Resources

An electric point charge q1=−4.00 nCq_1 = -4.00\text{ nC} is located at the origin x=0 mx = 0\text{ m}, and a second charge q2=+9.00 nCq_2 = +9.00\text{ nC} is placed at x=2.00 mx = 2.00\text{ m} along the xx-axis. Determine the exact coordinate xx where the net electric field E⃗(x)\vec{E}(x) is zero. Express the position with appropriate sign, unit symbol, and state the excluded domain points where E⃗(x)\vec{E}(x) is undefined due to point charge singularities.

Answer and steps

Final answer

x=−4.00 mx = -4.00\text{ m}; excluded points: x∈R∖{0 m,2.00 m}x \in \mathbb{R} \setminus \{0\text{ m}, 2.00\text{ m}\}

Steps

01

Identify the Domain Restrictions

The electric field of an idealized point charge qq located at x0x_0 has magnitude E=k∣q∣(x−x0)2E = \frac{k|q|}{(x - x_0)^2}. As x→x0x \to x_0, the distance approaches zero, creating a singularity where the field is undefined.

Because the two charges are located at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and x=2.00 mx = 2.00\text{ m}, the electric field function E⃗(x)\vec{E}(x) is undefined at these coordinates: Excluded points: x∈R∖{0 m,2.00 m}\text{Excluded points: } x \in \mathbb{R} \setminus \{0\text{ m}, 2.00\text{ m}\}


02

Determine Which Region Can Contain a Zero-Field Point

The xx-axis is divided into three distinct regions:

  • Between the charges (0 m<x<2.00 m0\text{ m} < x < 2.00\text{ m}):
    A test charge placed here experiences a field toward the negative charge q1q_1 (in the −x-x direction) and a field away from the positive charge q2q_2 (also in the −x-x direction). Since both electric field vectors point in the same direction, their sum can never be zero.
  • To the right of both charges (x>2.00 mx > 2.00\text{ m}):
    In this region, any point is closer to q2q_2 than to q1q_1 (r2<r1r_2 < r_1). Because ∣q2∣=9.00 nC>∣q1∣=4.00 nC|q_2| = 9.00\text{ nC} > |q_1| = 4.00\text{ nC}, the field from q2q_2 is always strictly greater in magnitude than the field from q1q_1 (E2>E1E_2 > E_1). Thus, they cannot cancel.
  • To the left of both charges (x<0 mx < 0\text{ m}):
    Here, the field E⃗1\vec{E}_1 points in the +x+x direction (attracted toward q1q_1), while E⃗2\vec{E}_2 points in the −x-x direction (repelled from q2q_2). Because the point is closer to the smaller charge ∣q1∣|q_1|, the two opposing fields can have equal magnitudes and cancel completely.

03

Set Up and Solve the Magnitude Equation

For x<0 mx < 0\text{ m}, let the distance from q1q_1 be r1=0−x=−xr_1 = 0 - x = -x, and the distance from q2q_2 be r2=2.00 m−xr_2 = 2.00\text{ m} - x.

Equating the magnitudes of the two fields: k∣q1∣r12=k∣q2∣r22\frac{k |q_1|}{r_1^2} = \frac{k |q_2|}{r_2^2}

Cancel the Coulomb constant kk and substitute the charge magnitudes: 4.00 nC(−x)2=9.00 nC(2.00−x)2\frac{4.00\text{ nC}}{(-x)^2} = \frac{9.00\text{ nC}}{(2.00 - x)^2}

Take the positive square root on both sides (noting that both −x>0-x > 0 and 2.00−x>02.00 - x > 0): 2.00−x=3.002.00−x\frac{2.00}{-x} = \frac{3.00}{2.00 - x}

Cross-multiply to solve for xx: 2.00(2.00−x)=3.00(−x)2.00(2.00 - x) = 3.00(-x) 4.00−2.00x=−3.00x4.00 - 2.00x = -3.00x x=−4.00 mx = -4.00\text{ m}


