Resources

Let u\mathbf{u} and v\mathbf{v} be non-zero vectors in R2\mathbb{R}^2 such that ∥u∥=5\|\mathbf{u}\| = 5 and ∥v∥=3\|\mathbf{v}\| = 3. A student assumes that multiplying each vector by a positive scalar will scale the difference such that ∥2u−2v∥=2∥u∥−2∥v∥\|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| = 2\|\mathbf{u}\| - 2\|\mathbf{v}\|. Evaluate this claim by computing the true value of ∥2u−2v∥\|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| when u=⟨5,0⟩\mathbf{u} = \langle 5, 0 \rangle and v=⟨0,3⟩\mathbf{v} = \langle 0, 3 \rangle, compare it with the student's scalar calculation 2(5)−2(3)=42(5) - 2(3) = 4, and determine the percent discrepancy relative to the true magnitude.

Answer and steps

Final answer

True value ∥2u−2v∥=234≈11.66\|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| = 2\sqrt{34} \approx 11.66; Student value =4= 4; Discrepancy =234−4234×100%≈65.7%= \frac{2\sqrt{34} - 4}{2\sqrt{34}} \times 100\% \approx 65.7\%

Steps

01

Find the True Vector Difference and Its Magnitude

Given the vectors: u=⟨5,0⟩,v=⟨0,3⟩\mathbf{u} = \langle 5, 0 \rangle, \quad \mathbf{v} = \langle 0, 3 \rangle

First, multiply each vector by the scalar 22: 2u=2⟨5,0⟩=⟨10,0⟩2\mathbf{u} = 2\langle 5, 0 \rangle = \langle 10, 0 \rangle 2v=2⟨0,3⟩=⟨0,6⟩2\mathbf{v} = 2\langle 0, 3 \rangle = \langle 0, 6 \rangle

Now, compute the vector difference 2u−2v2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}: 2u−2v=⟨10−0, 0−6⟩=⟨10,−6⟩2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v} = \langle 10 - 0, \, 0 - 6 \rangle = \langle 10, -6 \rangle

The true magnitude of this resulting vector is calculated using the Euclidean norm formula ∥w∥=wx2+wy2\|\mathbf{w}\| = \sqrt{w_x^2 + w_y^2}: ∥2u−2v∥=102+(−6)2=100+36=136=234\|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| = \sqrt{10^2 + (-6)^2} = \sqrt{100 + 36} = \sqrt{136} = 2\sqrt{34}

Approximating to two decimal places: ∥2u−2v∥≈11.66\|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| \approx 11.66


02

Compare with the Student's Calculation

The student assumed that the magnitude of a difference equals the difference of the magnitudes: Student’s value=2∥u∥−2∥v∥=2(5)−2(3)=10−6=4\text{Student's value} = 2\|\mathbf{u}\| - 2\|\mathbf{v}\| = 2(5) - 2(3) = 10 - 6 = 4

Pitfall to avoid: In general, ∥a−b∥≠∥a∥−∥b∥\|\mathbf{a} - \mathbf{b}\| \neq \|\mathbf{a}\| - \|\mathbf{b}\|. By the triangle inequality (specifically, the reverse triangle inequality), ∥a−b∥≥∣∥a∥−∥b∥∣\|\mathbf{a} - \mathbf{b}\| \ge |\|\mathbf{a}\| - \|\mathbf{b}\||, with equality holding only when a\mathbf{a} and b\mathbf{b} are parallel and point in the same direction. Because u\mathbf{u} and v\mathbf{v} are orthogonal here, they form the legs of a right triangle, so the magnitude of their difference corresponds to the hypotenuse, which is strictly greater than the difference in lengths.


03

Calculate the Percent Discrepancy

The discrepancy relative to the true magnitude is: Discrepancy=True Value−Student ValueTrue Value×100%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{\text{True Value} - \text{Student Value}}{\text{True Value}} \times 100\%

Substitute the exact values: Discrepancy=234−4234×100%=(1−234)×100%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{2\sqrt{34} - 4}{2\sqrt{34}} \times 100\% = \left(1 - \frac{2}{\sqrt{34}}\right) \times 100\%

Using 34≈5.831\sqrt{34} \approx 5.831: 234≈25.831≈0.343\frac{2}{\sqrt{34}} \approx \frac{2}{5.831} \approx 0.343 Discrepancy≈(1−0.343)×100%≈65.7%\text{Discrepancy} \approx (1 - 0.343) \times 100\% \approx 65.7\%

