Resources

Consider the system of linear equations: 2x+5y=12x + 5y = 1 and 3x−4y=133x - 4y = 13. Solve the system using two distinct algebraic methods: (1) the Method of Elimination (linear combinations) and (2) the Method of Substitution. State the solution as an ordered pair (x,y)(x, y), and evaluate which method requires fewer arithmetic fraction operations during intermediate steps.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Solution: (x,y)=(3,−1)(x, y) = (3, -1). Elimination requires fewer fractional operations (eliminating variables yields integer equations 23x=6923x = 69 after multiplying by constants 44 and 55), whereas substitution immediately introduces fractions (e.g., x=1−5y2x = \frac{1 - 5y}{2}) in the first step.

Steps

To solve the linear system and compare the algebraic efficiency of each method, we analyze the equations:

  1. 2x+5y=12x + 5y = 1
  2. 3x−4y=133x - 4y = 13

Method 1: Elimination (Linear Combinations)

  1. Align coefficients to eliminate a variable:
    The coefficients of yy are +5+5 and −4-4, which already have opposite signs. We find a common multiple of 55 and 44, which is 2020.

    • Multiply the first equation by 44: 4(2x+5y)=4(1)  ⟹  8x+20y=44(2x + 5y) = 4(1) \implies 8x + 20y = 4
    • Multiply the second equation by 55: 5(3x−4y)=5(13)  ⟹  15x−20y=655(3x - 4y) = 5(13) \implies 15x - 20y = 65
  2. Add the two equations: (8x+20y)+(15x−20y)=4+65(8x + 20y) + (15x - 20y) = 4 + 65 23x=6923x = 69 x=6923=3x = \frac{69}{23} = 3
  3. Back-substitute to find yy:
    Substitute x=3x = 3 into the first original equation: 2(3)+5y=12(3) + 5y = 1 6+5y=16 + 5y = 1 5y=−5  ⟹  y=−15y = -5 \implies y = -1

The ordered pair solution is (x,y)=(3,−1)(x, y) = (3, -1).


Method 2: Substitution

  1. Isolate one variable:
    Isolating xx in the first equation 2x+5y=12x + 5y = 1: 2x=1−5y  ⟹  x=1−5y22x = 1 - 5y \implies x = \frac{1 - 5y}{2}
  2. Substitute into the other equation:
    Replace xx with 1−5y2\frac{1 - 5y}{2} in the second equation: 3(1−5y2)−4y=133\left(\frac{1 - 5y}{2}\right) - 4y = 13 3−15y2−8y2=13\frac{3 - 15y}{2} - \frac{8y}{2} = 13 3−23y2=13\frac{3 - 23y}{2} = 13
  3. Solve for yy:
    Multiply both sides by 22: 3−23y=263 - 23y = 26 −23y=23  ⟹  y=−1-23y = 23 \implies y = -1
  4. Solve for xx:
    x=1−5(−1)2=1+52=3x = \frac{1 - 5(-1)}{2} = \frac{1 + 5}{2} = 3

The ordered pair solution is (x,y)=(3,−1)(x, y) = (3, -1).


Comparison of Methods

  • Elimination: Multiplying the original equations by integer factors (44 and 55) allows the coefficients to become opposites without introducing non-integer terms. All intermediate steps operate strictly on whole numbers until the final integer division (69÷23=369 \div 23 = 3).
  • Substitution: Because none of the variables in either equation have a coefficient of ±1\pm 1, solving for any variable immediately introduces fractional expressions (such as 1−5y2\frac{1 - 5y}{2}). Combining these requires finding common denominators.

Therefore, the Method of Elimination is more efficient here as it avoids arithmetic with fractions in the intermediate steps.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 When subtracting the multiplied equations in elimination, the student subtracts the positive terms but forgets to distribute the negative sign to -8y, writing 15y - 8y = 7y instead of 15y - (-8y) = 23y.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    3(2x+5y=1)  ⟹  6x+15y=33(2x + 5y = 1) \implies 6x + 15y = 3 and 2(3x−4y=13)  ⟹  6x−8y=262(3x - 4y = 13) \implies 6x - 8y = 26

  2. Step 2

    (6x+15y)−(6x−8y)=3−26  ⟹  7y=−23(6x + 15y) - (6x - 8y) = 3 - 26 \implies 7y = -23

    Correct

    (6x+15y)−(6x−8y)=3−26  ⟹  15y+8y=−23  ⟹  23y=−23(6x + 15y) - (6x - 8y) = 3 - 26 \implies 15y + 8y = -23 \implies 23y = -23

    When subtracting −(6x−8y)-(6x - 8y), the negative sign must distribute to both terms, giving 15y−(−8y)=15y+8y=23y15y - (-8y) = 15y + 8y = 23y, rather than 15y−8y=7y15y - 8y = 7y.

