Resources

An optimization problem requires finding the minimum surface area of a closed rectangular shipping container with a square base of side length ss and height hh, whose volume is fixed at V=2.000×104 cm3V = 2.000 \times 10^4\text{ cm}^3. Solve for the optimal dimensions (ss and hh) in meters (mm) using: Method 1 (Single-variable differential calculus by expressing A(s)A(s)) and Method 2 (The Arithmetic Mean-Geometric Mean Inequality, AM-GM, by decomposing the terms of AA). Give ss and hh rounded to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

s=0.342 ms = 0.342\text{ m}, h=0.342 mh = 0.342\text{ m}. In metric units, V=0.0200 m3V = 0.0200\text{ m}^3. Surface area A=s2+4Vs=s2+2Vs+2Vs≥3s2⋅2Vs⋅2Vs3=34V23A = s^2 + \frac{4V}{s} = s^2 + \frac{2V}{s} + \frac{2V}{s} \ge 3 \sqrt[3]{s^2 \cdot \frac{2V}{s} \cdot \frac{2V}{s}} = 3 \sqrt[3]{4V^2}. Equality holds when s2=2Vs  ⟹  s=2V3=0.04003≈0.342 ms^2 = \frac{2V}{s} \implies s = \sqrt[3]{2V} = \sqrt[3]{0.0400} \approx 0.342\text{ m}, giving a cube of side 0.342 m0.342\text{ m}.

Steps

Unit Conversion and Geometric Relations

First, convert the given volume from cubic centimeters to cubic meters: V=2.000×104 cm3=2.000×104×(10−2 m)3=0.0200 m3V = 2.000 \times 10^4\text{ cm}^3 = 2.000 \times 10^4 \times (10^{-2}\text{ m})^3 = 0.0200\text{ m}^3

The container has a square base of side length ss and height hh. The volume is: V=s2h  ⟹  h=Vs2V = s^2 h \implies h = \frac{V}{s^2}

Substituting h=Vs2h = \frac{V}{s^2} into the surface area expression gives: A(s)=s2+4sh=s2+4VsA(s) = s^2 + 4sh = s^2 + \frac{4V}{s}


Method 1: Single-Variable Differential Calculus

  1. Find the critical points: Differentiate A(s)A(s) with respect to ss: A′(s)=dds(s2+4Vs)=2s−4Vs2A'(s) = \frac{d}{ds}\left(s^2 + \frac{4V}{s}\right) = 2s - \frac{4V}{s^2}

    Set the first derivative to zero: 2s−4Vs2=0  ⟹  2s3=4V  ⟹  s3=2V2s - \frac{4V}{s^2} = 0 \implies 2s^3 = 4V \implies s^3 = 2V s=2V3s = \sqrt[3]{2V}

  2. Verify the minimum: Compute the second derivative: A′′(s)=2+8Vs3A''(s) = 2 + \frac{8V}{s^3} Since s>0s > 0 and V>0V > 0, A′′(s)>0A''(s) > 0 for all physical dimensions, confirming that s=2V3s = \sqrt[3]{2V} corresponds to a local and global minimum.
  3. Calculate the optimal dimensions: Substitute V=0.0200 m3V = 0.0200\text{ m}^3: s=2(0.0200)3=0.04003≈0.342 ms = \sqrt[3]{2(0.0200)} = \sqrt[3]{0.0400} \approx 0.342\text{ m} The corresponding optimal height of the cubic configuration is: h=0.342 mh = 0.342\text{ m}

Method 2: The AM-GM Inequality

The Arithmetic Mean-Geometric Mean (AM-GM) inequality states that for positive real numbers a,b,ca, b, c: a+b+c3≥abc3\frac{a + b + c}{3} \ge \sqrt[3]{abc} with equality holding if and only if a=b=ca = b = c.

