Resources

A civil engineer designs an open-topped rectangular concrete drainage channel of length L=50 mL = 50\text{ m} with a rectangular cross-section of width w mw\text{ m} and water depth d md\text{ m}. The cross-sectional wetted perimeter is given by P=w+2dP = w + 2d and the cross-sectional flow area is A=wdA = wd. Due to precast formwork limits, the total wetted perimeter cannot exceed 6.0 m6.0\text{ m}. Hydraulic efficiency requires A≥4.0 m2A \ge 4.0\text{ m}^2, while freeboard structural stability imposes the physical non-negativity boundaries w>0w > 0 and d>0d > 0. By formulating the constraint boundary equation w+2d=6.0w + 2d = 6.0, determine the critical threshold discriminant Δ\Delta of the resulting quadratic relation in dd, and state whether an allowable parameter domain exists for dd that satisfies both P≤6.0 mP \le 6.0\text{ m} and A≥4.0 m2A \ge 4.0\text{ m}^2.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Quadratic equation on boundary: 2d2−6.0d+4.0≤02d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0 \le 0; Discriminant: Δ=4.0>0\Delta = 4.0 > 0; Allowable parameter interval: 1.0 m≤d≤2.0 m1.0\text{ m} \le d \le 2.0\text{ m} (corresponding to 2.0 m≤w≤4.0 m2.0\text{ m} \le w \le 4.0\text{ m})

Steps

01

Express Width in Terms of Depth Using the Perimeter Boundary

The total wetted perimeter constraint is P≤6.0 mP \le 6.0\text{ m}, where: P=w+2dP = w + 2d

To investigate whether any configuration satisfies the area requirement, consider the upper boundary of the wetted perimeter: w+2d=6.0  ⟹  w=6.0−2dw + 2d = 6.0 \implies w = 6.0 - 2d

Because physical dimensions must be positive (w>0w > 0 and d>0d > 0), depth dd is restricted to: 6.0−2d>0  ⟹  0<d<3.0 m6.0 - 2d > 0 \implies 0 < d < 3.0\text{ m}


02

Formulate the Quadratic Area Relation

Substitute the expression for ww into the flow area formula A=wdA = wd: A=(6.0−2d)d=6.0d−2d2A = (6.0 - 2d)d = 6.0d - 2d^2

The hydraulic efficiency requirement specifies that A≥4.0 m2A \ge 4.0\text{ m}^2: 6.0d−2d2≥4.06.0d - 2d^2 \ge 4.0

Rearranging into standard quadratic inequality form gives: 2d2−6.0d+4.0≤02d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0 \le 0


03

Calculate the Discriminant Δ\Delta

For the quadratic equation representing the boundary of this region, 2d2−6.0d+4.0=02d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0 = 0, identify the coefficients:

  • a=2a = 2
  • b=−6.0b = -6.0
  • c=4.0c = 4.0

Calculate the discriminant Δ=b2−4ac\Delta = b^2 - 4ac: Δ=(−6.0)2−4(2)(4.0)=36.0−32.0=4.0\Delta = (-6.0)^2 - 4(2)(4.0) = 36.0 - 32.0 = 4.0

Since Δ=4.0>0\Delta = 4.0 > 0, the quadratic equation has two distinct real roots.


04

Determine the Allowable Parameter Domain

Find the boundary roots using the quadratic formula: d=−b±Δ2a=6.0±4.02(2)=6.0±2.04d = \frac{-b \pm \sqrt{\Delta}}{2a} = \frac{6.0 \pm \sqrt{4.0}}{2(2)} = \frac{6.0 \pm 2.0}{4}

This yields: d1=4.04=1.0 m,d2=8.04=2.0 md_1 = \frac{4.0}{4} = 1.0\text{ m}, \quad d_2 = \frac{8.0}{4} = 2.0\text{ m}

Because the parabola y=2d2−6.0d+4.0y = 2d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0 opens upward (a>0a > 0), the values satisfying 2d2−6.0d+4.0≤02d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0 \le 0 lie between the roots: 1.0 m≤d≤2.0 m1.0\text{ m} \le d \le 2.0\text{ m}

Evaluating the corresponding width w=6.0−2dw = 6.0 - 2d:

