Resources

Two isolated blocks made of the same metal, block A with mass mA=0.400 kgm_A = 0.400\text{ kg} and block B with mass mB=1.20 kgm_B = 1.20\text{ kg}, are brought into thermal contact inside an insulated calorimeter. Initially, block A is at TA=380 KT_A = 380\text{ K} and block B is at TB=260 KT_B = 260\text{ K}. Heat transfers between them until thermal equilibrium is established. Rather than finding the equilibrium temperature directly, determine the ratio of the magnitude of the change in internal energy of block A to that of block B, ∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣\frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|}, and calculate the ratio of their resulting temperature changes, ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣=1.00\frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|} = 1.00 and ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=3.00\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = 3.00.

Steps

01

Apply Conservation of Energy to the Isolated System

The two blocks are placed inside an insulated calorimeter, meaning no heat enters or leaves the system from the outside surroundings, and no mechanical work is done (W=0W = 0). By the first law of thermodynamics:

ΔU=Q−W=Q\Delta U = Q - W = Q

Since the total system (Block A + Block B) is isolated, the net change in internal energy is zero:

ΔUA+ΔUB=0  ⟹  ΔUA=−ΔUB\Delta U_A + \Delta U_B = 0 \implies \Delta U_A = -\Delta U_B

Taking the magnitude of both sides:

∣ΔUA∣=∣ΔUB∣|\Delta U_A| = |\Delta U_B|

Therefore, the ratio of the magnitude of their internal energy changes is:

∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣=1.00\frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|} = 1.00

Key Distinction: Heat (QQ) is the thermal energy transferred between systems due to a temperature difference, while internal energy (UU) is the total energy stored within a substance. All the energy lost by block A is transferred as heat and absorbed by block B as internal energy.


02

Relate Internal Energy Change to Temperature Change

For an incompressible solid undergoing a temperature change without a phase transition, the change in internal energy is related to temperature change by:

∣ΔU∣=mc∣ΔT∣|\Delta U| = m c |\Delta T|

where:

  • mm is the mass of the block,
  • cc is the specific heat capacity of the metal,
  • ∣ΔT∣|\Delta T| is the magnitude of the temperature change.

Since both blocks are composed of the identical metal, they share the same specific heat capacity cc.


03

Calculate the Ratio of Temperature Changes

Substitute the expressions for ∣ΔUA∣|\Delta U_A| and ∣ΔUB∣|\Delta U_B| into the equality ∣ΔUA∣=∣ΔUB∣|\Delta U_A| = |\Delta U_B|:

mAc∣ΔTA∣=mBc∣ΔTB∣m_A c |\Delta T_A| = m_B c |\Delta T_B|

Dividing both sides by cc:

mA∣ΔTA∣=mB∣ΔTB∣m_A |\Delta T_A| = m_B |\Delta T_B|

Rearranging to solve for the ratio ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|}:

∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=mBmA\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{m_B}{m_A}

Substitute the given mass values (mA=0.400 kgm_A = 0.400\text{ kg} and mB=1.20 kgm_B = 1.20\text{ kg}):

∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=1.20 kg0.400 kg=3.00\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{1.20\text{ kg}}{0.400\text{ kg}} = 3.00

A common pitfall is assuming that equal heat exchange implies equal temperature changes; the smaller mass experiences a proportionally larger temperature change because it has lower thermal mass (mcm c).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes that the ratio of changes in internal energy is directly proportional to the masses of the blocks rather than being equal from conservation of energy.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ΔU=m⋅c⋅ΔT\Delta U = m \cdot c \cdot \Delta T

  2. Step 2

    ∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣=mAmB  ⟹  ∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣=0.4001.20=13\frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|} = \frac{m_A}{m_B} \implies \frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|} = \frac{0.400}{1.20} = \frac{1}{3}

    Correct

    ΔUA+ΔUB=0  ⟹  ∣ΔUA∣=∣ΔUB∣  ⟹  ∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣=1.00\Delta U_A + \Delta U_B = 0 \implies |\Delta U_A| = |\Delta U_B| \implies \frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|} = 1.00

    Because the calorimeter is insulated, the system of two blocks is isolated and energy is conserved. All heat lost by block A is gained by block B (∣QA∣=∣QB∣|Q_A| = |Q_B|), so the magnitudes of their internal energy changes must be identical.

  3. Step 3

    ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=mBmA  ⟹  ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=1.200.400=3\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{m_B}{m_A} \implies \frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{1.20}{0.400} = 3

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly stated the relationship between internal energy change and temperature change: ΔU=mcΔT\Delta U = m c \Delta T.

