Resources
A small unmanned delivery drone flies round-trip between two distribution hubs positioned apart along a straight east-west flight path. On the outbound journey heading east, the drone encounters a constant tailwind and completes the trip in (). On the return trip heading west against the exact same headwind, the flight requires (). Coupling the kinematic distance formula with the superposition of velocity vectors, set up a system of linear equations in terms of the drone's airspeed in still air and the wind speed , and solve for both speeds in .
Answer and steps
Final answer
Let represent the drone's still-air speed in and represent the wind speed in . The system of equations is: , which simplifies to . The solution is and .
Steps
Identify the variables and relationship
Let:
- be the airspeed of the drone in still air (in ).
- be the constant wind speed (in ).
When an aircraft travels with a tailwind (in the same direction as the wind), the wind boosts its speed over the ground, giving an effective ground speed of:
When traveling against a headwind (opposing the wind), the wind reduces its effective ground speed to:
Using the distance formula :
-
Outbound Trip (East, with tailwind):
- Distance:
- Time:
- Equation:
-
Return Trip (West, against headwind):
- Distance:
- Time:
- Equation:
Simplify the linear system
Simplify each equation to express effective speeds directly:
- Multiply both sides of the outbound equation by :
- Simplify the return equation:
This gives the system of linear equations:
Solve the system
Add the two equations together using the elimination method to eliminate :
Now, substitute into the first simplified equation to solve for :
Common Pitfall: Always ensure time units match the speed units ( when finding speed in ). Using minutes directly (such as instead of ) leads to incorrect dimensions and values.
Typical errors
01 The student uses time in minutes directly instead of converting to hours, yielding ground speeds in miles per minute rather than mph.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
(v_a + v_w) 40 = 72 v_a + v_w = = 1.8
Correct(v_a + v_w) = 72 v_a + v_w = 108
You correctly recognized that a tailwind adds to the drone's speed, but you plugged in instead of converting to hours (). Because the desired speed unit is (miles per hour), the time must be in hours.
- Step 2
(v_a - v_w) 60 = 72 v_a - v_w = = 1.2
Correct1.0(v_a - v_w) = 72 v_a - v_w = 72
You correctly modeled the headwind subtracting from the drone's speed, but you used instead of .
- Step 3
2v_a = 3.0 v_a = 1.5
Correct2v_a = 180 v_a = 90
Your elimination technique of adding the two equations was executed correctly, but the values were affected by using minutes in earlier steps.
- Step 4
v_w = 0.3
Correctv_w = 108 - 90 = 18
You substituted accurately to find , but the resulting value is in miles per minute () rather than .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used for travel with a tailwind and for travel against a headwind.
You applied the elimination method accurately to solve your linear system.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou substituted elapsed time directly in minutes instead of converting to hours to match miles per hour.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking the unit compatibility requirement between speed (miles per hour) and time (minutes), which led to rates expressed in miles per minute.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check Rate-Time Units
In , the unit of time must match the denominator time unit of speed.
Before setting up rate equations, convert all times in minutes into hours by dividing by whenever speed is requested in .
- Sanity Check Real-World Speeds
Compare final numerical values against everyday intuition.
A delivery drone flying at would take to fly ; noticing that it flew in under an hour flags that the speed must be much greater than .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConvert the outbound time to hours: .
Set up the outbound equation: .
Convert the return time to hours: .
Set up the return equation: .
Add the two equations: .
Substitute into the first equation: .
v_a = 90, v_w = 18
02 The student reverses the signs of the wind assistance, treating the tailwind as opposing motion and the headwind as aiding motion.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
v_a - v_w = 72 / (2/3) = 108 v_a + v_w = 72 / 1 = 72
Correct\lbrace v_a + v_w = 72 / (2/3) = 108, v_a - v_w = 72 / 1 = 72
A tailwind pushes in the direction of motion, increasing ground speed to . A headwind opposes motion, decreasing ground speed to . You reversed these signs, assigning the subtraction to the tailwind and the addition to the headwind.
- Step 2
2v_a = 180 v_a = 90
Correct2v_a = 180 v_a = 90
You correctly added the two equations in your system to eliminate , which happened to give the correct still-air speed of because the sum of the ground speeds remains the same regardless of which equation has which sign.
- Step 3
v_w = -18
Correct90 + v_w = 108 v_w = 18
You substituted correctly into your setup, but because the signs were reversed, you obtained a negative speed of instead of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou converted into correctly.
You accurately computed the two ground speeds as and .
You used the elimination method correctly to solve for the drone's still-air speed.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou associated the faster trip with subtraction () and the slower trip with addition ().
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the physical effects of tailwinds and headwinds on ground speed. A tailwind assists motion and adds speed (), whereas a headwind resists motion and subtracts speed ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Ground Speed Sanity Check
Tailwind increases ground speed (); headwind decreases ground speed ().
Ensure the larger calculated speed is paired with and the smaller calculated speed is paired with .
- Physical Reality Check
Magnitude of wind speed must be a non-negative scalar ().
If your solution yields a negative speed such as , check immediately whether you swapped opposing and assisting signs in your initial setup.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the outbound equation with tailwind assistance: .
Set up the return equation against headwind resistance: .
Add the equations: .
Substitute into the outbound equation: .
The airspeed in still air is and the wind speed is .
03 The student multiplies by time instead of dividing to find effective velocity, setting va ± vw = d · t.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
v_a + v_w = 72 = 48 v_a - v_w = 72 1 = 72
Correct(v_a + v_w) = 72 v_a + v_w = 108 1.0(v_a - v_w) = 72 v_a - v_w = 72
From the kinematic relation , ground speed is given by , not . For the outbound trip, the effective speed is , not .
- Step 2
2v_a = 120 v_a = 60 v_w = -12
Correct2v_a = 180 v_a = 90 v_w = 18
Your elimination technique was algebraically consistent with your system of equations (), but the resulting values inherited the setup error from Step 1.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly set up the relative velocity expressions as with a tailwind and against a headwind.
You correctly applied the elimination method to solve your linear system by adding the two equations together.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeMultiplying distance by time instead of dividing distance by time to calculate velocity.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou inverted the relationship between speed, distance, and time. Because , isolating velocity requires dividing distance by time (). Notice also that traveling faster with a tailwind must yield a speed greater than traveling against a headwind, whereas was smaller than , and speed cannot be negative.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Dimensional and Unit Check
Speed has units of distance per unit time (miles per hour), so .
Always verify units: . Multiply only when solving for distance, and divide distance by time when solving for rate.
- Physical Sense Check
Tailwind ground speed must be strictly greater than headwind ground speed ().
Compare the two effective speed values before solving: since the outbound trip took less time, its speed must be larger than the return trip's speed.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet effective ground speed equal to : and .
Add the two linear equations: , which gives .
Divide by to obtain the still-air airspeed: .
Substitute into : , so .
v_a = 90, v_w = 18
Lock it in
When speed is measured in miles per hour (), what unit must time be in when using ?
Hours. If given in minutes, convert by dividing by : .
Similar question
A commuter train travels in . What is its average speed in ?
Answer
. Convert time: . Then .
A motorboat travels downstream with the current in and makes the return trip upstream against the current in . Find the boat's speed in still water and the current's speed in .
Answer
. Convert times to hours: , . The system is , and . Adding gives , so .
An airplane flies from City A to City B with a tailwind in . The return flight against the same wind takes . Determine the airplane's airspeed in still air and the wind speed in .
Answer
. Convert time: . The system is , and . Adding gives , and .