  • For d=1.0 md = 1.0\text{ m}: w=6.0−2(1.0)=4.0 mw = 6.0 - 2(1.0) = 4.0\text{ m}
  • For d=2.0 md = 2.0\text{ m}: w=6.0−2(2.0)=2.0 mw = 6.0 - 2(2.0) = 2.0\text{ m}

Thus, an allowable domain exists for both dimensions: 1.0 m≤d≤2.0 mcorresponding to2.0 m≤w≤4.0 m1.0\text{ m} \le d \le 2.0\text{ m} \quad \text{corresponding to} \quad 2.0\text{ m} \le w \le 4.0\text{ m}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misremembers the discriminant formula as b² - 2ac instead of b² - 4ac, altering the discriminant value while still finding real roots.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    w=6−2d  ⟹  A=(6−2d)d≥4  ⟹  2d2−6d+4≤0w = 6 - 2d \implies A = (6 - 2d)d \ge 4 \implies 2d^2 - 6d + 4 \le 0

  2. Step 2

    Δ=(−6)2−2(2)(4)=36−16=20\Delta = (-6)^2 - 2(2)(4) = 36 - 16 = 20

    Correct

    Δ=b2−4ac=(−6.0)2−4(2)(4.0)=36.0−32.0=4.0\Delta = b^2 - 4ac = (-6.0)^2 - 4(2)(4.0) = 36.0 - 32.0 = 4.0

    You used the factor 22 instead of 44 in the second term of the discriminant formula. The correct formula is Δ=b2−4ac\Delta = b^2 - 4ac, which yields Δ=36−32=4\Delta = 36 - 32 = 4.

  3. Step 3

    Since Δ>0, an allowable parameter domain exists.\text{Since } \Delta > 0\text{, an allowable parameter domain exists.}

    Correct

    Since Δ=4.0>0, two distinct real boundary roots exist: d=1.0 m and d=2.0 m, giving an allowable domain 1.0 m≤d≤2.0 m.\text{Since } \Delta = 4.0 > 0\text{, two distinct real boundary roots exist: } d = 1.0\text{ m and } d = 2.0\text{ m, giving an allowable domain } 1.0\text{ m} \le d \le 2.0\text{ m}.

    Your qualitative conclusion is correct because the true discriminant is also positive, but this step inherited your incorrect discriminant calculation.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the channel width in terms of depth using the wetted perimeter boundary.

You accurately formulated the hydraulic area constraint into a standard quadratic inequality.

You recognized that a positive discriminant indicates the existence of real solution roots.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Discriminant formula recall error

You accidentally wrote the second term of the discriminant as 2ac2ac instead of 4ac4ac.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the coefficient 44 in the discriminant formula Δ=b2−4ac\Delta = b^2 - 4ac with the denominator factor 2a2a from the quadratic formula.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Recall the complete quadratic discriminant formula
  • For a quadratic equation ax2+bx+c=0ax^2 + bx + c = 0, the discriminant is Δ=b2−4ac\Delta = b^2 - 4ac.

  • Always double-check that the second term subtracts four times the product of aa and cc, not two times.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the full discriminant formula: Δ=b2−4ac=(−6.0)2−4(2)(4.0)=36.0−32.0=4.0\Delta = b^2 - 4ac = (-6.0)^2 - 4(2)(4.0) = 36.0 - 32.0 = 4.0.

  2. Find the boundary depths using the quadratic formula: d=6.0±4.02(2)=6.0±2.04d = \frac{6.0 \pm \sqrt{4.0}}{2(2)} = \frac{6.0 \pm 2.0}{4}.

  3. This yields d1=1.0 md_1 = 1.0\text{ m} and d2=2.0 md_2 = 2.0\text{ m}.

  4. Because the parabola 2d2−6.0d+4.0≤02d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0 \le 0 opens upward, the allowable parameter domain is 1.0 m≤d≤2.0 m1.0\text{ m} \le d \le 2.0\text{ m}.

Final answer

Δ=4.0\Delta = 4.0; an allowable parameter domain exists (1.0 m≤d≤2.0 m1.0\text{ m} \le d \le 2.0\text{ m}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the quadratic formula and discriminant pair together: x=−b±b2−4ac2ax = \frac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a}, noting that the 44 belongs under the square root while the 22 belongs in the denominator.

