Resources

In a physics laboratory verification of radioactive decay simulation, a discrete detector records counts per interval kk. The observed count sequence begins with C1=500C_1 = 500, C2=350C_2 = 350, C3=245C_3 = 245, and C4=171.5C_4 = 171.5. A student conjectures that the data follows a discrete geometric model Ck=C1⋅rk−1C_k = C_1 \cdot r^{k-1}. Calculate the common ratio rr, validate the model against the empirical fourth value, and determine the smallest integer interval index kk at which the detected count drops below 10.010.0.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Common ratio r=0.700r = 0.700; validated since 500×(0.7)3=171.5500 \times (0.7)^3 = 171.5; threshold reached at interval k=12k = 12 (where C11≈14.12C_{11} \approx 14.12 and C12≈9.88C_{12} \approx 9.88).

Steps

01

Determine the Common Ratio rr

For a geometric sequence Ck=C1⋅rk−1C_k = C_1 \cdot r^{k-1}, the ratio between consecutive terms must be constant:

r=C2C1=350500=0.700r = \frac{C_2}{C_1} = \frac{350}{500} = 0.700

Checking the next pair of consecutive terms confirms this ratio:

C3C2=245350=0.700\frac{C_3}{C_2} = \frac{245}{350} = 0.700

Thus, the common ratio is r=0.700r = 0.700.


02

Validate the Model Against the Fourth Empirical Value

Using the model Ck=C1⋅rk−1C_k = C_1 \cdot r^{k-1} with C1=500C_1 = 500 and r=0.7r = 0.7, we calculate the expected value for k=4k = 4:

C4=500⋅(0.7)4−1=500⋅(0.7)3C_4 = 500 \cdot (0.7)^{4 - 1} = 500 \cdot (0.7)^3

C4=500⋅0.343=171.5C_4 = 500 \cdot 0.343 = 171.5

This matches the observed count C4=171.5C_4 = 171.5 exactly, validating the geometric model.


03

Find the Smallest Interval Index kk Where Ck<10.0C_k < 10.0

Set up the inequality representing the condition where the count drops below 10.010.0:

500⋅(0.7)k−1<10.0500 \cdot (0.7)^{k-1} < 10.0

Divide both sides by 500500:

(0.7)k−1<10.0500=0.02(0.7)^{k-1} < \frac{10.0}{500} = 0.02

Take the natural logarithm of both sides. Because ln⁡(0.7)<0\ln(0.7) < 0, dividing by ln⁡(0.7)\ln(0.7) reverses the inequality sign:

(k−1)ln⁡(0.7)<ln⁡(0.02)(k-1) \ln(0.7) < \ln(0.02)

k−1>ln⁡(0.02)ln⁡(0.7)k - 1 > \frac{\ln(0.02)}{\ln(0.7)}

Evaluating the numerical values:

ln⁡(0.02)≈−3.9120,ln⁡(0.7)≈−0.3567\ln(0.02) \approx -3.9120, \quad \ln(0.7) \approx -0.3567

k−1>−3.9120−0.3567≈10.968k - 1 > \frac{-3.9120}{-0.3567} \approx 10.968

k>11.968k > 11.968

Since kk must be an integer:

  • For k=11k = 11: C11=500⋅(0.7)10≈14.12≥10.0C_{11} = 500 \cdot (0.7)^{10} \approx 14.12 \ge 10.0
  • For k=12k = 12: C12=500⋅(0.7)11≈9.88<10.0C_{12} = 500 \cdot (0.7)^{11} \approx 9.88 < 10.0

Therefore, the smallest integer interval index is k=12k = 12.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student uses k instead of k - 1 in the geometric sequence exponent, resulting in an index that is one smaller than the correct value.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    r=C2C1=350500=0.7r = \frac{C_2}{C_1} = \frac{350}{500} = 0.7

  2. Step 2

    C4=500⋅(0.7)3=171.5  ⟹  Matches empirical value 171.5, so the model is validated.C_4 = 500 \cdot (0.7)^3 = 171.5 \implies \text{Matches empirical value } 171.5, \text{ so the model is validated.}

  3. Step 3

    Ck=500⋅(0.7)k<10  ⟹  (0.7)k<0.02  ⟹  k>ln⁡(0.02)ln⁡(0.7)≈10.97C_k = 500 \cdot (0.7)^k < 10 \implies (0.7)^k < 0.02 \implies k > \frac{\ln(0.02)}{\ln(0.7)} \approx 10.97

    Correct

    500⋅(0.7)k−1<10.0  ⟹  (0.7)k−1<0.02  ⟹  k−1>ln⁡(0.02)ln⁡(0.7)≈10.97500 \cdot (0.7)^{k-1} < 10.0 \implies (0.7)^{k-1} < 0.02 \implies k - 1 > \frac{\ln(0.02)}{\ln(0.7)} \approx 10.97

    You used the exponent kk rather than k−1k - 1. Since the sequence starts at k=1k = 1 with C1=500⋅(0.7)0C_1 = 500 \cdot (0.7)^0, the exponent for interval kk must be k−1k - 1.