You correctly related the temperature changes inversely to the masses of the two blocks.

You calculated the correct ratio for the temperature changes as 33.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Violating energy conservation in an isolated thermal exchange

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the ratio of internal energy changes as being directly proportional to mass, overlooking the first law of thermodynamics for an isolated system, which requires ∣ΔUA∣=∣ΔUB∣|\Delta U_A| = |\Delta U_B|.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Conservation of Energy in an Isolated System
  • For an insulated calorimeter with no external heat transfer or work, the total energy change is zero: ΔUA+ΔUB=0\Delta U_A + \Delta U_B = 0.

  • Always set the heat lost by the warmer object equal to the heat gained by the cooler object, which means ∣ΔUA∣=∣ΔUB∣|\Delta U_A| = |\Delta U_B|.

Distinguishing Total Energy from Change in Energy
  • While the total internal energy of a substance depends on its mass (U∝mU \propto m), the change in internal energy during an isolated transfer depends entirely on the energy transferred as heat (∣ΔU∣=∣Q∣|\Delta U| = |Q|).

  • Do not assume ∣ΔU∣∝m|\Delta U| \propto m unless the temperature changes are explicitly held equal.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply conservation of energy to the isolated system: ΔUtotal=ΔUA+ΔUB=0\Delta U_{\text{total}} = \Delta U_A + \Delta U_B = 0.

  2. Rearrange to relate the magnitudes: ∣ΔUA∣=∣ΔUB∣|\Delta U_A| = |\Delta U_B|.

  3. Compute the ratio: ∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣=∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUA∣=1.00\frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|} = \frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_A|} = 1.00.

Final answer

∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣=1.00\frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|} = 1.00 and ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=3.00\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = 3.00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of an isolated thermodynamic system and how the first law requires ΔUsys=0\Delta U_{\text{sys}} = 0.

  • Practice identifying when heat exchange enforces equal energy transfer (∣Qlost∣=∣Qgained∣|Q_{\text{lost}}| = |Q_{\text{gained}}|) regardless of block masses.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the ratio of temperature changes by setting it directly proportional to the masses instead of inversely proportional.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    QA+QB=0  ⟹  ∣ΔUA∣=∣ΔUB∣  ⟹  ∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣=1Q_A + Q_B = 0 \implies |\Delta U_A| = |\Delta U_B| \implies \frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|} = 1

  2. Step 2

    ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=mAmB\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{m_A}{m_B}

    Correct

    mAc∣ΔTA∣=mBc∣ΔTB∣  ⟹  ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=mBmAm_A c |\Delta T_A| = m_B c |\Delta T_B| \implies \frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{m_B}{m_A}

    Because ∣Q∣=mc∣ΔT∣|Q| = m c |\Delta T|, equal heat exchange means mA∣ΔTA∣=mB∣ΔTB∣m_A |\Delta T_A| = m_B |\Delta T_B|. Solving for the ratio gives ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=mBmA\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{m_B}{m_A}, showing that temperature change is inversely proportional to mass.

  3. Step 3

    ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=0.4001.20=13\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{0.400}{1.20} = \frac{1}{3}

    Correct

    ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=1.20 kg0.400 kg=3.00\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{1.20\text{ kg}}{0.400\text{ kg}} = 3.00

    You substituted the masses accurately into your formula, but the result is inverted due to the rearranged ratio in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used conservation of energy to find that the magnitudes of the internal energy changes are equal.

You correctly concluded that the ratio ∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣\frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|} equals 11.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted proportional relationship

You set ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=mAmB\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{m_A}{m_B} instead of cross-multiplying from mA∣ΔTA∣=mB∣ΔTB∣m_A |\Delta T_A| = m_B |\Delta T_B|.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing direct proportionality with inverse proportionality when rearranging a product of variables equal to a constant (m∣ΔT∣=constantm |\Delta T| = \text{constant}). For a fixed heat exchange, a smaller mass undergoes a larger temperature change.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Physical Reality Check
  • For a given amount of heat absorbed or released, objects with smaller thermal mass (mcm c) experience larger temperature swings.

  • Check whether your ratio makes physical sense: block A has one-third the mass of block B, so block A must undergo 33 times the temperature change, not 13\frac{1}{3}.

Cross-Multiplication Check
  • If x1y1=x2y2x_1 y_1 = x_2 y_2, then y1y2=x2x1\frac{y_1}{y_2} = \frac{x_2}{x_1}.

