Resources

A student sets up an illuminated miniature bulb at an object distance do=18.0 cmd_o = 18.0\text{ cm} in front of a thin converging lens (f=+12.0 cmf = +12.0\text{ cm}), forming a sharp, real, inverted image on a screen positioned at di=+36.0 cmd_i = +36.0\text{ cm}. The student then covers exactly the top half of the converging lens with an opaque black cardboard mask, hypothesizing that the upper half of the image on the screen will completely vanish. (a) Using the principles of geometric ray tracing and wave fronts, explain why the student's hypothesis is incorrect and describe the actual visual changes observed on the screen. (b) If the original illuminated image had an irradiance (brightness) of I0=80.0 W/m2I_0 = 80.0\text{ W/m}^2, calculate the new irradiance II on the screen assuming uniform lens illumination.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) The hypothesis is incorrect because every unobstructed point across the bottom half of the lens still refracts rays originating from every part of the object to their corresponding conjugate image points; the complete image remains intact in size, position, and orientation, but its brightness decreases; (b) I=40.0 W/m2I = 40.0\text{ W/m}^2.

Steps

Part (a): Explaining Why the Full Image Remains Visible

  1. Rays from Every Point of the Object Fill the Entire Lens

    • An illuminated point on an object emits light in all forward directions as expanding spherical wave fronts.
    • A converging lens collects the portion of light that intercepts its surface and refracts it toward a single conjugate point on the screen.
    • This means every point on the lens receives rays from every point of the object (both top, middle, and bottom).
  2. Effect of Covering Half the Lens

    • When an opaque mask covers the upper half of the lens, it blocks half of the total light rays leaving each point on the object.
    • However, the unobstructed lower half of the lens still collects light rays originating from all parts of the object. These remaining rays refract according to Snell's law and still converge at their exact conjugate image positions on the screen.
    • Consequently, the complete image remains visible: its geometry (size, position, and inverted orientation) is completely unchanged.
  3. Observed Changes on the Screen

    • Because fewer rays reach the screen, the image does not disappear partially; rather, it becomes dimmer (its brightness/irradiance decreases).
    • Common Pitfall: Students often confuse the standard three "principal rays" used in simple ray diagrams with the only rays that exist. While the parallel ray passing through the upper half of the lens is physically blocked, infinitely many non-principal rays still pass through the lower half to form the complete image.

Part (b): Calculating the New Irradiance

  1. Relationship Between Lens Area and Transmitted Power

    • The optical power PP captured by the lens and directed to the image plane is directly proportional to the effective clear aperture area AA of the lens exposed to uniform illumination: P∝AP \propto A
  2. Irradiance Calculation

    • Irradiance II is the optical power per unit area of the image on the screen (I=PAimageI = \frac{P}{A_{\text{image}}}).
    • Since the dimensions and magnification of the image remain identical, the area of the image AimageA_{\text{image}} is unchanged.
    • Covering exactly half of the lens reduces the effective aperture area by a factor of 22: Anew=12A0A_{\text{new}} = \frac{1}{2} A_0
    • Therefore, the transmitted light power and resulting irradiance are halved: I=12I0=12⋅80.0 W/m2=40.0 W/m2I = \frac{1}{2} I_0 = \frac{1}{2} \cdot 80.0\text{ W/m}^2 = 40.0\text{ W/m}^2

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student incorrectly believes that covering the top half of the lens blocks light originating from the bottom of the object due to ray inversion, leading them to conclude that the bottom half of the image disappears.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Because the real image formed by a converging lens is inverted, rays cross the optical axis. Blocking the top half of the lens blocks the rays forming the bottom of the inverted image.

    Correct

    Light from every point on the object spreads out into a cone that covers the entire lens surface. Blocking the top half blocks some rays, but the unblocked bottom half still intercepts rays from every point on the object and focuses them to their conjugate points.

    You treated the lens as having a direct geometric point-to-point correspondence with halves of the image. While rays cross the optical axis, an infinite number of rays from each object point pass through the lower half of the lens and converge to form the entire image.

  2. Step 2

    The bottom half of the image vanishes, while the top half remains visible at the same brightness.