  3. Step 3

    y=−237  ⟹  2x+5(−237)=1  ⟹  x=617  ⟹  (617,−237)y = -\frac{23}{7} \implies 2x + 5\left(-\frac{23}{7}\right) = 1 \implies x = \frac{61}{7} \implies \left(\frac{61}{7}, -\frac{23}{7}\right)

    Correct

    23y=−23  ⟹  y=−1  ⟹  2x+5(−1)=1  ⟹  x=3  ⟹  (3,−1)23y = -23 \implies y = -1 \implies 2x + 5(-1) = 1 \implies x = 3 \implies (3, -1)

    Your downstream back-substitution arithmetic is technically consistent with y=−237y = -\frac{23}{7}, but the resulting values are affected by the sign error in Step 2.

  4. Step 4

    x=1−5y2  ⟹  3(1−5y2)−4y=13  ⟹  3(1−5y)−8y=26  ⟹  −23y=23  ⟹  y=−1,x=3  ⟹  (3,−1)x = \frac{1 - 5y}{2} \implies 3\left(\frac{1 - 5y}{2}\right) - 4y = 13 \implies 3(1 - 5y) - 8y = 26 \implies -23y = 23 \implies y = -1, x = 3 \implies (3, -1)

  5. Step 5

    Elimination uses fewer fraction operations because it only involves integers until the end, whereas substitution creates fractions immediately.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly multiplied the linear equations by constants to align the leading coefficients of xx.

You executed the entire substitution method with precision, correctly clearing denominators and finding (3,−1)(3, -1).

You accurately identified that elimination avoids intermediate fractional arithmetic compared to substitution.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign distribution error when subtracting equations

You forgot to distribute the subtraction sign to the negative term −8y-8y, writing 15y−8y=7y15y - 8y = 7y instead of 15y−(−8y)=23y15y - (-8y) = 23y.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Failing to distribute a negative sign across terms inside parentheses when subtracting two expressions line-by-line, and omitting a consistency check when two independent solving methods yield different answers.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distribute Subtraction Over Negatives
  • Subtracting a negative quantity is equivalent to addition: a−(−b)=a+ba - (-b) = a + b.

  • Always distribute the negative sign explicitly across every term in the subtracted equation, or multiply the second equation by a negative factor and add instead.

Cross-Method Verification
  • A system of linear equations with a unique solution must produce the exact same ordered pair (x,y)(x, y) regardless of the algebraic method chosen.

  • If two distinct methods yield different ordered pairs, re-examine the intermediate steps of both to locate the discrepancy before finalizing your answer.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Distribute the negative sign carefully: (6x−6x)+(15y−(−8y))=−23(6x - 6x) + (15y - (-8y)) = -23

  2. Simplify the yy-terms: 15y+8y=23y15y + 8y = 23y, so 23y=−2323y = -23

  3. Divide by 2323 to solve for yy: y=−1y = -1

  4. Substitute y=−1y = -1 into 2x+5y=12x + 5y = 1: 2x+5(−1)=1  ⟹  2x−5=1  ⟹  2x=6  ⟹  x=32x + 5(-1) = 1 \implies 2x - 5 = 1 \implies 2x = 6 \implies x = 3

Final answer

The solution is (x,y)=(3,−1)(x, y) = (3, -1). Elimination requires fewer intermediate fraction operations.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice subtracting binomials with mixed signs to build automaticity with distributing negatives, e.g., (Ax+By)−(Cx−Dy)(Ax + By) - (Cx - Dy).

  • Consider using addition rather than subtraction during elimination by multiplying by opposite-sign multipliers (e.g., multiply by −2-2 instead of 22) to minimize sign slips.

  • Whenever asked to solve via two methods, always verify that your resulting ordered pairs match.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 When substituting the expression for x into the second equation, the student forgets to multiply the second term -4y by 2 when clearing the denominator 2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    3(2x+5y=1)  ⟹  6x+15y=33(2x + 5y = 1) \implies 6x + 15y = 3 2(3x−4y=13)  ⟹  6x−8y=262(3x - 4y = 13) \implies 6x - 8y = 26 15y−(−8y)=3−26  ⟹  23y=−23  ⟹  y=−115y - (-8y) = 3 - 26 \implies 23y = -23 \implies y = -1 2x+5(−1)=1  ⟹  2x=6  ⟹  x=32x + 5(-1) = 1 \implies 2x = 6 \implies x = 3 (3,−1)(3, -1)

  2. Step 2

    x=1−5y2  ⟹  3(1−5y2)−4y=13x = \frac{1 - 5y}{2} \implies 3\left(\frac{1 - 5y}{2}\right) - 4y = 13

  3. Step 3

    3(1−5y)−4y=263(1 - 5y) - 4y = 26

    Correct

    3(1−5y)−8y=263(1 - 5y) - 8y = 26

    When multiplying the equation by 22 to clear the fraction, you must multiply every term on both sides by 22. Multiplying −4y-4y by 22 yields −8y-8y, not −4y-4y.

