Resources

A continuous dataset of 120120 commute times is organized into five successive 1010-minute intervals spanning from 1010 to 6060 minutes: [10,20)[10, 20) with frequency 1515, [20,30)[20, 30) with frequency 2828, [30,40)[30, 40) with unknown frequency f3f_3, [40,50)[40, 50) with frequency 2525, and [50,60)[50, 60) with frequency 1414. Using the standard linear interpolation formula for grouped cumulative frequency distributions, the median (50th50\text{th} percentile) of the commute times was determined to be exactly 34.534.5 minutes. Reverse-engineer the grouped data to find the exact frequency f3f_3 of the modal class [30,40)[30, 40), and verify that the total sample size remains N=120N = 120.](streamdown:incomplete-link)

Answer and steps

Final answer

f3=38f_3 = 38

Steps

01

Identify the Known Quantities and Class Boundaries

The data is grouped into five continuous intervals with frequencies:

  • [10,20)[10, 20): f1=15f_1 = 15
  • [20,30)[20, 30): f2=28f_2 = 28
  • [30,40)[30, 40): f3f_3 (unknown frequency)
  • [40,50)[40, 50): f4=25f_4 = 25
  • [50,60)[50, 60): f5=14f_5 = 14

The total number of observations is N=120N = 120.

Summing the known frequencies gives: ∑i≠3fi=15+28+25+14=82\sum_{i \neq 3} f_i = 15 + 28 + 25 + 14 = 82

---](streamdown:incomplete-link)

02

Determine f3f_3 from the Total Sample Size

Since the total sample size must equal N=120N = 120: N=82+f3=120N = 82 + f_3 = 120

Solving directly for f3f_3: f3=120−82=38f_3 = 120 - 82 = 38

With f3=38f_3 = 38, the frequency of [30,40)[30, 40) is greater than all other class frequencies (38>28>25>15>1438 > 28 > 25 > 15 > 14), confirming that [30,40)[30, 40) is indeed the modal class.

---](streamdown:incomplete-link)

03

Verify with the Median Interpolation Formula

The median position for grouped continuous data of size N=120N = 120 is: Position=N2=1202=60\text{Position} = \frac{N}{2} = \frac{120}{2} = 60

  1. Cumulative frequency prior to the median class: CF=f1+f2=15+28=43CF = f_1 + f_2 = 15 + 28 = 43
  2. Median class parameters: Since CF=43<60CF = 43 < 60 and 43+38=81≥6043 + 38 = 81 \ge 60, the median lies in the interval [30,40)[30, 40):

    • Lower class boundary, L=30L = 30
    • Class width, w=40−30=10w = 40 - 30 = 10
    • Frequency of the median class, f3=38f_3 = 38
  3. Applying the linear interpolation formula: Median=L+(N2−CFf3)⋅w\text{Median} = L + \left( \frac{\frac{N}{2} - CF}{f_3} \right) \cdot w Median=30+(60−4338)⋅10=30+17038≈30+4.47=34.47 minutes\text{Median} = 30 + \left( \frac{60 - 43}{38} \right) \cdot 10 = 30 + \frac{170}{38} \approx 30 + 4.47 = 34.47\text{ minutes}

Rounded to one decimal place, this is 34.5 minutes34.5\text{ minutes}. Conversely, setting the interpolated median to 34.534.5 yields f3=1704.5≈37.78f_3 = \frac{170}{4.5} \approx 37.78, which rounds to the exact integer count of f3=38f_3 = 38, perfectly matching the total sample size N=120N = 120.](streamdown:incomplete-link)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats the sample size as an unknown function of f3 rather than using the given total N = 120 in the median rank position, leading to an incorrect algebraic formulation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    CF before [30,40)=15+28=43CF \text{ before } [30, 40) = 15 + 28 = 43](streamdown:incomplete-link)

  2. Step 2

    Total N=15+28+f3+25+14=82+f3  ⟹  Median rank=82+f32=41+0.5⋅f3\text{Total } N = 15 + 28 + f_3 + 25 + 14 = 82 + f_3 \implies \text{Median rank} = \frac{82 + f_3}{2} = 41 + 0.5 \cdot f_3

    Correct

    Median rank=N2=1202=60\text{Median rank} = \frac{N}{2} = \frac{120}{2} = 60

    You treated the sample size NN as an unknown expression 82+f382 + f_3. Because the problem explicitly specifies a fixed total of N=120N = 120 commute times, the median position is simply 1202=60\frac{120}{2} = 60. (Directly setting 82+f3=12082 + f_3 = 120 gives f3=38f_3 = 38.)

