Resources

In a physics laboratory report on simple harmonic motion, a student measures the period of a simple pendulum of length L=1.200 mL = 1.200\text{ m} released from rest at an initial angular displacement of θ0=45.0∘\theta_0 = 45.0^\circ (0.7854 rad0.7854\text{ rad}). Using the small-angle linearization model Tmodel=2πLgT_{\text{model}} = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{L}{g}} with g=9.800 m/s2g = 9.800\text{ m/s}^2, the student predicts Tmodel=2.199 sT_{\text{model}} = 2.199\text{ s}. (a) State the coordinate and mathematical approximation underlying this model equation. (b) Using the second-order Taylor expansion correction T≈2πLg(1+116θ02)T \approx 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{L}{g}}\left(1 + \frac{1}{16}\theta_0^2\right), calculate the accurate period TtrueT_{\text{true}} and the sign of the error defined as ΔT=Tmodel−Ttrue\Delta T = T_{\text{model}} - T_{\text{true}}. (c) Explain why this negative error trap arises mathematically from replacing the restoring torque with its linear approximation.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) The equation of motion d2θdt2+gLsin⁡θ=0\frac{d^2\theta}{dt^2} + \frac{g}{L}\sin\theta = 0 is linearized using the small-angle approximation sin⁡θ≈θ\sin\theta \approx \theta (in radians), which assumes θ3/6≈0\theta^3 / 6 \approx 0. (b) Ttrue≈2.199(1+116(0.7854)2)≈2.199(1+0.03855)≈2.284 sT_{\text{true}} \approx 2.199\left(1 + \frac{1}{16}(0.7854)^2\right) \approx 2.199(1 + 0.03855) \approx 2.284\text{ s}; error ΔT=2.199 s−2.284 s=−0.085 s\Delta T = 2.199\text{ s} - 2.284\text{ s} = -0.085\text{ s} (negative sign indicates the linear model systematically underestimates the true period). (c) Because sin⁡θ<θ\sin\theta < \theta for all θ>0\theta > 0, the linearized model overestimates the true restoring force magnitude (∣−gθ∣>∣−gsin⁡θ∣|-g\theta| > |-g\sin\theta|); an artificially stiffer restoring force causes the predicted oscillator to cycle faster, erroneously truncating the modeled period.

Steps

(a) Model Assumptions and Approximations

The exact equation of motion for an ideal simple pendulum of length LL swinging in a vertical plane under gravity gg is:

d2θdt2+gLsin⁡θ=0\frac{d^2\theta}{dt^2} + \frac{g}{L}\sin\theta = 0

where θ\theta represents the angular displacement from the vertical measured in radians.

To obtain the standard simple harmonic motion formula Tmodel=2πLgT_{\text{model}} = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{L}{g}}, the nonlinear restoring term sin⁡θ\sin\theta is expanded as a Maclaurin series:

sin⁡θ=θ−θ33!+θ55!−…\sin\theta = \theta - \frac{\theta^3}{3!} + \frac{\theta^5}{5!} - \dots

The model relies on the small-angle approximation:

sin⁡θ≈θ\sin\theta \approx \theta

This approximation assumes that higher-order terms—predominantly the cubic term θ36\frac{\theta^3}{6}—are negligibly small, which only holds when ∣θ∣≪1 rad|\theta| \ll 1\text{ rad}.


(b) Calculation of the Corrected Period and Error

Given:

  • Initial amplitude: θ0=45.0∘=0.7854 rad\theta_0 = 45.0^\circ = 0.7854\text{ rad}
  • Linearized period: Tmodel=2πLg≈2.199 sT_{\text{model}} = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{L}{g}} \approx 2.199\text{ s}

Using the second-order Taylor correction for the period:

Ttrue≈Tmodel(1+116θ02)T_{\text{true}} \approx T_{\text{model}}\left(1 + \frac{1}{16}\theta_0^2\right)

  1. Compute the correction factor: θ02=(0.7854)2≈0.6169\theta_0^2 = (0.7854)^2 \approx 0.6169 116θ02=0.616916≈0.03855\frac{1}{16}\theta_0^2 = \frac{0.6169}{16} \approx 0.03855
  2. Calculate TtrueT_{\text{true}}: Ttrue≈2.199 s⋅(1+0.03855)=2.199⋅1.03855≈2.284 sT_{\text{true}} \approx 2.199\text{ s} \cdot (1 + 0.03855) = 2.199 \cdot 1.03855 \approx 2.284\text{ s}
  3. Determine the error ΔT\Delta T: ΔT=Tmodel−Ttrue=2.199 s−2.284 s=−0.085 s\Delta T = T_{\text{model}} - T_{\text{true}} = 2.199\text{ s} - 2.284\text{ s} = -0.085\text{ s}

The error has a negative sign, indicating that the small-angle linear model systematically underestimates the true period of oscillation.