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the relative percent discrepancy by dividing by the student's value instead of the true magnitude.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    2u−2v=⟨10,0⟩−⟨0,6⟩=⟨10,−6⟩  ⟹  ∥2u−2v∥=102+(−6)2=136=234≈11.662\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v} = \langle 10, 0 \rangle - \langle 0, 6 \rangle = \langle 10, -6 \rangle \implies \|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| = \sqrt{10^2 + (-6)^2} = \sqrt{136} = 2\sqrt{34} \approx 11.66

  2. Step 2

    Student calculation=4  ⟹  4≠11.66, so the claim is false\text{Student calculation} = 4 \implies 4 \neq 11.66\text{, so the claim is false}

  3. Step 3

    Discrepancy=∣11.66−44∣×100%=7.664×100%=191.5%\text{Discrepancy} = \left| \frac{11.66 - 4}{4} \right| \times 100\% = \frac{7.66}{4} \times 100\% = 191.5\%

    Correct

    Discrepancy=∣11.66−4∣11.66×100%≈65.7%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{|11.66 - 4|}{11.66} \times 100\% \approx 65.7\%

    You placed the approximate student value 44 in the denominator. Because the problem specifies the discrepancy relative to the true magnitude, the true value (234≈11.662\sqrt{34} \approx 11.66) must be in the denominator.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the components of 2u−2v2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}.

You applied the Euclidean norm formula accurately to find the true magnitude of 2342\sqrt{34}.

You correctly compared the true vector magnitude with the scalar difference to refute the claim.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Wrong Base Value in Relative Percent Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You chose the estimated value rather than the reference base value for the denominator in the relative discrepancy formula. When calculating relative change or percent discrepancy 'relative to XX', the denominator must always be the reference quantity XX.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Reference Base Value
  • In relative error and percent discrepancy calculations, 'relative to XX' means dividing by XX: Discrepancy=∣Calculated−Reference∣Reference×100%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{|\text{Calculated} - \text{Reference}|}{\text{Reference}} \times 100\%.

  • Look for phrases like 'relative to the true magnitude' and ensure the true value is placed in the denominator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the relative discrepancy formula with the true magnitude as the denominator: Discrepancy=234−4234×100%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{2\sqrt{34} - 4}{2\sqrt{34}} \times 100\%.

  2. Substitute the approximation 34≈5.831\sqrt{34} \approx 5.831 (or 234≈11.662\sqrt{34} \approx 11.66): Discrepancy=(1−234)×100%≈(1−0.343)×100%\text{Discrepancy} = \left(1 - \frac{2}{\sqrt{34}}\right) \times 100\% \approx (1 - 0.343) \times 100\%.

  3. Compute the final percentage: 0.657×100%≈65.7%0.657 \times 100\% \approx 65.7\%.

Final answer

Percent discrepancy≈65.7%\text{Percent discrepancy} \approx 65.7\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always re-read the problem prompt to verify which quantity serves as the reference base before setting up a relative percentage formula.

  • Practice calculating relative discrepancies in vector and geometry problems by explicitly writing out ∣value−reference∣reference\frac{|\text{value} - \text{reference}|}{\text{reference}} with units or labels first.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student squares the negative component improperly without parentheses, subtracting 36 inside the square root instead of adding it.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    2u−2v=⟨10,−6⟩2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v} = \langle 10, -6 \rangle

  2. Step 2

    ∥2u−2v∥=102−62=100−36=64=8\|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| = \sqrt{10^2 - 6^2} = \sqrt{100 - 36} = \sqrt{64} = 8

    Correct

    ∥2u−2v∥=102+(−6)2=100+36=136=234≈11.66\|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| = \sqrt{10^2 + (-6)^2} = \sqrt{100 + 36} = \sqrt{136} = 2\sqrt{34} \approx 11.66

    When computing vector magnitude using the Euclidean norm formula ∥w∥=wx2+wy2\|\mathbf{w}\| = \sqrt{w_x^2 + w_y^2}, component squares must always be added, never subtracted. Writing −62-6^2 resulted in subtracting 3636 rather than adding (−6)2=36(-6)^2 = 36.

  3. Step 3

    Student scalar value=4  ⟹  8≠4, so the claim is false\text{Student scalar value} = 4 \implies 8 \neq 4\text{, so the claim is false}

  4. Step 4

    Discrepancy=∣4−8∣8×100%=48×100%=50%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{|4 - 8|}{8} \times 100\% = \frac{4}{8} \times 100\% = 50\%

    Correct

    Discrepancy=234−4234×100%≈65.7%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{2\sqrt{34} - 4}{2\sqrt{34}} \times 100\% \approx 65.7\%

    Your percent discrepancy calculation followed the right relative error structure, but it inherited the incorrect magnitude of 88 from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly scaled and subtracted the vectors component-wise.

