Resources

A rectangular solar collector has length L=(3.40±0.05) mL = (3.40 \pm 0.05)\text{ m} and width W=(1.50±0.02) mW = (1.50 \pm 0.02)\text{ m}. Calculate the area AA of the collector, along with its absolute propagated uncertainty δA\delta A assuming independent uncertainties, and state the final result with proper symbols, units, and significant figures. In addition, state the natural physical domain for both dimensions (L,W)(L, W) in set-builder notation.

Answer and steps

Final answer

A=(5.10±0.10) m2A = (5.10 \pm 0.10)\text{ m}^2; domain: {(L,W)∈R2∣L>0 and W>0}\{(L, W) \in \mathbb{R}^2 \mid L > 0 \text{ and } W > 0\}

Steps

01

Calculate the Nominal Area

The formula for the area of a rectangle is: A=L⋅WA = L \cdot W

Substitute the central values L=3.40 mL = 3.40\text{ m} and W=1.50 mW = 1.50\text{ m}: A=3.40 m⋅1.50 m=5.10 m2A = 3.40\text{ m} \cdot 1.50\text{ m} = 5.10\text{ m}^2


02

Determine the Propagated Uncertainty

When two independent physical quantities are multiplied, their fractional (relative) uncertainties add in quadrature: δAA=(δLL)2+(δWW)2\frac{\delta A}{A} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{\delta L}{L}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{\delta W}{W}\right)^2}

Calculate the relative uncertainties of each measurement: δLL=0.05 m3.40 m≈0.01471\frac{\delta L}{L} = \frac{0.05\text{ m}}{3.40\text{ m}} \approx 0.01471 δWW=0.02 m1.50 m≈0.01333\frac{\delta W}{W} = \frac{0.02\text{ m}}{1.50\text{ m}} \approx 0.01333

Combine them to find the relative uncertainty of the area: δAA=(0.01471)2+(0.01333)2≈0.0002164+0.0001777≈0.0003941≈0.01985\frac{\delta A}{A} = \sqrt{(0.01471)^2 + (0.01333)^2} \approx \sqrt{0.0002164 + 0.0001777} \approx \sqrt{0.0003941} \approx 0.01985

Multiply by the nominal area to obtain the absolute uncertainty δA\delta A: δA=5.10 m2⋅0.01985≈0.1012 m2\delta A = 5.10\text{ m}^2 \cdot 0.01985 \approx 0.1012\text{ m}^2


03

Match Significant Figures and Decimal Places

Uncertainties are generally expressed to one or two significant figures, and the nominal value must be rounded to match the precision (same decimal place) as the uncertainty:

  • The uncertainty rounds to two decimal places: δA=0.10 m2\delta A = 0.10\text{ m}^2.
  • The nominal area is reported to the same decimal place: A=5.10 m2A = 5.10\text{ m}^2.

Combining these gives: A=(5.10±0.10) m2A = (5.10 \pm 0.10)\text{ m}^2

Common Pitfall: Adding absolute uncertainties directly (δA≠W δL+L δW\delta A \neq W\,\delta L + L\,\delta W) overestimates error when uncertainties are independent and random; using root-sum-square (quadrature) is the standard method for independent errors.


04

State the Physical Domain

Physical dimensions like length and width must be strictly positive real numbers: Domain={(L,W)∈R2∣L>0 and W>0}\text{Domain} = \{(L, W) \in \mathbb{R}^2 \mid L > 0 \text{ and } W > 0\}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student adds absolute uncertainties directly instead of using error propagation in quadrature for multiplication, yielding an inflated uncertainty.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    A=3.40×1.50=5.10 m2A = 3.40 \times 1.50 = 5.10\text{ m}^2

  2. Step 2

    δA=δL+δW=0.05+0.02=0.07 m2\delta A = \delta L + \delta W = 0.05 + 0.02 = 0.07\text{ m}^2

    Correct

    δAA=(δLL)2+(δWW)2  ⟹  δA=5.10⋅(0.053.40)2+(0.021.50)2≈0.10 m2\frac{\delta A}{A} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{\delta L}{L}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{\delta W}{W}\right)^2} \implies \delta A = 5.10 \cdot \sqrt{\left(\frac{0.05}{3.40}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{0.02}{1.50}\right)^2} \approx 0.10\text{ m}^2

    When quantities are multiplied, absolute uncertainties cannot be added directly. For independent variables, relative (fractional) uncertainties add in quadrature.

