Resources

A civil engineer models the trajectory of a water droplet ejected from a high-pressure agricultural irrigation nozzle placed 1.5 m1.5\text{ m} above horizontal ground. The height yy (in meters) as a function of horizontal distance xx (in meters) is modeled by the quadratic equation y=−0.05x2+1.2x+1.5y = -0.05x^2 + 1.2x + 1.5. (a) Find the two horizontal roots of the equation y=0y = 0 to three significant figures. (b) Explain why the negative mathematical root must be discarded in the physical context, and interpret what the positive root represents for positioning crops in the field.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) x≈−1.19 mx \approx -1.19\text{ m} and x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m}; (b) The negative root x≈−1.19 mx \approx -1.19\text{ m} is mathematically extraneous because the nozzle discharges water strictly in the forward direction (x≥0x \ge 0); the positive root x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m} represents the maximum horizontal ground spray range, indicating crops planted beyond 25.2 m25.2\text{ m} from the sprinkler head will receive no direct irrigation.

Steps

Part (a): Finding the Horizontal Roots

To find the horizontal roots where the droplet reaches ground level, set the height yy to 00:

−0.05x2+1.2x+1.5=0-0.05x^2 + 1.2x + 1.5 = 0

For ease of calculation, multiply the entire equation by −20-20 to make the leading coefficient 11:

x2−24x−30=0x^2 - 24x - 30 = 0

Apply the quadratic formula, x=−b±b2−4ac2ax = \dfrac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a}, with a=1a = 1, b=−24b = -24, and c=−30c = -30:

x=−(−24)±(−24)2−4(1)(−30)2(1)x = \dfrac{-(-24) \pm \sqrt{(-24)^2 - 4(1)(-30)}}{2(1)}

x=24±576+1202=24±6962=12±174x = \dfrac{24 \pm \sqrt{576 + 120}}{2} = \dfrac{24 \pm \sqrt{696}}{2} = 12 \pm \sqrt{174}

Evaluate the square root: 174≈13.191\sqrt{174} \approx 13.191

Calculate each root to three significant figures:

  • x1=12−13.191=−1.191≈−1.19 mx_1 = 12 - 13.191 = -1.191 \approx -1.19\text{ m}
  • x2=12+13.191=25.191≈25.2 mx_2 = 12 + 13.191 = 25.191 \approx 25.2\text{ m}

Part (b): Physical Interpretation and Context

  1. Rejection of the Negative Root:

    • The irrigation nozzle is positioned at x=0x = 0 and height y=1.5 my = 1.5\text{ m}, discharging water exclusively in the forward direction (x≥0x \ge 0).
    • The negative root x≈−1.19 mx \approx -1.19\text{ m} lies behind the nozzle. It represents a hypothetical point where the parabolic trajectory would have emerged from the ground had the water originated behind the sprinkler, making it physically impossible and extraneous in this context.
  2. Significance of the Positive Root:

    • The positive root x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m} represents the maximum horizontal distance the spray reaches before striking the ground.
    • In practical terms for crop management, this defines the coverage boundary: crops must be planted within a radius of 25.2 m25.2\text{ m} from the nozzle to receive direct irrigation, while any crops planted beyond 25.2 m25.2\text{ m} will not be reached by this sprinkler.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets the negative sign in the denominator 2a when applying the quadratic formula, leading to inverted signs for both roots.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    −0.05x2+1.2x+1.5=0  ⟹  a=−0.05,b=1.2,c=1.5-0.05x^2 + 1.2x + 1.5 = 0 \implies a = -0.05, b = 1.2, c = 1.5

  2. Step 2

    x=−1.2±1.44−4(−0.05)(1.5)2(0.05)  ⟹  x=−1.2±1.740.1  ⟹  x=−1.2±1.3190.1x = \frac{-1.2 \pm \sqrt{1.44 - 4(-0.05)(1.5)}}{2(0.05)} \implies x = \frac{-1.2 \pm \sqrt{1.74}}{0.1} \implies x = \frac{-1.2 \pm 1.319}{0.1}

    Correct

    x=−1.2±1.44−4(−0.05)(1.5)2(−0.05)=−1.2±1.74−0.1≈−1.2±1.319−0.1x = \frac{-1.2 \pm \sqrt{1.44 - 4(-0.05)(1.5)}}{2(-0.05)} = \frac{-1.2 \pm \sqrt{1.74}}{-0.1} \approx \frac{-1.2 \pm 1.319}{-0.1}

    You omitted the negative sign in the denominator when substituting a=−0.05a = -0.05. The denominator is 2a=2(−0.05)=−0.12a = 2(-0.05) = -0.1, not 0.10.1.