You correctly recognized that the scalar difference does not equal the vector magnitude.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Magnitude Formula Sign Error

You wrote −62-6^2 instead of +(−6)2+(-6)^2 under the radical, subtracting 3636 from 100100 instead of adding it.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing vector subtraction with the Pythagorean magnitude formula: subtracting vectors affects the signs of the components, but the norm formula always sums the squared components, which are strictly non-negative.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Always Sum Squares in the Norm
  • For any vector w=⟨x,y⟩\mathbf{w} = \langle x, y \rangle, ∥w∥=x2+y2\|\mathbf{w}\| = \sqrt{x^2 + y^2}.

  • Place parentheses around negative components before squaring, such as (−6)2(-6)^2, and keep a plus sign between the squared terms.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the true magnitude: ∥2u−2v∥=102+(−6)2=100+36=136=234≈11.66\|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| = \sqrt{10^2 + (-6)^2} = \sqrt{100 + 36} = \sqrt{136} = 2\sqrt{34} \approx 11.66.

  2. Calculate the relative percent discrepancy: 234−4234×100%=(1−234)×100%≈65.7%\frac{2\sqrt{34} - 4}{2\sqrt{34}} \times 100\% = \left(1 - \frac{2}{\sqrt{34}}\right) \times 100\% \approx 65.7\%.

Final answer

True value ∥2u−2v∥=234≈11.66\|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| = 2\sqrt{34} \approx 11.66; Discrepancy ≈65.7%\approx 65.7\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember to wrap negative components in parentheses like (−y)2(-y)^2 so they become positive upon squaring.

  • Verify that your vector magnitude is always at least as large as the absolute value of each individual component.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student distributes the square root over addition, writing √(100 + 36) = √100 + √36.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    2u−2v=⟨10,−6⟩2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v} = \langle 10, -6 \rangle

  2. Step 2

    ∥2u−2v∥=102+(−6)2=100+36=10+6=16\|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| = \sqrt{10^2 + (-6)^2} = \sqrt{100 + 36} = 10 + 6 = 16

    Correct

    ∥2u−2v∥=102+(−6)2=136=234≈11.66\|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| = \sqrt{10^2 + (-6)^2} = \sqrt{136} = 2\sqrt{34} \approx 11.66

    The square root operation does not distribute across addition; a+b≠a+b\sqrt{a + b} \neq \sqrt{a} + \sqrt{b}. You must add the terms inside the radicand first: 100+36=136=234\sqrt{100 + 36} = \sqrt{136} = 2\sqrt{34}.

  3. Step 3

    Student scalar value=4  ⟹  16≠4, so the claim is false\text{Student scalar value} = 4 \implies 16 \neq 4\text{, so the claim is false}

    Correct

    234≈11.66≠4, so the claim is false2\sqrt{34} \approx 11.66 \neq 4\text{, so the claim is false}

    Your reasoning that the claim is false is correct, but your comparison used your incorrect magnitude of 1616 instead of 234≈11.662\sqrt{34} \approx 11.66.

  4. Step 4

    Discrepancy=∣4−16∣16×100%=1216×100%=75%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{|4 - 16|}{16} \times 100\% = \frac{12}{16} \times 100\% = 75\%

    Correct

    Discrepancy=234−4234×100%≈65.7%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{2\sqrt{34} - 4}{2\sqrt{34}} \times 100\% \approx 65.7\%

    Your formula structure for percent discrepancy was set up correctly, but substituting 1616 instead of 2342\sqrt{34} propagated the earlier calculation error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the components of the scaled vector difference 2u−2v=⟨10,−6⟩2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v} = \langle 10, -6 \rangle.

You correctly recalled the standard vector magnitude formula ∥w∥=wx2+wy2\|\mathbf{w}\| = \sqrt{w_x^2 + w_y^2}.

You correctly recognized that the claim failed because the true vector magnitude did not match the scalar difference.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Radical distribution over addition

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the square root as a linear operator that distributes across terms in an addition, evaluating 100+36\sqrt{100 + 36} as 100+36\sqrt{100} + \sqrt{36} rather than simplifying the sum inside the radical first.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Radical Addition Rule
  • In general, a+b≠a+b\sqrt{a + b} \neq \sqrt{a} + \sqrt{b} for non-zero positive numbers.

