Resources
Consider the linear equation , where is a real constant. Find the unique value of that makes the equation an identity with infinitely many solutions, and state what type of solution set results if .
Answer and steps
Final answer
The equation has infinitely many solutions when (or ). If , the equation has no solution.
Steps
Simplify both sides of the equation
Begin by expanding and combining like terms on each side of the given equation:
- Left-Hand Side (LHS): Apply the distributive property:
- Right-Hand Side (RHS): Apply the distributive property and combine like terms:
Now, equate the two simplified expressions:
Analyze the conditions for the solution set
Subtract from both sides to collect the variable terms:
Notice that the coefficients of on both sides are identical (), so the variable cancels out completely (). The equation now depends entirely on the constant terms:
-
Infinitely Many Solutions (Identity): An equation of the form has infinitely many solutions if and only if , producing the always-true statement .
Balancing the constant terms gives:
When , both sides become identically , which is true for all real values of .
- No Solution (Contradiction): If , the constant terms on the left and right sides are not equal. Subtracting yields a statement of the form: Because this is a contradiction (a false statement for any value of ), the equation has no solution.
Summary of Pitfalls
- Pitfall: Assuming that variable cancellation always means "no solution." When the variable drops out, always check the constants: if the resulting statement is true (), there are infinitely many solutions; if it is false (), there is no solution.
Typical errors
01 The student forgets to distribute the factor 5 to the constant term k, writing 5(2x - k) as 10x - k.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
10x - k + 14 = 12x + 3 - 2x 10x - k + 14 = 10x + 3
Correct10x - 5k + 14 = 12x + 3 - 2x 10x - 5k + 14 = 10x + 3
When expanding , the factor must multiply every term inside the parentheses. Distributing gives , but you only multiplied the first term, writing .
- Step 2
-k + 14 = 3 -k = -11 k = 11
Correct-5k + 14 = 3 -5k = -11 k = 2.2
Your algebraic isolation of followed logically from your previous expression, but the result was altered by the earlier distribution error.
- Step 3
k \neq 11$$\text{, the constant terms are unequal while the } x $\text{ coefficients are equal, so there is no solution.}$$
Correct.2 x
Your conceptual reasoning is completely sound: when the coefficients of match on both sides but the constants differ, the equation reduces to a contradiction ( with ), yielding no solution. Only the benchmark value of was affected by the earlier arithmetic error.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou expanded the right-hand side into completely and accurately.
You correctly recognized that an identity occurs when the constant terms on both sides are equal after the variable terms cancel.
You clearly explained why unequal constant terms lead to no solution when the variable coefficients are identical.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou forgot to distribute the factor to the second term inside the parentheses, writing as instead of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking the multiplier on terms containing parameters or variables other than during distributive expansion.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Full Distributive Coverage
Every single term inside parentheses must be multiplied by the outside factor: .
Draw distribution arcs from the outside factor to each internal term before multiplying, especially when a parameter like is involved.
- Equation Classification Test
For an equation : if and , it is an identity (infinitely many solutions); if and , it is a contradiction (no solution).
Equate the fully simplified constant terms to solve for the parameter directly.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDistribute across both terms in :
Equate the simplified left and right sides:
Subtract from both sides to equate the constants:
Conclude the solution classification: if , the equation is an identity with infinitely many solutions; if , the constants differ, so there is no solution.
The equation has infinitely many solutions when (or if balancing signs as stated in source conventions). If does not equal this value, the equation has no solution.
02 The student makes a sign error when subtracting 14 from 3, obtaining 11 instead of -11.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
When subtracting from both sides, , not . This sign error produced and gave instead of .
- Step 3
When , the coefficients of match but the constants differ, so there is no solution.
CorrectWhen , the -coefficients match () while the constant terms differ (), yielding the contradiction with , so there is no solution.
Your conceptual rule is entirely correct—matching variable coefficients with different constants yield no solution—but the condition is affected by the incorrect value of from Step 2.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou expanded both sides using the distributive property accurately.
You combined like terms on the right-hand side correctly to get .
You correctly understood that an identity requires the constant terms on both sides to be equal once the variable terms cancel.
You correctly stated that differing constants with matching variable coefficients result in no solution.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou evaluated as instead of when isolating .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou subtracted the smaller number from the larger number () without preserving the negative sign required by .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Subtracting a Larger Positive Number
For any real numbers where , .
Write out the subtraction explicitly as before solving for the variable.
- Verify by Substitution
For an identity, substituting the value of back into the simplified constant expression must match the other side.
Check : . Check : , confirming .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet the constant terms equal so both sides are identical: .
Subtract from both sides: .
Divide both sides by : .
Conclude that the equation is an identity with infinitely many solutions when , and has no solution when .
Infinitely many solutions when (or ); no solution when .
Lock it in
What is the result of fully expanding using the distributive property?
. Remember that the factor outside must multiply every individual term inside the parentheses, including terms containing parameters or negative signs.
Similar question
Solve for the constant such that has infinitely many solutions.
Answer
. Expanding both sides gives . Subtracting yields .
Determine the value of for which the equation is an identity. What is the solution set if ?
Answer
; no solution. Simplifying the LHS gives . Equating constants gives . If , the coefficients match but the constants differ, so there is no solution.
For what values of and does the equation have (a) infinitely many solutions, and (b) no solution?
Answer
(a) and ; (b) and . Expanding gives . Matching -coefficients requires . For an identity, constants must match: . For no solution, -coefficients must match while constants differ: and .