Resources

A chemistry student prepares 500 mL500\text{ mL} of a 0.280 M0.280\text{ M} hydrochloric acid (HCl\text{HCl}) solution by mixing two stock solutions: Stock Solution A (0.100 M HCl0.100\text{ M } \text{HCl}) and Stock Solution B (0.400 M HCl0.400\text{ M } \text{HCl}). Setting VAV_A and VBV_B as the volumes (in milliliters) of Stock Solutions A and B respectively, the mixture satisfies the total volume equation VA+VB=500V_A + V_B = 500 and the molar conservation equation 0.100VA+0.400VB=0.280×500=1400.100 V_A + 0.400 V_B = 0.280 \times 500 = 140. Use substitution to find the exact volume of each stock solution required.

Answer and steps

Final answer

VA=200 mLV_A = 200\text{ mL}, VB=300 mLV_B = 300\text{ mL}

Steps

01

Write down the system of equations

To find the required volume of each stock solution using the substitution method, follow these steps:

From the problem, we have two equations relating the volumes VAV_A and VBV_B:

  1. Total volume: VA+VB=500V_A + V_B = 500
  2. Total amount of solute (HCl\ce{HCl}): 0.100VA+0.400VB=1400.100 V_A + 0.400 V_B = 140
02

Express one variable in terms of the other

Isolate VAV_A in the total volume equation: VA=500−VBV_A = 500 - V_B

03

Substitute the expression into the second equation

Replace VAV_A with (500−VB)(500 - V_B) in the molar conservation equation: 0.100(500−VB)+0.400VB=1400.100(500 - V_B) + 0.400 V_B = 140

Pitfall to avoid: Remember to distribute 0.1000.100 to both terms inside the parentheses (500500 and −VB-V_B).

04

Solve for VBV_B

Expand and combine like terms: 50−0.100VB+0.400VB=14050 - 0.100 V_B + 0.400 V_B = 140 50+0.300VB=14050 + 0.300 V_B = 140

Subtract 5050 from both sides: 0.300VB=900.300 V_B = 90

Divide by 0.3000.300: VB=900.300=300 mLV_B = \frac{90}{0.300} = 300\text{ mL}

05

Substitute VBV_B back to find VAV_A

Use the equation isolated in Step 2: VA=500−300=200 mLV_A = 500 - 300 = 200\text{ mL}

06

Verify the solution

Check the values in the molar conservation equation: 0.100(200)+0.400(300)=20+120=1400.100(200) + 0.400(300) = 20 + 120 = 140 Both equations are satisfied.

Thus, the required volumes are VA=200 mLV_A = 200\text{ mL} and VB=300 mLV_B = 300\text{ mL}.

Educational illustration for this question

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to distribute the coefficient 0.100 to both terms inside the parentheses during substitution, leading to incorrect volumes.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    VA=500−VB  ⟹  0.100(500−VB)+0.400VB=140V_A = 500 - V_B \implies 0.100(500 - V_B) + 0.400 V_B = 140

  2. Step 2

    500−0.100VB+0.400VB=140  ⟹  500+0.300VB=140500 - 0.100 V_B + 0.400 V_B = 140 \implies 500 + 0.300 V_B = 140

    Correct

    50−0.100VB+0.400VB=140  ⟹  50+0.300VB=14050 - 0.100 V_B + 0.400 V_B = 140 \implies 50 + 0.300 V_B = 140

    You multiplied 0.1000.100 by −VB-V_B but forgot to multiply 0.1000.100 by 500500. The product 0.100×5000.100 \times 500 equals 5050, not 500500.

  3. Step 3

    0.300VB=−360  ⟹  VB=−1200 mL0.300 V_B = -360 \implies V_B = -1200\text{ mL}

    Correct

    0.300VB=90  ⟹  VB=300 mL0.300 V_B = 90 \implies V_B = 300\text{ mL}

    Your subsequent algebraic isolation was executed correctly, but it inherited the distribution error and produced an extraneous negative value.

  4. Step 4

    VA=500−(−1200)=1700 mLV_A = 500 - (-1200) = 1700\text{ mL}

    Correct

    VA=500−300=200 mLV_A = 500 - 300 = 200\text{ mL}

    Substituting the erroneous VBV_B back into the volume relation yielded an incorrect value for VAV_A.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly isolated the variable VAV_A in terms of VBV_B from the total volume equation.

You correctly substituted (500−VB)(500 - V_B) into the molar conservation equation.

You combined like terms and solved the linear equation algebraically using consistent inverse operations.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incomplete Distribution

You copied 500500 directly into the next line instead of computing 0.100×500=500.100 \times 500 = 50.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Failing to apply the distributive property k(a−b)=ka−kbk(a - b) = ka - kb to every term inside the parentheses, specifically leaving the constant term unmultiplied by the outer decimal factor.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Complete Distribution Rule
  • For any expression k(a−b)k(a - b), multiply kk by both terms: k×a−k×bk \times a - k \times b.

  • Draw distribution arcs from the outer multiplier to each term inside the parentheses before writing the expanded line.