    Correct

    The entire image remains intact on the screen (no part disappears), but the overall image becomes dimmer.

    Because your underlying premise in Step 1 was incorrect, you concluded that the bottom half disappears. Since all parts of the image still receive converging rays, the complete image remains visible.

  3. Step 3

    The remaining visible half of the image retains the original brightness. ⟹ I=80.0 W/m2I = 80.0\text{ W/m}^2

    Correct

    I=12I0=12(80.0 W/m2)=40.0 W/m2I = \frac{1}{2}I_0 = \frac{1}{2}(80.0\text{ W/m}^2) = 40.0\text{ W/m}^2

    Because the unblocked half of the lens captures half of the total light power while focusing it over the same full image area, the new irradiance is halved to 40.0 W/m240.0\text{ W/m}^2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that a real image produced by a converging lens is inverted relative to the object.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Aperture-Image Spatial Mapping Fallacy

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the path of a single principal ray crossing the optical axis with the entire cone of light rays emitted by an object point, leading to the misconception that each half of the lens forms a corresponding half of the image.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Every Lens Segment Forms the Full Image
  • Every illuminated object point emits light across the entire lens aperture, and every unobstructed patch of the lens refracts those rays to form the complete image.

  • When a portion of a lens is covered, keep the image geometry, size, and position identical, and only adjust the image brightness.

Irradiance Scales with Clear Aperture Area
  • Transmitted optical power is directly proportional to the unobstructed lens area: P∝AlensP \propto A_{\text{lens}}, while the image area AimageA_{\text{image}} remains unchanged.

  • Calculate the new irradiance using Inew=AopenAtotalI0I_{\text{new}} = \frac{A_{\text{open}}}{A_{\text{total}}} I_0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that every point on the object sends a diverging cone of light across the entire lens surface.

  2. Observe that covering the top half blocks half the rays, but the remaining lower half still refracts rays from every point of the object into their respective image points, keeping the whole image visible.

  3. Calculate the new irradiance by scaling with the unobstructed area fraction: I=AopenAtotalI0=12(80.0 W/m2)=40.0 W/m2I = \frac{A_{\text{open}}}{A_{\text{total}}} I_0 = \frac{1}{2}(80.0\text{ W/m}^2) = 40.0\text{ W/m}^2.

Final answer

(a) The hypothesis is incorrect because every point on the object sends light through the entire lens; the unobstructed bottom half still converges light from all points of the object, so the entire image remains intact with reduced brightness. (b) I=40.0 W/m2I = 40.0\text{ W/m}^2.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch ray cones from both the tip and base of an arrow through both the top and bottom halves of a lens to see how each half independently forms the entire image.

  • Practice calculating irradiance changes when lenses are masked with circular stops or annular rings.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student correctly recognizes that the full image remains but misapplies the inverse-square law to the lens aperture radius, erroneously squaring the linear dimension factor to calculate irradiance.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Every point on the object sends light through all parts of the lens.   ⟹  \implies Light passing through the bottom half still forms the complete image.   ⟹  \implies The entire image remains visible on the screen, but it appears dimmer.

  2. Step 2

    Intensity is proportional to the square of the transmission factor.   ⟹  I=I0×(12)2  ⟹  I=80.0 W/m2×14=20.0 W/m2\implies I = I_0 \times \left(\frac{1}{2}\right)^2 \implies I = 80.0\text{ W/m}^2 \times \frac{1}{4} = 20.0\text{ W/m}^2

    Correct

    P∝Alens  ⟹  I=AnewA0I0=12I0=12(80.0 W/m2)=40.0 W/m2P \propto A_{\text{lens}} \implies I = \frac{A_{\text{new}}}{A_0} I_0 = \frac{1}{2} I_0 = \frac{1}{2}(80.0\text{ W/m}^2) = 40.0\text{ W/m}^2

    The factor of 12\frac{1}{2} represents the fraction of the total lens surface area that remains uncovered, not a linear field amplitude or radius. Optical power collected by the lens is directly proportional to the clear aperture area, so the transmitted power and image irradiance scale linearly with area (I∝AI \propto A), not with area squared.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly reasoned that every point on an object emits rays through the entire lens aperture.

