Resources
An introductory physics student solves a coupled system: a block of mass rests on a frictionless horizontal tabletop and is connected via a light string passing over a massless, frictionless pulley to a hanging mass . The student computes the system acceleration and string tension . (a) Explicitly state the two idealized mechanical assumptions made concerning the string and the pulley. (b) Couple rotational dynamics to this system: if the pulley is instead a solid uniform disk of mass and radius (moment of inertia ) where the cord does not slip, calculate the true acceleration and explain why the original single tension assumption fails.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) The string is assumed to be perfectly massless and inextensible (maintaining uniform tension along its entire length), and the pulley is assumed to be massless and frictionless (requiring zero torque to undergo angular acceleration). (b) Setting up the coupled equations , , and yields . The single-tension assumption fails because a net torque is required to accelerate the rotational inertia of the real pulley, forcing .
Steps
Write Newton's Second Law for Each Component
Part (a): Identifying the Idealized Assumptions
In the simplified introductory model, two major mechanical idealizations are made:
- Assumptions about the string:
The string is assumed to be massless and inextensible (it does not stretch).- A massless string ensures that no force is needed to accelerate the string itself, which keeps the tension magnitude uniform along any straight section.
- Inextensibility ensures that both masses experience the exact same linear acceleration .
- Assumptions about the pulley:
The pulley is assumed to be massless (or having negligible moment of inertia, ) and frictionless at its axle.- Because the pulley has zero rotational inertia, it requires zero net torque () to spin and accelerate, allowing the tension on either side of the pulley to be identical ().
Part (b): Coupled Rotational Dynamics and Acceleration
When the pulley has a non-zero mass and rotational inertia , the tension is no longer uniform across the pulley. Let:
- be the tension in the horizontal segment acting on mass ,
- be the tension in the vertical segment acting on mass .
- Horizontal block ():
- Hanging block ():
- Pulley (rotational motion about the axle):
Assuming the cord does not slip, the angular acceleration of the pulley is related to the linear acceleration by . The net torque rotating the pulley clockwise is:
Combine the Equations
Substitute and into the torque equation:
Dividing both sides by :
Now add all three dynamic equations to eliminate internal tensions and :
T_1 &= m_1 a \\ (T_2 - T_1) &= \frac{1}{2}M a \\ m_2 g - T_2 &= m_2 a \end{aligned}$$Summing the left-hand sides and right-hand sides:
Compute the Coupled Acceleration
Solve for the linear acceleration :
Substitute the given numerical values (, , , and ):
Why the Single-Tension Assumption Fails
In the ideal system, setting implies a net torque of . However, a massive pulley possesses rotational inertia (). To undergo angular acceleration as the system speeds up, it must experience a net torque: Because part of the downward driving force of gravity on is consumed to provide this net torque, must be strictly greater than , invalidating the single-tension model.
Typical errors
01 The student forgets the factor of 1/2 in the moment of inertia or treats the pulley as adding its full mass M directly to the linear inertia of the system.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The string is massless and inextensible. The pulley is frictionless and has zero mass.
- Step 2Correct
You set the tension difference equal to instead of . Because the pulley is a uniform solid disk, its moment of inertia is , so the net torque equation gives .
- Step 3Correct
Your algebra and numerical calculation followed consistently from your torque equation, but the missing factor of propagated into an effective mass of instead of .
- Step 4
The tensions must differ because a net torque is needed to accelerate the massive pulley.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou stated both idealized assumptions regarding the massless, inextensible string and the massless, frictionless pulley with complete accuracy.
You correctly set up Newton's second law for both translating blocks.
You provided a solid conceptual explanation of why non-zero rotational inertia breaks the single-tension assumption.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the pulley's rotational inertia as equivalent to a point mass at the rim () rather than incorporating the geometric shape factor of a uniform solid disk ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Rotational Inertia to Effective Linear Mass
For non-slipping rotation, the effective inertia contributed by a rotating body is . For a solid cylinder/disk, .
Always write out with and explicitly before canceling .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the torque balance about the fixed axle: .
Substitute the disk's moment of inertia and the no-slip condition : .
Divide by to obtain the correct tension difference: .
Add the equations: .
Compute the numerical value: .