  4. Step 4

    k=11k = 11

    Correct

    k>11.97  ⟹  k=12k > 11.97 \implies k = 12

    Choosing 1111 was the consistent integer ceiling for your inequality k>10.97k > 10.97, but with the corrected condition k−1>10.97k - 1 > 10.97, the threshold requires k=12k = 12.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the common ratio from the first two terms.

You verified the fourth term using the correct exponent of 3.

You correctly reversed the inequality when dividing by the negative value ln⁡(0.7)\ln(0.7).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Index Shift Error in Geometric Sequence Exponent

You temporarily swapped the 1-indexed formula Ck=C1⋅rk−1C_k = C_1 \cdot r^{k-1} for the 0-indexed exponential form Ck=C0⋅rkC_k = C_0 \cdot r^k.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing a geometric sequence starting at index k=1k=1 (which uses power k−1k-1) with continuous or zero-indexed exponential decay starting at t=0t=0 (which uses power tt).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Initial Index
  • For a geometric sequence defined for k=1,2,3,…k = 1, 2, 3, \dots, the kk-th term is Ck=C1⋅rk−1C_k = C_1 \cdot r^{k-1}.

  • Verify that setting k=1k = 1 yields r0=1r^0 = 1 so that C1C_1 equals the initial recorded value.

Discrete Boundary Evaluation
  • After solving for an inequality boundary, test the candidate integer and its predecessor.

  • Calculate C11=500⋅(0.7)10≈14.12≥10C_{11} = 500 \cdot (0.7)^{10} \approx 14.12 \ge 10 and C12=500⋅(0.7)11≈9.88<10C_{12} = 500 \cdot (0.7)^{11} \approx 9.88 < 10 to confirm that interval 12 is the first to drop below 10.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the threshold inequality using the model's explicit formula: 500⋅(0.7)k−1<10.0500 \cdot (0.7)^{k-1} < 10.0.

  2. Divide by 500500: (0.7)k−1<0.02(0.7)^{k-1} < 0.02.

  3. Take the natural logarithm and divide by ln⁡(0.7)\ln(0.7) (reversing the inequality since ln⁡(0.7)<0\ln(0.7) < 0): k−1>ln⁡(0.02)ln⁡(0.7)≈10.968k - 1 > \frac{\ln(0.02)}{\ln(0.7)} \approx 10.968.

  4. Add 1 to isolate kk: k>11.968k > 11.968.

Final answer

k=12k = 12

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between 1-based indexing (an=a1rn−1a_n = a_1 r^{n-1}) and 0-based indexing (y=y0rty = y_0 r^t).

  • Practice checking boundary values by plugging candidate indices back into the original sequence formula before finalizing an answer.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to reverse the inequality sign when dividing by ln(0.7), which is negative, concluding that k must be less than 11.97 and choosing k = 11.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    r=350500=0.7  ⟹  C4=500⋅(0.7)3=171.5  ⟹  Predicted value matches empirical 171.5, validating the model.r = \frac{350}{500} = 0.7 \implies C_4 = 500 \cdot (0.7)^3 = 171.5 \implies \text{Predicted value matches empirical 171.5, validating the model.}

  2. Step 2

    500⋅(0.7)k−1<10  ⟹  (0.7)k−1<0.02  ⟹  (k−1)ln⁡(0.7)<ln⁡(0.02)500 \cdot (0.7)^{k-1} < 10 \implies (0.7)^{k-1} < 0.02 \implies (k-1) \ln(0.7) < \ln(0.02)

  3. Step 3

    k−1<ln⁡(0.02)ln⁡(0.7)≈10.97k - 1 < \frac{\ln(0.02)}{\ln(0.7)} \approx 10.97

    Correct

    k−1>ln⁡(0.02)ln⁡(0.7)≈10.97k - 1 > \frac{\ln(0.02)}{\ln(0.7)} \approx 10.97

    Because 0<0.7<10 < 0.7 < 1, its natural log is negative: ln⁡(0.7)≈−0.3567\ln(0.7) \approx -0.3567. Dividing an inequality by a negative number reverses the direction of the inequality sign from << to >>.