  3. Step 3

    30+(41+0.5⋅f3−43f3)⋅10=34.5  ⟹  4.5=(0.5⋅f3−2f3)⋅10  ⟹  4.5⋅f3=5⋅f3−20  ⟹  0.5⋅f3=2030 + \left(\frac{41 + 0.5 \cdot f_3 - 43}{f_3}\right) \cdot 10 = 34.5 \implies 4.5 = \left(\frac{0.5 \cdot f_3 - 2}{f_3}\right) \cdot 10 \implies 4.5 \cdot f_3 = 5 \cdot f_3 - 20 \implies 0.5 \cdot f_3 = 20

    Correct

    30+(60−43f3)⋅10=34.5  ⟹  4.5=170f3  ⟹  f3=1704.5≈37.8  ⟹  f3=3830 + \left(\frac{60 - 43}{f_3}\right) \cdot 10 = 34.5 \implies 4.5 = \frac{170}{f_3} \implies f_3 = \frac{170}{4.5} \approx 37.8 \implies f_3 = 38

    Your algebraic manipulation of the interpolation formula was executed correctly, but it used the incorrect rank expression from the previous step.

  4. Step 4

    f3=40f_3 = 40

    Correct

    f3=38f_3 = 38

    Because of the variable rank substitution in Step 2, your final frequency is 4040, which would make the total sample size 122122 instead of the given 120120.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the cumulative frequency CF=43CF = 43 for the classes preceding the median interval.

You correctly recalled the linear interpolation formula for grouped median, including the lower boundary L=30L = 30 and class width w=10w = 10.

You solved the resulting linear fractional equation with sound algebraic steps.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Variable Sample Size Misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked the fixed total sample size N=120N = 120 provided in the problem statement and substituted a variable sum N=82+f3N = 82 + f_3 into the median rank formula N2\frac{N}{2}. When the total population or sample size is given upfront, the rank N2\frac{N}{2} is a fixed constant, not a function of the unknown class frequency.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Fixed vs. Unknown Constraints
  • If the total sample size NN is stated in the problem (N=120N = 120), use NN as a known constant for rank calculations, and use ∑fi=N\sum f_i = N as an immediate constraint.

  • Check whether the total sample size NN is already provided before expressing it in terms of unknown frequencies.

Verify Sample Size Consistency
  • Any solved frequency fkf_k must satisfy ∑fi=N\sum f_i = N.

  • After solving for an unknown frequency, sum all frequencies to confirm they match the given total NN.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use the given total sample size N=120N = 120 to find the median rank: Rank=N2=1202=60\text{Rank} = \frac{N}{2} = \frac{120}{2} = 60.

  2. Substitute Rank=60\text{Rank} = 60, L=30L = 30, CF=43CF = 43, and w=10w = 10 into the interpolation formula: 34.5=30+(60−43f3)⋅1034.5 = 30 + \left(\frac{60 - 43}{f_3}\right) \cdot 10.

  3. Simplify: 4.5=170f3  ⟹  f3=1704.5≈37.78≈384.5 = \frac{170}{f_3} \implies f_3 = \frac{170}{4.5} \approx 37.78 \approx 38.

  4. Alternatively, solve directly from the total frequency sum: 15+28+f3+25+14=120  ⟹  82+f3=120  ⟹  f3=3815 + 28 + f_3 + 25 + 14 = 120 \implies 82 + f_3 = 120 \implies f_3 = 38.

Final answer

f3=38f_3 = 38

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always scan the problem statement for the total sample size NN before creating variable expressions for rank positions.

  • When an unknown frequency appears, write the total frequency equation ∑fi=N\sum f_i = N first to see if it immediately determines the unknown.

  • Use the median formula as an independent check to verify that your solved frequency yields the stated percentile.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student subtracts only the frequency of the immediately preceding class (28) instead of the cumulative frequency of all preceding classes (43).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Median position=1202=60\text{Median position} = \frac{120}{2} = 60

  2. Step 2

    Preceding frequency F=28\text{Preceding frequency } F = 28

    Correct

    CF=f1+f2=15+28=43CF = f_1 + f_2 = 15 + 28 = 43

    In the grouped median formula, CFCF represents the total cumulative frequency of all classes below the median class boundary (15+28=4315 + 28 = 43), rather than just the frequency of the immediately preceding class (2828).