  4. Step 4

    3−15y−4y=26  ⟹  −19y=23  ⟹  y=−2319  ⟹  x=6719  ⟹  (6719,−2319)3 - 15y - 4y = 26 \implies -19y = 23 \implies y = -\frac{23}{19} \implies x = \frac{67}{19} \implies \left(\frac{67}{19}, -\frac{23}{19}\right)

    Correct

    3−15y−8y=26  ⟹  −23y=23  ⟹  y=−1  ⟹  x=3  ⟹  (3,−1)3 - 15y - 8y = 26 \implies -23y = 23 \implies y = -1 \implies x = 3 \implies (3, -1)

    Your subsequent algebra followed logically from the previous equation, but the values were affected by the missing factor of 22 in the −4y-4y term.

  5. Step 5

    Elimination requires fewer fraction operations because all intermediate steps stay in integers, while substitution immediately introduces fractions.\text{Elimination requires fewer fraction operations because all intermediate steps stay in integers, while substitution immediately introduces fractions.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You executed the elimination method accurately to find (3,−1)(3, -1).

You isolated xx correctly and set up the substitution into the second equation.

You correctly identified that elimination avoids intermediate fraction operations.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incomplete distribution when clearing denominators

You multiplied the fraction and the right-hand side by 22, but left the middle integer term −4y-4y unmultiplied.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When clearing fractions across an equation, each separate additive term must be multiplied by the common denominator. Multiplying only the fractional term and the constant on the other side violates the multiplication property of equality.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Multiply Every Term
  • When multiplying an equation A+B=CA + B = C by a scalar kk, the property requires k⋅A+k⋅B=k⋅Ck\cdot A + k\cdot B = k\cdot C.

  • Bracket the entire side of the equation, as in 2⋅[3(1−5y2)−4y]=2⋅132\cdot\left[3\left(\frac{1-5y}{2}\right) - 4y\right] = 2\cdot 13, before expanding.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply every term on both sides by 22: 2⋅3(1−5y2)−2⋅4y=2⋅132 \cdot 3\left(\frac{1 - 5y}{2}\right) - 2 \cdot 4y = 2 \cdot 13

  2. Simplify each term: 3(1−5y)−8y=263(1 - 5y) - 8y = 26

  3. Expand and combine like terms: 3−15y−8y=26  ⟹  3−23y=263 - 15y - 8y = 26 \implies 3 - 23y = 26

  4. Subtract 33 from both sides: −23y=23  ⟹  y=−1-23y = 23 \implies y = -1

  5. Substitute y=−1y = -1 back into x=1−5y2x = \frac{1 - 5y}{2}: x=1−5(−1)2=62=3x = \frac{1 - 5(-1)}{2} = \frac{6}{2} = 3

Final answer

(x,y)=(3,−1)(x, y) = (3, -1)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When clearing fractions in linear equations, place parentheses around each side of the equation before distributing the common denominator.

  • Verify that the solutions obtained from two different methods match; finding differing solutions is an immediate signal to check for an algebraic error.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student mistakenly concludes that substitution uses fewer fractions by assuming substitution never produces fractions or overlooking the necessary division by 2 to isolate x.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    3(2x+5y=1)  ⟹  6x+15y=33(2x + 5y = 1) \implies 6x + 15y = 3 2(3x−4y=13)  ⟹  6x−8y=262(3x - 4y = 13) \implies 6x - 8y = 26 23y=−23  ⟹  y=−123y = -23 \implies y = -1 2x+5(−1)=1  ⟹  2x=6  ⟹  x=32x + 5(-1) = 1 \implies 2x = 6 \implies x = 3 (3,−1)(3, -1)

  2. Step 2

    2x=1−5y  ⟹  x=1−5y22x = 1 - 5y \implies x = \frac{1 - 5y}{2} 3(1−5y2)−4y=13  ⟹  3(1−5y)−8y=26  ⟹  3−23y=26  ⟹  y=−13\left(\frac{1 - 5y}{2}\right) - 4y = 13 \implies 3(1 - 5y) - 8y = 26 \implies 3 - 23y = 26 \implies y = -1 x=1−5(−1)2=3x = \frac{1 - 5(-1)}{2} = 3 (3,−1)(3, -1)

  3. Step 3

    "Substitution requires fewer arithmetic fraction operations because directly plugging in an isolated variable avoids working with multiple equations."

    Correct

    Elimination requires fewer intermediate fraction operations because multiplying by integer constants (33 and 22) avoids introducing non-integer terms, whereas substitution immediately introduces a denominator of 22 when isolating xx.