Physical Reality Check
  • Component volumes in a physical mixture must satisfy 0<V<Vtotal0 < V < V_{\text{total}}.

  • If you obtain a negative volume or a volume exceeding 500 mL500\text{ mL}, stop and re-check your algebraic expansion.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Distribute 0.1000.100 completely: 0.100(500)−0.100VB+0.400VB=140  ⟹  50+0.300VB=1400.100(500) - 0.100 V_B + 0.400 V_B = 140 \implies 50 + 0.300 V_B = 140.

  2. Subtract 5050 from both sides: 0.300VB=140−50=900.300 V_B = 140 - 50 = 90.

  3. Divide by 0.3000.300: VB=900.300=300 mLV_B = \frac{90}{0.300} = 300\text{ mL}.

  4. Substitute VB=300V_B = 300 back into VA=500−VBV_A = 500 - V_B: VA=500−300=200 mLV_A = 500 - 300 = 200\text{ mL}.

Final answer

VA=200 mLV_A = 200\text{ mL}, VB=300 mLV_B = 300\text{ mL}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice distributing decimal coefficients across two-term binomials.

  • Always review the real-world feasibility of your answers in applied mixture problems.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student swaps the concentration coefficients associated with Stock Solutions A and B when setting up the substitution, misattributing the volumes.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    V_A = 500 - V_B

  2. Step 2

    0.400 V_A + 0.100 V_B = 140   ⟹  \implies 0.400(500 - V_B) + 0.100 V_B = 140

    Correct

    0.100 V_A + 0.400 V_B = 140   ⟹  \implies 0.100(500 - V_B) + 0.400 V_B = 140

    You swapped the concentration coefficients. Stock Solution A has a concentration of 0.100 M0.100\text{ M} and Stock Solution B has a concentration of 0.400 M0.400\text{ M}, so the equation must be 0.100VA+0.400VB=1400.100 V_A + 0.400 V_B = 140.

  3. Step 3

    200 - 0.400 V_B + 0.100 V_B = 140   ⟹  \implies 200 - 0.300 V_B = 140   ⟹  \implies -0.300 V_B = -60   ⟹  \implies V_B = 200 mL\text{ mL}

    Correct

    50 - 0.100 V_B + 0.400 V_B = 140   ⟹  \implies 50 + 0.300 V_B = 140   ⟹  \implies 0.300 V_B = 90   ⟹  \implies V_B = 300 mL\text{ mL}

    Your algebraic solving steps were executed correctly, but the result was affected by the swapped coefficients from Step 2.

  4. Step 4

    V_A = 500 - 200 = 300 mL\text{ mL}

    Correct

    V_A = 500 - 300 = 200 mL\text{ mL}

    You correctly subtracted VBV_B from 500500, but this value is inverted due to the earlier coefficient swap.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed VAV_A in terms of VBV_B using the total volume equation.

You expanded parentheses and combined like terms with accurate arithmetic.

You correctly substituted your solved volume back into the linear relation to find the second volume.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Variable-Coefficient Mismatch

You assigned the 0.400 M0.400\text{ M} concentration to VAV_A and the 0.100 M0.100\text{ M} concentration to VBV_B instead of matching Solution A with 0.100 M0.100\text{ M} and Solution B with 0.400 M0.400\text{ M}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Failing to verify variable-to-parameter alignment when transcribing the system of equations from the word problem, likely caused by writing the second equation from memory rather than checking each labeled quantity.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match Variable Labels to Data
  • Every coefficient must correspond directly to the specific solution represented by its subscript variable.

  • Before substituting, write the named pairs explicitly: Solution A→(0.100,VA)\text{Solution A} \to (0.100, V_A) and Solution B→(0.400,VB)\text{Solution B} \to (0.400, V_B).

Weighted Average Sanity Check
  • The final concentration (0.280 M0.280\text{ M}) is closer to Stock B (0.400 M0.400\text{ M}) than Stock A (0.100 M0.100\text{ M}), so VBV_B must be larger than VAV_A.

  • Compare ∣0.280−0.100∣=0.180|0.280 - 0.100| = 0.180 and ∣0.400−0.280∣=0.120|0.400 - 0.280| = 0.120. Since the mixture is closer to B, VB>VAV_B > V_A must hold.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute VA=500−VBV_A = 500 - V_B: 0.100(500−VB)+0.400VB=1400.100(500 - V_B) + 0.400 V_B = 140

  2. Expand and simplify: 50+0.300VB=14050 + 0.300 V_B = 140

  3. Subtract 5050: 0.300VB=900.300 V_B = 90, so VB=300 mLV_B = 300\text{ mL}

  4. Back-substitute to find VAV_A: VA=500−300=200 mLV_A = 500 - 300 = 200\text{ mL}

Final answer

V_A = 200 mL\text{ mL},   V_B = 300 mL\text{ mL}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that each numerical coefficient matches its designated subscript variable before starting the algebraic substitution.

