Resources

A truth-functional circuit evaluator outputs False\text{False} for the compound proposition ¬(p∨¬q)∨(q∧¬r)\neg (p \lor \neg q) \lor (q \land \neg r). If it is known that q=Trueq = \text{True}, determine the required truth values for propositions pp and rr.

Answer and steps

Final answer

p=Truep = \text{True} and r=Truer = \text{True}

Steps

To find the truth values of pp and rr, we analyze the compound proposition using the standard rules of logical disjunction (∨\lor), conjunction (∧\land), and negation (¬\neg).

Step 1: Deconstruct the main logical connective

The given expression is a disjunction of two sub-propositions: ¬(p∨¬q)∨(q∧¬r)=False\neg (p \lor \neg q) \lor (q \land \neg r) = \text{False}

A disjunction A∨BA \lor B evaluates to False\text{False} if and only if both parts are False\text{False}. Therefore, both of the following must hold simultaneously:

  1. ¬(p∨¬q)=False\neg (p \lor \neg q) = \text{False}
  2. q∧¬r=Falseq \land \neg r = \text{False}

Step 2: Solve for pp using the first condition

From the first condition: ¬(p∨¬q)=False  ⟹  p∨¬q=True\neg (p \lor \neg q) = \text{False} \implies p \lor \neg q = \text{True}

We are given that q=Trueq = \text{True}, which means its negation is: ¬q=False\neg q = \text{False}

Substitute ¬q=False\neg q = \text{False} into the disjunction: p∨False=Truep \lor \text{False} = \text{True}

For a disjunction with False\text{False} to be True\text{True}, the other component must be True\text{True}: p=Truep = \text{True}


Step 3: Solve for rr using the second condition

From the second condition: q∧¬r=Falseq \land \neg r = \text{False}

Substitute the known truth value q=Trueq = \text{True}: True∧¬r=False\text{True} \land \neg r = \text{False}

A conjunction requires both inputs to be True\text{True} to yield True\text{True}. Since the result is False\text{False} and the first input is True\text{True}, the second input must be False\text{False}: ¬r=False\neg r = \text{False}

Negating both sides gives: r=Truer = \text{True}


Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is distributing the negation incorrectly into (p∨¬q)(p \lor \neg q) without changing the operator, or confusing the requirement for a disjunction to be false (both operands must be false) with the requirement for a conjunction (at least one operand must be false). Working backward step-by-step from the main operator avoids these errors.

Thus, the required truth values are p=Truep = \text{True} and r=Truer = \text{True}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets the condition for a conjunction (q ∧ ¬r) to be False, concluding that ¬r must be True instead of False.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ¬(p∨¬q)∨(q∧¬r)=False  ⟹  ¬(p∨¬q)=False and q∧¬r=False\neg (p \lor \neg q) \lor (q \land \neg r) = \text{False} \implies \neg (p \lor \neg q) = \text{False} \text{ and } q \land \neg r = \text{False}

  2. Step 2

    p∨¬q=True  ⟹  Since q=True,¬q=False, so p=Truep \lor \neg q = \text{True} \implies \text{Since } q = \text{True}, \neg q = \text{False}, \text{ so } p = \text{True}

  3. Step 3

    q∧¬r=False with q=True gives ¬r=Trueq \land \neg r = \text{False} \text{ with } q = \text{True gives } \neg r = \text{True}

    Correct

    True∧¬r=False  ⟹  ¬r=False\text{True} \land \neg r = \text{False} \implies \neg r = \text{False}

    A conjunction True∧X\text{True} \land X evaluates to False\text{False} only when X=FalseX = \text{False}. Therefore, ¬r\neg r must be False\text{False}, not True\text{True}.

  4. Step 4

    r=False  ⟹  p=True,r=Falser = \text{False} \implies p = \text{True}, r = \text{False}

    Correct

    ¬r=False  ⟹  r=True  ⟹  p=True,r=True\neg r = \text{False} \implies r = \text{True} \implies p = \text{True}, r = \text{True}

    This step correctly negates your previous value of ¬r\neg r, but the conclusion is incorrect due to the error in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly split the false outer disjunction into two required false statements.

You accurately evaluated ¬q\neg q and solved the first branch to get p=Truep = \text{True}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conjunction truth value misinterpretation

You treated the conjunction True∧¬r=False\text{True} \land \neg r = \text{False} as if it required ¬r\neg r to be True\text{True}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the truth condition of a conjunction: True∧X=X\text{True} \land X = X, so for the conjunction to be False\text{False}, the unknown term XX must be False\text{False}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate conjunctions with a known True operand
  • For any proposition XX, True∧X≡X\text{True} \land X \equiv X. Therefore, True∧X=False  ⟺  X=False\text{True} \land X = \text{False} \iff X = \text{False}.

  • Whenever you encounter True∧X=False\text{True} \land X = \text{False}, directly replace True∧X\text{True} \land X with XX to get X=FalseX = \text{False}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute q=Trueq = \text{True} into the conjunction: True∧¬r=False\text{True} \land \neg r = \text{False}.