02 The student assumes the tension is still uniform across the pulley, setting T1 = T2 and neglecting the torque needed to rotate the pulley.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
, , and
Because the pulley has mass and rotational inertia , rotating it with angular acceleration requires a net torque . Therefore, the tension on the hanging side () must be greater than the tension on the horizontal side ().
- Step 3Correct
This numerical value is affected by omitting the pulley's rotational inertia term from the effective system mass in the denominator.
- Step 4Correct
The single-tension assumption fails because accelerating the pulley's moment of inertia requires a net torque, , forcing even with a frictionless axle.
Axle friction is not required for tensions to differ during acceleration. Even with zero axle friction, non-zero rotational inertia () demands a torque difference whenever .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recalled that an idealized introductory string is massless and inextensible.
You correctly stated that an idealized pulley is treated as massless and frictionless.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou reused the massless pulley equations for part (b) instead of introducing distinct tensions and and setting up the torque equation .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating rotational inertia with axle friction. You assumed that tension can only differ across a pulley if energy is lost to friction, overlooking Newton's second law for rotation (), which requires unequal tensions whenever an inertia-bearing pulley undergoes angular acceleration.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Unequal Tensions Across a Real Pulley
If a pulley has mass () and accelerates angularly, the cord tensions on opposite sides must be unequal: .
Always define distinct tension variables ( and ) on either side of any pulley that has rotational inertia.
- No-Slip Tangential Coupling
For a cord that rolls without slipping over a disk of radius , the linear and angular accelerations are coupled by .
Substitute and into to get .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite Newton's second law for mass : .
Write Newton's second law for mass : .
Apply rotational dynamics to the pulley: .
Add all three equations to eliminate the tensions: .
Solve for : .
; because a net torque is required to angularly accelerate the pulley's rotational inertia.
03 The student subtracts rather than adds the pulley's rotational inertia term in the effective mass denominator.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The string is massless and inextensible. The pulley has no friction and zero mass.
- Step 2Correct
You subtracted the pulley's rotational inertia term instead of adding it. Adding the three equations of motion (, , and ) yields because the pulley's inertia adds resistance to acceleration.
- Step 3Correct
Your arithmetic correctly followed your equation from Step 2, but the numerical result is too large due to the negative sign in the denominator. A real pulley must slow the system down below , not speed it up.
- Step 4
Tension must be different to provide a net torque for rotation.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly stated the physical assumptions regarding the massless, inextensible string and frictionless, massless pulley.
You correctly identified that the tension must differ across the pulley to produce a net torque.
You accurately carried out your numerical calculations based on your written formula.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the pulley's rotational inertia as a reduction in system inertia rather than recognizing that rotating a massive object requires extra torque and adds an equivalent linear mass to the denominator.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- System Inertia Check
Every accelerating part of a coupled system adds to the total effective inertia in .
Always add positive mass-equivalent terms: .
- Physical Reality Check
Adding mass or rotational inertia to an existing machine must decrease the acceleration if the driving force is unchanged.
Compare your answer to the ideal acceleration: must always hold.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the torque equation relating tensions to angular acceleration: , giving .
Add this to the linear equations and : .
Substitute the numerical values: .
Divide to find the final value: .
Lock it in
How does a rotating pulley of moment of inertia and radius contribute to the total equivalent linear inertia of an accelerating system without cord slip?
It adds an effective mass of to the denominator of the acceleration formula.
Similar question
A mass hangs vertically from a light cord wrapped around a fixed-axle uniform solid disk pulley of mass and radius . Assuming no cord slippage and , find the linear downward acceleration of the mass.
Answer
. Equations: and . Summing yields , so .
In a modified Atwood machine, block of mass sits on a frictionless horizontal surface and is connected by an inextensible cord to hanging block of mass . The pulley is a uniform cylindrical shell (thin hoop) of mass (). Find the system acceleration with .
Answer
. For a thin hoop, , so . Adding the block equations gives . Thus .
A classic symmetric Atwood machine consists of two hanging masses and connected over a uniform solid disk pulley of mass and radius . With and no rope slippage, calculate the string tensions (above ) and (above ).
Answer
and . Net driving force is . Total equivalent mass is , giving . Then , and (verifying ).