Resources

Consider the polynomial P(n)=n2+n+41P(n) = n^2 + n + 41, which generates prime numbers for n=0,1,2,…n = 0, 1, 2, \dots. A student conjectures: 'For every non-negative integer nn, P(n)P(n) is a prime number.' Determine the smallest positive integer threshold n=ncritn = n_{\text{crit}} at which this conjecture fails, and evaluate the prime factorization of P(ncrit)P(n_{\text{crit}}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

ncrit=40n_{\text{crit}} = 40, with P(40)=402+40+41=40(41)+41=412=1681P(40) = 40^2 + 40 + 41 = 40(41) + 41 = 41^2 = 1681.

Steps

01

Factor by grouping

To test the conjecture that P(n)=n2+n+41P(n) = n^2 + n + 41 is prime for every non-negative integer nn, we look for the smallest integer n≥0n \ge 0 that makes P(n)P(n) composite.

Rewrite the polynomial by factoring nn out of the first two terms: P(n)=n(n+1)+41P(n) = n(n + 1) + 41

For P(n)P(n) to be a composite number divisible by 4141, the first term n(n+1)n(n + 1) must also be divisible by 4141.

02

Find the smallest value of nn

Because 4141 is a prime number, 4141 divides the product n(n+1)n(n + 1) if and only if 4141 divides nn or 4141 divides (n+1)(n + 1):

  • If 41∣(n+1)41 \mid (n + 1), the smallest non-negative integer is n+1=41n + 1 = 41, which gives n=40n = 40.
  • If 41∣n41 \mid n, the smallest positive integer is n=41n = 41 (while n=0n = 0 gives P(0)=41P(0) = 41, which is prime).

Thus, the smallest non-negative candidate for which P(n)P(n) is a multiple of 4141 greater than 4141 is n=40n = 40.

03

Evaluate and factor P(40)P(40)

Substitute n=40n = 40 into the polynomial: P(40)=40(40+1)+41=40(41)+41P(40) = 40(40 + 1) + 41 = 40(41) + 41

Factor out the common factor of 4141: P(40)=41⋅(40+1)=41⋅41=412=1681P(40) = 41 \cdot (40 + 1) = 41 \cdot 41 = 41^2 = 1681

Since P(40)=412P(40) = 41^2, it has three distinct positive divisors (1,41,16811, 41, 1681) and is therefore composite. For all integers 0≤n≤390 \le n \le 39, P(n)P(n) produces prime numbers (known as Euler's lucky numbers).

Hence, the smallest threshold is ncrit=40n_{\text{crit}} = 40, with P(40)=402+40+41=40(41)+41=412=1681P(40) = 40^2 + 40 + 41 = 40(41) + 41 = 41^2 = 1681.

Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is jumping directly to n=41n = 41, observing that 412+41+41=41(43)41^2 + 41 + 41 = 41(43) is composite. While correct that P(41)P(41) is composite, this misses the smaller counterexample n=40n = 40, where n+1=41n + 1 = 41 already introduces the factor of 4141.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student focuses solely on setting n equal to the constant term 41 to factor out 41, overlooking the smaller threshold at n = 40 where 40² + 40 = 40(41).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Set \text{Set } n = 41  to factor out \text{ to factor out } 41   ⟹  \implies P(41) = 41^2 + 41 + 41 = 41(41 + 1 + 1) = 41 ×\times 43   ⟹  \implies n_{crit\text{crit}} = 41_

    Correct

    P(n) = n(n + 1) + 41   ⟹  \implies 41 ∣\mid n(n + 1)   ⟹  \implies n + 1 = 41   ⟹  \implies n_{crit\text{crit}} = 40_

    You correctly showed that P(41)P(41) is composite, but setting n=41n = 41 does not yield the smallest positive integer. Factoring P(n)P(n) as n(n+1)+41n(n+1) + 41 shows that P(n)P(n) is also divisible by 4141 when n+1=41n+1 = 41, which gives the smaller threshold n=40n = 40.

  2. Step 2

    P(41) = 41 ×\times 43   ⟹  \implies 41  and \text{ and } 43  are prime\text{ are prime}   ⟹  \implies Prime factorization of \text{Prime factorization of } P(n_{crit\text{crit}}) = 41 ×\times 43_

    Correct

    P(40) = 40(41) + 41 = 41(40 + 1) = 41^2

    This step correctly factors the value of P(41)P(41), but it is marked affected because it relies on the incorrect threshold ncrit=41n_{\text{crit}} = 41 from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly realized that making every term divisible by 4141 produces a composite number.

You accurately factored P(41)P(41) into the prime factors 41×4341 \times 43.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Premature direct substitution without factoring

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You substituted n=41n = 41 directly into the polynomial rather than grouping the variable terms as n(n+1)n(n+1), which would reveal that the product n(n+1)n(n+1) is divisible by 4141 as early as n+1=41n+1 = 41 (or n=40n = 40).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Group variable terms before testing divisibility
  • To find when n2+n+cn^2 + n + c shares a factor with cc, write it in grouped form: n(n+1)+cn(n + 1) + c.

  • Check both factors: test whether cc divides nn or cc divides (n+1)(n + 1) to find the minimum integer.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Rewrite the polynomial by grouping: P(n)=n(n+1)+41P(n) = n(n + 1) + 41.

  2. Set the smaller factor n+1n + 1 equal to 4141, which gives n=40n = 40.

  3. Evaluate P(40)=40(41)+41=41(40+1)=412P(40) = 40(41) + 41 = 41(40 + 1) = 41^2.

  4. Confirm 41241^2 is composite and 4141 is prime, so the prime factorization is 41241^2.

Final answer

ncrit=40n_{\text{crit}} = 40, with prime factorization P(40)=412P(40) = 41^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write quadratics of the form n2+n+cn^2 + n + c as n(n+1)+cn(n + 1) + c when seeking common factors with cc.