  • Write out the product equation mAc∣ΔTA∣=mBc∣ΔTB∣m_A c |\Delta T_A| = m_B c |\Delta T_B| fully before isolating the ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Since both blocks are made of the same metal, they have the same specific heat capacity cc.

  2. Equate the magnitudes of heat transfer: mAc∣ΔTA∣=mBc∣ΔTB∣m_A c |\Delta T_A| = m_B c |\Delta T_B|.

  3. Divide both sides by cc: mA∣ΔTA∣=mB∣ΔTB∣m_A |\Delta T_A| = m_B |\Delta T_B|.

  4. Rearrange to form the ratio: ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=mBmA\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{m_B}{m_A}.

  5. Substitute the given masses: ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=1.20 kg0.400 kg=3.00\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{1.20\text{ kg}}{0.400\text{ kg}} = 3.00.

Final answer

∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣=1.00\frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|} = 1.00 and ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=3.00\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = 3.00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the product equality m1ΔT1=m2ΔT2m_1 \Delta T_1 = m_2 \Delta T_2 explicitly before dividing to avoid accidental inversion.

  • Perform a quick intuition check: the lighter object should always have the larger temperature change when equal heat is exchanged.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses the ratio of the initial temperatures instead of applying thermal physics principles to find the ratio of temperature changes.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ∣ΔUA∣=∣ΔUB∣  ⟹  ∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣=1|\Delta U_A| = |\Delta U_B| \implies \frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|} = 1

  2. Step 2

    ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=TATB\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{T_A}{T_B}

    Correct

    mAc∣ΔTA∣=mBc∣ΔTB∣  ⟹  ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=mBmAm_A c |\Delta T_A| = m_B c |\Delta T_B| \implies \frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{m_B}{m_A}

    You assumed that the ratio of temperature changes equals the ratio of the initial temperatures. Instead, temperature change relates to internal energy change via ∣ΔU∣=mc∣ΔT∣|\Delta U| = m c |\Delta T|, which means the temperature changes are inversely proportional to the masses.

  3. Step 3

    ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=380260=1913\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{380}{260} = \frac{19}{13}

    Correct

    ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=1.20 kg0.400 kg=3.00\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{1.20\text{ kg}}{0.400\text{ kg}} = 3.00

    Because the relationship in the previous step was incorrect, substituting the initial temperatures produced an incorrect numerical ratio.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used conservation of energy to determine that the two blocks exchange equal magnitudes of internal energy.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ratio of temperature changes equated to initial temperatures

You substituted the ratio of initial temperatures TATB\frac{T_A}{T_B} in place of the ratio of temperature changes ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing an absolute state variable (temperature TT) with a process change variable (temperature change ΔT\Delta T), while neglecting the role of mass and heat capacity in determining how much temperature changes for a given transfer of heat.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
State vs. Change
  • Initial temperature TT describes a thermal state, while temperature change ΔT=Tf−Ti\Delta T = T_f - T_i describes a process.

  • Never replace a ratio of changes ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} with the ratio of initial temperatures TATB\frac{T_A}{T_B}.

Thermal Mass Relation
  • For substances with identical specific heat capacities exchanging heat, ∣Q∣=mc∣ΔT∣|Q| = m c |\Delta T|. Equal heat exchange implies mA∣ΔTA∣=mB∣ΔTB∣m_A |\Delta T_A| = m_B |\Delta T_B|.

  • Set the temperature change ratio inversely proportional to the mass ratio: ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=mBmA\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{m_B}{m_A}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the thermal energy change formula for each block: ∣ΔUA∣=mAc∣ΔTA∣|\Delta U_A| = m_A c |\Delta T_A| and ∣ΔUB∣=mBc∣ΔTB∣|\Delta U_B| = m_B c |\Delta T_B|.

  2. Equate the two energy changes using ∣ΔUA∣=∣ΔUB∣|\Delta U_A| = |\Delta U_B|: mAc∣ΔTA∣=mBc∣ΔTB∣m_A c |\Delta T_A| = m_B c |\Delta T_B|.

  3. Divide by cc and rearrange to solve for the ratio: ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=mBmA=1.20 kg0.400 kg=3.00\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = \frac{m_B}{m_A} = \frac{1.20\text{ kg}}{0.400\text{ kg}} = 3.00.

Final answer

∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣=1.00\frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|} = 1.00 and ∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=3.00\frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = 3.00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between absolute temperature TT and temperature change ΔT\Delta T.

