Resources

In an analytical chemistry laboratory, a student analyzes a 50.0 mL50.0\text{ mL} aliquot of an aqueous mixture containing both sulfuric acid (H2SO4\text{H}_2\text{SO}_4, diprotic) and hydrochloric acid (HCl\text{HCl}, monoprotic). The total acid content in the 50.0 mL50.0\text{ mL} sample requires exactly 38.4 mL38.4\text{ mL} of standardized 0.250 M NaOH0.250\text{ M}\text{ NaOH} to reach the phenolphthalein end point. A second identical 50.0 mL50.0\text{ mL} aliquot is treated with excess aqueous barium chloride (BaCl2\text{BaCl}_2), precipitating all sulfate quantitatively as pure, dry barium sulfate (BaSO4\text{BaSO}_4, molar mass 233.39 g/mol233.39\text{ g/mol}); the recovered precipitate has a dry mass of 0.6535 g0.6535\text{ g}. Define variables for the molar concentrations CH2SO4C_{\text{H}_2\text{SO}_4} and CHClC_{\text{HCl}}, write the system of linear equations modeling the millimoles of titratable protons and precipitated sulfate, and solve for the molarity of each acid in the original mixture.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Let CH2SO4C_{\text{H}_2\text{SO}_4} and CHClC_{\text{HCl}} denote the molar concentrations (in mol/L\text{mol/L}) of sulfuric acid and hydrochloric acid, respectively. The system of equations is: {2(0.0500)CH2SO4+(0.0500)CHCl=(0.250)(0.0384)(0.0500)CH2SO4=0.6535233.39\begin{cases} 2(0.0500)C_{\text{H}_2\text{SO}_4} + (0.0500)C_{\text{HCl}} = (0.250)(0.0384) \\ (0.0500)C_{\text{H}_2\text{SO}_4} = \frac{0.6535}{233.39} \end{cases}, which simplifies to {0.1000CH2SO4+0.0500CHCl=0.009600.0500CH2SO4=0.002800\begin{cases} 0.1000C_{\text{H}_2\text{SO}_4} + 0.0500C_{\text{HCl}} = 0.00960 \\ 0.0500C_{\text{H}_2\text{SO}_4} = 0.002800 \end{cases}. Solving gives CH2SO4=0.0560 MC_{\text{H}_2\text{SO}_4} = 0.0560\text{ M} and CHCl=0.0800 MC_{\text{HCl}} = 0.0800\text{ M}.

Steps

01

Define the Variables

Let:

  • CHX2SOX4C_{\ce{H2SO4}} represent the molar concentration (mol/L\text{mol/L} or M\text{M}) of sulfuric acid in the mixture.
  • CHClC_{\ce{HCl}} represent the molar concentration (mol/L\text{mol/L} or M\text{M}) of hydrochloric acid in the mixture.

The volume of each aliquot is 50.0 mL=0.0500 L50.0\text{ mL} = 0.0500\text{ L}.


02

Set Up the Acid-Base Neutralization Equation

Sulfuric acid (HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4}) is a diprotic acid, meaning each mole of HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} provides 2 moles2\text{ moles} of HX+\ce{H+} ions. Hydrochloric acid (HCl\ce{HCl}) is a monoprotic acid, providing 1 mole1\text{ mole} of HX+\ce{H+} per mole of acid.

The moles of HX+\ce{H+} neutralized by NaOH\ce{NaOH} equal the moles of OHX−\ce{OH-} supplied: Moles of HX+=2⋅(0.0500 L)⋅CHX2SOX4+1⋅(0.0500 L)⋅CHCl\text{Moles of }\ce{H+} = 2 \cdot (0.0500\text{ L}) \cdot C_{\ce{H2SO4}} + 1 \cdot (0.0500\text{ L}) \cdot C_{\ce{HCl}}

The moles of OHX−\ce{OH-} consumed during titration are: Moles of OHX−=(0.250 mol/L)⋅(0.0384 L)=0.00960 mol\text{Moles of }\ce{OH-} = (0.250\text{ mol/L}) \cdot (0.0384\text{ L}) = 0.00960\text{ mol}

Equating the moles of HX+\ce{H+} to the moles of OHX−\ce{OH-} gives the first equation: 0.1000⋅CHX2SOX4+0.0500⋅CHCl=0.009600.1000 \cdot C_{\ce{H2SO4}} + 0.0500 \cdot C_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.00960

Pitfall: A common error is neglecting the diprotic nature of HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4}. Forgetting the stoichiometric factor of 22 for HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} leads to an incorrect total proton balance.