04

Summary of the Position and Domain

  • Position of zero net field: x=−4.00 mx = -4.00\text{ m}
  • Excluded points of the domain: x∈R∖{0 m,2.00 m}x \in \mathbb{R} \setminus \{0\text{ m}, 2.00\text{ m}\}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes the zero-field location must lie between the two charges and solves 2/x = 3/(2 - x), leading to x = 0.80 m.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E1=E2  ⟹  k(4.00)x2=k(9.00)(2.00−x)2E_1 = E_2 \implies \frac{k(4.00)}{x^2} = \frac{k(9.00)}{(2.00 - x)^2}

    Correct

    k(4.00)(−x)2=k(9.00)(2.00−x)2for x<0 m\frac{k(4.00)}{(-x)^2} = \frac{k(9.00)}{(2.00 - x)^2} \quad \text{for } x < 0\text{ m}

    You placed the test point between the charges (0<x<2.00 m0 < x < 2.00\text{ m}). However, because q1q_1 is negative and q2q_2 is positive, both electric field vectors point in the −x-x direction in that region. For opposite charges, the fields can only cancel outside the charges, closer to the charge with the smaller absolute magnitude (x<0 mx < 0\text{ m}).

  2. Step 2

    2.00x=3.002.00−x  ⟹  3.00x=4.00−2.00x  ⟹  5.00x=4.00  ⟹  x=0.80 m\frac{2.00}{x} = \frac{3.00}{2.00 - x} \implies 3.00x = 4.00 - 2.00x \implies 5.00x = 4.00 \implies x = 0.80\text{ m}

    Correct

    2.00−x=3.002.00−x  ⟹  4.00−2.00x=−3.00x  ⟹  x=−4.00 m\frac{2.00}{-x} = \frac{3.00}{2.00 - x} \implies 4.00 - 2.00x = -3.00x \implies x = -4.00\text{ m}

    Your algebraic manipulation and cross-multiplication were clean and accurate, but this result inherits the incorrect geometric setup from the first step.

  3. Step 3

    b) x=0 m,  x=2.00 m\text{b) } x = 0\text{ m}, \; x = 2.00\text{ m}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the two coordinate locations where the electric field has undefined singularities.

You solved the rational equation accurately using square roots and cross-multiplication.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Wrong region for zero net field

You equated the magnitudes as if the opposing fields could cancel between the charges.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the electric field balance purely as an equality of magnitudes without checking vector directions. For two charges of opposite signs, the electric fields point in the same direction between them and can only point in opposite directions in the exterior regions.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check vector directions by region
  • For opposite-sign charges, the field vectors add constructively in the interior region and oppose each other only in the exterior regions.

  • Draw test-charge field arrows in all three regions (x<x1x < x_1, x1<x<x2x_1 < x < x_2, and x>x2x > x_2) before setting up the distance equation.

Identify the side with the smaller magnitude
  • Net zero field can only occur closer to the charge with the smaller absolute magnitude: ∣qsmall∣rsmall2=∣qlarge∣rlarge2\frac{|q_{\text{small}}|}{r_{\text{small}}^2} = \frac{|q_{\text{large}}|}{r_{\text{large}}^2}.

  • Since ∣q1∣=4.00 nC<∣q2∣=9.00 nC|q_1| = 4.00\text{ nC} < |q_2| = 9.00\text{ nC}, place the balance point on the exterior side closer to q1q_1, meaning x<0 mx < 0\text{ m}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. For x<0 mx < 0\text{ m}, the distance to q1q_1 at the origin is r1=−xr_1 = -x, and the distance to q2q_2 at x=2.00 mx = 2.00\text{ m} is r2=2.00−xr_2 = 2.00 - x.

  2. Equate the two field magnitudes: k(4.00 nC)(−x)2=k(9.00 nC)(2.00−x)2\frac{k(4.00\text{ nC})}{(-x)^2} = \frac{k(9.00\text{ nC})}{(2.00 - x)^2}.