  • Practice computing discriminants on quadratic models before extracting feasible parameter ranges.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student moves terms across the inequality sign without reversing or correctly matching signs, obtaining 2d² - 6d - 4 = 0 and evaluating Δ as 68.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    w=6−2d  ⟹  6d−2d2≥4w = 6 - 2d \implies 6d - 2d^2 \ge 4

  2. Step 2

    2d2−6d−4=02d^2 - 6d - 4 = 0

    Correct

    2d2−6.0d+4.0=02d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0 = 0

    When rearranging 6d−2d2≥46d - 2d^2 \ge 4 into standard form, adding 2d22d^2 and subtracting 6d6d from both sides gives 0≥2d2−6d+40 \ge 2d^2 - 6d + 4. The constant term +4+4 remains positive; it does not change to −4-4.

  3. Step 3

    Δ=(−6)2−4(2)(−4)=36+32=68\Delta = (-6)^2 - 4(2)(-4) = 36 + 32 = 68

    Correct

    Δ=(−6.0)2−4(2)(4.0)=36.0−32.0=4.0\Delta = (-6.0)^2 - 4(2)(4.0) = 36.0 - 32.0 = 4.0

    You calculated the discriminant accurately using your equation's coefficients, but because of the sign error on the constant term c=−4c = -4, you obtained Δ=68\Delta = 68 instead of Δ=4.0\Delta = 4.0.

  4. Step 4

    Since Δ>0, an allowable parameter domain exists.\text{Since } \Delta > 0\text{, an allowable parameter domain exists.}

    Correct

    Δ=4.0>0  ⟹  1.0 m≤d≤2.0 m (an allowable domain exists)\Delta = 4.0 > 0 \implies 1.0\text{ m} \le d \le 2.0\text{ m}\text{ (an allowable domain exists)}

    Your conclusion that an allowable domain exists is qualitatively correct because Δ>0\Delta > 0, but it rests on the incorrect discriminant value and does not verify whether the resulting roots satisfy the physical positivity bounds d>0d > 0 and w>0w > 0.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly isolated ww from the perimeter constraint boundary w+2d=6.0w + 2d = 6.0.

You successfully substituted ww into the area formula to create a single-variable inequality in dd.

You correctly recalled and applied the quadratic discriminant formula Δ=b2−4ac\Delta = b^2 - 4ac.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic Sign Error During Transposition

You changed the sign of the constant +4+4 to −4-4 when moving the other terms to its side of the relation.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing which terms cross the inequality sign versus which term remains in place when transforming 6d−2d2≥46d - 2d^2 \ge 4 into standard form ad2+bd+c≤0a d^2 + b d + c \le 0.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Keep stationary terms intact
  • When moving terms to one side of an inequality, terms that remain on their original side retain their original sign.

  • From 6d−2d2≥46d - 2d^2 \ge 4, move all terms to the right by adding 2d22d^2 and subtracting 6d6d: 0≥2d2−6d+40 \ge 2d^2 - 6d + 4, leaving +4+4 unchanged.

Verify boundary root feasibility
  • In physical modeling, positive discriminants must yield roots that comply with physical domain bounds (w>0w > 0 and d>0d > 0).

  • Always find the explicit boundary roots d1,d2d_1, d_2 to ensure they lie within the feasible geometric interval 0<d<3.0 m0 < d < 3.0\text{ m}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Rearrange 6.0d−2d2≥4.06.0d - 2d^2 \ge 4.0 by moving all terms to the right side: 0≥2d2−6.0d+4.00 \ge 2d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0, or 2d2−6.0d+4.0≤02d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0 \le 0.

  2. Identify the coefficients of the boundary equation 2d2−6.0d+4.0=02d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0 = 0: a=2a = 2, b=−6.0b = -6.0, c=4.0c = 4.0.

  3. Compute the discriminant: Δ=b2−4ac=(−6.0)2−4(2)(4.0)=36.0−32.0=4.0\Delta = b^2 - 4ac = (-6.0)^2 - 4(2)(4.0) = 36.0 - 32.0 = 4.0.

  4. Solve for the boundary depths: d=6.0±4.02(2)=6.0±2.04d = \frac{6.0 \pm \sqrt{4.0}}{2(2)} = \frac{6.0 \pm 2.0}{4}, giving d1=1.0 md_1 = 1.0\text{ m} and d2=2.0 md_2 = 2.0\text{ m}.