  1. Decompose the surface area terms: To eliminate the variable ss in the geometric mean product, split the 4Vs\frac{4V}{s} term into two equal parts: A(s)=s2+2Vs+2VsA(s) = s^2 + \frac{2V}{s} + \frac{2V}{s}
  2. Apply AM-GM to the three terms: s2+2Vs+2Vs≥3s2⋅2Vs⋅2Vs3=34V23s^2 + \frac{2V}{s} + \frac{2V}{s} \ge 3 \sqrt[3]{s^2 \cdot \frac{2V}{s} \cdot \frac{2V}{s}} = 3 \sqrt[3]{4V^2}

    The right-hand side is constant, meaning the minimum surface area is achieved when all three terms are equal: s2=2Vss^2 = \frac{2V}{s}

  3. Solve for the optimal dimension: s3=2V  ⟹  s=2V3=0.04003≈0.342 ms^3 = 2V \implies s = \sqrt[3]{2V} = \sqrt[3]{0.0400} \approx 0.342\text{ m}

Both methods yield identical optimal dimensions of s=0.342 ms = 0.342\text{ m} and h=0.342 mh = 0.342\text{ m}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats the box as an open-top container with only one square base, leading to an incorrect surface area formula and wrong optimal dimensions.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    V=s2h=20000  ⟹  h=20000s2V = s^2 h = 20000 \implies h = \frac{20000}{s^2}

  2. Step 2

    A=s2+4sh=s2+80000sA = s^2 + 4sh = s^2 + \frac{80000}{s}

    Correct

    A=2s2+4sh=2s2+4Vs=2s2+80000sA = 2s^2 + 4sh = 2s^2 + \frac{4V}{s} = 2s^2 + \frac{80000}{s}

    The problem states that the shipping container is closed, meaning it has both a bottom base and a top lid. The correct surface area is A=2s2+4shA = 2s^2 + 4sh, but your formula only includes one square base (s2s^2).

  3. Step 3

    dAds=2s−80000s2=0  ⟹  2s3=80000  ⟹  s3=40000  ⟹  s=34.2 cm=0.342 m  ⟹  h=20000(34.2)2=17.1 cm=0.171 m\frac{dA}{ds} = 2s - \frac{80000}{s^2} = 0 \implies 2s^3 = 80000 \implies s^3 = 40000 \implies s = 34.2\text{ cm} = 0.342\text{ m} \implies h = \frac{20000}{(34.2)^2} = 17.1\text{ cm} = 0.171\text{ m}

    Correct

    dAds=4s−80000s2=0  ⟹  4s3=80000  ⟹  s3=20000 cm3  ⟹  s=200003≈27.1 cm=0.271 m  ⟹  h=0.271 m\frac{dA}{ds} = 4s - \frac{80000}{s^2} = 0 \implies 4s^3 = 80000 \implies s^3 = 20000\text{ cm}^3 \implies s = \sqrt[3]{20000} \approx 27.1\text{ cm} = 0.271\text{ m} \implies h = 0.271\text{ m}

    Your calculus procedure was executed correctly on your objective function, but the numerical results were affected by the missing base in Step 2.

  4. Step 4

    A=s2+40000s+40000s  ⟹  s2=40000s  ⟹  s3=40000  ⟹  s=0.342 m,h=0.171 mA = s^2 + \frac{40000}{s} + \frac{40000}{s} \implies s^2 = \frac{40000}{s} \implies s^3 = 40000 \implies s = 0.342\text{ m}, h = 0.171\text{ m}

    Correct

    A=2s2+40000s+40000s  ⟹  2s2=40000s  ⟹  s3=20000 cm3  ⟹  s=0.271 m,h=0.271 mA = 2s^2 + \frac{40000}{s} + \frac{40000}{s} \implies 2s^2 = \frac{40000}{s} \implies s^3 = 20000\text{ cm}^3 \implies s = 0.271\text{ m}, h = 0.271\text{ m}

    Your application of the AM-GM inequality successfully split the 4Vs\frac{4V}{s} term to eliminate ss in the product, but the equality condition was affected by using s2s^2 instead of 2s22s^2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the volume constraint V=s2hV = s^2 h and isolated h=Vs2h = \frac{V}{s^2}.

You correctly computed the derivative and set it to zero to find the critical point in Method 1.

You correctly split the reciprocal term into two equal halves to eliminate the variable ss when applying the AM-GM inequality in Method 2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Missing Base in Surface Area Formulation

You wrote s2s^2 instead of 2s22s^2 in the surface area equation, leaving off the top face of the container.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking boundary specifications such as 'closed' versus 'open-top' leads to an incomplete count of faces. A closed box with a square base has 6 faces: 2 square bases (area 2s22s^2) and 4 lateral rectangular faces (area 4sh4sh).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Enumerate All Faces
  • A closed rectangular container with a square base has top and bottom bases plus four lateral walls: A=2s2+4shA = 2s^2 + 4sh. An open-top container has A=s2+4shA = s^2 + 4sh.