  3. Take the positive square root on both sides: 2.00−x=3.002.00−x\frac{2.00}{-x} = \frac{3.00}{2.00 - x}.

  4. Cross-multiply to solve for xx: 2.00(2.00−x)=3.00(−x)  ⟹  4.00−2.00x=−3.00x  ⟹  x=−4.00 m2.00(2.00 - x) = 3.00(-x) \implies 4.00 - 2.00x = -3.00x \implies x = -4.00\text{ m}.

Final answer

x=−4.00 mx = -4.00\text{ m}; excluded points: x∈R∖{0 m,2.00 m}x \in \mathbb{R} \setminus \{0\text{ m}, 2.00\text{ m}\}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch electric field arrows for each charge in each separated region before writing equations.

  • Verify that the resulting coordinate lies on the side of the smaller charge magnitude when the charges have opposite signs.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student uses an inverse-distance dependence instead of an inverse-square dependence for the electric field.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    k∣q1∣−x=k∣q2∣2.00−x\frac{k|q_1|}{-x} = \frac{k|q_2|}{2.00 - x}

    Correct

    k∣q1∣(−x)2=k∣q2∣(2.00−x)2\frac{k|q_1|}{(-x)^2} = \frac{k|q_2|}{(2.00 - x)^2}

    You set up the magnitudes using an inverse-distance relationship k∣q∣r\frac{k|q|}{r}, which corresponds to electric potential rather than electric field. The magnitude of the electric field from an idealized point charge follows an inverse-square law, E=k∣q∣r2E = \frac{k|q|}{r^2}.

  2. Step 2

    4.00−x=9.002.00−x  ⟹  4.00(2.00−x)=−9.00x  ⟹  8.00−4.00x=−9.00x  ⟹  5.00x=−8.00  ⟹  x=−1.60 m\frac{4.00}{-x} = \frac{9.00}{2.00 - x} \implies 4.00(2.00 - x) = -9.00x \implies 8.00 - 4.00x = -9.00x \implies 5.00x = -8.00 \implies x = -1.60\text{ m}

    Correct

    4.00(−x)2=9.00(2.00−x)2  ⟹  2.00−x=3.002.00−x  ⟹  x=−4.00 m\frac{4.00}{(-x)^2} = \frac{9.00}{(2.00 - x)^2} \implies \frac{2.00}{-x} = \frac{3.00}{2.00 - x} \implies x = -4.00\text{ m}

    Your cross-multiplication and algebraic solving were carried out correctly, but the resulting coordinate x=−1.60 mx = -1.60\text{ m} is affected by the missing squared distance in the denominators.

  3. Step 3

    x=0 m,x=2.00 mx = 0\text{ m}, \quad x = 2.00\text{ m}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the cancellation point must occur in the region x<0 mx < 0\text{ m}, writing the positive distances as −x-x and 2.00−x2.00 - x.

You executed linear algebra and cross-multiplication accurately.

You identified the exact coordinates of the point charge singularities.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse-Distance vs. Inverse-Square Law

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You substituted the electric potential formula V=kqrV = \frac{kq}{r} (or omitted the exponent) instead of the inverse-square electric field formula E=k∣q∣r2E = \frac{k|q|}{r^2} when balancing the opposing field magnitudes.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Point Charge Field Formula
  • E=k∣q∣r2E = \frac{k|q|}{r^2}

  • Always verify that the distance in the denominator is squared whenever you calculate electric field or electrostatic force.

Square Root Simplification
  • a2r12=ar1\sqrt{\frac{a^2}{r_1^2}} = \frac{a}{r_1} for positive geometric distances r1,r2>0r_1, r_2 > 0

  • Take the square root of both sides after substituting charge magnitudes to avoid expanding into an unnecessary quadratic equation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Equate the inverse-square magnitudes for x<0 mx < 0\text{ m}: k∣q1∣(−x)2=k∣q2∣(2.00−x)2\frac{k|q_1|}{(-x)^2} = \frac{k|q_2|}{(2.00 - x)^2}.

  2. Cancel kk and substitute ∣q1∣=4.00 nC|q_1| = 4.00\text{ nC} and ∣q2∣=9.00 nC|q_2| = 9.00\text{ nC}: 4.00(−x)2=9.00(2.00−x)2\frac{4.00}{(-x)^2} = \frac{9.00}{(2.00 - x)^2}.