You accurately identified that the bottom half of the lens still focuses light from all parts of the object to form a complete, dimmer image.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Linear vs. Area Scaling Misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You mistakenly applied a quadratic relationship (squaring the transmission factor 12\frac{1}{2}) to an area reduction. While intensity is proportional to the square of wave amplitude or aperture radius, it is directly linear with respect to the open aperture area and transmitted power.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Power and Aperture Area
  • Total optical power intercepted and focused by a lens is directly proportional to the clear surface area: P∝AlensP \propto A_{\text{lens}}.

  • Check whether a given fraction refers to a linear dimension (such as radius or diameter) or an area. If half the lens area is covered, exactly half the total optical power passes through.

Irradiance on the Screen
  • Image irradiance is I=PimageAimageI = \frac{P_{\text{image}}}{A_{\text{image}}}. Because the image size and magnification do not change, irradiance scales directly with transmitted power (I∝PI \propto P).

  • Multiply the initial irradiance by the area transmission fraction directly: I=fareaI0I = f_{\text{area}} I_0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express the optical power collected by the lens in terms of its open area: P=Iincident⋅AlensP = I_{\text{incident}} \cdot A_{\text{lens}}.

  2. Determine the new open area: covering the top half gives Anew=12A0A_{\text{new}} = \frac{1}{2} A_0.

  3. Relate image irradiance to collected power: since the image dimensions are unchanged, I∝P∝AI \propto P \propto A.

  4. Calculate the new irradiance: I=12I0=12(80.0 W/m2)=40.0 W/m2I = \frac{1}{2} I_0 = \frac{1}{2} (80.0\text{ W/m}^2) = 40.0\text{ W/m}^2.

Final answer

(a) The full image remains visible and intact because rays from all parts of the object still pass through the uncovered bottom half of the lens; only its brightness decreases. (b) I=40.0 W/m2I = 40.0\text{ W/m}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always distinguish whether an aperture mask reduces an area directly (linear scaling of power) or reduces a diameter/radius (quadratic scaling of power).

  • Review how optical irradiance relates to captured radiant flux versus wave amplitude.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A converging lens forms a real image of a candle flame on a white screen with an irradiance of 60.0 W/m260.0\text{ W/m}^2. If an opaque circular disk covering the central 36%36\% of the lens area is placed over the lens, describe the image formed and calculate the new irradiance on the screen.

Answer

The full flame image remains visible and sharp at the same location. The unobstructed area fraction is 1−0.36=0.641 - 0.36 = 0.64, so the new irradiance is I=0.64×60.0 W/m2=38.4 W/m2I = 0.64 \times 60.0\text{ W/m}^2 = 38.4\text{ W/m}^2.

02

An illuminated object is imaged onto a screen using a thin lens of diameter D=4.0 cmD = 4.0\text{ cm}. An iris diaphragm in front of the lens is stopped down, reducing the open diameter to d=2.0 cmd = 2.0\text{ cm}. If the original image had an irradiance of 120 W/m2120\text{ W/m}^2, determine the factor by which the irradiance decreases and find the new irradiance.

Answer

The aperture area scales with the square of the diameter: Anew/Aold=(d/D)2=(2.0/4.0)2=1/4A_{\text{new}} / A_{\text{old}} = (d/D)^2 = (2.0/4.0)^2 = 1/4. Irradiance decreases by a factor of 44, yielding I=120 W/m2/4=30.0 W/m2I = 120\text{ W/m}^2 / 4 = 30.0\text{ W/m}^2.

03

A projector lens projects a sharp image of a slide onto a wall. A tiny fly lands on the outer surface of the projection lens, covering about 2%2\% of the lens area. Explain what the audience sees on the projection screen: does a silhouette of the fly appear?

Answer

No silhouette appears. The fly is far outside the focal plane and only blocks about 2%2\% of the light rays from each point on the slide; the audience sees the entire slide image completely intact, with a negligible 2%2\% reduction in overall brightness.

Loading workspace…