  • Highlight whether the container is closed or open before writing the objective function, and count the total number of faces.

Optimal Geometry for Closed Prisms
  • For a fixed volume, the surface area of a closed rectangular prism is minimized when all dimensions are equal, forming a cube (s=h=V3s = h = \sqrt[3]{V}).

  • Check if your final optimal dimensions for a closed box satisfy s=hs = h. If h=12sh = \frac{1}{2}s, you likely solved for an open-top container.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the total surface area for a closed container: A(s)=2s2+4sh=2s2+4Vs=2s2+80000s cm2A(s) = 2s^2 + 4sh = 2s^2 + \frac{4V}{s} = 2s^2 + \frac{80000}{s}\text{ cm}^2.

  2. Method 1 (Calculus): Differentiate with respect to ss: A′(s)=4s−80000s2=0  ⟹  4s3=80000  ⟹  s3=20000 cm3=0.0200 m3A'(s) = 4s - \frac{80000}{s^2} = 0 \implies 4s^3 = 80000 \implies s^3 = 20000\text{ cm}^3 = 0.0200\text{ m}^3.

  3. Method 2 (AM-GM): Decompose into three terms: A(s)=2s2+40000s+40000s≥32s2⋅40000s⋅40000s3=33.2×1093A(s) = 2s^2 + \frac{40000}{s} + \frac{40000}{s} \ge 3\sqrt[3]{2s^2 \cdot \frac{40000}{s} \cdot \frac{40000}{s}} = 3\sqrt[3]{3.2 \times 10^9}. Equality holds when 2s2=40000s  ⟹  s3=20000 cm32s^2 = \frac{40000}{s} \implies s^3 = 20000\text{ cm}^3.

  4. Solve for ss and hh in meters: s=0.0200 m33≈0.271 ms = \sqrt[3]{0.0200\text{ m}^3} \approx 0.271\text{ m}, and h=Vs2=0.0200(0.271)2≈0.271 mh = \frac{V}{s^2} = \frac{0.0200}{(0.271)^2} \approx 0.271\text{ m}.

Final answer

s=0.271 ms = 0.271\text{ m}, h=0.271 mh = 0.271\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review whether containers in 3D optimization problems are closed or open-top to ensure all faces are included.

  • Remember that minimizing the surface area of a closed rectangular box always results in a cube (s=hs = h).

  • Practice using both calculus and AM-GM on cylinder and prism optimization problems to verify your solutions.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student directly applies AM-GM to the two terms of A without splitting the lateral area term, which leaves s in the product and fails to establish an independent lower bound.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    V=s2h=20000  ⟹  h=20000s2  ⟹  A=2s2+80000sV = s^2 h = 20000 \implies h = \frac{20000}{s^2} \implies A = 2s^2 + \frac{80000}{s}

  2. Step 2

    dAds=4s−80000s2=0  ⟹  4s3=80000  ⟹  s3=20000  ⟹  s=27.1 cm=0.271 m,  h=0.271 m\frac{dA}{ds} = 4s - \frac{80000}{s^2} = 0 \implies 4s^3 = 80000 \implies s^3 = 20000 \implies s = 27.1\text{ cm} = 0.271\text{ m},\; h = 0.271\text{ m}

  3. Step 3

    2s2+80000/s2≥2s2⋅80000s\frac{2s^2 + 80000/s}{2} \ge \sqrt{2s^2 \cdot \frac{80000}{s}}

    Correct

    2s2+40000s+40000s3≥2s2⋅40000s⋅40000s3\frac{2s^2 + \frac{40000}{s} + \frac{40000}{s}}{3} \ge \sqrt[3]{2s^2 \cdot \frac{40000}{s} \cdot \frac{40000}{s}}

    To apply AM-GM to find an absolute minimum, the product of the terms in the geometric mean must be a constant independent of the variable ss. Multiplying 2s22s^2 by 80000s\frac{80000}{s} yields 160000s160000s, which still depends on ss and therefore does not provide a constant lower bound.