  3. Step 3

    A±δA=(5.10±0.07) m2A \pm \delta A = (5.10 \pm 0.07)\text{ m}^2

    Correct

    A=(5.10±0.10) m2A = (5.10 \pm 0.10)\text{ m}^2

    Your formatting and significant figures follow standard conventions, but the value is affected by the incorrect uncertainty calculated in the previous step.

  4. Step 4

    {(L,W)∈R2∣L>0,W>0}\{(L, W) \in \mathbb{R}^2 \mid L > 0, W > 0\}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the nominal area with proper units.

You stated the physical domain accurately using standard set-builder notation.

You wrote the final combined measurement with consistent decimal places and units.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Linear addition of absolute uncertainties for multiplication

No

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the uncertainty of a product (A=L⋅WA = L \cdot W) as if it were a sum (P=L+WP = L + W), adding absolute uncertainties directly rather than adding fractional uncertainties in quadrature.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Addition vs. Multiplication Propagation
  • For Q=x±yQ = x \pm y, absolute uncertainties combine: δQ=(δx)2+(δy)2\delta Q = \sqrt{(\delta x)^2 + (\delta y)^2}. For Q=x⋅yQ = x \cdot y or Q=x/yQ = x / y, relative uncertainties combine: δQQ=(δxx)2+(δyy)2\frac{\delta Q}{Q} = \sqrt{(\frac{\delta x}{x})^2 + (\frac{\delta y}{y})^2}.

  • Identify the mathematical operation between measurements before writing the uncertainty formula.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the fractional uncertainties: δLL=0.053.40≈0.01471\frac{\delta L}{L} = \frac{0.05}{3.40} \approx 0.01471 and δWW=0.021.50≈0.01333\frac{\delta W}{W} = \frac{0.02}{1.50} \approx 0.01333.

  2. Combine them in quadrature: δAA=(0.01471)2+(0.01333)2≈0.01985\frac{\delta A}{A} = \sqrt{(0.01471)^2 + (0.01333)^2} \approx 0.01985.

  3. Multiply by nominal area A=5.10 m2A = 5.10\text{ m}^2: δA=5.10×0.01985≈0.1012 m2≈0.10 m2\delta A = 5.10 \times 0.01985 \approx 0.1012\text{ m}^2 \approx 0.10\text{ m}^2.

  4. Combine with nominal value to match precision: A=(5.10±0.10) m2A = (5.10 \pm 0.10)\text{ m}^2.

Final answer

A=(5.10±0.10) m2A = (5.10 \pm 0.10)\text{ m}^2; domain: {(L,W)∈R2∣L>0 and W>0}\{(L, W) \in \mathbb{R}^2 \mid L > 0 \text{ and } W > 0\}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the difference in error propagation between sums/differences (absolute uncertainties) and products/quotients (relative uncertainties).

  • Practice converting absolute uncertainties into fractional uncertainties before combining them for products.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student adds relative uncertainties linearly instead of combining them in quadrature for independent variables.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    A=3.40×1.50=5.10 m2A = 3.40 \times 1.50 = 5.10\text{ m}^2

  2. Step 2

    δAA=δLL+δWW=0.053.40+0.021.50  ⟹  δAA=0.0147+0.0133=0.0280\frac{\delta A}{A} = \frac{\delta L}{L} + \frac{\delta W}{W} = \frac{0.05}{3.40} + \frac{0.02}{1.50} \implies \frac{\delta A}{A} = 0.0147 + 0.0133 = 0.0280

    Correct

    δAA=(δLL)2+(δWW)2=(0.01471)2+(0.01333)2≈0.01985\frac{\delta A}{A} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{\delta L}{L}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{\delta W}{W}\right)^2} = \sqrt{(0.01471)^2 + (0.01333)^2} \approx 0.01985

    You added the relative uncertainties linearly. For independent and uncorrelated measurements, relative uncertainties add in quadrature via the square root of the sum of squares.

  3. Step 3

    δA=5.10×0.0280=0.14 m2  ⟹  A±δA=(5.10±0.14) m2\delta A = 5.10 \times 0.0280 = 0.14\text{ m}^2 \implies A \pm \delta A = (5.10 \pm 0.14)\text{ m}^2

    Correct

    δA=5.10 m2⋅0.01985≈0.10 m2  ⟹  A=(5.10±0.10) m2\delta A = 5.10\text{ m}^2 \cdot 0.01985 \approx 0.10\text{ m}^2 \implies A = (5.10 \pm 0.10)\text{ m}^2

    Your multiplication and presentation format were carried out correctly, but the numerical uncertainty was affected by adding the relative uncertainties linearly in the previous step.

