Resources
In an analytical chemistry laboratory, a student analyzes a aliquot of an aqueous mixture containing both sulfuric acid (, diprotic) and hydrochloric acid (, monoprotic). The total acid content in the sample requires exactly of standardized to reach the phenolphthalein end point. A second identical aliquot is treated with excess aqueous barium chloride (), precipitating all sulfate quantitatively as pure, dry barium sulfate (, molar mass ); the recovered precipitate has a dry mass of . Define variables for the molar concentrations and , write the system of linear equations modeling the millimoles of titratable protons and precipitated sulfate, and solve for the molarity of each acid in the original mixture.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Let and denote the molar concentrations (in ) of sulfuric acid and hydrochloric acid, respectively. The system of equations is: , which simplifies to . Solving gives and .
Steps
Define the Variables
Let:
- represent the molar concentration ( or ) of sulfuric acid in the mixture.
- represent the molar concentration ( or ) of hydrochloric acid in the mixture.
The volume of each aliquot is .
Set Up the Acid-Base Neutralization Equation
Sulfuric acid () is a diprotic acid, meaning each mole of provides of ions. Hydrochloric acid () is a monoprotic acid, providing of per mole of acid.
The moles of neutralized by equal the moles of supplied:
The moles of consumed during titration are:
Equating the moles of to the moles of gives the first equation:
Pitfall: A common error is neglecting the diprotic nature of . Forgetting the stoichiometric factor of for leads to an incorrect total proton balance.
Set Up the Sulfate Precipitation Equation
Adding excess precipitates all sulfate ions as barium sulfate ():
Each mole of produces of sulfate ions (). Hydrochloric acid contains no sulfate.
The moles of precipitated are calculated from its mass and molar mass:
Since the sample contained all of this sulfate:
This yields the second equation:
Write and Solve the System of Linear Equations
The system of equations is:
Solve for directly from the second equation:
Substitute into the first equation:
The concentrations in the original mixture are and .
Typical errors
01 The student treats sulfuric acid as monoprotic during the neutralization reaction, forgetting that each mole of H2SO4 donates two moles of protons.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
\text{mmol }$$\ce{BaSO4} = 1000 = 2.800 50.0 C_{} = 2.800 C_{} = 0.0560$\text{ M}$$
- Step 2
= 38.4 0.250 = 9.60 50.0 C_{} + 50.0 C_{} = 9.60
Correct2(50.0)C_{} + 50.0 C_{} = 9.60 100.0 C_{} + 50.0 C_{} = 9.60
Sulfuric acid is diprotic, meaning each mole of yields of ions upon complete neutralization with . Your equation treats as monoprotic by using a stoichiometric coefficient of instead of .
- Step 3
50.0 0.0560 + 50.0 C_{} = 9.60 2.80 + 50.0 C_{} = 9.60 C_{} = 0.136_
Correct100.0(0.0560) + 50.0 C_{} = 9.60 5.60 + 50.0 C_{} = 9.60 C_{} = 0.0800_
Your algebraic substitution and solving steps were executed cleanly, but the resulting concentration for is incorrect due to the missing factor of in the neutralization equation.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly defined your variables and calculated the millimoles of barium sulfate precipitate accurately.
You correctly formulated and solved the linear equation for the sulfate mass balance.
You correctly calculated the total millimoles of sodium hydroxide used in the titration.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated sulfuric acid as a monoprotic acid providing of protons per mole of acid during the neutralization balance, overlooking that diprotic releases of per mole.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check Acid Proticity
Every mole of a diprotic acid neutralizes of strong base .
Always multiply the moles or molarity of a polyprotic acid by its proticity when writing total titratable proton balance equations ().
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the total millimoles of titratable : .
Substitute : .
Simplify the product: .
Isolate the term: .
Divide by volume: .
and
02 The student mistakenly doubles the sulfate amount, believing the stoichiometric coefficient 2 in H2SO4 means two moles of sulfate are produced per mole of acid.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You multiplied the millimoles of by when setting up the precipitate balance. While sulfuric acid is diprotic (providing of per mole), it contains only of sulfate ion (). Therefore, the stoichiometric ratio between and is .
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
Your algebraic steps to solve for were logically executed, but your result was affected by substituting the incorrect value of from Step 2.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly defined the molar concentration variables for both acids.
You correctly calculated the millimoles of titrant and precipitate from the laboratory data.
You properly applied the stoichiometric factor of for the diprotic acid in the neutralization equation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou transferred the diprotic factor of (which applies to titratable protons, ) onto the sulfate ion balance, overlooking that one formula unit of yields only one ion upon dissociation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Ion Stoichiometry Check
For a polyprotic compound , of acid produces of , but only of conjugate anion .
Always separate the ion dissociation equation into its cation and anion components before writing conservation equations.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEquate the millimoles of sulfate precipitate directly to the millimoles of sulfuric acid: .
Solve for the concentration of sulfuric acid: .
Substitute into the neutralization equation: .
Simplify and solve for : .
and
Lock it in
How many moles of are required to completely neutralize of a diprotic acid like ?
of . Each molecule of releases two titratable protons ().
Similar question
A sample containing a mixture of sulfuric acid (diprotic) and nitric acid (monoprotic) requires of to reach the equivalence point. If the concentration of is known to be , find the concentration of .
Answer
. Total millimoles of . Setting up the proton balance: .
A aliquot of an aqueous solution containing phosphoric acid (triprotic, ) and hydrochloric acid (monoprotic, ) requires of for complete neutralization to the third equivalence point. A second aliquot precipitates all phosphate as magnesium ammonium phosphate, yielding of precipitate. Determine the molar concentrations of both acids in the mixture.
Answer
and . From the precipitate: . Total base used: . Proton balance: .
A solution contains a mixture of and oxalic acid (, diprotic). Titration of a aliquot requires of for complete neutralization. A separate aliquot requires of in acidic solution for complete oxidation of the oxalate (). Calculate the molarities of and .
Answer
and . Millimoles of . Moles of oxalate: . Thus, . Neutralization balance: . Substitute oxalate: .