  • Practice setting up energy conservation equations in the form m1c1∣ΔT1∣=m2c2∣ΔT2∣m_1 c_1 |\Delta T_1| = m_2 c_2 |\Delta T_2| before substituting numbers.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 0.200 kg0.200\text{ kg} copper block at 350 K350\text{ K} is placed into an insulated container with a 0.800 kg0.800\text{ kg} copper block at 290 K290\text{ K}. Find the ratio of the magnitude of their heat transfers, ∣Qhot∣∣Qcold∣\frac{|Q_{\text{hot}}|}{|Q_{\text{cold}}|}, and the ratio of their temperature changes, ∣ΔThot∣∣ΔTcold∣\frac{|\Delta T_{\text{hot}}|}{|\Delta T_{\text{cold}}|}.

Answer

By energy conservation in an isolated system, ∣Qhot∣=∣Qcold∣|Q_{\text{hot}}| = |Q_{\text{cold}}|, so ∣Qhot∣∣Qcold∣=1.00\frac{|Q_{\text{hot}}|}{|Q_{\text{cold}}|} = 1.00. Since Q=mcΔTQ = m c \Delta T and both blocks are copper, mhot∣ΔThot∣=mcold∣ΔTcold∣m_{\text{hot}} |\Delta T_{\text{hot}}| = m_{\text{cold}} |\Delta T_{\text{cold}}|, giving ∣ΔThot∣∣ΔTcold∣=mcoldmhot=0.8000.200=4.00\frac{|\Delta T_{\text{hot}}|}{|\Delta T_{\text{cold}}|} = \frac{m_{\text{cold}}}{m_{\text{hot}}} = \frac{0.800}{0.200} = 4.00.

02

Block X (mX=0.500 kgm_X = 0.500\text{ kg}, cX=400 J/(kg⋅K)c_X = 400\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}) and Block Y (mY=0.250 kgm_Y = 0.250\text{ kg}, cY=800 J/(kg⋅K)c_Y = 800\text{ J/(kg}\cdot\text{K)}) are brought into thermal contact in an insulated calorimeter. Determine the ratio ∣ΔUX∣∣ΔUY∣\frac{|\Delta U_X|}{|\Delta U_Y|} and the ratio ∣ΔTX∣∣ΔTY∣\frac{|\Delta T_X|}{|\Delta T_Y|}.

Answer

Because the system is isolated, energy conservation gives ∣ΔUX∣=∣ΔUY∣|\Delta U_X| = |\Delta U_Y|, so ∣ΔUX∣∣ΔUY∣=1.00\frac{|\Delta U_X|}{|\Delta U_Y|} = 1.00. Equating energy changes: mXcX∣ΔTX∣=mYcY∣ΔTY∣m_X c_X |\Delta T_X| = m_Y c_Y |\Delta T_Y|. Compute heat capacities: CX=0.500×400=200 J/KC_X = 0.500 \times 400 = 200\text{ J/K} and CY=0.250×800=200 J/KC_Y = 0.250 \times 800 = 200\text{ J/K}. Since CX=CYC_X = C_Y, the temperature change ratio is ∣ΔTX∣∣ΔTY∣=CYCX=1.00\frac{|\Delta T_X|}{|\Delta T_Y|} = \frac{C_Y}{C_X} = 1.00.

03

A 0.100 kg0.100\text{ kg} aluminum cube at 400 K400\text{ K} and an unknown mass mBm_B of aluminum at 300 K300\text{ K} reach thermal equilibrium inside an insulated vessel. If the temperature change of the cube is four times that of block B (∣ΔTA∣/∣ΔTB∣=4.00|\Delta T_A| / |\Delta T_B| = 4.00), determine ∣ΔUA∣/∣ΔUB∣|\Delta U_A| / |\Delta U_B| and the mass mBm_B.

Answer

Conservation of energy dictates that the energy lost by A equals the energy gained by B, so ∣ΔUA∣∣ΔUB∣=1.00\frac{|\Delta U_A|}{|\Delta U_B|} = 1.00. From mAc∣ΔTA∣=mBc∣ΔTB∣m_A c |\Delta T_A| = m_B c |\Delta T_B|, we have mBmA=∣ΔTA∣∣ΔTB∣=4.00\frac{m_B}{m_A} = \frac{|\Delta T_A|}{|\Delta T_B|} = 4.00. Thus, mB=4.00×mA=4.00×0.100 kg=0.400 kgm_B = 4.00 \times m_A = 4.00 \times 0.100\text{ kg} = 0.400\text{ kg}.

Loading workspace…