  3. Step 3

    Median=30+(60−28f3)⋅10  ⟹  34.5=30+320f3  ⟹  4.5=320f3  ⟹  f3=3204.5=71.11\text{Median} = 30 + \left(\frac{60 - 28}{f_3}\right) \cdot 10 \implies 34.5 = 30 + \frac{320}{f_3} \implies 4.5 = \frac{320}{f_3} \implies f_3 = \frac{320}{4.5} = 71.11

    Correct

    34.5=30+(60−43f3)⋅10  ⟹  4.5=170f3  ⟹  f3=1704.5≈3834.5 = 30 + \left(\frac{60 - 43}{f_3}\right) \cdot 10 \implies 4.5 = \frac{170}{f_3} \implies f_3 = \frac{170}{4.5} \approx 38

    Your algebraic solving steps were logically executed, but they yielded an incorrect frequency because of the mistaken cumulative frequency value.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the median rank as N2=60\frac{N}{2} = 60.

You correctly identified the lower boundary L=30L = 30 and class width w=10w = 10 for the median class [30,40)[30, 40).](streamdown:incomplete-link)

You applied sound algebraic techniques to isolate the unknown frequency f3f_3.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Cumulative vs. Single Class Frequency Confusion

You substituted the frequency of only the preceding interval (f2=28f_2 = 28) into the cumulative frequency term.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the cumulative frequency prior to the median class (CF=∑i<mfiCF = \sum_{i < m} f_i) with the simple frequency of the immediately adjacent class (fm−1f_{m-1}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Cumulative Frequency Definition
  • In grouped percentile interpolation, the subtracted quantity CFCF must account for all observations accumulated before the lower boundary of the target class.

  • Sum every frequency from the very first interval up to the target interval before substituting into the formula.

Total Sample Size Sanity Check
  • The sum of all class frequencies must equal the given total sample size NN.

  • Check whether your calculated frequency satisfies ∑fi=N\sum f_i = N. Here, 15+28+71.11+25+14=153.11≠12015 + 28 + 71.11 + 25 + 14 = 153.11 \neq 120, which immediately signals an error.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the true cumulative frequency before class [30,40)[30, 40): CF=15+28=43CF = 15 + 28 = 43.](streamdown:incomplete-link)

  2. Substitute CF=43CF = 43 into the linear interpolation formula: 34.5=30+(60−43f3)⋅1034.5 = 30 + \left(\frac{60 - 43}{f_3}\right) \cdot 10.

  3. Simplify the equation: 4.5=170f34.5 = \frac{170}{f_3}.

  4. Solve for f3f_3: f3=1704.5=37.7‾≈38f_3 = \frac{170}{4.5} = 37.\overline{7} \approx 38.

  5. Verify the total sample count: 15+28+38+25+14=12015 + 28 + 38 + 25 + 14 = 120.

Final answer

f3=38f_3 = 38

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always build a running cumulative frequency column next to your frequency table before writing the interpolation formula.

  • Perform a quick total count check whenever a problem states the exact total sample size NN.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student applies an unnecessary continuity correction by using a lower boundary of 29.5 instead of the given continuous interval boundary of 30.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Median rank=1202=60  ⟹  Cumulative frequency before median class=15+28=43\text{Median rank} = \frac{120}{2} = 60 \implies \text{Cumulative frequency before median class} = 15 + 28 = 43

  2. Step 2

    Lower boundary L=29.5\text{Lower boundary } L = 29.5

    Correct

    Lower boundary L=30\text{Lower boundary } L = 30

    The classes are given as continuous half-open intervals [20,30)[20, 30) and [30,40)[30, 40) with no gaps between them, so the exact lower class boundary is 3030, not 29.529.5.](streamdown:incomplete-link)

  3. Step 3

    34.5=29.5+(60−43f3)⋅10  ⟹  5=(17f3)⋅10  ⟹  5⋅f3=170  ⟹  f3=3434.5 = 29.5 + \left(\frac{60 - 43}{f_3}\right) \cdot 10 \implies 5 = \left(\frac{17}{f_3}\right) \cdot 10 \implies 5 \cdot f_3 = 170 \implies f_3 = 34

    Correct

    34.5=30+(60−43f3)⋅10  ⟹  4.5=170f3  ⟹  f3=1704.5≈37.78  ⟹  f3=3834.5 = 30 + \left(\frac{60 - 43}{f_3}\right) \cdot 10 \implies 4.5 = \frac{170}{f_3} \implies f_3 = \frac{170}{4.5} \approx 37.78 \implies f_3 = 38 (or f3=120−82=38f_3 = 120 - 82 = 38)

    Because you used L=29.5L = 29.5, your equation gave f3=34f_3 = 34. Using the correct boundary L=30L = 30 yields f3≈37.78f_3 \approx 37.78, which rounds to 3838 and satisfies the total sample size constraint N=120N = 120.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the median rank N2=60\frac{N}{2} = 60.

You correctly summed the frequencies of the classes preceding the median class to get CF=43CF = 43.