  4. Step 4

    k<11.97  ⟹  k=11k < 11.97 \implies k = 11

    Correct

    k>11.97  ⟹  k=12k > 11.97 \implies k = 12

    Because the inequality was not flipped, you solved for k<11.97k < 11.97 instead of k>11.97k > 11.97. The smallest integer strictly greater than 11.9711.97 is k=12k = 12.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You calculated the common ratio accurately from the observed values.

You validated the model against the fourth data point with clear mathematical justification.

You formulated the correct inequality representing the count dropping below 10.010.0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inequality Direction After Dividing by Negative Logarithm

Dividing by ln⁡(0.7)\ln(0.7) without reversing the inequality symbol.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking that ln⁡(x)<0\ln(x) < 0 whenever 0<x<10 < x < 1. Because the logarithm of a base between 0 and 1 is negative, dividing both sides of an inequality by that logarithm requires reversing the inequality sign.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Logarithm Sign Check
  • For any base argument 0<b<10 < b < 1, ln⁡(b)<0\ln(b) < 0.

  • Before dividing by ln⁡(b)\ln(b), check whether b<1b < 1. If it is, immediately flip the inequality sign.

Physical Reality Check
  • Decay models decrease over time; reaching a threshold lower than the initial count must occur at later intervals, not earlier ones.

  • Verify your result against the context: C11≈14.12≥10.0C_{11} \approx 14.12 \ge 10.0, while C12≈9.88<10.0C_{12} \approx 9.88 < 10.0, confirming k=12k = 12.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that ln⁡(0.7)≈−0.3567<0\ln(0.7) \approx -0.3567 < 0.

  2. Divide both sides by ln⁡(0.7)\ln(0.7) and reverse the inequality: k−1>ln⁡(0.02)ln⁡(0.7)k - 1 > \frac{\ln(0.02)}{\ln(0.7)}.

  3. Compute the numerical quotient: k−1>−3.9120−0.3567≈10.968k - 1 > \frac{-3.9120}{-0.3567} \approx 10.968.

  4. Add 11 to both sides: k>11.968k > 11.968.

  5. Identify the smallest integer satisfying this condition: k=12k = 12.

Final answer

The common ratio is r=0.700r = 0.700, the model is validated by 500⋅(0.7)3=171.5500 \cdot (0.7)^3 = 171.5, and the smallest integer interval index is k=12k = 12.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice checking the sign of ln⁡(x)\ln(x) whenever you solve exponential decay inequalities.

  • Always test your calculated integer boundary in the original model equation to confirm the threshold condition is truly met.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student rounds down the calculated decimal boundary of 11.97 instead of rounding up to satisfy the strict inequality, leading to k = 11.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    r=350500=0.7r = \frac{350}{500} = 0.7

  2. Step 2

    C4=500⋅(0.7)3=171.5  ⟹  Matches 171.5, model is validated.C_4 = 500 \cdot (0.7)^3 = 171.5 \implies \text{Matches } 171.5, \text{ model is validated.}

  3. Step 3

    500⋅(0.7)k−1<10  ⟹  (0.7)k−1<0.02  ⟹  k−1>ln⁡(0.02)ln⁡(0.7)≈10.97  ⟹  k>11.97500 \cdot (0.7)^{k-1} < 10 \implies (0.7)^{k-1} < 0.02 \implies k-1 > \frac{\ln(0.02)}{\ln(0.7)} \approx 10.97 \implies k > 11.97

  4. Step 4

    k=11k = 11

    Correct

    k=12k = 12

    The condition requires an integer kk strictly greater than 11.9711.97. Since 11<11.9711 < 11.97, k=11k = 11 does not satisfy the inequality; the smallest integer greater than 11.9711.97 is k=12k = 12.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the common ratio r=0.7r = 0.7.

You validated the model against the empirical fourth data point.

You properly manipulated the exponential inequality and inverted the inequality sign when dividing by ln⁡(0.7)\ln(0.7).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inequality integer boundary error

You truncated or rounded down the decimal boundary 11.9711.97 to 1111 rather than finding the smallest integer strictly greater than 11.9711.97.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing rounding to the nearest integer (or truncating) with taking the ceiling integer to satisfy a strict 'greater than' inequality (k>11.97k > 11.97).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Ceiling vs. Floor in Inequalities
  • If kk must be an integer and k>ak > a, the smallest valid integer is ⌈a⌉\lceil a \rceil, which is the next integer strictly above aa.