  4. Step 4

    {(L,W)∈R2∣L>0,W>0}\{(L, W) \in \mathbb{R}^2 \mid L > 0, W > 0\}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the nominal area with the correct unit.

You formatted the final expression with matching decimal places and units.

You stated the natural physical domain accurately using set-builder notation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Linear vs. Quadrature Error Propagation

You used simple linear addition for relative uncertainties instead of combining them in quadrature for independent variables.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating upper-bound (worst-case) uncertainty propagation with standard statistical error propagation for independent, normally distributed random variables.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Variable Independence
  • When physical uncertainties are random and independent, errors can partially cancel out rather than always reinforcing each other.

  • Check whether the problem states or assumes independent uncertainties.

Quadrature for Products and Quotients
  • For Q=x⋅yQ = x \cdot y, independent relative uncertainties combine as δQQ=(δxx)2+(δyy)2\frac{\delta Q}{Q} = \sqrt{(\frac{\delta x}{x})^2 + (\frac{\delta y}{y})^2}.

  • Square each fractional uncertainty, sum them, and take the square root.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. δLL=0.053.40≈0.01471\frac{\delta L}{L} = \frac{0.05}{3.40} \approx 0.01471 and δWW=0.021.50≈0.01333\frac{\delta W}{W} = \frac{0.02}{1.50} \approx 0.01333

  2. δAA=(0.01471)2+(0.01333)2=0.0002164+0.0001777≈0.01985\frac{\delta A}{A} = \sqrt{(0.01471)^2 + (0.01333)^2} = \sqrt{0.0002164 + 0.0001777} \approx 0.01985

  3. δA=5.10 m2⋅0.01985≈0.1012 m2≈0.10 m2\delta A = 5.10\text{ m}^2 \cdot 0.01985 \approx 0.1012\text{ m}^2 \approx 0.10\text{ m}^2

Final answer

A=(5.10±0.10) m2A = (5.10 \pm 0.10)\text{ m}^2; domain: {(L,W)∈R2∣L>0 and W>0}\{(L, W) \in \mathbb{R}^2 \mid L > 0 \text{ and } W > 0\}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the difference between worst-case (linear) uncertainty bounds and standard statistical quadrature.

  • Practice propagating uncertainties through products and quotients using the root-sum-square formula.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 A student omits strictly positive constraints on physical length and width, writing non-negative conditions that include impossible zero dimensions.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    A=3.40×1.50=5.10 m2A = 3.40 \times 1.50 = 5.10\text{ m}^2

  2. Step 2

    δAA=(0.053.40)2+(0.021.50)2=0.01985  ⟹  δA=5.10×0.01985=0.10 m2\frac{\delta A}{A} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{0.05}{3.40}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{0.02}{1.50}\right)^2} = 0.01985 \implies \delta A = 5.10 \times 0.01985 = 0.10\text{ m}^2

  3. Step 3

    A±δA=(5.10±0.10) m2A \pm \delta A = (5.10 \pm 0.10)\text{ m}^2

  4. Step 4

    {(L,W)∈R2∣L≥0,W≥0}\{(L, W) \in \mathbb{R}^2 \mid L \ge 0, W \ge 0\}

    Correct

    {(L,W)∈R2∣L>0 and W>0}\{(L, W) \in \mathbb{R}^2 \mid L > 0 \text{ and } W > 0\}

    You used non-negative inequalities (≥\ge) rather than strict inequalities (>>). A real physical collector cannot have zero length or zero width, as that would collapse the rectangle into a line segment or point.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the nominal area with proper units.

You accurately applied error propagation in quadrature for independent variables.

You rounded the absolute uncertainty and nominal value to consistent significant figures and decimal places.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
domain-physical-constraint-error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating non-negative mathematical domains with strictly positive constraints for physical geometric quantities.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Physical Dimension Constraints
  • A physical object with spatial extent requires strictly positive dimensions (x>0x > 0), because a dimension of zero represents a degenerate object with no area or volume.

  • Inspect physical constraints carefully: use strict inequalities (>>) when zero is physically impossible or meaningless for the real-world object.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall that a physical rectangle requires both dimensions to be non-zero to possess an area.

