Resources

An algebraic expression was simplified by rationalizing its binomial denominator containing square roots. The resulting simplified expression is 35+63\sqrt{5} + 6. If the numerator of the original unsimplified expression was 99, and its denominator was of the form 5−k\sqrt{5} - k where kk is a positive integer constant, determine the exact value of the original constant kk.

Answer and steps

Final answer

22

Steps

01

Set up the rationalization

To find the value of the constant kk, we examine the algebraic process of rationalizing the denominator.

The original expression has a numerator of 99 and a denominator of 5−k\sqrt{5} - k:

95−k\frac{9}{\sqrt{5} - k}

To rationalize a binomial denominator of the form a−b\sqrt{a} - b, multiply both the numerator and the denominator by its conjugate, a+b\sqrt{a} + b:

95−k⋅5+k5+k=9(5+k)(5−k)(5+k)\frac{9}{\sqrt{5} - k} \cdot \frac{\sqrt{5} + k}{\sqrt{5} + k} = \frac{9(\sqrt{5} + k)}{(\sqrt{5} - k)(\sqrt{5} + k)}

02

Analyze the structure of the simplified numerator

After multiplying out the denominator, the denominator becomes a rational scalar, which we can call DD. The expression takes the form:

9D(5+k)=(9D)5+(9D)k\frac{9}{D}(\sqrt{5} + k) = \left(\frac{9}{D}\right)\sqrt{5} + \left(\frac{9}{D}\right)k

Notice that the entire expression is a scalar multiple of the conjugate factor (5+k)(\sqrt{5} + k).

03

Compare with the simplified expression

We are given that the simplified expression is 35+63\sqrt{5} + 6.

Factor out the common scalar factor from this expression:

35+6=3(5+2)3\sqrt{5} + 6 = 3(\sqrt{5} + 2)

Equating this to the general rationalized form:

(9D)(5+k)=3(5+2)\left(\frac{9}{D}\right)(\sqrt{5} + k) = 3(\sqrt{5} + 2)

By matching the terms inside the binomial:

  • The coefficient of 5\sqrt{5} inside the parentheses is 11 in both expressions.
  • The constant term inside the parentheses gives:

k=2k = 2

Alternative Check: Ratio of Terms

We can also find kk by comparing the ratio of the constant term to the coefficient of the radical term:

  • In the rationalized form, constant termcoefficient of 5=(9D)k9D=k\dfrac{\text{constant term}}{\text{coefficient of } \sqrt{5}} = \dfrac{\left(\frac{9}{D}\right)k}{\frac{9}{D}} = k.
  • In the simplified expression 35+63\sqrt{5} + 6, the ratio is 63=2\dfrac{6}{3} = 2.

Therefore, k=2k = 2.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student cross-multiplies to solve for k but equates the rational constant terms instead of the radical coefficients.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    95−k=35+6  ⟹  9=(35+6)(5−k)\frac{9}{\sqrt{5}-k} = 3\sqrt{5}+6 \implies 9 = (3\sqrt{5}+6)(\sqrt{5}-k)

  2. Step 2

    9=15−3k5+65−6k  ⟹  9=(15−6k)+(6−3k)59 = 15 - 3k\sqrt{5} + 6\sqrt{5} - 6k \implies 9 = (15-6k) + (6-3k)\sqrt{5}

  3. Step 3

    15−6k=9  ⟹  6k=615 - 6k = 9 \implies 6k = 6

    Correct

    6−3k=0  ⟹  3k=66 - 3k = 0 \implies 3k = 6

    Because the left side 9=9+059 = 9 + 0\sqrt{5} has no radical part, the coefficient of 5\sqrt{5} on the right side must be 00, giving 6−3k=06 - 3k = 0. Equating only the rational terms led to an incorrect value.

  4. Step 4

    k=1k = 1

    Correct

    k=2k = 2

    Solving 6−3k=06 - 3k = 0 yields k=2k = 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You set up the relation between the unsimplified and simplified expressions correctly.

You expanded the product of the two binomials accurately and grouped like terms.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equated rational constant instead of radical coefficient

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When equating expressions of the form A+Bn=C+DnA + B\sqrt{n} = C + D\sqrt{n} where A,B,C,DA, B, C, D are rational and n\sqrt{n} is irrational, the radical components must match (B=DB = D). Because the left-hand side has no 5\sqrt{5} term, the coefficient of 5\sqrt{5} must vanish (6−3k=06 - 3k = 0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Matching Radical Components
  • For rational numbers a,b,c,da, b, c, d and irrational N\sqrt{N}, if a+bN=c+dNa + b\sqrt{N} = c + d\sqrt{N}, then a=ca = c and b=db = d.

  • Always check both the rational parts and the radical coefficients when solving for an unknown.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the coefficient of the irrational term 5\sqrt{5} equal to 00: 6−3k=06 - 3k = 0.