  • Whenever an inequality states k>decimalk > \text{decimal}, test both adjacent integers (1111 and 1212) directly in the original expression to confirm which one satisfies the condition.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the smallest integer strictly greater than 11.9711.97, which is 1212.

  2. Check k=11k = 11: C11=500⋅(0.7)10≈14.12≥10.0C_{11} = 500 \cdot (0.7)^{10} \approx 14.12 \ge 10.0 (threshold not yet passed).

  3. Check k=12k = 12: C12=500⋅(0.7)11≈9.88<10.0C_{12} = 500 \cdot (0.7)^{11} \approx 9.88 < 10.0 (first count below 10.010.0).

Final answer

Common ratio r=0.700r = 0.700; model validated since C4=171.5C_4 = 171.5; smallest integer interval is k=12k = 12.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how to select integer solutions from strict inequalities like n>cn > c versus n<cn < c.

  • Always evaluate the original sequence formula at your chosen index to double-check that it meets the threshold.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A discrete population model predicts count Pn=800⋅(0.5)n−1P_n = 800 \cdot (0.5)^{n-1} for cycle n=1,2,3,…n = 1, 2, 3, \dots. Find the smallest integer cycle nn at which the population drops below 2020.

Answer

n=7n = 7. Set 800⋅(0.5)n−1<20  ⟹  (0.5)n−1<0.025800 \cdot (0.5)^{n-1} < 20 \implies (0.5)^{n-1} < 0.025. Taking logarithms: n−1>ln⁡(0.025)ln⁡(0.5)≈5.322  ⟹  n>6.322n - 1 > \frac{\ln(0.025)}{\ln(0.5)} \approx 5.322 \implies n > 6.322, so the smallest integer is n=7n = 7.

02

An industrial cooling tank records temperatures T1=200∘CT_1 = 200^\circ\text{C}, T2=160∘CT_2 = 160^\circ\text{C}, and T3=128∘CT_3 = 128^\circ\text{C} at regular inspection intervals k=1,2,3k = 1, 2, 3. Assuming Tk=T1⋅rk−1T_k = T_1 \cdot r^{k-1}, determine rr and find the first interval index kk where the temperature drops below 50∘C50^\circ\text{C}.

Answer

r=0.8r = 0.8 and k=8k = 8. Ratio r=160200=0.8r = \frac{160}{200} = 0.8. Set 200⋅(0.8)k−1<50  ⟹  (0.8)k−1<0.25200 \cdot (0.8)^{k-1} < 50 \implies (0.8)^{k-1} < 0.25. Taking natural logs: k−1>ln⁡(0.25)ln⁡(0.8)≈6.213  ⟹  k>7.213k - 1 > \frac{\ln(0.25)}{\ln(0.8)} \approx 6.213 \implies k > 7.213, so the first integer index is k=8k = 8.

03

A signal filter attenuates power such that Sk=S1⋅(0.6)k−1S_k = S_1 \cdot (0.6)^{k-1} with initial signal S1=1250 mWS_1 = 1250\text{ mW}. An alarm triggers on the first stage kk where power falls below 5 mW5\text{ mW}. Find the alarm stage index kk, and compute the exact signal values for stage k−1k-1 and stage kk to verify the threshold crossing.

Answer

Stage k=12k = 12. Inequality: 1250⋅(0.6)k−1<5  ⟹  (0.6)k−1<0.004  ⟹  k−1>ln⁡(0.004)ln⁡(0.6)≈10.809  ⟹  k>11.8091250 \cdot (0.6)^{k-1} < 5 \implies (0.6)^{k-1} < 0.004 \implies k - 1 > \frac{\ln(0.004)}{\ln(0.6)} \approx 10.809 \implies k > 11.809, yielding k=12k = 12. Verification: S11=1250⋅(0.6)10≈7.56 mW≥5 mWS_{11} = 1250 \cdot (0.6)^{10} \approx 7.56\text{ mW} \ge 5\text{ mW}, and S12=1250⋅(0.6)11≈4.54 mW<5 mWS_{12} = 1250 \cdot (0.6)^{11} \approx 4.54\text{ mW} < 5\text{ mW}.

Loading workspace…