  3. Step 3

    x=1.19 or x=−25.2x = 1.19 \text{ or } x = -25.2

    Correct

    x≈−1.19 m or x≈25.2 mx \approx -1.19\text{ m} \text{ or } x \approx 25.2\text{ m}

    Because of the missing negative sign in the denominator in the previous step, your roots have their signs inverted.

  4. Step 4

    Distance cannot be negative, so discard x=−25.2 m. The positive root x=1.19 m is the landing distance where crops can receive water.\text{Distance cannot be negative, so discard } x = -25.2\text{ m}. \text{ The positive root } x = 1.19\text{ m} \text{ is the landing distance where crops can receive water.}

    Correct

    Discard the negative root x≈−1.19 m because water is ejected forward (x≥0); the positive root x≈25.2 m represents the maximum spray range for irrigating crops.\text{Discard the negative root } x \approx -1.19\text{ m} \text{ because water is ejected forward } (x \ge 0); \text{ the positive root } x \approx 25.2\text{ m} \text{ represents the maximum spray range for irrigating crops.}

    Your physical reasoning—that horizontal distance along the spray trajectory must be non-negative and that the positive root gives the landing distance—is sound, but it was applied to the inverted roots from part (a).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly translated the physical condition of hitting the ground into setting y=0y = 0.

You accurately identified the quadratic coefficients aa, bb, and cc.

You calculated the discriminant Δ=b2−4ac=1.74\Delta = b^2 - 4ac = 1.74 and its square root ≈1.319\approx 1.319 correctly.

You understood the physical principle that negative horizontal distance is extraneous for forward irrigation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in quadratic formula denominator

You substituted 0.050.05 instead of −0.05-0.05 into 2a2a, writing 2(0.05)=0.12(0.05) = 0.1 in the denominator.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the leading negative sign of the quadratic coefficient aa when evaluating the denominator 2a2a, which negates the entire quotient and flips the signs of both resulting roots.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Denominator Sign Check
  • In the quadratic formula x=−b±b2−4ac2ax = \frac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a}, the denominator carries the sign of aa.

  • Always write parentheses around negative coefficients when substituting: 2(a)=2(−0.05)=−0.12(a) = 2(-0.05) = -0.1.

Sanity Check with the Physical Model
  • A water nozzle at (0,1.5)(0, 1.5) spraying outward and downward must travel forward a significant horizontal distance before hitting y=0y = 0.

  • Check if a range of 1.19 m1.19\text{ m} makes sense for an upward velocity component of +1.2x+1.2x; with a positive initial slope, the droplet must land much farther than 1.19 m1.19\text{ m}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute a=−0.05a = -0.05, b=1.2b = 1.2, and c=1.5c = 1.5 with proper signs: x=−1.2±1.22−4(−0.05)(1.5)2(−0.05)x = \frac{-1.2 \pm \sqrt{1.2^2 - 4(-0.05)(1.5)}}{2(-0.05)}.

  2. Simplify numerator and denominator: x=−1.2±1.74−0.1≈−1.2±1.3191−0.1x = \frac{-1.2 \pm \sqrt{1.74}}{-0.1} \approx \frac{-1.2 \pm 1.3191}{-0.1}.

  3. Calculate both roots: x1=−1.2+1.3191−0.1=0.1191−0.1≈−1.19 mx_1 = \frac{-1.2 + 1.3191}{-0.1} = \frac{0.1191}{-0.1} \approx -1.19\text{ m} and x2=−1.2−1.3191−0.1=−2.5191−0.1≈25.2 mx_2 = \frac{-1.2 - 1.3191}{-0.1} = \frac{-2.5191}{-0.1} \approx 25.2\text{ m}.