  2. Solve for kk: 3k=6  ⟹  k=23k = 6 \implies k = 2.

Final answer

k=2k = 2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how to equate rational and irrational parts in equations involving square roots.

  • Practice finding unknown coefficients by rationalizing binomial radical denominators directly.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student makes a sign error when expanding (3√5 + 6)(√5 - k), writing +3k√5 instead of -3k√5, leading to a negative value for k.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    9=(35+6)(5−k)9 = (3\sqrt{5} + 6)(\sqrt{5} - k)

  2. Step 2

    9=15+3k5+65−6k  ⟹  9=(15−6k)+(3k+6)59 = 15 + 3k\sqrt{5} + 6\sqrt{5} - 6k \implies 9 = (15 - 6k) + (3k + 6)\sqrt{5}

    Correct

    9=15−3k5+65−6k  ⟹  9=(15−6k)+(6−3k)59 = 15 - 3k\sqrt{5} + 6\sqrt{5} - 6k \implies 9 = (15 - 6k) + (6 - 3k)\sqrt{5}

    When expanding (35)⋅(−k)(3\sqrt{5}) \cdot (-k), the resulting term is −3k5-3k\sqrt{5}, but you wrote +3k5+3k\sqrt{5}.

  3. Step 3

    3k+6=0  ⟹  3k=−6  ⟹  k=−23k + 6 = 0 \implies 3k = -6 \implies k = -2

    Correct

    6−3k=0  ⟹  3k=6  ⟹  k=26 - 3k = 0 \implies 3k = 6 \implies k = 2

    Your reasoning to set the irrational coefficient to zero was sound, but solving the affected equation gave k=−2k = -2 instead of k=2k = 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You set up a clear and direct equation relating the original expression to the simplified result.

You recognized that because the left side is a rational integer, the coefficient of the radical 5\sqrt{5} on the right side must equal 00.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in binomial expansion

You accidentally treated (35)⋅(−k)(3\sqrt{5}) \cdot (-k) as positive +3k5+3k\sqrt{5} instead of negative −3k5-3k\sqrt{5}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Distributing across terms with mixed positive and negative signs led to dropping the negative sign on the radical cross-term.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Sign tracking during FOIL
  • A positive term multiplied by a negative term yields a negative term: (+a)⋅(−b)=−ab(+a) \cdot (-b) = -ab.

  • Write out the signs explicitly during intermediate expansion steps before collecting like terms.

Domain constraint check
  • The problem specifies that kk is a positive integer constant (k>0k > 0).

  • Always compare your final numerical result against stated constraints; arriving at k=−2k = -2 signals a prior sign error.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Expand the product carefully: (35+6)(5−k)=35⋅5+35⋅(−k)+6⋅5+6⋅(−k)(3\sqrt{5} + 6)(\sqrt{5} - k) = 3\sqrt{5}\cdot\sqrt{5} + 3\sqrt{5}\cdot(-k) + 6\cdot\sqrt{5} + 6\cdot(-k).

  2. Simplify the terms: 15−3k5+65−6k=(15−6k)+(6−3k)515 - 3k\sqrt{5} + 6\sqrt{5} - 6k = (15 - 6k) + (6 - 3k)\sqrt{5}.

  3. Set the coefficient of 5\sqrt{5} equal to 00: 6−3k=0  ⟹  3k=6  ⟹  k=26 - 3k = 0 \implies 3k = 6 \implies k = 2.

Final answer

k=2k = 2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice expanding binomials containing both radicals and negative terms with explicit sign tracking.

  • Perform a sanity check at the end of each problem by verifying that your solution satisfies all problem constraints, such as positivity.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student adds instead of subtracts in the difference of squares formula when rationalizing the denominator, writing (√5)² + k².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    95−k=9(5+k)(5−k)(5+k)\frac{9}{\sqrt{5} - k} = \frac{9(\sqrt{5} + k)}{(\sqrt{5} - k)(\sqrt{5} + k)}

  2. Step 2

    =95+9k5+k2= \frac{9\sqrt{5} + 9k}{5 + k^2}

    Correct

    =95+9k5−k2= \frac{9\sqrt{5} + 9k}{5 - k^2}

    When multiplying conjugate binomials, the difference of squares formula gives (a−b)(a+b)=a2−b2(a - b)(a + b) = a^2 - b^2. Here, (5−k)(5+k)=(5)2−k2=5−k2(\sqrt{5} - k)(\sqrt{5} + k) = (\sqrt{5})^2 - k^2 = 5 - k^2, not 5+k25 + k^2.