  4. Step 4

    2s2=80000s  ⟹  s3=40000  ⟹  s=0.342 m,  h=0.171 m2s^2 = \frac{80000}{s} \implies s^3 = 40000 \implies s = 0.342\text{ m},\; h = 0.171\text{ m}

    Correct

    2s2=40000s  ⟹  s3=20000  ⟹  s=0.271 m,  h=0.271 m2s^2 = \frac{40000}{s} \implies s^3 = 20000 \implies s = 0.271\text{ m},\; h = 0.271\text{ m}

    Because the terms were not decomposed to eliminate ss in the product, equating the two terms yielded an incorrect dimension that contradicted your Method 1 result.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the total surface area of a closed rectangular container as A(s)=2s2+80000sA(s) = 2s^2 + \frac{80000}{s}.

You executed the calculus optimization flawlessly in Method 1 to find s=h=0.271 ms = h = 0.271\text{ m}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
AM-GM Variable Elimination Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You applied AM-GM to two terms without ensuring that the powers of ss cancel to a constant in the geometric mean. Because the degrees did not balance (s2s^2 vs. s−1s^{-1}), the lateral term needed to be split into two equal parts: 40000s+40000s\frac{40000}{s} + \frac{40000}{s}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Constant Product Condition for AM-GM
  • For the minimum of ∑xi\sum x_i to occur when x1=x2=⋯=xkx_1 = x_2 = \dots = x_k, their product ∏xi\prod x_i must be independent of the variable.

  • Check the exponents: to cancel s2s^2, you must multiply by (s−1)2(s^{-1})^2, which requires splitting the 1s\frac{1}{s} term into two equal terms.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Rewrite A(s)=2s2+40000s+40000sA(s) = 2s^2 + \frac{40000}{s} + \frac{40000}{s} so the product of the three terms has power s2−1−1=s0s^{2 - 1 - 1} = s^0.

  2. Apply 3-term AM-GM: 2s2+40000s+40000s3≥2s2⋅40000s⋅40000s3=3.2×1093\frac{2s^2 + \frac{40000}{s} + \frac{40000}{s}}{3} \ge \sqrt[3]{2s^2 \cdot \frac{40000}{s} \cdot \frac{40000}{s}} = \sqrt[3]{3.2 \times 10^9}.

  3. Set the terms equal for the minimum: 2s2=40000s  ⟹  s3=200002s^2 = \frac{40000}{s} \implies s^3 = 20000.

  4. Solve for the dimensions: s=200003≈27.1 cm=0.271 ms = \sqrt[3]{20000} \approx 27.1\text{ cm} = 0.271\text{ m} and h=20000(27.1)2≈27.1 cm=0.271 mh = \frac{20000}{(27.1)^2} \approx 27.1\text{ cm} = 0.271\text{ m}.

Final answer

s=0.271 ms = 0.271\text{ m}, h=0.271 mh = 0.271\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Whenever you apply AM-GM to find an extremum, always verify that the product inside the root evaluates to a constant.

  • Compare the results of different solving methods: noticing that Method 1 and Method 2 produced different values (0.271 m0.271\text{ m} vs. 0.342 m0.342\text{ m}) provides an immediate clue to re-examine the AM-GM step.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student solves for the optimal dimensions in centimeters correctly but forgets to convert the final answers to meters as requested.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    V=s2h  ⟹  h=20000s2  ⟹  A(s)=2s2+80000sV = s^2 h \implies h = \frac{20000}{s^2} \implies A(s) = 2s^2 + \frac{80000}{s}

  2. Step 2

    A′(s)=4s−80000s2=0  ⟹  s3=20000A'(s) = 4s - \frac{80000}{s^2} = 0 \implies s^3 = 20000

  3. Step 3

    A=2s2+40000s+40000s  ⟹  2s2=40000s  ⟹  s3=20000A = 2s^2 + \frac{40000}{s} + \frac{40000}{s} \implies 2s^2 = \frac{40000}{s} \implies s^3 = 20000

  4. Step 4

    s=27.1 cm, h=27.1 cms = 27.1\text{ cm},\ h = 27.1\text{ cm}

    Correct

    s=0.271 m, h=0.271 ms = 0.271\text{ m},\ h = 0.271\text{ m}

    You solved for the numerical dimensions correctly in centimeters, but the prompt specifically asked for the optimal dimensions in meters (mm).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly formulated the surface area for a closed rectangular prism with a square base.