  4. Interpret physically: Discard x≈−1.19 mx \approx -1.19\text{ m} since water sprays forward (x≥0x \ge 0). The positive root x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m} is the landing point, meaning crops must be planted within 25.2 m25.2\text{ m} of the nozzle to receive direct irrigation.

Final answer

(a) x≈−1.19 mx \approx -1.19\text{ m} and x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m}; (b) Discard x≈−1.19 mx \approx -1.19\text{ m} as it lies behind the nozzle (x<0x < 0); x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m} marks the outer coverage limit of the sprinkler.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice substituting negative leading coefficients into the quadratic formula using explicit parentheses around 2(a)2(a).

  • Perform a physical sanity check on trajectory problems: compare the vertex horizontal position xv=−b2ax_v = -\frac{b}{2a} to the landing distance to ensure the positive landing root is greater than the apex.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student subtracts instead of adding in the discriminant formula because of a sign error with 4ac, obtaining an incorrect radicand.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    −0.05x2+1.2x+1.5=0  ⟹  x=−1.2±1.22−4(−0.05)(1.5)2(−0.05)-0.05x^2 + 1.2x + 1.5 = 0 \implies x = \frac{-1.2 \pm \sqrt{1.2^2 - 4(-0.05)(1.5)}}{2(-0.05)}

  2. Step 2

    x=−1.2±1.44−0.30−0.1  ⟹  x=−1.2±1.14−0.1x = \frac{-1.2 \pm \sqrt{1.44 - 0.30}}{-0.1} \implies x = \frac{-1.2 \pm \sqrt{1.14}}{-0.1}

    Correct

    x=−1.2±1.44+0.30−0.1  ⟹  x=−1.2±1.74−0.1x = \frac{-1.2 \pm \sqrt{1.44 + 0.30}}{-0.1} \implies x = \frac{-1.2 \pm \sqrt{1.74}}{-0.1}

    When simplifying −4ac=−4(−0.05)(1.5)-4ac = -4(-0.05)(1.5), the two negative signs multiply to give +0.30+0.30. You wrote −0.30-0.30, giving an incorrect radicand of 1.141.14 instead of 1.741.74.

  3. Step 3

    x=−1.2±1.068−0.1  ⟹  x=1.32 or x=22.7x = \frac{-1.2 \pm 1.068}{-0.1} \implies x = 1.32 \text{ or } x = 22.7

    Correct

    x=−1.2±1.319−0.1  ⟹  x≈−1.19 m or x≈25.2 mx = \frac{-1.2 \pm 1.319}{-0.1} \implies x \approx -1.19 \text{ m} \text{ or } x \approx 25.2 \text{ m}

    You evaluated your formula correctly based on 1.14≈1.068\sqrt{1.14} \approx 1.068, but the values are shifted because of the earlier discriminant error.

  4. Step 4

    "The root x=1.32 mx = 1.32\text{ m} is discarded because the water must travel further away from the nozzle. The positive root x=22.7 mx = 22.7\text{ m} represents the maximum horizontal distance where the water reaches the ground."

    Correct

    "The negative root x≈−1.19 mx \approx -1.19\text{ m} is discarded because it lies behind the nozzle (x<0x < 0), where water does not travel. The positive root x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m} represents the maximum horizontal distance, meaning crops planted beyond 25.2 m25.2\text{ m} receive no direct spray."

    Because your calculation yielded two positive roots, you discarded x=1.32 mx = 1.32\text{ m} without addressing the expected negative root behind the nozzle. You correctly interpreted the larger root as the maximum horizontal ground reach, though you did not connect it specifically to crop positioning.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up the quadratic equation y=0y = 0 to find the ground-level landing distances.

You correctly recalled and substituted the coefficients into the quadratic formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in discriminant calculation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked that the product of two negative values, −4-4 and a=−0.05a = -0.05, yields a positive term +0.20+0.20, which when multiplied by c=1.5c = 1.5 gives +0.30+0.30. This sign error changed b2−4acb^2 - 4ac from an addition into a subtraction, altering the nature of the roots.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Track negative factors in $-4ac$
  • In b2−4acb^2 - 4ac, count the total number of negative signs across the subtraction and the coefficients aa and cc: an odd count yields a minus, while an even count yields a plus.

  • Here, −4-4 (negative) and a=−0.05a = -0.05 (negative) make two negative signs, so −4ac=+0.30-4ac = +0.30.