03

Set Up the Sulfate Precipitation Equation

Adding excess BaClX2\ce{BaCl2} precipitates all sulfate ions as barium sulfate (BaSOX4\ce{BaSO4}): BaX2++SOX4X2−→BaSOX4(s)\ce{Ba^2+ + SO4^2- -> BaSO4(s)}

Each mole of HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} produces 1 mole1\text{ mole} of sulfate ions (SOX4X2−\ce{SO4^2-}). Hydrochloric acid contains no sulfate.

The moles of BaSOX4\ce{BaSO4} precipitated are calculated from its mass and molar mass: Moles of BaSOX4=0.6535 g233.39 g/mol≈0.002800 mol\text{Moles of }\ce{BaSO4} = \frac{0.6535\text{ g}}{233.39\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.002800\text{ mol}

Since the 50.0 mL50.0\text{ mL} sample contained all of this sulfate: (0.0500 L)⋅CHX2SOX4=0.002800 mol(0.0500\text{ L}) \cdot C_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.002800\text{ mol}

This yields the second equation: 0.0500⋅CHX2SOX4=0.0028000.0500 \cdot C_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.002800


04

Write and Solve the System of Linear Equations

The system of equations is: {0.1000⋅CHX2SOX4+0.0500⋅CHCl=0.00960,0.0500⋅CHX2SOX4=0.002800\lbrace 0.1000 \cdot C_{\ce{H2SO4}} + 0.0500 \cdot C_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.00960,\quad 0.0500 \cdot C_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.002800

Solve for CHX2SOX4C_{\ce{H2SO4}} directly from the second equation: CHX2SOX4=0.0028000.0500=0.0560 MC_{\ce{H2SO4}} = \frac{0.002800}{0.0500} = 0.0560\text{ M}

Substitute CHX2SOX4=0.0560 MC_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.0560\text{ M} into the first equation: 0.1000⋅(0.0560)+0.0500⋅CHCl=0.009600.1000 \cdot (0.0560) + 0.0500 \cdot C_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.00960 0.00560+0.0500⋅CHCl=0.009600.00560 + 0.0500 \cdot C_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.00960 0.0500⋅CHCl=0.00960−0.005600.0500 \cdot C_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.00960 - 0.00560 0.0500⋅CHCl=0.004000.0500 \cdot C_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.00400 CHCl=0.004000.0500=0.0800 MC_{\ce{HCl}} = \frac{0.00400}{0.0500} = 0.0800\text{ M}

The concentrations in the original mixture are CHX2SOX4=0.0560 MC_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.0560\text{ M} and CHCl=0.0800 MC_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.0800\text{ M}.

Educational illustration for this question

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats sulfuric acid as monoprotic during the neutralization reaction, forgetting that each mole of H2SO4 donates two moles of protons.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    \text{mmol }$$\ce{BaSO4} = 0.6535233.39\frac{0.6535}{233.39} ×\times 1000 = 2.800 mmol\text{ mmol}   ⟹  \implies 50.0 ×\times C_{HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4}} = 2.800   ⟹  \implies C_{HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.0560$\text{ M}$$

  2. Step 2

    mmol NaOH\text{mmol NaOH} = 38.4 ×\times 0.250 = 9.60 mmol\text{ mmol}   ⟹  \implies 50.0 ×\times C_{HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4}} + 50.0 ×\times C_{HCl\ce{HCl}} = 9.60

    Correct

    2(50.0)C_{HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4}} + 50.0 ⋅\cdot C_{HCl\ce{HCl}} = 9.60   ⟹  \implies 100.0 ⋅\cdot C_{HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4}} + 50.0 ⋅\cdot C_{HCl\ce{HCl}} = 9.60

    Sulfuric acid is diprotic, meaning each mole of HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} yields 2 moles2\text{ moles} of HX+\ce{H+} ions upon complete neutralization with NaOH\ce{NaOH}. Your equation treats HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} as monoprotic by using a stoichiometric coefficient of 11 instead of 22.