  5. Since a=2>0a = 2 > 0, the inequality 2d2−6.0d+4.0≤02d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0 \le 0 holds between the roots: 1.0 m≤d≤2.0 m1.0\text{ m} \le d \le 2.0\text{ m}. Both depths yield positive widths (2.0 m≤w≤4.0 m2.0\text{ m} \le w \le 4.0\text{ m}), confirming that an allowable parameter domain exists.

Final answer

Boundary quadratic: 2d2−6.0d+4.0≤02d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0 \le 0; Discriminant: Δ=4.0\Delta = 4.0; An allowable parameter domain exists (1.0 m≤d≤2.0 m1.0\text{ m} \le d \le 2.0\text{ m}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice moving terms across equations step-by-step by writing out the explicit addition or subtraction on both sides.

  • Double-check the constant term's sign before identifying a,b,ca, b, c for the discriminant formula.

  • Solve for the actual numerical interval of the variable to verify that the roots are physically meaningful.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets that the channel has two wet side walls and uses the closed perimeter formula P = 2w + 2d, resulting in a negative discriminant and incorrectly concluding no allowable domain exists.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    2w+2d=6  ⟹  w=3−d2w + 2d = 6 \implies w = 3 - d

    Correct

    w+2d=6.0  ⟹  w=6.0−2dw + 2d = 6.0 \implies w = 6.0 - 2d

    An open-topped drainage channel only has water contacting the bottom and the two vertical sides, so the wetted perimeter has only one width: P=w+2dP = w + 2d rather than 2w+2d2w + 2d.

  2. Step 2

    A=(3−d)d≥4  ⟹  d2−3d+4≤0A = (3-d)d \ge 4 \implies d^2 - 3d + 4 \le 0

    Correct

    A=(6.0−2d)d≥4.0  ⟹  2d2−6.0d+4.0≤0A = (6.0 - 2d)d \ge 4.0 \implies 2d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0 \le 0

    Your substitution and algebraic rearrangement followed logically from your expression for ww, but inherited the incorrect relation.

  3. Step 3

    Δ=(−3)2−4(1)(4)=9−16=−7\Delta = (-3)^2 - 4(1)(4) = 9 - 16 = -7

    Correct

    Δ=(−6.0)2−4(2)(4.0)=36.0−32.0=4.0\Delta = (-6.0)^2 - 4(2)(4.0) = 36.0 - 32.0 = 4.0

    You calculated the discriminant accurately for your quadratic, but the correct quadratic yields Δ=4.0\Delta = 4.0.

  4. Step 4

    Since Δ<0\Delta < 0, no allowable parameter domain exists.

    Correct

    Since Δ=4.0>0\Delta = 4.0 > 0, an allowable parameter domain exists: 1.0 m≤d≤2.0 m1.0\text{ m} \le d \le 2.0\text{ m} (with 2.0 m≤w≤4.0 m2.0\text{ m} \le w \le 4.0\text{ m}).

    Because your discriminant was negative, you concluded no solution existed; with the correct boundary equation, Δ>0\Delta > 0 yields a valid physical range between the roots.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the expression for width into the area formula.

You rearranged the inequality into standard quadratic form with correct signs.

You accurately applied the discriminant formula Δ=b2−4ac\Delta = b^2 - 4ac to your quadratic equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect boundary constraint formulation

You modeled the perimeter as a closed four-sided rectangle (2w+2d2w + 2d) rather than an open three-sided channel (w+2dw + 2d).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the physical geometry of an 'open-topped' channel and defaulting to the standard geometric perimeter formula for a closed rectangle.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Count the Contact Surfaces
  • Wetted perimeter PP measures only the boundary where fluid touches the channel wall and bed: P=bottom+2×sides=w+2dP = \text{bottom} + 2 \times \text{sides} = w + 2d.

  • Always sketch the cross-section and highlight only the boundaries in contact with the fluid before writing the perimeter equation.

Verify Model Assumptions
  • Open structures have fewer bounding edges than closed polygons.

  • Check the problem description for keywords like 'open-topped', 'gutter', or 'trough' to ensure no 'lid' edge is added.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the boundary equation using the open-channel wetted perimeter: w+2d=6.0  ⟹  w=6.0−2dw + 2d = 6.0 \implies w = 6.0 - 2d.

