Resources
A student attempts to evaluate the limit by coupling trigonometric identity substitution with L'Hôpital's Rule: Step 1: Check the indeterminate form: as , and , giving . Step 2: Apply L'Hôpital's Rule by differentiating the numerator and denominator: . Step 3: Apply L'Hôpital's Rule a second time without checking prerequisites: . Step 4: Evaluate the limit: . While the numerical limit in Step 4 is accidentally correct, evaluate whether Step 3 correctly satisfied the prerequisite condition for a second application of L'Hôpital's Rule, and specify what that prerequisite condition is.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Step 3 correctly satisfies the prerequisite condition because and , maintaining an indeterminate form of type ; L'Hôpital's Rule requires that the quotient must form an indeterminate type or before each differentiation.
Steps
State the Prerequisite Condition for L'Hôpital's Rule
Before applying L'Hôpital's Rule to any quotient , two main criteria must be met:
- The functions and must be differentiable on an open interval around (except possibly at itself), with near .
- The limit must produce an indeterminate form, specifically of the type:
This prerequisite must be verified prior to every single application of the rule.
Evaluate the Expression Prior to Step 3
At the end of Step 2, the expression is:
To verify whether a second differentiation is valid, evaluate the limits of the numerator and denominator separately as :
- Numerator:
- Denominator:
Because both the numerator and the denominator approach , the quotient remains an indeterminate form of type .
Conclusion on Step 3
Although the student stated they proceeded "without checking prerequisites," the prerequisite condition itself was objectively satisfied:
- The indeterminate form still holds at .
- Both and are continuously differentiable near , and the derivative of the denominator, , is non-zero near .
Therefore, Step 3 correctly satisfied the mathematical prerequisite for applying L'Hôpital's Rule a second time.
Common Pitfall: Applying L'Hôpital's Rule when a fraction is determinate (e.g., if the denominator approaches a non-zero constant) produces an incorrect result. Always confirm that the quotient is still of the form or before differentiating again.
Typical errors
01 The student conflates failing to explicitly write down the check with the condition itself being mathematically unsatisfied.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Step 3 states that L'Hôpital's Rule was applied without checking prerequisites. Because the check was not performed, the prerequisite condition was not satisfied.
CorrectStep 3 did satisfy the prerequisite condition because and , which forms an indeterminate quotient of type .
A mathematical condition is an objective property of the expressions, not the act of writing down the verification. Even though the step did not show the check, the limit evaluated to , meaning the prerequisite was mathematically satisfied.
- Step 2
The prerequisite condition is verifying that the form is before differentiating.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that L'Hôpital's Rule requires the quotient to be of the indeterminate form .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the procedural act of writing down a verification with whether the mathematical property itself holds true. A condition is satisfied if the mathematical objects possess that property, regardless of whether the solver explicitly checked or wrote it down.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish Property from Procedure
A mathematical prerequisite depends on the objective values of the functions (e.g., whether is indeed ), not on whether the written solution includes an explicit checking step.
To decide whether a condition is satisfied, evaluate the mathematical expressions directly rather than inspecting whether the solver wrote down the verification.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate the numerator at : .
Evaluate the denominator at : .
Observe that the ratio is of indeterminate form , and both functions are differentiable near with .
Step 3 correctly satisfied the prerequisite condition because and , forming the indeterminate type .
02 The student confuses the prerequisite of L'Hôpital's Rule with the quotient rule or expects the derivative to be non-zero before applying the rule.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The prerequisite condition is that the denominator must not equal .
CorrectThe prerequisite condition is that the limit must be of indeterminate form or , with functions differentiable near the limit point.
You confused the condition for ordinary direct substitution with the condition for L'Hôpital's Rule. L'Hôpital's Rule requires both the numerator and denominator to approach (or both approach ); if the denominator were non-zero, the fraction would be determinate and L'Hôpital's Rule would be invalid.
- Step 2
Step 3 did not satisfy the prerequisite condition. Since the denominator , L'Hôpital's Rule cannot be used again.
CorrectStep 3 did satisfy the prerequisite condition because as , and , which yields the indeterminate form .
Because your stated prerequisite was reversed, you incorrectly concluded that Step 3 failed. Since both and , the ratio is still of type , meaning the second application of L'Hôpital's Rule is mathematically valid.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou checked the behavior of the denominator as by evaluating .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated division by zero as a forbidden condition rather than identifying it as the necessary indeterminate form required for L'Hôpital's Rule.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the domain condition for evaluating a rational expression by direct substitution () with the indeterminate condition required to activate L'Hôpital's Rule ( and , or both ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check Indeterminate Form Before Each Application
L'Hôpital's Rule applies to only if direct substitution yields or .
Always test both numerator and denominator limits separately prior to differentiating.
- Recognize Determinate vs. Indeterminate
If the denominator approaches a non-zero number, the quotient is determinate and L'Hôpital's Rule cannot be applied.
If , use direct evaluation or standard algebraic limit laws instead.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCheck the numerator: .
Check the denominator: .
Observe that the quotient remains of the indeterminate form .
Verify that both and are differentiable near with near .
Step 3 correctly satisfied the prerequisite condition because and , which maintains the required indeterminate form of type .
Lock it in
What is the difference between an unjustified mathematical step and an invalid step?
An unjustified step omits the required verification, while an invalid step relies on a prerequisite that is actually false.
Similar question
A student evaluates by directly writing without stating any prerequisites. Did this application of L'Hôpital's Rule satisfy the prerequisite condition? Explain why or why not.
Answer
Yes, the prerequisite condition was satisfied. Evaluating the numerator gives and the denominator gives , which is the required indeterminate form , and both functions are differentiable near .
Consider the limit . A student applies L'Hôpital's Rule and writes . Does this step satisfy the prerequisite conditions for L'Hôpital's Rule? State the correct limit.
Answer
No, the prerequisite condition was not satisfied because and , which is the determinate form , not or . The correct limit by direct substitution is .
A student solves through repeated differentiation: Step 1 gives , Step 2 gives , and Step 3 gives . The student only verified the condition before Step 1. Determine which of Steps 2 and 3 mathematically satisfied the prerequisite conditions for L'Hôpital's Rule.
Answer
Both Step 2 and Step 3 satisfied the prerequisite conditions. Before Step 2, and (yielding ). Before Step 3, and (also yielding ). Both intermediate quotients were valid indeterminate forms.