  3. Step 3

    50.0 ×\times 0.0560 + 50.0 ×\times C_{HCl\ce{HCl}} = 9.60   ⟹  \implies 2.80 + 50.0 ×\times C_{HCl\ce{HCl}} = 9.60   ⟹  \implies C_{HCl\ce{HCl}} = 0.136 M\text{ M}_

    Correct

    100.0(0.0560) + 50.0 ⋅\cdot C_{HCl\ce{HCl}} = 9.60   ⟹  \implies 5.60 + 50.0 ⋅\cdot C_{HCl\ce{HCl}} = 9.60   ⟹  \implies C_{HCl\ce{HCl}} = 0.0800 M\text{ M}_

    Your algebraic substitution and solving steps were executed cleanly, but the resulting concentration for HCl\ce{HCl} is incorrect due to the missing factor of 22 in the neutralization equation.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You clearly defined your variables and calculated the millimoles of barium sulfate precipitate accurately.

You correctly formulated and solved the linear equation for the sulfate mass balance.

You correctly calculated the total millimoles of sodium hydroxide used in the titration.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Polyprotic Stoichiometric Factor

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated sulfuric acid as a monoprotic acid providing 1 mole1\text{ mole} of protons per mole of acid during the neutralization balance, overlooking that diprotic HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} releases 2 moles2\text{ moles} of HX+\ce{H+} per mole.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Acid Proticity
  • Every mole of a diprotic acid HX2A\ce{H2A} neutralizes 2 moles2\text{ moles} of strong base OHX−\ce{OH-}.

  • Always multiply the moles or molarity of a polyprotic acid by its proticity nn when writing total titratable proton balance equations (n⋅V⋅Cn \cdot V \cdot C).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the total millimoles of titratable HX+\ce{H+}: 2(50.0 mL)CHX2SOX4+(50.0 mL)CHCl=9.60 mmol2(50.0\text{ mL})C_{\ce{H2SO4}} + (50.0\text{ mL})C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.60\text{ mmol}.

  2. Substitute CHX2SOX4=0.0560 MC_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.0560\text{ M}: 2(50.0)(0.0560)+50.0⋅CHCl=9.602(50.0)(0.0560) + 50.0 \cdot C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.60.

  3. Simplify the product: 5.60+50.0⋅CHCl=9.605.60 + 50.0 \cdot C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.60.

  4. Isolate the HCl\ce{HCl} term: 50.0⋅CHCl=9.60−5.60=4.0050.0 \cdot C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.60 - 5.60 = 4.00.

  5. Divide by volume: CHCl=4.0050.0=0.0800 MC_{\ce{HCl}} = \frac{4.00}{50.0} = 0.0800\text{ M}.

Final answer

CHX2SOX4=0.0560 MC_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.0560\text{ M} and CHCl=0.0800 MC_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.0800\text{ M}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before setting up neutralization balances, explicitly write down the ionization ratio of HX+\ce{H+} to acid molecule for each component.

  • Practice converting word problems into systems of linear equations involving polyprotic acids such as HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} and HX3POX4\ce{H3PO4}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly doubles the sulfate amount, believing the stoichiometric coefficient 2 in H2SO4 means two moles of sulfate are produced per mole of acid.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mmol BaSO4=0.6535233.39×1000=2.800 mmol\text{mmol BaSO}_4 = \frac{0.6535}{233.39} \times 1000 = 2.800\text{ mmol}

  2. Step 2

    2×50.0×CHX2SOX4=2.800  ⟹  100.0×CHX2SOX4=2.800  ⟹  CHX2SOX4=0.0280 M2 \times 50.0 \times C_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 2.800 \implies 100.0 \times C_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 2.800 \implies C_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.0280\text{ M}

    Correct

    50.0×CHX2SOX4=2.800  ⟹  CHX2SOX4=2.80050.0=0.0560 M50.0 \times C_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 2.800 \implies C_{\ce{H2SO4}} = \frac{2.800}{50.0} = 0.0560\text{ M}

    You multiplied the millimoles of HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} by 22 when setting up the precipitate balance. While sulfuric acid is diprotic (providing 2 moles2\text{ moles} of HX+\ce{H+} per mole), it contains only 1 mole1\text{ mole} of sulfate ion (SOX4X2−\ce{SO4^2-}). Therefore, the stoichiometric ratio between HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} and BaSOX4\ce{BaSO4} is 1:11:1.