  2. Exclude zero by replacing the non-negative inequalities with strict inequalities: L>0L > 0 and W>0W > 0.

Final answer

{(L,W)∈R2∣L>0 and W>0}\{(L, W) \in \mathbb{R}^2 \mid L > 0 \text{ and } W > 0\}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When modeling real physical objects, check whether zero is physically reachable or represents a collapsed, degenerate case.

  • Always distinguish between mathematical domains (where zero might be algebraically defined) and physical domains (where dimensions must exceed zero).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A rectangular sheet of metal has length L=(2.00±0.04) mL = (2.00 \pm 0.04)\text{ m} and width W=(1.00±0.03) mW = (1.00 \pm 0.03)\text{ m}. Calculate the area AA and its propagated uncertainty δA\delta A.

Answer

A=2.00 m×1.00 m=2.00 m2A = 2.00\text{ m} \times 1.00\text{ m} = 2.00\text{ m}^2. Relative uncertainties: δLL=0.042.00=0.02\frac{\delta L}{L} = \frac{0.04}{2.00} = 0.02, δWW=0.031.00=0.03\frac{\delta W}{W} = \frac{0.03}{1.00} = 0.03. δAA=0.022+0.032=0.0004+0.0009=0.0013≈0.03606\frac{\delta A}{A} = \sqrt{0.02^2 + 0.03^2} = \sqrt{0.0004 + 0.0009} = \sqrt{0.0013} \approx 0.03606. δA=2.00×0.03606≈0.072 m2≈0.07 m2\delta A = 2.00 \times 0.03606 \approx 0.072\text{ m}^2 \approx 0.07\text{ m}^2. Final result: A=(2.00±0.07) m2A = (2.00 \pm 0.07)\text{ m}^2.

02

The perimeter of the same rectangular sheet (L=2.00±0.04 mL = 2.00 \pm 0.04\text{ m}, W=1.00±0.03 mW = 1.00 \pm 0.03\text{ m}) is given by P=2L+2WP = 2L + 2W. Calculate PP and its absolute uncertainty δP\delta P, assuming independent uncertainties.

Answer

Nominal perimeter: P=2(2.00)+2(1.00)=6.00 mP = 2(2.00) + 2(1.00) = 6.00\text{ m}. For sums with constants P=2L+2WP = 2L + 2W, absolute uncertainties add in quadrature: δP=(2 δL)2+(2 δW)2=(2×0.04)2+(2×0.03)2=0.082+0.062=0.0064+0.0036=0.10 m\delta P = \sqrt{(2\,\delta L)^2 + (2\,\delta W)^2} = \sqrt{(2 \times 0.04)^2 + (2 \times 0.03)^2} = \sqrt{0.08^2 + 0.06^2} = \sqrt{0.0064 + 0.0036} = 0.10\text{ m}. Final result: P=(6.00±0.10) mP = (6.00 \pm 0.10)\text{ m}.

03

A student calculates the density ρ=mV\rho = \frac{m}{V} of a block with mass m=(120.0±1.2) gm = (120.0 \pm 1.2)\text{ g} and volume V=(40.0±0.8) cm3V = (40.0 \pm 0.8)\text{ cm}^3. Find ρ±δρ\rho \pm \delta \rho with appropriate units and significant figures.

Answer

Nominal density: ρ=120.040.0=3.00 g/cm3\rho = \frac{120.0}{40.0} = 3.00\text{ g/cm}^3. Relative uncertainties: δmm=1.2120.0=0.010\frac{\delta m}{m} = \frac{1.2}{120.0} = 0.010, δVV=0.840.0=0.020\frac{\delta V}{V} = \frac{0.8}{40.0} = 0.020. Combined relative uncertainty: δρρ=(0.010)2+(0.020)2=0.0001+0.0004=0.0005≈0.02236\frac{\delta \rho}{\rho} = \sqrt{(0.010)^2 + (0.020)^2} = \sqrt{0.0001 + 0.0004} = \sqrt{0.0005} \approx 0.02236. Absolute uncertainty: δρ=3.00×0.02236≈0.067 g/cm3≈0.07 g/cm3\delta \rho = 3.00 \times 0.02236 \approx 0.067\text{ g/cm}^3 \approx 0.07\text{ g/cm}^3. Final result: ρ=(3.00±0.07) g/cm3\rho = (3.00 \pm 0.07)\text{ g/cm}^3.

Loading workspace…