    In your substitution work, isolating xx created the fraction 1−5y2\frac{1 - 5y}{2}, which required clearing denominators or finding common denominators. In contrast, your elimination work used only integer coefficients throughout every intermediate step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You executed the linear combination method accurately without making any arithmetic slips.

You correctly isolated a variable and solved the resulting linear equation in the substitution method.

You obtained the correct final ordered pair (3,−1)(3, -1) in both methods.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Method Comparison Misconception

You initially wrote 'Elimination requires', which was correct, but crossed it out to choose substitution based on equation count rather than fraction count.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the conceptual simplicity of having one isolated formula with arithmetic efficiency, overlooking that isolating any variable with a coefficient other than ±1\pm 1 forces fractional expressions into the substitution process.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Variable Coefficients
  • If no variable in the system has a coefficient of 11 or −1-1, solving for any variable introduces a fraction.

  • Scan the coefficients of xx and yy first; if none are ±1\pm 1, recognize that substitution will require fractional terms.

Count Intermediate Fractions
  • Elimination allows clearing or matching coefficients entirely through integer multiplication.

  • Observe whether any step in elimination required dividing by a non-factor before the very last step.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Observe the coefficients of xx and yy in both equations: 2,5,3,−42, 5, 3, -4. None are ±1\pm 1.

  2. In substitution, isolating any variable divides by its coefficient, yielding fractions such as x=1−5y2x = \frac{1 - 5y}{2}.

  3. In elimination, scaling equation (1) by 33 and equation (2) by 22 produces integer equations (6x+15y=36x + 15y = 3 and 6x−8y=266x - 8y = 26) with zero fractional operations.

Final answer

The Method of Elimination requires fewer arithmetic fraction operations.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before choosing a method, inspect the coefficients: use substitution when a coefficient is ±1\pm 1, and prefer elimination when all coefficients are integers greater than 11 or less than −1-1.

  • Distinguish between working with 'multiple equations' and working with 'fractions' when assessing algebraic efficiency.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Solve the system using elimination by subtraction, paying special attention to distributing negative signs: 4x+3y=114x + 3y = 11 and 4x−5y=−134x - 5y = -13.

Answer

Subtract the second equation from the first: (4x−4x)+[3y−(−5y)]=11−(−13)  ⟹  8y=24  ⟹  y=3(4x - 4x) + [3y - (-5y)] = 11 - (-13) \implies 8y = 24 \implies y = 3. Substitute into 4x+3(3)=11  ⟹  4x=2  ⟹  x=124x + 3(3) = 11 \implies 4x = 2 \implies x = \frac{1}{2}. Solution: (x,y)=(12,3)(x, y) = \left(\frac{1}{2}, 3\right).

02

Solve the system 3x+2y=83x + 2y = 8 and 2x−3y=142x - 3y = 14 using both elimination and substitution. Confirm that both methods yield the same ordered pair.

Answer

Elimination: Multiply first by 33 (9x+6y=249x + 6y = 24) and second by 22 (4x−6y=284x - 6y = 28). Adding gives 13x=52  ⟹  x=413x = 52 \implies x = 4. Then 3(4)+2y=8  ⟹  2y=−4  ⟹  y=−23(4) + 2y = 8 \implies 2y = -4 \implies y = -2. Substitution: y=8−3x2  ⟹  2x−3(8−3x2)=14  ⟹  4x−24+9x=28  ⟹  13x=52  ⟹  x=4y = \frac{8 - 3x}{2} \implies 2x - 3\left(\frac{8 - 3x}{2}\right) = 14 \implies 4x - 24 + 9x = 28 \implies 13x = 52 \implies x = 4, y=−2y = -2. Both methods yield (x,y)=(4,−2)(x, y) = (4, -2).

03

Given the system 5x−3y=195x - 3y = 19 and 2x−7y=202x - 7y = 20, (a) determine which method (substitution or elimination) requires fewer intermediate fraction operations, and (b) solve the system.

Answer

(a) Elimination requires fewer fraction operations because none of the variable coefficients are ±1\pm 1; substitution immediately creates fractions with denominators of 5,3,25, 3, 2, or 77. (b) Multiply first equation by 22 (10x−6y=3810x - 6y = 38) and second by 55 (10x−35y=10010x - 35y = 100). Subtract: [−6y−(−35y)]=38−100  ⟹  29y=−62  ⟹  y=−6229[-6y - (-35y)] = 38 - 100 \implies 29y = -62 \implies y = -\frac{62}{29}. Then 5x=19+3(−6229)=551−18629=36529  ⟹  x=73295x = 19 + 3\left(-\frac{62}{29}\right) = \frac{551 - 186}{29} = \frac{365}{29} \implies x = \frac{73}{29}. Solution: (x,y)=(7329,−6229)(x, y) = \left(\frac{73}{29}, -\frac{62}{29}\right).

Loading workspace…