(c) Mathematical and Physical Reason for the Negative Error

The true restoring torque acting on the pendulum bob is proportional to −sin⁡θ-\sin\theta, while the linearized model assumes a restoring torque proportional to −θ-\theta.

  • For any displacement θ>0\theta > 0, the series expansion shows: sin⁡θ=θ−θ36+⋯<θ\sin\theta = \theta - \frac{\theta^3}{6} + \dots < \theta
  • Consequently, the linear approximation overestimates the magnitude of the restoring force: ∣−gθ∣>∣−gsin⁡θ∣|-g\theta| > |-g\sin\theta|

Because the model assumes a restoring force that is stronger ("stiffer") than the actual force at every non-zero angle, it predicts that the pendulum accelerates back to the equilibrium position faster than it actually does. This artificially accelerates each cycle, causing the model to yield a shorter period (Tmodel<TtrueT_{\text{model}} < T_{\text{true}}) and resulting in a negative prediction error (ΔT<0\Delta T < 0).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student substitutes the amplitude in degrees rather than radians into the Taylor expansion correction formula, producing an unrealistically large period.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Angular coordinate θ\theta from vertical ⟹\Longrightarrow Approximation: sin⁡(θ)≈θ\sin(\theta) \approx \theta

  2. Step 2

    Ttrue=2.199×(1+116×45.02)⟹Ttrue=2.199×(1+126.56)=280.5 sT_{\text{true}} = 2.199 \times \left(1 + \frac{1}{16} \times 45.0^2\right) \Longrightarrow T_{\text{true}} = 2.199 \times (1 + 126.56) = 280.5\text{ s}

    Correct

    Ttrue≈2.199(1+116(0.7854)2)≈2.199(1+0.03855)≈2.284 sT_{\text{true}} \approx 2.199\left(1 + \frac{1}{16}(0.7854)^2\right) \approx 2.199(1 + 0.03855) \approx 2.284\text{ s}

    Taylor series expansions for trigonometric functions and derived correction formulas are defined exclusively for angles in radians. Substituting 45.0∘45.0^\circ treats the angular amplitude as 45 rad45\text{ rad} rather than 0.7854 rad0.7854\text{ rad}.

  3. Step 3

    ΔT=2.199 s−280.5 s=−278.3 s\Delta T = 2.199\text{ s} - 280.5\text{ s} = -278.3\text{ s}, negative

    Correct

    ΔT=2.199 s−2.284 s=−0.085 s\Delta T = 2.199\text{ s} - 2.284\text{ s} = -0.085\text{ s}, negative

    Your subtraction step and identification of the negative sign were logically applied to your previous number, but the numerical magnitude was affected by the degree substitution error in the previous step.

  4. Step 4

    Since sin⁡(θ)<θ\sin(\theta) < \theta, the true restoring force is weaker than the linearized force. This makes the pendulum slower and the true period longer, so ΔT\Delta T is negative.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly stated the angular coordinate and the small-angle approximation sin⁡θ≈θ\sin\theta \approx \theta.

You accurately reasoned that sin⁡θ<θ\sin\theta < \theta makes the true restoring force weaker and the true period longer.

You correctly defined and calculated the error difference formula ΔT=Tmodel−Ttrue\Delta T = T_{\text{model}} - T_{\text{true}} and identified its sign.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Degree vs. radian unit error in series approximation

In part (b), you wrote 45.0245.0^2 directly inside the bracketed correction factor instead of using the provided radian value θ0=0.7854 rad\theta_0 = 0.7854\text{ rad}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Taylor series expansions and analytical approximations of trigonometric functions derive directly from calculus limits where lim⁡θ→0sin⁡θθ=1\lim_{\theta \to 0} \frac{\sin\theta}{\theta} = 1, which is valid only when θ\theta is expressed in dimensionless radians.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Calculus and Series Angle Requirement
  • Any series expansion, derivative, or power-series correction formula involving angle variables requires the angle to be in radians.

  • Always verify that angular quantities are converted to radians before squaring or inserting into Taylor series correction terms.

Order of Magnitude Reality Check
  • A second-order correction term for a moderate angle should adjust the period by only a few percent (typically 116θ02<0.1\frac{1}{16}\theta_0^2 < 0.1).

  • If a correction factor yields an increase of over 100×100\times (such as 1+126.561 + 126.56), stop and check if an angle was entered in degrees.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert the angle to radians or use the given value: θ0=0.7854 rad\theta_0 = 0.7854\text{ rad}.