You accurately found the critical point using single-variable calculus.

You decomposed the surface area terms effectively to apply the AM-GM equality condition.

You correctly determined that the optimal container geometry is a cube.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unconverted target unit

You left the final answers in centimeters (extcm ext{cm}) rather than converting them to meters (extm ext{m}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You solved the entire algebraic optimization using the given centimeter values and completed the calculation without checking back against the target units specified in the prompt.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Prompt Unit Verification
  • Always circle or highlight requested final units at the start and check them right before writing your concluding line.

  • Convert linear dimensions from centimeters to meters by dividing by 100100: 27.14 cm=0.271 m27.14\text{ cm} = 0.271\text{ m}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Solve for side length ss in centimeters: s=200003≈27.144 cms = \sqrt[3]{20000} \approx 27.144\text{ cm}.

  2. Convert the linear dimensions to meters: s=27.144 cm100 cm/m≈0.271 ms = \frac{27.144\text{ cm}}{100\text{ cm/m}} \approx 0.271\text{ m}.

  3. Calculate height hh in meters: h=s=0.271 mh = s = 0.271\text{ m}.

Final answer

s=0.271 m, h=0.271 ms = 0.271\text{ m},\ h = 0.271\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Adopt a habit of underlining target units in the question before starting calculations.

  • Practice converting volume units upfront (V=2.000×104 cm3=0.0200 m3V = 2.000 \times 10^4\text{ cm}^3 = 0.0200\text{ m}^3) to avoid end-of-problem unit oversights.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A closed shipping carton with a square base of side ss and height hh must have a volume of V=64 m3V = 64\text{ m}^3. Find the dimensions ss and hh that minimize the total surface area.

Answer

s=4 ms = 4\text{ m}, h=4 mh = 4\text{ m}. Key steps: Total surface area is A=2s2+4(64)sA = 2s^2 + \frac{4(64)}{s}. Setting A′(s)=4s−256s2=0A'(s) = 4s - \frac{256}{s^2} = 0 yields s3=64  ⟹  s=4 ms^3 = 64 \implies s = 4\text{ m}. Then h=64s2=4 mh = \frac{64}{s^2} = 4\text{ m}.

02

An open-top storage bin with a square base of side ss and height hh has a fixed volume V=32 m3V = 32\text{ m}^3. Find the optimal dimensions ss and hh that minimize surface area.

Answer

s=4 ms = 4\text{ m}, h=2 mh = 2\text{ m}. Key steps: For an open top, A=s2+4sh=s2+128sA = s^2 + 4sh = s^2 + \frac{128}{s}. Split into three terms: s2+64s+64ss^2 + \frac{64}{s} + \frac{64}{s}. By AM-GM, equality requires s2=64s  ⟹  s3=64  ⟹  s=4 ms^2 = \frac{64}{s} \implies s^3 = 64 \implies s = 4\text{ m}. Then h=3242=2 mh = \frac{32}{4^2} = 2\text{ m}.

03

A closed cylindrical can has a fixed volume V=54π cm3V = 54\pi\text{ cm}^3. Use the AM-GM inequality on its total surface area A=2πr2+2πrhA = 2\pi r^2 + 2\pi rh to find the optimal radius rr and height hh.

Answer

r=3 cmr = 3\text{ cm}, h=6 cmh = 6\text{ cm}. Key steps: With h=Vπr2h = \frac{V}{\pi r^2}, A=2πr2+2Vr=2πr2+Vr+VrA = 2\pi r^2 + \frac{2V}{r} = 2\pi r^2 + \frac{V}{r} + \frac{V}{r}. By AM-GM, equality holds when 2πr2=Vr  ⟹  2πr3=V=54π  ⟹  r3=27  ⟹  r=3 cm2\pi r^2 = \frac{V}{r} \implies 2\pi r^3 = V = 54\pi \implies r^3 = 27 \implies r = 3\text{ cm}. Then h=54ππ(32)=6 cmh = \frac{54\pi}{\pi(3^2)} = 6\text{ cm} (so h=2rh = 2r).

Loading workspace…