  3. Step 3

    mmol NaOH=38.4×0.250=9.60 mmol  ⟹  100.0×CHX2SOX4+50.0×CHCl=9.60\text{mmol NaOH} = 38.4 \times 0.250 = 9.60\text{ mmol} \implies 100.0 \times C_{\ce{H2SO4}} + 50.0 \times C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.60

  4. Step 4

    100.0×0.0280+50.0×CHCl=9.60  ⟹  2.80+50.0×CHCl=9.60  ⟹  50.0×CHCl=6.80  ⟹  CHCl=0.136 M100.0 \times 0.0280 + 50.0 \times C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.60 \implies 2.80 + 50.0 \times C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.60 \implies 50.0 \times C_{\ce{HCl}} = 6.80 \implies C_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.136\text{ M}

    Correct

    100.0(0.0560)+50.0CHCl=9.60  ⟹  5.60+50.0CHCl=9.60  ⟹  50.0CHCl=4.00  ⟹  CHCl=0.0800 M100.0(0.0560) + 50.0C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.60 \implies 5.60 + 50.0C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.60 \implies 50.0C_{\ce{HCl}} = 4.00 \implies C_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.0800\text{ M}

    Your algebraic steps to solve for CHClC_{\ce{HCl}} were logically executed, but your result was affected by substituting the incorrect value of CHX2SOX4C_{\ce{H2SO4}} from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You clearly defined the molar concentration variables for both acids.

You correctly calculated the millimoles of titrant and precipitate from the laboratory data.

You properly applied the stoichiometric factor of 22 for the diprotic acid in the neutralization equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Stoichiometric coefficient overextension

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You transferred the diprotic factor of 22 (which applies to titratable protons, HX+\ce{H+}) onto the sulfate ion balance, overlooking that one formula unit of HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} yields only one SOX4X2−\ce{SO4^2-} ion upon dissociation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Ion Stoichiometry Check
  • For a polyprotic compound HnA\ce{H}_n\ce{A}, 1 mole1\text{ mole} of acid produces n molesn\text{ moles} of HX+\ce{H+}, but only 1 mole1\text{ mole} of conjugate anion An−\ce{A}^{n-}.

  • Always separate the ion dissociation equation into its cation and anion components before writing conservation equations.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Equate the millimoles of sulfate precipitate directly to the millimoles of sulfuric acid: 50.0×CHX2SOX4=2.80050.0 \times C_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 2.800.

  2. Solve for the concentration of sulfuric acid: CHX2SOX4=2.80050.0=0.0560 MC_{\ce{H2SO4}} = \frac{2.800}{50.0} = 0.0560\text{ M}.

  3. Substitute CHX2SOX4=0.0560 MC_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.0560\text{ M} into the neutralization equation: 100.0(0.0560)+50.0CHCl=9.60100.0(0.0560) + 50.0C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.60.

  4. Simplify and solve for CHClC_{\ce{HCl}}: 5.60+50.0CHCl=9.60  ⟹  50.0CHCl=4.00  ⟹  CHCl=0.0800 M5.60 + 50.0C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.60 \implies 50.0C_{\ce{HCl}} = 4.00 \implies C_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.0800\text{ M}.

Final answer

CHX2SOX4=0.0560 MC_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.0560\text{ M} and CHCl=0.0800 MC_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.0800\text{ M}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the full dissociation equation HX2SOX4→2 HX++SOX4X2−\ce{H2SO4 -> 2H+ + SO4^2-} whenever you build multi-reaction systems.

  • Review whether each conservation equation balances protons, anions, or total molecules before inserting stoichiometric factors.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 20.0 mL20.0\text{ mL} sample containing a mixture of sulfuric acid (diprotic) and nitric acid (monoprotic) requires 30.0 mL30.0\text{ mL} of 0.100 M NaOH0.100\text{ M }\ce{NaOH} to reach the equivalence point. If the concentration of HNOX3\ce{HNO3} is known to be 0.050 M0.050\text{ M}, find the concentration of HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4}.

Answer

0.050 M0.050\text{ M}. Total millimoles of OHX−=30.0×0.100=3.00 mmol\ce{OH-} = 30.0 \times 0.100 = 3.00\text{ mmol}. Setting up the proton balance: 2(20.0)CHX2SOX4+(20.0)(0.050)=3.00  ⟹  40.0CHX2SOX4+1.00=3.00  ⟹  40.0CHX2SOX4=2.00  ⟹  CHX2SOX4=0.050 M2(20.0)C_{\ce{H2SO4}} + (20.0)(0.050) = 3.00 \implies 40.0 C_{\ce{H2SO4}} + 1.00 = 3.00 \implies 40.0 C_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 2.00 \implies C_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.050\text{ M}.