You correctly set up and solved the linear interpolation algebraic structure.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Continuity correction error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You subtracted 0.50.5 from the lower limit to create a continuity correction, confusing discrete class limits (such as 30–3930\text{--}39) with continuous class intervals [30,40)[30, 40) that already share exact boundaries.](streamdown:incomplete-link)

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Continuous Intervals vs. Discrete Limits
  • When intervals are expressed as [a,b)[a, b) or continuous ranges, the boundaries touch (bb is both the upper boundary of one class and the lower boundary of the next). Do not subtract or add 0.50.5.](streamdown:incomplete-link)

  • Check whether the data has gaps between classes. If the classes are [20,30)[20, 30) and [30,40)[30, 40), use L=30L = 30 directly.](streamdown:incomplete-link)

Total Frequency Sanity Check
  • The sum of all class frequencies must equal the total sample size NN.

  • Always verify your calculated frequency: 15+28+34+25+14=116≠12015 + 28 + 34 + 25 + 14 = 116 \neq 120, which immediately alerts you that f3=34f_3 = 34 cannot be correct.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use the true lower boundary L=30L = 30 for the continuous interval [30,40)[30, 40).](streamdown:incomplete-link)

  2. Substitute L=30L = 30, N2=60\frac{N}{2} = 60, CF=43CF = 43, and width w=10w = 10 into the interpolation formula: 34.5=30+(60−43f3)⋅1034.5 = 30 + \left(\frac{60 - 43}{f_3}\right) \cdot 10.

  3. Subtract 3030 from both sides: 4.5=170f34.5 = \frac{170}{f_3}, so f3=1704.5≈37.78f_3 = \frac{170}{4.5} \approx 37.78.

  4. Check against the integer constraint from the total sample size: f3=120−(15+28+25+14)=120−82=38f_3 = 120 - (15 + 28 + 25 + 14) = 120 - 82 = 38.

Final answer

f3=38f_3 = 38

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between discrete grouped data limits (e.g., 30–3930\text{--}39) and continuous interval boundaries (e.g., [30,40)[30, 40)).](streamdown:incomplete-link)

  • Whenever a problem gives the total sample size NN, use the frequency sum as a direct check on any reverse-interpolated frequency.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A continuous dataset of 100100 scores is grouped into intervals: [0,10)[0, 10) with frequency 1212, [10,20)[10, 20) with frequency 2222, [20,30)[20, 30) with frequency f3f_3, [30,40)[30, 40) with frequency 2020, and [40,50)[40, 50) with frequency 1616. Find f3f_3 and determine the median position N2\frac{N}{2}.](streamdown:incomplete-link)

Answer

Median rank=1002=50\text{Median rank} = \frac{100}{2} = 50. Sum of known frequencies =12+22+20+16=70= 12 + 22 + 20 + 16 = 70. Thus, f3=100−70=30f_3 = 100 - 70 = 30.

02

In a grouped distribution of 8080 call durations with intervals of width 55, the median is 17.517.5 minutes. The median class is [15,20)[15, 20) with preceding cumulative frequency CF=26CF = 26. Using linear interpolation, find the frequency ff of the median class.](streamdown:incomplete-link)

Answer

Using Median=L+(N2−CFf)⋅w\text{Median} = L + \left(\frac{\frac{N}{2} - CF}{f}\right) \cdot w: 17.5=15+(40−26f)⋅5  ⟹  2.5=70f  ⟹  f=702.5=2817.5 = 15 + \left(\frac{40 - 26}{f}\right) \cdot 5 \implies 2.5 = \frac{70}{f} \implies f = \frac{70}{2.5} = 28.

03

A continuous distribution with unknown total NN has four intervals: [0,10)[0, 10) with frequency 1010, [10,20)[10, 20) with frequency f2f_2, [20,30)[20, 30) with frequency 1818, and [30,40)[30, 40) with frequency 1212. The median is given as 18.018.0 minutes. Set up the linear interpolation equation and solve for f2f_2 and the total sample size NN.](streamdown:incomplete-link)

Answer

Here NN is not given, so N=f2+40N = f_2 + 40 and Rank=0.5f2+20\text{Rank} = 0.5f_2 + 20. Preceding CF=10CF = 10, L=10L = 10, w=10w = 10. Then 18=10+(0.5f2+20−10f2)⋅10  ⟹  8=5f2+100f2  ⟹  8f2=5f2+100  ⟹  3f2=100  ⟹  f2≈33.3318 = 10 + \left(\frac{0.5f_2 + 20 - 10}{f_2}\right) \cdot 10 \implies 8 = \frac{5f_2 + 100}{f_2} \implies 8f_2 = 5f_2 + 100 \implies 3f_2 = 100 \implies f_2 \approx 33.33 (or f2=33f_2 = 33 with integer counts, giving N=73N = 73).

Loading workspace…