Resources
A cylindrical glass beaker of mass and inner height has a uniform circular cross-section and a flat, thin base. The beaker is initially completely filled to the brim with water of total mass . As water slowly evaporates, the center of mass of the combined beaker-and-water system initially drops, reaches a minimum height above the base, and subsequently rises back up to the midpoint of the empty beaker when fully dry. Calculate the liquid water depth remaining in the beaker at the exact moment the center of mass of the system reaches its absolute minimum height , and evaluate .
Answer and steps
Final answer
, with
Steps
Identify the masses and centers of mass
- Empty beaker: The beaker has mass and inner height . Its walls and cross-section are uniform, so its center of mass lies at its geometric midpoint:
-
Water inside the beaker: When filled to the brim, the combined system has a total mass of , which means the full mass of the water alone is:
When the remaining water depth is (where ), the mass of the water is proportional to its height: Since the liquid column is uniform, its center of mass is located at half its depth:
Formulate the center of mass of the combined system
The height of the center of mass of the beaker-water system measured from the base is:
Dividing the numerator and denominator by :
Determine the condition for minimum center of mass
To find the depth that minimizes , we can use a key physical principle:
Key Insight: When the system's center of mass reaches its minimum height, the center of mass must coincide with the free surface of the liquid: Reasoning: Adding an infinitesimal layer of water at the water surface (height ) will lower the center of mass if , and raise it if . Thus, the stationary point (minimum) occurs precisely when the surface height equals the system's center of mass height, .
Setting :
Multiply both sides by :
Rearrange into standard quadratic form:
Solve for and evaluate
Apply the quadratic formula to solve for :
Since depth must be positive, we take the positive root:
Substitute :
Since :
Typical errors
01 The student incorrectly assumes the center of mass of the water column is at its full surface height y instead of its midpoint y/2.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
A uniform column of liquid of depth has its center of mass at half its depth, , not at the top surface . Additionally, the water alone has mass when full, giving .
- Step 3Correct
Because you used and , the expression for inherited those errors, though your algebraic reduction of your expression was carried out consistently.
- Step 4Correct
Your physical condition is insightful and correct. However, setting erroneously canceled the term on both sides, yielding instead of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the center of mass of the empty beaker as its geometric midpoint.
You used the powerful physical insight that the minimum center of mass occurs when the system's center of mass coincides with the liquid surface.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou set the water's center of mass to its surface height instead of its geometric midpoint .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the total height of a continuous uniform body with the location of its center of mass. For any uniform object with symmetric vertical mass distribution, the center of mass is located at its midpoint, not at its upper boundary.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Continuous Uniform Column Center of Mass
For a uniform vertical cylinder or column of height , the center of mass is located at above the base.
Always represent the position coordinate of the liquid column as when setting up the weighted center of mass formula.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationThe mass of the water column is , and its center of mass is .
Form the combined center of mass: .
Apply the stationary condition : .
Solve for the positive root: .
02 The student misidentifies the minimum condition by simply minimizing the numerator of the center of mass function rather than differentiating the quotient.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You minimized only the numerator of . Because the denominator also depends on (the total mass varies as water evaporates), you must either apply the quotient rule to differentiate the full expression or use the physical principle that the minimum occurs when the center of mass lies exactly on the water surface, .
- Step 3Correct
This result follows directly from setting only the numerator derivative to zero. A depth of represents an empty beaker, which corresponds to the final state rather than the intermediate minimum height described in the problem.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly expressed the composite center-of-mass equation in terms of the individual components' masses and centers of gravity.
You correctly placed the empty beaker's center of mass at its midpoint .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou differentiated only the numerator of a rational function to find its minimum, treating the denominator as if it were a constant.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisWhen optimizing a rational function where the denominator varies with , setting is mathematically invalid because changes in simultaneously alter both the numerator and the denominator. In this physical problem, adding or evaporating liquid changes both the total first moment and the total mass. The stationary point occurs precisely when the center of mass coincides with the liquid surface ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Physical Surface Criterion
For a container with evaporating or draining liquid, the center of mass reaches its minimum height exactly when it lies on the liquid's free surface: .
Set and solve the resulting quadratic equation instead of taking an unneeded derivative.
- Quotient Rule Optimization
If differentiating directly, .
Always account for the rate of change of the denominator when finding extrema of rational functions.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationApply the condition for minimum center-of-mass height: the center of mass must lie at the liquid surface, so .
Substitute , giving .
Equate to : .
Rearrange to standard form: .
Solve for positive : .
, with
03 The student omits the beaker mass in the denominator when calculating the system center of mass, dividing only by the total water mass.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You included the mass moment of the beaker () and the water column () in the numerator, but the denominator of the center-of-mass definition must be the total instantaneous mass of the entire system, . By dividing only by the constant initial water mass , you omitted the beaker's mass from the total and treated the water mass as non-varying.
- Step 2Correct
Because your expression for was a simple upward parabola due to the constant denominator, differentiation led to the erroneous result that the minimum occurs when the beaker is completely dry (). With the variable denominator, the stationary point occurs where the center of mass meets the water surface.
- Step 3Correct
Substituting into your parabolic equation gave , which propagated from the incorrect mass formulation in Step 1.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly located the center of mass of the uniform empty beaker at its midpoint ().
You correctly represented the height of the water column's center of mass as half its depth ().
You correctly applied calculus to locate the extremum of your formulated function.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou substituted the constant initial mass into the denominator rather than expressing the denominator as a function of the remaining water depth .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisMisunderstanding the definition of center of mass for a variable-composition system: in , the denominator represents the instantaneous total mass of all system components present at that moment, which varies as water evaporates.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Instantaneous Total Mass Check
For any multi-body system where contents change, must include every component present at that specific state.
Always write out before performing algebraic division or differentiation.
- Physical Equilibrium Intuition
At the minimum height of the center of mass, the system's center of mass must lie exactly on the liquid's free surface: .
Use as a rapid solvability shortcut instead of carrying out the quotient rule on .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the total instantaneous mass of the system as a function of remaining depth : (since the linear water density is , or with , ).
Form the true center-of-mass function: .
Set at the minimum: .
Solve for the positive root: .
Lock it in
Where is the center of mass of a uniform vertical fluid column of depth located relative to the bottom?
. A uniform object has its center of mass at its geometric centroid, not at its free surface.
Similar question
A uniform open cylindrical can of mass and height has a thin base of negligible mass. It is filled with liquid of mass up to height . Write the expression for the center of mass height in terms of and .
Answer
. Key steps: The can's center of mass is at , liquid mass is with center of mass at . Substitute into .
A cylindrical container of mass and height holds a liquid whose total full mass is . Find the depth at which the overall center of mass is lowest.
Answer
. Key steps: Set . The positive root is .
A cylindrical cup has mass and height . When completely full, the liquid inside has mass (twice the cup's mass). Find the depth where the combined center of mass reaches its minimum height.
Answer
. Key steps: Liquid mass at depth is at height . Total center of mass is . Set . Solving gives .