02

A 25.0 mL25.0\text{ mL} aliquot of an aqueous solution containing phosphoric acid (triprotic, HX3POX4\ce{H3PO4}) and hydrochloric acid (monoprotic, HCl\ce{HCl}) requires 45.0 mL45.0\text{ mL} of 0.200 M NaOH0.200\text{ M }\ce{NaOH} for complete neutralization to the third equivalence point. A second 25.0 mL25.0\text{ mL} aliquot precipitates all phosphate as magnesium ammonium phosphate, yielding 0.00200 mol0.00200\text{ mol} of precipitate. Determine the molar concentrations of both acids in the mixture.

Answer

CHX3POX4=0.0800 MC_{\ce{H3PO4}} = 0.0800\text{ M} and CHCl=0.120 MC_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.120\text{ M}. From the precipitate: (0.0250)CHX3POX4=0.00200  ⟹  CHX3POX4=0.0800 M(0.0250)C_{\ce{H3PO4}} = 0.00200 \implies C_{\ce{H3PO4}} = 0.0800\text{ M}. Total base used: 45.0×0.200=9.00 mmol45.0 \times 0.200 = 9.00\text{ mmol}. Proton balance: 3(25.0)CHX3POX4+25.0CHCl=9.00  ⟹  3(25.0)(0.0800)+25.0CHCl=9.00  ⟹  6.00+25.0CHCl=9.00  ⟹  25.0CHCl=3.00  ⟹  CHCl=0.120 M3(25.0)C_{\ce{H3PO4}} + 25.0 C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.00 \implies 3(25.0)(0.0800) + 25.0 C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.00 \implies 6.00 + 25.0 C_{\ce{HCl}} = 9.00 \implies 25.0 C_{\ce{HCl}} = 3.00 \implies C_{\ce{HCl}} = 0.120\text{ M}.

03

A 100.0 mL100.0\text{ mL} solution contains a mixture of HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} and oxalic acid (HX2CX2OX4\ce{H2C2O4}, diprotic). Titration of a 25.0 mL25.0\text{ mL} aliquot requires 35.0 mL35.0\text{ mL} of 0.100 M NaOH0.100\text{ M }\ce{NaOH} for complete neutralization. A separate 25.0 mL25.0\text{ mL} aliquot requires 12.0 mL12.0\text{ mL} of 0.0200 M KMnOX40.0200\text{ M }\ce{KMnO4} in acidic solution for complete oxidation of the oxalate (5CX2OX4X2−+2MnOX4X−+16HX+→10COX2+2MnX2++8HX2O5\ce{C2O4^2-} + 2\ce{MnO4^-} + 16\ce{H+} \to 10\ce{CO2} + 2\ce{Mn^2+} + 8\ce{H2O}). Calculate the molarities of HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} and HX2CX2OX4\ce{H2C2O4}.

Answer

CHX2CX2OX4=0.0240 MC_{\ce{H2C2O4}} = 0.0240\text{ M} and CHX2SOX4=0.0460 MC_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.0460\text{ M}. Millimoles of MnOX4X−=12.0×0.0200=0.240 mmol\ce{MnO4^-} = 12.0 \times 0.0200 = 0.240\text{ mmol}. Moles of oxalate: 0.240×52=0.600 mmol0.240 \times \frac{5}{2} = 0.600\text{ mmol}. Thus, 25.0CHX2CX2OX4=0.600  ⟹  CHX2CX2OX4=0.0240 M25.0 C_{\ce{H2C2O4}} = 0.600 \implies C_{\ce{H2C2O4}} = 0.0240\text{ M}. Neutralization balance: 2(25.0)CHX2SOX4+2(25.0)CHX2CX2OX4=35.0×0.100=3.50 mmol2(25.0)C_{\ce{H2SO4}} + 2(25.0)C_{\ce{H2C2O4}} = 35.0 \times 0.100 = 3.50\text{ mmol}. Substitute oxalate: 50.0CHX2SOX4+50.0(0.0240)=3.50  ⟹  50.0CHX2SOX4+1.20=3.50  ⟹  50.0CHX2SOX4=2.30  ⟹  CHX2SOX4=0.0460 M50.0 C_{\ce{H2SO4}} + 50.0(0.0240) = 3.50 \implies 50.0 C_{\ce{H2SO4}} + 1.20 = 3.50 \implies 50.0 C_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 2.30 \implies C_{\ce{H2SO4}} = 0.0460\text{ M}.

Loading workspace…