  • Check both branch conditions: n=cn = c and n+1=cn + 1 = c, choosing the smaller positive integer.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student correctly identifies n_crit = 40 and calculates P(40) = 1681, but mistakenly concludes that 1681 is prime because it has no small prime factors.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    P(40)=402+40+41=41×41  ⟹  ncrit=40P(40) = 40^2 + 40 + 41 = 41 \times 41 \implies n_{\text{crit}} = 40

  2. Step 2

    P(40)=1681  ⟹  1681 is not divisible by 2,3,5, or 7  ⟹  Prime factorization of P(ncrit)=1681P(40) = 1681 \implies 1681 \text{ is not divisible by } 2, 3, 5, \text{ or } 7 \implies \text{Prime factorization of } P(n_{\text{crit}}) = 1681

    Correct

    Prime factorization of P(40)=412\text{Prime factorization of } P(40) = 41^2

    Testing divisibility only up to 77 is insufficient to declare a four-digit number prime (one must check primes up to 1681=41\sqrt{1681} = 41). More directly, your earlier line already proved that 1681=41×411681 = 41 \times 41, so the prime factorization is 41241^2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the critical threshold value ncrit=40n_{\text{crit}} = 40.

You correctly observed that evaluating P(40)P(40) yields 41×41=168141 \times 41 = 1681.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incomplete Primality Test / Overlooking Known Factors

You stopped testing prime divisors at 77 and declared 16811681 prime, contradicting your earlier algebraic factorization 41×4141 \times 41.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated primality testing as checking only the first few small primes (2,3,5,72, 3, 5, 7) rather than checking primes up to ⌊N⌋=41\lfloor\sqrt{N}\rfloor = 41, and you disconnected your numerical calculation (16811681) from the algebraic structure (41×4141 \times 41) you had already derived.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Use existing algebraic factors
  • If an expression is factored algebraically as a×ba \times b, use those factors directly instead of expanding and trial-dividing from scratch.

  • Since P(40)=40(41)+41=41(41)P(40) = 40(41) + 41 = 41(41), keep 41241^2 as the factored form rather than expanding to 16811681 and searching for new factors.

Trial division stopping bound
  • To prove an integer NN is prime by trial division, you must check all prime numbers up to N\sqrt{N}.

  • For N=1681N = 1681, 1681=41\sqrt{1681} = 41, so you must test primes up to 4141 before declaring NN prime.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Rewrite P(40)P(40) using the common factor: P(40)=40(41)+41=41(40+1)=41×41=412P(40) = 40(41) + 41 = 41(40 + 1) = 41 \times 41 = 41^2.

  2. Because 4141 is prime, 41241^2 is already the complete prime factorization of P(40)P(40).

Final answer

ncrit=40n_{\text{crit}} = 40, with prime factorization P(ncrit)=412P(n_{\text{crit}}) = 41^2 (or 41×4141 \times 41)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Trust your algebraic grouping: when a polynomial factors into prime components like 41×4141 \times 41, write the prime factorization as 41241^2 immediately without expanding.

  • Remember that a number NN is only confirmed prime by trial division after testing all primes p≤Np \le \sqrt{N}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Consider the polynomial Q(n)=n2+n+11Q(n) = n^2 + n + 11. Find the smallest positive integer nn for which Q(n)Q(n) is composite, and write down its prime factorization.

Answer

Rewrite as Q(n)=n(n+1)+11Q(n) = n(n + 1) + 11. For 1111 to divide n(n+1)n(n + 1), set n+1=11n + 1 = 11, so n=10n = 10. Then Q(10)=10(11)+11=11(10+1)=112Q(10) = 10(11) + 11 = 11(10 + 1) = 11^2. The smallest threshold is n=10n = 10, with prime factorization 11211^2.

02

Consider the polynomial R(n)=n2−n+41R(n) = n^2 - n + 41 for integers n≥1n \ge 1. Find the smallest integer n>1n > 1 such that R(n)R(n) is composite, and evaluate R(n)R(n) in factored form.

Answer

Rewrite as R(n)=n(n−1)+41R(n) = n(n - 1) + 41. To make R(n)R(n) a multiple of 4141, set either n=41n = 41 or n−1=41  ⟹  n=42n - 1 = 41 \implies n = 42. The smaller integer strictly greater than 11 is n=41n = 41. Then R(41)=41(40)+41=41(41)=412R(41) = 41(40) + 41 = 41(41) = 41^2.

03

Let f(n)=n2+3n+5f(n) = n^2 + 3n + 5. Find the smallest non-negative integer nn for which f(n)f(n) is not prime. Show your decomposition steps.

Answer

Factor by grouping: f(n)=n(n+3)+5f(n) = n(n + 3) + 5. To have 5∣n(n+3)5 \mid n(n + 3), either 5∣n5 \mid n or 5∣(n+3)5 \mid (n + 3). For n≥0n \ge 0:

  • n+3=5  ⟹  n=2n + 3 = 5 \implies n = 2, yielding f(2)=2(5)+5=15=3×5f(2) = 2(5) + 5 = 15 = 3 \times 5 (composite).
  • n=0n = 0 gives f(0)=5f(0) = 5 (prime). Thus, the smallest non-negative integer is n=2n = 2, yielding f(2)=15=3×5f(2) = 15 = 3 \times 5.
Loading workspace…