  • Always evaluate or combine the sum inside the radical completely before attempting to simplify or extract roots.

Simplifying Square Roots of Sums
  • To simplify x2+y2\sqrt{x^2 + y^2}, factor out perfect square factors from the entire evaluated sum, not individual terms.

  • Compute 100+36=136100 + 36 = 136, factor 136=4×34136 = 4 \times 34, and take out 4\sqrt{4} to get 2342\sqrt{34}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate the radicand completely: ∥2u−2v∥=102+(−6)2=100+36=136\|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| = \sqrt{10^2 + (-6)^2} = \sqrt{100 + 36} = \sqrt{136}.

  2. Factor out perfect squares from the sum: 136=4×34=234≈11.66\sqrt{136} = \sqrt{4 \times 34} = 2\sqrt{34} \approx 11.66.

  3. Compare with the student scalar calculation: 234≠42\sqrt{34} \neq 4, disproving the claim.

  4. Calculate the relative discrepancy: 234−4234×100%=(1−234)×100%≈65.7%\frac{2\sqrt{34} - 4}{2\sqrt{34}} \times 100\% = \left(1 - \frac{2}{\sqrt{34}}\right) \times 100\% \approx 65.7\%.

Final answer

True value ∥2u−2v∥=234≈11.66\|2\mathbf{u} - 2\mathbf{v}\| = 2\sqrt{34} \approx 11.66; Student value =4= 4; Discrepancy ≈65.7%\approx 65.7\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review properties of radicals and practice simplifying expressions of the form a2+b2\sqrt{a^2 + b^2} without splitting the root.

  • Solve problems involving the triangle inequality ∥u−v∥≥∣∥u∥−∥v∥∣\|\mathbf{u} - \mathbf{v}\| \ge |\|\mathbf{u}\| - \|\mathbf{v}\|| to understand geometrically why vector differences rarely equal scalar differences.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Let p=⟨4,0⟩\mathbf{p} = \langle 4, 0 \rangle and q=⟨0,3⟩\mathbf{q} = \langle 0, 3 \rangle. Compute the true magnitude ∥p−q∥\|\mathbf{p} - \mathbf{q}\| and compare it to the scalar difference ∥p∥−∥q∥\|\mathbf{p}\| - \|\mathbf{q}\|. Then find the percent discrepancy of the scalar difference relative to the true magnitude.

Answer

True magnitude: ∥p−q∥=∥⟨4,−3⟩∥=42+(−3)2=5\|\mathbf{p} - \mathbf{q}\| = \|\langle 4, -3 \rangle\| = \sqrt{4^2 + (-3)^2} = 5. Scalar difference: 4−3=14 - 3 = 1. Discrepancy: 5−15×100%=80%\frac{5 - 1}{5} \times 100\% = 80\%.

02

For vectors u=⟨3,4⟩\mathbf{u} = \langle 3, 4 \rangle and v=⟨3,0⟩\mathbf{v} = \langle 3, 0 \rangle, calculate the true value of ∥3u−3v∥\|3\mathbf{u} - 3\mathbf{v}\| and compare it to 3∥u∥−3∥v∥3\|\mathbf{u}\| - 3\|\mathbf{v}\|. Determine the percent discrepancy of the scalar calculation relative to the true magnitude.

Answer

True vector: 3u−3v=3⟨0,4⟩=⟨0,12⟩3\mathbf{u} - 3\mathbf{v} = 3\langle 0, 4 \rangle = \langle 0, 12 \rangle, so ∥3u−3v∥=12\|3\mathbf{u} - 3\mathbf{v}\| = 12. Scalar calculation: 3(5)−3(3)=15−9=63(5) - 3(3) = 15 - 9 = 6. Discrepancy relative to true magnitude: 12−612×100%=50%\frac{12 - 6}{12} \times 100\% = 50\%.

03

An experiment measures an observed magnitude of 15.0 N15.0\text{ N}, whereas the theoretical true magnitude is 12.0 N12.0\text{ N}. Find the relative percent error relative to the theoretical magnitude, and explain what error occurs if the observed value is mistakenly placed in the denominator.

Answer

Correct relative error: ∣15.0−12.0∣12.0×100%=25.0%\frac{|15.0 - 12.0|}{12.0} \times 100\% = 25.0\%. If the observed value 15.015.0 is mistakenly used as the base, the calculation yields 3.015.0×100%=20.0%\frac{3.0}{15.0} \times 100\% = 20.0\%, understating the error relative to the true benchmark.

Loading workspace…