  3. Step 3

    95+9k5+k2=35+6  ⟹  95+k2=3\frac{9\sqrt{5} + 9k}{5 + k^2} = 3\sqrt{5} + 6 \implies \frac{9}{5 + k^2} = 3

    Correct

    95+9k5−k2=35+6  ⟹  95−k2=3\frac{9\sqrt{5} + 9k}{5 - k^2} = 3\sqrt{5} + 6 \implies \frac{9}{5 - k^2} = 3

    Your strategy of equating the coefficient ratio 9denominator=3\frac{9}{\text{denominator}} = 3 is sound, but this step is affected by the plus sign in the denominator.

  4. Step 4

    5+k2=3  ⟹  k2=−2  ⟹  k=25 + k^2 = 3 \implies k^2 = -2 \implies k = \sqrt{2}

    Correct

    5−k2=3  ⟹  k2=2  ⟹  k=25 - k^2 = 3 \implies k^2 = 2 \implies k = \sqrt{2} (or by equating constant terms 9k=6(5−k2)=18  ⟹  k=29k = 6(5 - k^2) = 18 \implies k = 2)

    Because of the earlier sign error, you reached an impossible equation k2=−2k^2 = -2. Notice that if the correct denominator 5−k2=35 - k^2 = 3 is used, you obtain k2=2k^2 = 2, but checking the constant term reveals an even simpler relation: comparing 3(5+2)3(\sqrt{5} + 2) with 9D(5+k)\frac{9}{D}(\sqrt{5} + k) shows directly that k=2k = 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the conjugate of 5−k\sqrt{5} - k is 5+k\sqrt{5} + k.

You correctly multiplied the numerator by the conjugate and distributed 9(5+k)=95+9k9(\sqrt{5} + k) = 9\sqrt{5} + 9k.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Difference of squares sign error

You wrote 5+k25 + k^2 instead of 5−k25 - k^2 when expanding (5−k)(5+k)(\sqrt{5} - k)(\sqrt{5} + k).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the difference of squares identity (a−b)(a+b)=a2−b2(a - b)(a + b) = a^2 - b^2 with a sum of squares, causing the radical denominator to retain an incorrect positive sign.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Difference of Squares Identity
  • (a−b)(a+b)=a2−b2(a - b)(a + b) = a^2 - b^2

  • Always verify that multiplying conjugates produces a subtraction sign between the squared terms.

Binomial Factor Matching
  • If 9D(5+k)=3(5+2)\frac{9}{D}(\sqrt{5} + k) = 3(\sqrt{5} + 2), the expressions inside the parentheses must match directly.

  • Factor out the common coefficient from the simplified expression to read the value of kk by direct comparison.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply the conjugate factors: (5−k)(5+k)=(5)2−k2=5−k2(\sqrt{5} - k)(\sqrt{5} + k) = (\sqrt{5})^2 - k^2 = 5 - k^2.

  2. Write the rationalized expression: 9(5+k)5−k2=(95−k2)(5+k)\frac{9(\sqrt{5} + k)}{5 - k^2} = \left(\frac{9}{5 - k^2}\right)(\sqrt{5} + k).

  3. Compare this with the simplified form factored as 3(5+2)3(\sqrt{5} + 2).

  4. Match the terms inside the parentheses: 5+k=5+2\sqrt{5} + k = \sqrt{5} + 2, which gives k=2k = 2.

Final answer

k=2k = 2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the conjugate product identity (a−b)(a+b)=a2−b2(a - b)(a + b) = a^2 - b^2 to ensure you always subtract the squares.

  • Try factoring out common scalars before solving systems of equations to see matching terms directly.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

If (12−4k)+(k−3)2=0(12 - 4k) + (k - 3)\sqrt{2} = 0 for a rational constant kk, find the value of kk.

Answer

k=3k = 3. Set the coefficient of 2\sqrt{2} equal to 00: k−3=0  ⟹  k=3k - 3 = 0 \implies k = 3. Notice this also satisfies 12−4(3)=012 - 4(3) = 0.

02

The expression 43−k\frac{4}{\sqrt{3} - k} simplifies upon rationalizing to a form proportional to 3+5\sqrt{3} + 5. What is the value of the positive constant kk?

Answer

k=5k = 5. Rationalizing 43−k\frac{4}{\sqrt{3}-k} requires multiplying by the conjugate 3+k\sqrt{3}+k. Since the result is proportional to 3+5\sqrt{3}+5, matching the terms gives k=5k = 5.

03

An expression A7−k\frac{A}{\sqrt{7} - k} simplifies to 27+62\sqrt{7} + 6. If kk is a positive integer, determine kk by equating the radical coefficient after multiplying both sides by 7−k\sqrt{7} - k.

Answer

k=3k = 3. Multiplying gives A=(27+6)(7−k)=(14−6k)+(6−2k)7A = (2\sqrt{7} + 6)(\sqrt{7} - k) = (14 - 6k) + (6 - 2k)\sqrt{7}. Since AA is rational, the radical coefficient must be zero: 6−2k=0  ⟹  k=36 - 2k = 0 \implies k = 3.

Loading workspace…