Sanity-check physical roots against the scenario
  • A projectile launched from an initial elevation y0>0y_0 > 0 with downward curvature (a<0a < 0) must produce one negative root (behind launch) and one positive root (downrange).

  • If you obtain two positive roots, immediately re-verify the signs in your discriminant and denominator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate the discriminant with the corrected sign: b2−4ac=1.22−4(−0.05)(1.5)=1.44+0.30=1.74b^2 - 4ac = 1.2^2 - 4(-0.05)(1.5) = 1.44 + 0.30 = 1.74.

  2. Take the square root: 1.74≈1.3191\sqrt{1.74} \approx 1.3191.

  3. Compute the two roots: x=−1.2±1.3191−0.1x = \frac{-1.2 \pm 1.3191}{-0.1}, yielding x1=−1.2+1.3191−0.1=0.1191−0.1≈−1.19 mx_1 = \frac{-1.2 + 1.3191}{-0.1} = \frac{0.1191}{-0.1} \approx -1.19\text{ m} and x2=−1.2−1.3191−0.1=−2.5191−0.1≈25.2 mx_2 = \frac{-1.2 - 1.3191}{-0.1} = \frac{-2.5191}{-0.1} \approx 25.2\text{ m}.

  4. Explain in context: Discard x≈−1.19 mx \approx -1.19\text{ m} because the nozzle sprays forward (x≥0x \ge 0). The positive root x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m} is the maximum reach, so crops placed beyond 25.2 m25.2\text{ m} will not be irrigated.

Final answer

(a) x≈−1.19 mx \approx -1.19\text{ m} and x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m}; (b) The negative root x≈−1.19 mx \approx -1.19\text{ m} is physically impossible because water travels only forward from x=0x = 0; the positive root x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m} marks the maximum spray boundary, meaning crops must be planted within 25.2 m25.2\text{ m} of the nozzle to receive water.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out −4ac-4ac in parentheses, e.g., −[4(−0.05)(1.5)]-[4(-0.05)(1.5)], to carefully count and resolve the negative signs.

  • Whenever an object launches above ground level (c>0c > 0) with downward gravity/curvature (a<0a < 0), expect exactly one positive root and one negative root.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets the positive root as the location of the vertex or highest spray height rather than the landing distance on the ground.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    −0.05x2+1.2x+1.5=0  ⟹  x=−1.2±1.44−4(−0.05)(1.5)−0.1  ⟹  x=−1.2±1.74−0.1  ⟹  x=−1.2±1.319−0.1  ⟹  x=−1.19 or x=25.2-0.05x^2 + 1.2x + 1.5 = 0 \implies x = \frac{-1.2 \pm \sqrt{1.44 - 4(-0.05)(1.5)}}{-0.1} \implies x = \frac{-1.2 \pm \sqrt{1.74}}{-0.1} \implies x = \frac{-1.2 \pm 1.319}{-0.1} \implies x = -1.19 \text{ or } x = 25.2

  2. Step 2

    The negative root x=−1.19 mx = -1.19\text{ m} is discarded because negative distance behind the nozzle has no physical meaning.

  3. Step 3

    The positive root x=25.2 mx = 25.2\text{ m} indicates the horizontal position where the water reaches its maximum height above the crops.

    Correct

    The positive root x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m} indicates where the water droplet hits the ground (y=0y = 0), representing the maximum horizontal irrigation distance. Crops must be planted within 25.2 m25.2\text{ m} from the nozzle to receive water.

    You confused the horizontal root (y=0y = 0, where the trajectory meets the ground) with the parabola's vertex (where yy attains its maximum height). Since y=0y = 0 defines ground level, x=25.2 mx = 25.2\text{ m} is where the water lands.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You set up and evaluated the quadratic formula with complete arithmetic precision.

You gave both mathematical roots rounded correctly to three significant figures.

You correctly justified rejecting the negative root based on the physical position of the nozzle.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Root vs. Vertex Misinterpretation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the condition y=0y = 0 (the horizontal intercept / ground level) with the vertex condition (the maximum height of the trajectory).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Variable Meaning Check
  • The equation y=0y = 0 represents the height when an object reaches ground level, not its maximum elevation.