  2. Compute the second-order correction factor: 116θ02=(0.7854)216≈0.616916≈0.03855\frac{1}{16}\theta_0^2 = \frac{(0.7854)^2}{16} \approx \frac{0.6169}{16} \approx 0.03855.

  3. Calculate the corrected period: Ttrue≈2.199(1+0.03855)≈2.284 sT_{\text{true}} \approx 2.199(1 + 0.03855) \approx 2.284\text{ s}.

  4. Compute the prediction error: ΔT=2.199 s−2.284 s=−0.085 s\Delta T = 2.199\text{ s} - 2.284\text{ s} = -0.085\text{ s}.

Final answer

Ttrue≈2.284 sT_{\text{true}} \approx 2.284\text{ s}, with error ΔT=−0.085 s\Delta T = -0.085\text{ s} (negative sign).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review why geometric series and trigonometric Maclaurin expansions strictly require radian measure.

  • Practice spotting unreasonable values by comparing correction factor percentages against the baseline period.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to square the initial angle θ_0 in the correction factor, underestimating the second-order period increase.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Angular coordinate θ\theta measured from downward vertical   ⟹  \implies Approximation is sin⁡(θ)≈θ\sin(\theta) \approx \theta

  2. Step 2

    Ttrue=2.199×(1+116×0.7854)=2.199×(1+0.04909)=2.307 sT_{\text{true}} = 2.199 \times \left(1 + \frac{1}{16} \times 0.7854\right) = 2.199 \times (1 + 0.04909) = 2.307\text{ s}

    Correct

    Ttrue≈2.199×(1+116(0.7854)2)≈2.199×(1+0.03855)≈2.284 sT_{\text{true}} \approx 2.199 \times \left(1 + \frac{1}{16}(0.7854)^2\right) \approx 2.199 \times (1 + 0.03855) \approx 2.284\text{ s}

    You substituted θ0=0.7854 rad\theta_0 = 0.7854\text{ rad} linearly instead of squaring it as required by the formula term 116θ02\frac{1}{16}\theta_0^2.

  3. Step 3

    ΔT=2.199 s−2.307 s=−0.108 s\Delta T = 2.199\text{ s} - 2.307\text{ s} = -0.108\text{ s}, negative

    Correct

    ΔT=2.199 s−2.284 s=−0.085 s\Delta T = 2.199\text{ s} - 2.284\text{ s} = -0.085\text{ s}, negative

    Your subtraction and sign identification are logically sound, but the numerical result is affected by using Ttrue=2.307 sT_{\text{true}} = 2.307\text{ s} instead of 2.284 s2.284\text{ s}.

  4. Step 4

    Because sin⁡(θ)<θ\sin(\theta) < \theta, the true restoring torque is smaller than the model torque. A smaller restoring torque causes a slower return and longer period, yielding ΔT<0\Delta T < 0.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the small-angle approximation sin⁡θ≈θ\sin\theta \approx \theta.

You accurately reasoned that sin⁡θ<θ\sin\theta < \theta leads to a smaller true restoring torque, a longer actual period, and a negative error ΔT<0\Delta T < 0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Exponent in Formula Substitution

You substituted θ0\theta_0 as a linear factor rather than evaluating θ02\theta_0^2 in 116θ02\frac{1}{16}\theta_0^2.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking powers of dimensionless parameters in perturbation and Taylor series corrections, often caused by treating correction terms as simple percentage scalers.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the Order of the Expansion Term
  • Perturbation corrections in symmetric systems often depend on even powers (like θ02\theta_0^2), not linear terms.

  • Always circle exponents in series approximations before plugging in numerical values.

Dimensionless Quantity Check
  • In 1+kθ0n1 + k\theta_0^n, the term kθ0nk\theta_0^n represents a fractional correction and must match the formula's degree exactly.

  • Compute θ02\theta_0^2 as a distinct intermediate value before dividing by 1616.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute the square of the initial amplitude: θ02=(0.7854)2≈0.61685\theta_0^2 = (0.7854)^2 \approx 0.61685

  2. Calculate the fractional correction: 116θ02=0.6168516≈0.03855\frac{1}{16}\theta_0^2 = \frac{0.61685}{16} \approx 0.03855

  3. Evaluate the true period: Ttrue≈2.199×(1+0.03855)≈2.284 sT_{\text{true}} \approx 2.199 \times (1 + 0.03855) \approx 2.284\text{ s}

  4. Compute the modeling error: ΔT=2.199 s−2.284 s=−0.085 s\Delta T = 2.199\text{ s} - 2.284\text{ s} = -0.085\text{ s}

Final answer

Ttrue≈2.284 sT_{\text{true}} \approx 2.284\text{ s} and ΔT=−0.085 s\Delta T = -0.085\text{ s} (negative)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out intermediate steps like θ02=…\theta_0^2 = \dots explicitly rather than combining exponentiation and division in one mental step.