  • Use a quick concentration reasonableness check (closer to 0.400 M0.400\text{ M} means more of Solution B) to verify your final answers.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student subtracts terms incorrectly across the equals sign by adding 50 to 140 instead of subtracting it, arriving at incorrect solution volumes.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    V_A = 500 - V_B

  2. Step 2

    0.100(500 - V_B) + 0.400 V_B = 140   ⟹  \implies 50 - 0.100 V_B + 0.400 V_B = 140   ⟹  \implies 50 + 0.300 V_B = 140

  3. Step 3

    0.300 V_B = 190   ⟹  \implies V_B = 633.33 mL\text{ mL}

    Correct

    0.300 V_B = 140 - 50 = 90   ⟹  \implies V_B = 900.300\frac{90}{0.300} = 300 mL\text{ mL}

    To move +50+50 across the equals sign, you must subtract 5050 from both sides (140−50=90140 - 50 = 90), not add it (140+50=190140 + 50 = 190).

  4. Step 4

    V_A = 500 - 633.33 = -133.33 mL\text{ mL}

    Correct

    V_A = 500 - 300 = 200 mL\text{ mL}

    This step carried over the incorrect value of VBV_B. Notice also that a negative volume (−133.33 mL-133.33\text{ mL}) is physically impossible in a mixture problem, which is a helpful signal to check your algebra.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly isolated VAV_A from the total volume equation.

You substituted the expression into the conservation equation accurately.

You correctly distributed 0.1000.100 and combined the variable terms.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse Operation Error Across Equals Sign

You added 5050 to 140140 to get 190190 instead of subtracting 5050 to get 9090.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Applying the same sign when transposing a constant term to the other side of an equation rather than applying the inverse operation (subtracting 5050 from both sides).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Balance with Inverse Operations
  • Adding a positive constant cc to one side means you must subtract cc from both sides to isolate the variable term: c+ax=b  ⟹  ax=b−cc + ax = b \implies ax = b - c.

  • Always explicitly write −50- 50 on both sides of 50+0.300VB=14050 + 0.300 V_B = 140 before calculating.

Physical Reality Check
  • Volumes and concentrations in mixture problems must be positive and cannot exceed the total mixture volume.

  • If your answer yields a volume greater than the total (633.33>500633.33 > 500) or a negative volume (−133.33 mL-133.33\text{ mL}), pause immediately to inspect your inverse operations.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Subtract 5050 from both sides of 50+0.300VB=14050 + 0.300 V_B = 140: 0.300VB=140−50=900.300 V_B = 140 - 50 = 90

  2. Divide both sides by 0.3000.300: VB=900.300=300 mLV_B = \frac{90}{0.300} = 300\text{ mL}

  3. Substitute VB=300 mLV_B = 300\text{ mL} into VA=500−VBV_A = 500 - V_B: VA=500−300=200 mLV_A = 500 - 300 = 200\text{ mL}

Final answer

VA=200 mLV_A = 200\text{ mL}, VB=300 mLV_B = 300\text{ mL}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice isolating variable terms by writing the inverse operation beneath both sides of the equals sign.

  • Perform a sanity check on real-world constraints (e.g., 0<VA,VB<5000 < V_A, V_B < 500) as soon as you find a variable's value.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Solve for xx by substitution: {x+y=80,0.20x+0.60y=32\lbrace x + y = 80 ,\quad 0.20x + 0.60y = 32.

Answer

x=40x = 40, y=40y = 40. Substitute x=80−yx = 80 - y: 0.20(80−y)+0.60y=32  ⟹  16−0.20y+0.60y=32  ⟹  0.40y=16  ⟹  y=400.20(80 - y) + 0.60y = 32 \implies 16 - 0.20y + 0.60y = 32 \implies 0.40y = 16 \implies y = 40, then x=80−40=40x = 80 - 40 = 40.

02

A chemist needs 600 mL600\text{ mL} of a 15%15\% acid solution by mixing an 8%8\% solution (xx) and a 20%20\% solution (yy). Solve for xx and yy using substitution.

Answer

x=250 mLx = 250\text{ mL}, y=350 mLy = 350\text{ mL}. From x+y=600x + y = 600, substitute x=600−yx = 600 - y into 0.08x+0.20y=900.08x + 0.20y = 90: 0.08(600−y)+0.20y=90  ⟹  48+0.12y=90  ⟹  0.12y=42  ⟹  y=350 mL0.08(600 - y) + 0.20y = 90 \implies 48 + 0.12y = 90 \implies 0.12y = 42 \implies y = 350\text{ mL}, then x=600−350=250 mLx = 600 - 350 = 250\text{ mL}.

03

Solve the system using substitution: {2s+t=150,0.15s−0.25t=−5\lbrace 2s + t = 150 ,\quad 0.15s - 0.25t = -5.

Answer

s=50s = 50, t=50t = 50. Isolate t=150−2st = 150 - 2s and substitute into the second equation: 0.15s−0.25(150−2s)=−5  ⟹  0.15s−37.5+0.50s=−5  ⟹  0.65s=32.5  ⟹  s=500.15s - 0.25(150 - 2s) = -5 \implies 0.15s - 37.5 + 0.50s = -5 \implies 0.65s = 32.5 \implies s = 50. Then t=150−2(50)=50t = 150 - 2(50) = 50.

Loading workspace…