  2. Since True∧X=X\text{True} \land X = X, this simplifies directly to ¬r=False\neg r = \text{False}.

  3. Take the negation of both sides: r=¬(False)=Truer = \neg(\text{False}) = \text{True}.

Final answer

p=Truep = \text{True} and r=Truer = \text{True}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the truth table for conjunction (∧\land) to reinforce that True∧True=True\text{True} \land \text{True} = \text{True} and True∧False=False\text{True} \land \text{False} = \text{False}.

  • Practice isolating variables inside compound logical statements by evaluating known truth values first.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the negation of a disjunction with its original truth value, setting p ∨ ¬q = False instead of True.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ¬(p∨¬q)∨(q∧¬r)=False  ⟹  ¬(p∨¬q)=False and q∧¬r=False\neg (p \lor \neg q) \lor (q \land \neg r) = \text{False} \implies \neg (p \lor \neg q) = \text{False} \text{ and } q \land \neg r = \text{False}

  2. Step 2

    p∨¬q=Falsep \lor \neg q = \text{False}

    Correct

    p∨¬q=Truep \lor \neg q = \text{True}

    If the negation of a statement is False\text{False}, the underlying statement must be True\text{True}. Since ¬(p∨¬q)=False\neg (p \lor \neg q) = \text{False}, you must have p∨¬q=Truep \lor \neg q = \text{True}, not False\text{False}.

  3. Step 3

    p=False and ¬q=Falsep = \text{False} \text{ and } \neg q = \text{False}

    Correct

    p∨False=True  ⟹  p=Truep \lor \text{False} = \text{True} \implies p = \text{True}

    Because you set p∨¬q=Falsep \lor \neg q = \text{False}, you deduced that p=Falsep = \text{False}. Substituting the given value ¬q=False\neg q = \text{False} into the correct equation p∨False=Truep \lor \text{False} = \text{True} gives p=Truep = \text{True}.

  4. Step 4

    q∧¬r=False with q=True gives ¬r=False, so r=Trueq \land \neg r = \text{False} \text{ with } q = \text{True} \text{ gives } \neg r = \text{False}, \text{ so } r = \text{True}

  5. Step 5

    p=False,r=Truep = \text{False}, r = \text{True}

    Correct

    p=True,r=Truep = \text{True}, r = \text{True}

    The final conclusion carries over the earlier sign inversion error for proposition pp.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly broke down the outer disjunction by requiring both operands to be False\text{False}.

You correctly substituted q=Trueq = \text{True} into the conjunction and solved for r=Truer = \text{True}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Negation evaluation error

You dropped the outer negation operator ¬\neg without inverting the truth value of the equality from False\text{False} to True\text{True}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the truth value of a proposition with the truth value of its negation, treating ¬A=False\neg A = \text{False} as if it directly implied A=FalseA = \text{False}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Inverting Negated Equalities
  • For any proposition AA, ¬A=False  ⟺  A=True\neg A = \text{False} \iff A = \text{True}.

  • Whenever you remove an outer negation sign across an equals sign, invert the truth value on the opposite side.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the definition of logical negation: if ¬A=False\neg A = \text{False}, then A=TrueA = \text{True}, so p∨¬q=Truep \lor \neg q = \text{True}.

  2. Since q=Trueq = \text{True}, its negation is ¬q=False\neg q = \text{False}.

  3. Substitute ¬q=False\neg q = \text{False} into the disjunction: p∨False=Truep \lor \text{False} = \text{True}.

  4. For a disjunction with False\text{False} to evaluate to True\text{True}, the other operand must be True\text{True}, hence p=Truep = \text{True}.

Final answer

p=Truep = \text{True} and r=Truer = \text{True}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the basic truth table for logical negation (¬)(\neg) to reinforce that ¬A=False  ⟹  A=True\neg A = \text{False} \implies A = \text{True}.

  • Practice peeling off outer logical operators one layer at a time and verifying truth values after each step.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student incorrectly applies De Morgan's laws or distribution by dropping the outer negation as ¬p ∨ ¬q instead of ¬p ∧ q.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ¬(p∨¬q)=¬p∨q\neg (p \lor \neg q) = \neg p \lor q

    Correct

    ¬(p∨¬q)≡¬p∧q\neg (p \lor \neg q) \equiv \neg p \land q

    When negating a disjunction using De Morgan's laws, the operator changes from ∨\lor to ∧\land, giving ¬p∧¬(¬q)≡¬p∧q\neg p \land \neg(\neg q) \equiv \neg p \land q.

  2. Step 2

    ¬p∨q∨(q∧¬r)=False  ⟹  ¬p∨q=False\neg p \lor q \lor (q \land \neg r) = \text{False} \implies \neg p \lor q = \text{False}

    Correct

    ¬(p∨¬q)=False and (q∧¬r)=False\neg (p \lor \neg q) = \text{False} \text{ and } (q \land \neg r) = \text{False}

    This step inherits the incorrect disjunction ¬p∨q\neg p \lor q from step 1.