  • Check whether your correction factor increases quadratically with amplitude by comparing 15∘15^\circ, 30∘30^\circ, and 45∘45^\circ swings.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student reverses the sign of the error or claims the model overestimates the period because sin(θ) < θ is incorrectly interpreted as meaning the true period must be smaller.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Coordinate θ\theta from downward vertical ⟹ Mathematical approximation: sin⁡(θ)≈θ\sin(\theta) \approx \theta

  2. Step 2

    Ttrue=2.199×(1+(116)×0.78542)=2.199×(1+0.03855)=2.284 sT_{\text{true}} = 2.199 \times \left(1 + \left(\frac{1}{16}\right) \times 0.7854^2\right) = 2.199 \times (1 + 0.03855) = 2.284\text{ s}

  3. Step 3

    ΔT=Ttrue−Tmodel=2.284 s−2.199 s=+0.085 s\Delta T = T_{\text{true}} - T_{\text{model}} = 2.284\text{ s} - 2.199\text{ s} = +0.085\text{ s}, positive

    Correct

    ΔT=Tmodel−Ttrue=2.199 s−2.284 s=−0.085 s\Delta T = T_{\text{model}} - T_{\text{true}} = 2.199\text{ s} - 2.284\text{ s} = -0.085\text{ s}, negative

    You reversed the subtraction order. The question explicitly defined the error as ΔT=Tmodel−Ttrue\Delta T = T_{\text{model}} - T_{\text{true}}, which gives −0.085 s-0.085\text{ s}, indicating a negative error.

  4. Step 4

    Replacing sin⁡(θ)\sin(\theta) with the larger value heta heta overestimates the restoring torque. The student computes ΔT\Delta T as Ttrue−TmodelT_{\text{true}} - T_{\text{model}}, giving a positive error.

    Correct

    Since sin⁡θ<θ\sin\theta < \theta for θ>0\theta > 0, the linear model overestimates the magnitude of the restoring torque (∣−mgLθ∣>∣−mgLsin⁡θ∣|-mgL\theta| > |-mgL\sin\theta|). An artificially stronger restoring force causes the modeled pendulum to accelerate faster, resulting in a shorter modeled period (Tmodel<TtrueT_{\text{model}} < T_{\text{true}}) and a negative error ΔT=Tmodel−Ttrue<0\Delta T = T_{\text{model}} - T_{\text{true}} < 0.

    You correctly noted that replacing sin⁡θ\sin\theta with θ\theta overestimates the restoring torque, but you did not link that stiffer restoring torque to a faster cycle (Tmodel<TtrueT_{\text{model}} < T_{\text{true}}) causing a negative error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You clearly identified the downward vertical reference coordinate and the linearization sin⁡θ≈θ\sin\theta \approx \theta.

You correctly substituted the amplitude in radians into the second-order period correction formula to obtain 2.284 s2.284\text{ s}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed error definition and incomplete physical chain

You computed the difference as Ttrue−TmodelT_{\text{true}} - T_{\text{model}} rather than following the prompt's defined order ΔT=Tmodel−Ttrue\Delta T = T_{\text{model}} - T_{\text{true}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated modeling error as an unsigned or arbitrarily ordered difference, overlooking that the standard definition of prediction error is Model−True\text{Model} - \text{True}. This prevented you from recognizing that an overestimated restoring torque accelerates the modeled oscillation, making Tmodel<TtrueT_{\text{model}} < T_{\text{true}} and therefore creating a negative error.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the Error Definition
  • Modeling error is defined by the prompt (usually Error=Model−True\text{Error} = \text{Model} - \text{True}).

  • Always substitute the values in the exact order specified: ΔT=Tmodel−Ttrue\Delta T = T_{\text{model}} - T_{\text{true}}.

Connect Restoring Force to Period
  • Period scales inversely with the square root of the restoring stiffness (T∝1/keffT \propto 1/\sqrt{k_{\text{eff}}}).

  • When a linearization overestimates restoring torque (∣τmodel∣>∣τtrue∣|\tau_{\text{model}}| > |\tau_{\text{true}}|), the model predicts faster return to center, meaning Tmodel<TtrueT_{\text{model}} < T_{\text{true}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the given definition: ΔT=Tmodel−Ttrue=2.199 s−2.284 s=−0.085 s\Delta T = T_{\text{model}} - T_{\text{true}} = 2.199\text{ s} - 2.284\text{ s} = -0.085\text{ s}.