  • Always re-read the definition of the dependent variable: here yy is height, so setting y=0y = 0 finds where height is zero (ground impact).

Vertex vs. Intercept Distinction
  • Maximum height occurs at the parabola's vertex (x=−b2ax = -\frac{b}{2a}), whereas roots (y=0y = 0) represent landing or ground contact.

  • To find where maximum height occurs, locate the axis of symmetry x=−b2ax = -\frac{b}{2a}; do not confuse it with the horizontal roots.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall that yy measures height above the ground, so solving y=0y = 0 gives the horizontal position where the water droplet returns to ground level (y=0y = 0).

  2. Therefore, x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m} marks the maximum horizontal distance the spray travels before hitting the ground.

  3. In the farming context, this establishes the irrigation boundary: crops planted within 25.2 m25.2\text{ m} of the nozzle will receive water, while crops placed beyond 25.2 m25.2\text{ m} will remain dry.

Final answer

(a) x≈−1.19 mx \approx -1.19\text{ m} and x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m}; (b) The negative root is discarded because the nozzle only sprays forward (x≥0x \ge 0). The positive root x≈25.2 mx \approx 25.2\text{ m} represents the maximum horizontal distance where water strikes the ground, so crops must be planted within 25.2 m25.2\text{ m} of the nozzle to receive direct spray.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how key geometric features of a parabola (intercepts vs. vertex) translate to real-world measurements like landing distance versus peak altitude.

  • Practice sketching trajectory parabolas with axes labeled with units to visually verify the meaning of roots and the vertex before writing interpretations.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A fountain nozzle at ground level shoots water along the path y=−0.2x2+1.8xy = -0.2x^2 + 1.8x, where xx and yy are in meters. Find the horizontal distance where the water returns to ground level (y=0y = 0).

Answer

9 m9\text{ m}. Set −0.2x2+1.8x=0  ⟹  x(−0.2x+1.8)=0-0.2x^2 + 1.8x = 0 \implies x(-0.2x + 1.8) = 0. The roots are x=0x = 0 (nozzle launch) and x=−1.8−0.2=9 mx = \frac{-1.8}{-0.2} = 9\text{ m}.

02

A projectile is launched from a platform 2 m2\text{ m} above the ground with trajectory y=−0.1x2+x+2y = -0.1x^2 + x + 2. Find both mathematical roots of y=0y = 0 to three significant figures, and identify which root represents the landing position.

Answer

Roots: x≈−1.71 mx \approx -1.71\text{ m} and x≈11.7 mx \approx 11.7\text{ m}; landing position: x≈11.7 mx \approx 11.7\text{ m}. Using x=−1±1−4(−0.1)(2)2(−0.1)=−1±1.8−0.2x = \frac{-1 \pm \sqrt{1 - 4(-0.1)(2)}}{2(-0.1)} = \frac{-1 \pm \sqrt{1.8}}{-0.2}, the roots are −1+1.3416−0.2≈−1.71\frac{-1 + 1.3416}{-0.2} \approx -1.71 and −1−1.3416−0.2≈11.7\frac{-1 - 1.3416}{-0.2} \approx 11.7.

03

An industrial sprayer follows the model y=−0.04x2+0.6x+2.5y = -0.04x^2 + 0.6x + 2.5. A barrier is placed at horizontal distance x=18 mx = 18\text{ m}. By finding the ground landing distance (where y=0y = 0), determine whether the spray clears the ground before or after the barrier.

Answer

After the barrier, at x≈18.5 mx \approx 18.5\text{ m}. Solving −0.04x2+0.6x+2.5=0-0.04x^2 + 0.6x + 2.5 = 0: x=−0.6±0.36−4(−0.04)(2.5)2(−0.04)=−0.6±0.76−0.08=−0.6±0.8718−0.08x = \frac{-0.6 \pm \sqrt{0.36 - 4(-0.04)(2.5)}}{2(-0.04)} = \frac{-0.6 \pm \sqrt{0.76}}{-0.08} = \frac{-0.6 \pm 0.8718}{-0.08}. The positive root is x≈18.5 mx \approx 18.5\text{ m}, so the water reaches the ground beyond the 18 m18\text{ m} barrier.

Loading workspace…