Resources

A student claims that the negation of "x>3x > 3 and y≤5y \le 5" is "x≤3x \le 3 and y>5y > 5". Apply De Morgan's laws to find the correct negation of the statement, and determine whether the pair of values (x,y)=(2,4)(x, y) = (2, 4) serves as a counterexample that exposes the student's conceptual trap.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Correct negation: x≤3∨y>5x \le 3 \lor y > 5; the point (x,y)=(2,4)(x, y) = (2, 4) is a valid counterexample because it satisfies the true negation (2≤32 \le 3 is True\text{True}) but evaluates to False\text{False} under the student's flawed conjunction (4>54 > 5 is False\text{False}).

Steps

01

Represent the Statement Symbolically

Let the original compound statement be represented by two simple statements connected by a logical conjunction ("and"):

  • Let PP be the condition x>3x > 3.
  • Let QQ be the condition y≤5y \le 5.

The given statement is therefore: P∧QP \land Q

02

Apply De Morgan's Laws

De Morgan's law states that the negation of a conjunction is logically equivalent to the disjunction ("or") of the negations: ¬(P∧Q)≡¬P∨¬Q\neg(P \land Q) \equiv \neg P \lor \neg Q

Next, find the negation of each component inequality:

  • The negation of PP (x>3x > 3) is ¬P≡x≤3\neg P \equiv x \le 3.
  • The negation of QQ (y≤5y \le 5) is ¬Q≡y>5\neg Q \equiv y > 5.

Combining these using the disjunction gives the correct negation: x≤3∨y>5x \le 3 \lor y > 5

Common Pitfall: A frequent misconception is simply negating each piece while keeping the connector unchanged: ¬(P∧Q)≠¬P∧¬Q\neg(P \land Q) \neq \neg P \land \neg Q. Negating an "and" statement always changes the connective to an "or".


03

Evaluate the Point (x,y)=(2,4)(x, y) = (2, 4)

To show that the student's claim is incorrect, a counterexample must be a point where the true negation and the student's claimed statement produce different truth values.

  1. Evaluate under the true negation (x≤3∨y>5x \le 3 \lor y > 5):

    • Check x≤3x \le 3: 2≤32 \le 3 is True\text{True}.
    • Check y>5y > 5: 4>54 > 5 is False\text{False}.
    • Since a disjunction is true when at least one condition holds, True∨False\text{True} \lor \text{False} evaluates to True\text{True}.
  2. Evaluate under the student's claimed negation (x≤3∧y>5x \le 3 \land y > 5):

    • Check x≤3x \le 3: 2≤32 \le 3 is True\text{True}.
    • Check y>5y > 5: 4>54 > 5 is False\text{False}.
    • Since a conjunction requires both parts to be true, True∧False\text{True} \land \text{False} evaluates to False\text{False}.

Conclusion

The point (2,4)(2, 4) belongs to the set defined by the true negation, but it is excluded by the student's proposed statement. Therefore, (x,y)=(2,4)(x, y) = (2, 4) is a valid counterexample that exposes the student's conceptual error.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to reverse the inequality symbol when negating strict versus non-strict inequalities, writing strict inequalities for both negations.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    (not x>3) or (not y≤5)  ⟹  x<3 or y>5(\text{not } x > 3) \text{ or } (\text{not } y \le 5) \implies x < 3 \text{ or } y > 5

    Correct

    ¬(x>3∧y≤5)≡x≤3∨y>5\neg(x > 3 \land y \le 5) \equiv x \le 3 \lor y > 5

    You correctly converted the connective from "and" to "or" using De Morgan's law, but the logical negation of a strict inequality x>3x > 3 must include the boundary value, giving x≤3x \le 3 rather than x<3x < 3.

  2. Step 2

    x<3 is 2<3, which is true. The correct negation is true at (2,4).Student’s claim: 2≤3 is true, but 4>5 is false, so it is false.(2,4) serves as a counterexample.x < 3 \text{ is } 2 < 3\text{, which is true. The correct negation is true at } (2,4).\newline\text{Student's claim: } 2 \le 3 \text{ is true, but } 4 > 5 \text{ is false, so it is false.}\newline(2,4) \text{ serves as a counterexample.}

    Correct

    At (2,4), 2≤3 is True, so x≤3∨y>5 is True. In the claimed conjunction, 4>5 is False, so the claim is False. Thus, (2,4) is a valid counterexample.\text{At } (2, 4)\text{, } 2 \le 3 \text{ is True, so } x \le 3 \lor y > 5 \text{ is True. In the claimed conjunction, } 4 > 5 \text{ is False, so the claim is False. Thus, } (2, 4) \text{ is a valid counterexample.}

    Your reasoning and conclusion that (2,4)(2, 4) is a counterexample are conceptually sound, but your check in the first line evaluated x<3x < 3 instead of the correct negated condition x≤3x \le 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly switched the logical conjunction ("and") to a disjunction ("or") when applying De Morgan's law.

You correctly negated the non-strict inequality y≤5y \le 5 to the strict inequality y>5y > 5.

You correctly evaluated the truth values of the component conditions at (2,4)(2, 4) to show why it acts as a counterexample.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Negation of Strict Inequality

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the complement of a strict inequality as another strict inequality, overlooking that the boundary point must belong to exactly one of the two statements.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Complementarity of Inequalities
  • Every real number satisfies either x>cx > c or x≤cx \le c, with no overlap and no omissions.