  2. State the sign: The error ΔT\Delta T is negative, showing the small-angle model underestimates the real period.

  3. Complete the physical reasoning: Because θ>sin⁡θ\theta > \sin\theta for θ>0\theta > 0, the linear model assumes a stronger restoring force than reality, driving the oscillator back to equilibrium faster and yielding a shorter modeled period (Tmodel<TtrueT_{\text{model}} < T_{\text{true}}).

Final answer

(b) Ttrue≈2.284 sT_{\text{true}} \approx 2.284\text{ s}; ΔT=−0.085 s\Delta T = -0.085\text{ s} (negative). (c) The linear approximation overestimates the restoring torque (∣−gθ∣>∣−gsin⁡θ∣|-g\theta| > |-g\sin\theta|), making the modeled oscillator artificially stiffer and faster, which leads to Tmodel<TtrueT_{\text{model}} < T_{\text{true}} and thus a negative prediction error.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Carefully circle the sign and order of terms whenever an error formula like ΔT=Tmodel−Ttrue\Delta T = T_{\text{model}} - T_{\text{true}} is explicitly defined.

  • Practice tracing the physical chain: Restoring force magnitude →\rightarrow Acceleration →\rightarrow Cycle duration →\rightarrow Sign of ΔT\Delta T.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A simple pendulum with linearized period T0=1.500 sT_0 = 1.500\text{ s} is released from an angle of θ0=30.0∘\theta_0 = 30.0^\circ. Using T≈T0(1+116θ02)T \approx T_0\left(1 + \frac{1}{16}\theta_0^2\right), calculate the accurate period TT and the modeling error ΔT=T0−T\Delta T = T_0 - T.

Answer

Convert 30.0∘=π6≈0.5236 rad30.0^\circ = \frac{\pi}{6} \approx 0.5236\text{ rad}. The correction is 116(0.5236)2≈0.01713\frac{1}{16}(0.5236)^2 \approx 0.01713. Thus, T≈1.500(1+0.01713)≈1.526 sT \approx 1.500(1 + 0.01713) \approx 1.526\text{ s}. The modeling error is ΔT=1.500 s−1.526 s=−0.026 s\Delta T = 1.500\text{ s} - 1.526\text{ s} = -0.026\text{ s}.

02

In a physical pendulum experiment, an engineer estimates the restoring torque using the small-angle model τmodel=−κθ\tau_{\text{model}} = -\kappa \theta. If the true restoring torque is τtrue=−κsin⁡θ\tau_{\text{true}} = -\kappa \sin\theta, find the percentage error τmodel−τtrueτtrue×100%\frac{\tau_{\text{model}} - \tau_{\text{true}}}{\tau_{\text{true}}} \times 100\% at an operating angle of θ=0.500 rad\theta = 0.500\text{ rad}.

Answer

At θ=0.500 rad\theta = 0.500\text{ rad}, sin⁡(0.500)≈0.4794\sin(0.500) \approx 0.4794. The relative error is 0.500−0.47940.4794×100%≈+4.30%\frac{0.500 - 0.4794}{0.4794} \times 100\% \approx +4.30\%. The linear model overestimates the restoring torque magnitude by approximately 4.3%4.3\%.

03

The finite-amplitude period of a pendulum can be approximated to fourth order as T=T0(1+116θ02+113072θ04)T = T_0\left(1 + \frac{1}{16}\theta_0^2 + \frac{11}{3072}\theta_0^4\right). For an amplitude of θ0=60.0∘\theta_0 = 60.0^\circ (1.0472 rad1.0472\text{ rad}) and T0=2.000 sT_0 = 2.000\text{ s}, calculate the second-order correction term, the fourth-order correction term, and the resulting period TT.

Answer

With θ0=1.0472 rad\theta_0 = 1.0472\text{ rad}: the second-order term is 116(1.0472)2≈0.06854\frac{1}{16}(1.0472)^2 \approx 0.06854 (+6.85%+6.85\%); the fourth-order term is 113072(1.0472)4≈0.00431\frac{11}{3072}(1.0472)^4 \approx 0.00431 (+0.43%+0.43\%). The total factor is 1+0.06854+0.00431=1.072851 + 0.06854 + 0.00431 = 1.07285, yielding T≈2.000×1.07285≈2.146 sT \approx 2.000 \times 1.07285 \approx 2.146\text{ s}.

Loading workspace…