  3. Step 3

    ¬p=False and q=False\neg p = \text{False} \text{ and } q = \text{False}

    Correct

    p∨¬q=True  ⟹  p∨False=True  ⟹  p=Truep \lor \neg q = \text{True} \implies p \lor \text{False} = \text{True} \implies p = \text{True}

    Because of the previous mistake, you deduced q=Falseq = \text{False}, which directly conflicted with the problem premise.

  4. Step 4

    Contradiction with q=True, so no solution exists\text{Contradiction with } q = \text{True} \text{, so no solution exists}

    Correct

    p=True and r=Truep = \text{True} \text{ and } r = \text{True}

    The contradiction arose entirely from distributing the negation without flipping ∨\lor to ∧\land.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that a disjunction A∨BA \lor B requires both disjuncts to be False\text{False} in order to evaluate to False\text{False}.

You correctly simplified the double negation ¬(¬q)\neg(\neg q) to qq.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
De Morgan's Laws Error

You distributed the outer negation to pp and ¬q\neg q, but left the logical connective as ∨\lor instead of switching it to ∧\land.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the negation of a compound proposition with algebraic distribution, forgetting that negating an OR (∨)(\lor) statement turns it into an AND (∧)(\land) statement.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
De Morgan's Laws for Disjunction
  • ¬(A∨B)≡¬A∧¬B\neg(A \lor B) \equiv \neg A \land \neg B

  • Always flip ∨\lor to ∧\land and ∧\land to ∨\lor whenever you distribute a negation across parentheses.

Outer Negation Simplification Strategy
  • If ¬X=False\neg X = \text{False}, then X=TrueX = \text{True}.

  • Avoid expanding with De Morgan's laws when an expression equals False\text{False}; simply strip the outer negation by setting the inside expression to True\text{True}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Start from the main connective: ¬(p∨¬q)∨(q∧¬r)=False\neg (p \lor \neg q) \lor (q \land \neg r) = \text{False} means both ¬(p∨¬q)=False\neg (p \lor \neg q) = \text{False} and q∧¬r=Falseq \land \neg r = \text{False}.

  2. From ¬(p∨¬q)=False\neg (p \lor \neg q) = \text{False}, we have p∨¬q=Truep \lor \neg q = \text{True}.

  3. Substitute q=Trueq = \text{True}, so ¬q=False\neg q = \text{False}, giving p∨False=Truep \lor \text{False} = \text{True}, which requires p=Truep = \text{True}.

  4. From q∧¬r=Falseq \land \neg r = \text{False}, substitute q=Trueq = \text{True} to get True∧¬r=False\text{True} \land \neg r = \text{False}, which requires ¬r=False\neg r = \text{False}, meaning r=Truer = \text{True}.

Final answer

p=Truep = \text{True} and r=Truer = \text{True}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review De Morgan's laws: ¬(A∨B)≡¬A∧¬B\neg(A \lor B) \equiv \neg A \land \neg B and ¬(A∧B)≡¬A∨¬B\neg(A \land B) \equiv \neg A \lor \neg B.

  • Practice working backwards from the top-level operator instead of expanding sub-expressions first.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Given that (A∧B)=False(A \land B) = \text{False} and A=TrueA = \text{True}, find the truth value of BB.

Answer

B=FalseB = \text{False}. Since A=TrueA = \text{True}, we have True∧B=False  ⟹  B=False\text{True} \land B = \text{False} \implies B = \text{False}.

02

A logical evaluator outputs False\text{False} for (p∧¬q)∨(q∧r)(p \land \neg q) \lor (q \land r). If q=Trueq = \text{True}, determine the truth value of rr.

Answer

r=Falser = \text{False}. A disjunction is False\text{False} only if both disjuncts are False\text{False}. Thus, q∧r=Falseq \land r = \text{False}. Since q=Trueq = \text{True}, True∧r=False  ⟹  r=False\text{True} \land r = \text{False} \implies r = \text{False}.

03

The compound statement ¬(p∧q)∧(¬p∨¬r)\neg (p \land q) \land (\neg p \lor \neg r) evaluates to True\text{True}. If p=Truep = \text{True}, determine the truth values of qq and rr.

Answer

q=Falseq = \text{False} and r=Falser = \text{False}. Both sides of the outer conjunction must be True\text{True}: (1) ¬(p∧q)=True  ⟹  p∧q=False\neg(p \land q) = \text{True} \implies p \land q = \text{False}. Since p=Truep = \text{True}, q=Falseq = \text{False}. (2) ¬p∨¬r=True  ⟹  False∨¬r=True  ⟹  ¬r=True  ⟹  r=False\neg p \lor \neg r = \text{True} \implies \text{False} \lor \neg r = \text{True} \implies \neg r = \text{True} \implies r = \text{False}.

Loading workspace…