  3. Take the positive square root on both sides: 2.00−x=3.002.00−x\frac{2.00}{-x} = \frac{3.00}{2.00 - x}.

  4. Cross-multiply and solve for xx: 2.00(2.00−x)=3.00(−x)  ⟹  4.00−2.00x=−3.00x  ⟹  x=−4.00 m2.00(2.00 - x) = 3.00(-x) \implies 4.00 - 2.00x = -3.00x \implies x = -4.00\text{ m}.

Final answer

x=−4.00 mx = -4.00\text{ m}; excluded points: x∈R∖{0 m,2.00 m}x \in \mathbb{R} \setminus \{0\text{ m}, 2.00\text{ m}\}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between electric field magnitude (E=k∣q∣r2E = \frac{k|q|}{r^2}) and electric potential (V=kqrV = \frac{kq}{r}).

  • Practice balancing vector fields with unequal point charges along a line by setting up distance ratios.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student writes distance to q₁ as x instead of -x when setting up the square-root equation for x < 0, obtaining an unphysical coordinate x = 4.00 m.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    4.00x2=9.00(2.00−x)2\frac{4.00}{x^2} = \frac{9.00}{(2.00-x)^2}

  2. Step 2

    2.00x=3.00(2.00−x)\frac{2.00}{x} = \frac{3.00}{(2.00-x)}

    Correct

    2.00−x=3.002.00−x\frac{2.00}{-x} = \frac{3.00}{2.00-x}

    Because q1q_1 is negative and q2q_2 is positive, the fields point in the same direction between them (0<x<2.00 m0 < x < 2.00\text{ m}) and can never cancel there. Cancellation is only possible to the left of the origin (x<0 mx < 0\text{ m}), where the distance to the origin is ∣x∣=−x|x| = -x. Writing x2=x\sqrt{x^2} = x assumes x>0x > 0.

  3. Step 3

    2.00(2.00−x)=3.00x  ⟹  4.00−2.00x=3.00x  ⟹  5.00x=4.00  ⟹  x=4.00 m2.00(2.00-x) = 3.00x \implies 4.00 - 2.00x = 3.00x \implies 5.00x = 4.00 \implies x = 4.00\text{ m}

    Correct

    2.00(2.00−x)=3.00(−x)  ⟹  4.00−2.00x=−3.00x  ⟹  x=−4.00 m2.00(2.00-x) = 3.00(-x) \implies 4.00 - 2.00x = -3.00x \implies x = -4.00\text{ m}

    Even within your equation, solving 5.00x=4.005.00x = 4.00 yields x=0.80 mx = 0.80\text{ m}, not 4.00 m4.00\text{ m}. Using the correct distance expression with −x-x leads directly to x=−4.00 mx = -4.00\text{ m}.

  4. Step 4

    x=0 m,x=2.00 mx = 0\text{ m}, x = 2.00\text{ m}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly equated the Coulomb magnitude formulas for the two point charges.

You correctly identified the two charge locations where the field diverges and must be excluded from the domain.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Distance sign in directional coordinates

You solved 5.00x=4.005.00x = 4.00 as x=4.00 mx = 4.00\text{ m} instead of dividing by 5.005.00.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated distance as the coordinate xx instead of the absolute value ∣x∣=−x|x| = -x for coordinates to the left of the origin, overlooking that electric fields only oppose each other in the region x<0 mx < 0\text{ m}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Region vector analysis
  • For opposite signs, fields oppose only outside the segment connecting the charges, nearer to the smaller-magnitude charge.

  • Sketch the field vectors in all three regions before setting up algebra to confirm where cancellation is physically possible.

Coordinate vs. distance
  • Distance rr is always strictly positive: for x<0x < 0, r=∣x∣=−xr = |x| = -x.

  • Express distances explicitly as positive geometric lengths before simplifying square roots.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that fields can only cancel when x<0 mx < 0\text{ m}, so the distance to the origin is r1=−xr_1 = -x and distance to q2q_2 is r2=2.00−xr_2 = 2.00 - x.

