz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Treat any acoustic reflection or echo problem as a two-step process: find the frequency received by the reflector first, then find the frequency received by the detector.

  • Remember that the numerator in the Doppler formula accounts for observer motion relative to the air, while the denominator accounts for source motion relative to the air.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A stationary bat emits a sound pulse at 50.0 kHz50.0\text{ kHz}. An insect flies directly toward the bat at 6.0 m/s6.0\text{ m/s}. If the speed of sound is 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}, what echo frequency does the bat detect?

Answer

51.8 kHz51.8\text{ kHz}. In stage 1, the stationary bat emits to the approaching insect: f′=50.0(340+6.0340)f' = 50.0\left(\frac{340 + 6.0}{340}\right). In stage 2, the moving insect reflects sound to the stationary bat: f′′=f′(340340−6.0)=50.0(346334)≈51.8 kHzf'' = f'\left(\frac{340}{340 - 6.0}\right) = 50.0\left(\frac{346}{334}\right) \approx 51.8\text{ kHz}.

02

A police car travels at 30.0 m/s30.0\text{ m/s} toward a stationary flat cliff while sounding its siren at 600 Hz600\text{ Hz}. Taking the speed of sound to be 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}, calculate the beat frequency heard by the police officer between the emitted siren and the echo reflected from the cliff.

Answer

116 Hz116\text{ Hz}. The cliff receives f′=600(340340−30.0)f' = 600\left(\frac{340}{340 - 30.0}\right). The reflected echo received by the moving car is f′′=f′(340+30.0340)=600(370310)≈716.1 Hzf'' = f'\left(\frac{340 + 30.0}{340}\right) = 600\left(\frac{370}{310}\right) \approx 716.1\text{ Hz}. The beat frequency is ∣f′′−f0∣=716.1−600≈116 Hz|f'' - f_0| = 716.1 - 600 \approx 116\text{ Hz}.

03

A submarine moves at 12.0 m/s12.0\text{ m/s} through water (vsound=1500 m/sv_{\text{sound}} = 1500\text{ m/s}) directly behind an enemy vessel moving at 8.0 m/s8.0\text{ m/s} in the same direction. The submarine emits an active sonar ping at 1200 Hz1200\text{ Hz}. What frequency is received back at the submarine after reflecting off the enemy vessel?

Answer

1206 Hz1206\text{ Hz}. Stage 1 (outbound): Submarine chases vessel, so f′=1200(1500−8.01500−12.0)=1200(14921488)f' = 1200\left(\frac{1500 - 8.0}{1500 - 12.0}\right) = 1200\left(\frac{1492}{1488}\right). Stage 2 (echo): Vessel reflects as source moving away from the pursuing submarine observer, so f′′=f′(1500+12.01500+8.0)=1200(1492×15121488×1508)≈1206.4 Hzf'' = f'\left(\frac{1500 + 12.0}{1500 + 8.0}\right) = 1200\left(\frac{1492 \times 1512}{1488 \times 1508}\right) \approx 1206.4\text{ Hz}.

Loading workspace…