  2. Substitute ww into the flow area inequality: A=wd=(6.0−2d)d≥4.0A = wd = (6.0 - 2d)d \ge 4.0.

  3. Expand and rearrange: 6.0d−2d2≥4.0  ⟹  2d2−6.0d+4.0≤06.0d - 2d^2 \ge 4.0 \implies 2d^2 - 6.0d + 4.0 \le 0.

  4. Calculate the discriminant: Δ=(−6.0)2−4(2)(4.0)=36.0−32.0=4.0\Delta = (-6.0)^2 - 4(2)(4.0) = 36.0 - 32.0 = 4.0.

  5. Solve for the roots: d=6.0±4.02(2)=6.0±2.04d = \frac{6.0 \pm \sqrt{4.0}}{2(2)} = \frac{6.0 \pm 2.0}{4}, giving d1=1.0 md_1 = 1.0\text{ m} and d2=2.0 md_2 = 2.0\text{ m}.

Final answer

Δ=4.0\Delta = 4.0; an allowable domain exists for depth dd: 1.0 m≤d≤2.0 m1.0\text{ m} \le d \le 2.0\text{ m} (corresponding to 2.0 m≤w≤4.0 m2.0\text{ m} \le w \le 4.0\text{ m}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice sketching open cross-sections to trace wetted perimeter correctly.

  • Re-evaluate optimization problems involving troughs, gutters, and flumes to reinforce three-sided versus four-sided perimeters.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A rectangular storage pen is enclosed along a barn wall such that its perimeter without the wall is x+2y=12 mx + 2y = 12\text{ m}, where xx is the length and yy is the width. If the enclosed area must satisfy xy≥16 m2xy \ge 16\text{ m}^2, write the boundary quadratic equation in standard form ay2+by+c=0ay^2 + by + c = 0 and calculate its discriminant Δ\Delta.

Answer

Substituting x=12−2yx = 12 - 2y yields (12−2y)y≥16(12 - 2y)y \ge 16, which rearranges to 2y2−12y+16≤02y^2 - 12y + 16 \le 0. For the boundary equation 2y2−12y+16=02y^2 - 12y + 16 = 0, the discriminant is Δ=(−12)2−4(2)(16)=144−128=16\Delta = (-12)^2 - 4(2)(16) = 144 - 128 = 16.

02

A civil engineer designs an open rectangular flume with wetted perimeter P=w+2d=8.0 mP = w + 2d = 8.0\text{ m} and flow area A=wd≥9.0 m2A = wd \ge 9.0\text{ m}^2. Determine the discriminant Δ\Delta of the boundary quadratic in dd and state whether an allowable real depth dd exists.

Answer

Substituting w=8.0−2dw = 8.0 - 2d gives (8.0−2d)d≥9.0  ⟹  2d2−8.0d+9.0≤0(8.0 - 2d)d \ge 9.0 \implies 2d^2 - 8.0d + 9.0 \le 0. The discriminant is Δ=(−8.0)2−4(2)(9.0)=64.0−72.0=−8.0\Delta = (-8.0)^2 - 4(2)(9.0) = 64.0 - 72.0 = -8.0. Because Δ<0\Delta < 0 and the parabola opens upward, the inequality has no real solutions; hence no allowable depth domain exists.

03

An open rectangular channel has a fixed wetted perimeter constraint w+2d=P0w + 2d = P_0 and requires a minimum flow area A0A_0. Derive the critical discriminant Δ\Delta in terms of P0P_0 and A0A_0, and determine the maximum required area A0,maxA_{0,\text{max}} for which an allowable physical configuration still exists.

Answer

Substituting w=P0−2dw = P_0 - 2d into wd≥A0wd \ge A_0 yields 2d2−P0d+A0≤02d^2 - P_0 d + A_0 \le 0. The boundary discriminant is Δ=(−P0)2−4(2)(A0)=P02−8A0\Delta = (-P_0)^2 - 4(2)(A_0) = P_0^2 - 8A_0. An allowable real configuration exists when Δ≥0\Delta \ge 0, which requires P02−8A0≥0P_0^2 - 8A_0 \ge 0, meaning the maximum feasible area is A0,max=P028A_{0,\text{max}} = \frac{P_0^2}{8}.

Loading workspace…