  2. Set up the magnitude equality: 2.00−x=3.002.00−x\frac{2.00}{-x} = \frac{3.00}{2.00 - x}.

  3. Cross-multiply: 2.00(2.00−x)=−3.00x2.00(2.00 - x) = -3.00x.

  4. Expand and solve for xx: 4.00−2.00x=−3.00x  ⟹  x=−4.00 m4.00 - 2.00x = -3.00x \implies x = -4.00\text{ m}.

Final answer

x=−4.00 mx = -4.00\text{ m}; excluded points: x∈R∖{0 m,2.00 m}x \in \mathbb{R} \setminus \{0\text{ m}, 2.00\text{ m}\}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch electric field direction arrows in all three regions along the axis before setting up equations.

  • Always express geometric distances as ∣x−x0∣|x - x_0| and replace absolute values according to the chosen region before solving.

  • Double-check algebraic divisions when isolating variables in linear equations.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two charges q1=+2.00 nCq_1 = +2.00\text{ nC} at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and q2=+8.00 nCq_2 = +8.00\text{ nC} at x=3.00 mx = 3.00\text{ m} lie on the xx-axis. Determine the coordinate xx where the net electric field is zero.

Answer

x=1.00 mx = 1.00\text{ m}. For like charges, the zero lies between them: 2.00x2=8.00(3.00−x)2  ⟹  1x=23.00−x  ⟹  3.00−x=2x  ⟹  x=1.00 m\frac{2.00}{x^2} = \frac{8.00}{(3.00 - x)^2} \implies \frac{1}{x} = \frac{2}{3.00 - x} \implies 3.00 - x = 2x \implies x = 1.00\text{ m}.

02

A point charge q1=+16.0 nCq_1 = +16.0\text{ nC} is at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and q2=−4.00 nCq_2 = -4.00\text{ nC} is at x=3.00 mx = 3.00\text{ m}. Find the coordinate xx where the net electric field is zero and state the excluded domain points.

Answer

x=6.00 mx = 6.00\text{ m}; excluded points: x∈R∖{0 m,3.00 m}x \in \mathbb{R} \setminus \{0\text{ m}, 3.00\text{ m}\}. Since the charges have opposite signs, the zero lies outside, closer to the smaller charge ∣q2∣|q_2| (x>3.00 mx > 3.00\text{ m}). Solving 16.0x2=4.00(x−3.00)2  ⟹  4.0x=2.0x−3.00  ⟹  4x−12.0=2x  ⟹  x=6.00 m\frac{16.0}{x^2} = \frac{4.00}{(x - 3.00)^2} \implies \frac{4.0}{x} = \frac{2.0}{x - 3.00} \implies 4x - 12.0 = 2x \implies x = 6.00\text{ m}.

03

Charge q1=−9.00 μCq_1 = -9.00\,\mu\text{C} is at x=−1.00 mx = -1.00\text{ m} and charge q2=+25.0 μCq_2 = +25.0\,\mu\text{C} is at x=3.00 mx = 3.00\text{ m}. Find all points on the xx-axis where a test charge experiences zero net electrostatic force.

Answer

x=−7.00 mx = -7.00\text{ m}. Zero force requires zero net field. With opposite charges, the point lies to the left of q1q_1 (x<−1.00 mx < -1.00\text{ m}). Let d=−1.00−xd = -1.00 - x. Then the distance to q2q_2 is d+4.00d + 4.00. Setting 9.00d2=25.0(d+4.00)2  ⟹  3d=5d+4.00  ⟹  3d+12.00=5d  ⟹  d=6.00 m\frac{9.00}{d^2} = \frac{25.0}{(d + 4.00)^2} \implies \frac{3}{d} = \frac{5}{d + 4.00} \implies 3d + 12.00 = 5d \implies d = 6.00\text{ m}, so x=−1.00−6.00=−7.00 mx = -1.00 - 6.00 = -7.00\text{ m}.

Loading workspace…