  • Whenever you negate a strict inequality (>> or <<), always include the equals sign (≤\le or ≥\ge).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Negate the component x>3x > 3: ¬(x>3)  ⟺  x≤3\neg(x > 3) \iff x \le 3.

  2. Negate the component y≤5y \le 5: ¬(y≤5)  ⟺  y>5\neg(y \le 5) \iff y > 5.

  3. Apply De Morgan's law: ¬(P∧Q)≡¬P∨¬Q\neg(P \land Q) \equiv \neg P \lor \neg Q, yielding x≤3∨y>5x \le 3 \lor y > 5.

Final answer

The correct negation is x≤3∨y>5x \le 3 \lor y > 5, and (2,4)(2, 4) is a valid counterexample.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the complement pairs for inequalities: >> pairs with ≤\le, and << pairs with ≥\ge.

  • Test boundary numbers (like x=3x = 3) to verify that exactly one of the original or negated statements is true.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student believes a counterexample must make the original statement true rather than disproving the student's claimed equivalence to the true negation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    The negation of "P and Q" is "not P or not Q".   ⟹  x≤3 or y>5\implies x \le 3 \text{ or } y > 5

  2. Step 2

    Original statement at (2,4)(2,4): 2>32 > 3 is false, 4≤54 \le 5 is true, so "x>3x > 3 and y≤5y \le 5" is false.   ⟹  \implies Since the original statement is false at (2,4)(2,4), it does not satisfy the initial condition.

    Correct

    At (2,4)(2, 4), the true negation evaluates to 2≤3∨4>52 \le 3 \lor 4 > 5 (True∨False=True\text{True} \lor \text{False} = \text{True}), while the claimed negation evaluates to 2≤3∧4>52 \le 3 \land 4 > 5 (True∧False=False\text{True} \land \text{False} = \text{False}).

    To test whether a point is a counterexample to the claimed negation, you must compare the truth value of the true negation against the truth value of the claimed negation. Showing that the original statement is false actually confirms that the point belongs to the true negation.

  3. Step 3

    (2,4)(2,4) does not serve as a counterexample.

    Correct

    Since the true negation is True\text{True} and the claimed negation is False\text{False} at (2,4)(2, 4), the pair (2,4)(2, 4) is a valid counterexample.

    Because of the evaluation error in the previous step, you reached an incorrect final conclusion about the counterexample.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled that the negation of an "and" statement becomes an "or" statement under De Morgan's laws.

You accurately determined the negations of the two individual inequalities as x≤3x \le 3 and y>5y > 5.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Counterexample verification target error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the original statement as a premise that must be satisfied for a counterexample to exist, rather than recognizing that a counterexample to an equivalence claim must produce differing truth values between the true negation and the proposed negation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define what constitutes a counterexample to a logical equivalence
  • Two statements AA and BB are logically equivalent if and only if they have identical truth values in every case. A counterexample is an instance where one is true and the other is false.

  • Always evaluate both the correct expression and the proposed expression at the test point and check if their truth values differ.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate the true negation x≤3∨y>5x \le 3 \lor y > 5: 2≤32 \le 3 is True\text{True}, so the disjunction is True\text{True}.

  2. Evaluate the claimed negation x≤3∧y>5x \le 3 \land y > 5: 4>54 > 5 is False\text{False}, so the conjunction is False\text{False}.

Final answer

Because the true negation is True\text{True} while the claimed negation is False\text{False}, (x,y)=(2,4)(x, y) = (2, 4) is a valid counterexample.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice disproving proposed logical equivalences by checking truth values for both statements side-by-side.

  • Remember that if a point makes the original statement false, it makes the true negation true.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Find the negation of the compound statement: "x≥−2x \ge -2 and y<8y < 8".

Answer

x<−2∨y≥8x < -2 \lor y \ge 8. Key steps: Negate x≥−2x \ge -2 to get x<−2x < -2, negate y<8y < 8 to get y≥8y \ge 8, and apply De Morgan's law to switch "and" to "or".

02

A student writes that the negation of x>4∨y≤1x > 4 \lor y \le 1 is x<4∧y>1x < 4 \land y > 1. Determine whether the point (x,y)=(4,3)(x, y) = (4, 3) disproves their statement.

Answer

Yes, (4,3)(4, 3) is a counterexample. The correct negation is x≤4∧y>1x \le 4 \land y > 1. At (4,3)(4, 3), 4≤44 \le 4 is True and 3>13 > 1 is True, so the true negation is True. However, under the student's expression, 4<44 < 4 is False, making their statement False.

03

Consider the statement SS: "−1<x≤5-1 < x \le 5", which means "x>−1x > -1 and x≤5x \le 5". Write its negation as a single compound statement and specify all real values of xx that satisfy the negation.

Answer

x≤−1∨x>5x \le -1 \lor x > 5. Key steps: Express SS as (x>−1)∧(x≤5)(x > -1) \land (x \le 5). Apply De Morgan's law: ¬(x>−1)∨¬(x≤5)≡x≤−1∨x>5\neg(x > -1) \lor \neg(x \le 5) \equiv x \le -1 \lor x > 5. In interval notation, the solution set is (−∞,−1]∪(5,∞)(-\infty, -1] \cup (5, \infty).

Loading workspace…