Resources

A student attempts to graph p(x)=−3x+12p(x) = \sqrt{-3x + 12} by applying transformations to f(x)=xf(x) = \sqrt{x}. The student asserts: 'Because there is +12+12 inside the radical, the graph shifts 1212 units to the left, followed by a reflection across the yy-axis and a horizontal compression by factor 13\frac{1}{3}.' Identify the factoring step required to evaluate the true horizontal translation, state the correct direction and magnitude of the shift, and find the domain of p(x)p(x).

Answer and steps

Final answer

Factored form is p(x)=−3(x−4)p(x) = \sqrt{-3(x - 4)}; the true horizontal translation is 44 units to the right; the domain of p(x)p(x) is (−∞,4](-\infty, 4]

Steps

01

Factor the expression inside the radical

When analyzing horizontal transformations on a function f(x)f(x), the input must be written in the standard form: f(B(x−h))f(B(x - h)) where:

  • ∣B∣|B| determines horizontal compression or stretch.
  • A negative sign on BB indicates a reflection across the yy-axis.
  • hh represents the true horizontal translation.

In the function p(x)=−3x+12p(x) = \sqrt{-3x + 12}, factor out the coefficient of xx, which is −3-3: p(x)=−3(x−4)p(x) = \sqrt{-3(x - 4)}

Common Pitfall: Looking at the constant +12+12 before factoring leads to the incorrect conclusion that the graph shifts 1212 units to the left. The shift depends solely on the value of hh once xx has a coefficient of 11.


02

Determine the true horizontal translation

From the factored form p(x)=−3(x−4)p(x) = \sqrt{-3(x - 4)}:

  • The term inside the inner parentheses is (x−4)(x - 4), so h=4h = 4.
  • Therefore, the true horizontal translation is 44 units to the right.

(Applying transformations from inside out: the base graph y=xy = \sqrt{x} shifts right by 44 units, reflects across the vertical line x=4x = 4 due to the negative sign, and compresses horizontally toward that line by a factor of 13\frac{1}{3}.)


03

Find the domain of p(x)p(x)

The radicand of an even root must be non-negative: −3x+12≥0-3x + 12 \ge 0

Subtract 1212 from both sides: −3x≥−12-3x \ge -12

Divide by −3-3 (reversing the inequality sign): x≤4x \le 4

In interval notation, the domain of p(x)p(x) is (−∞,4](-\infty, 4].

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student factors out 3 instead of -3, leading to an incorrect shift of 4 units to the left and reversing the inequality for the domain.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    p(x)=3(−x+4)=−3(x+4)p(x) = \sqrt{3(-x+4)} = \sqrt{-3(x+4)}

    Correct

    p(x)=−3(x−4)p(x) = \sqrt{-3(x - 4)}

    When factoring out a negative factor from a sum, the sign of each term inside the parentheses must change. Factoring −3-3 out of −3x+12-3x + 12 leaves (x−4)(x - 4), because −3⋅(−4)=+12-3 \cdot (-4) = +12.

  2. Step 2

    Shift 44 units to the left

    Correct

    Shift 44 units to the right

    Because the correct factored form is −3(x−4)\sqrt{-3(x - 4)}, the term inside is (x−4)(x - 4), which corresponds to h=4h = 4. This represents a horizontal translation of 44 units to the right.

  3. Step 3

    −x−4≥0  ⟹  −x≥4  ⟹  x≥4  ⟹  Domain: [4,∞)-x - 4 \ge 0 \implies -x \ge 4 \implies x \ge 4 \implies \text{Domain: } [4, \infty)](streamdown:incomplete-link)

    Correct

    −3x+12≥0  ⟹  −3x≥−12  ⟹  x≤4  ⟹  Domain: (−∞,4]-3x + 12 \ge 0 \implies -3x \ge -12 \implies x \le 4 \implies \text{Domain: } (-\infty, 4]

    This step contains two errors: it propagated the incorrect factored expression, and when dividing both sides of −x≥4-x \ge 4 by −1-1, the inequality sign was not reversed.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You knew to factor out the leading coefficient of xx to identify the true horizontal transformation.

You correctly set the radicand expression to be greater than or equal to 00 to find the domain.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Factoring negative leading coefficient and inequality sign reversal

You factored out the negative sign in 3(−x+4)3(-x+4) without distributing it to change the +4+4 into −4-4.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Difficulty tracking sign changes when factoring negative constants out of binomials, combined with forgetting to reverse the inequality symbol when dividing by a negative number.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distribute to verify factoring
  • −a(b−c)=−ab+ac-a(b - c) = -ab + ac

  • Always multiply your factored expression back out to confirm that it matches the original radicand.

Reverse inequality on negative division
  • If −x≥c-x \ge c, then x≤−cx \le -c.

  • Whenever you multiply or divide an inequality by a negative value, flip the inequality symbol immediately.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Factor −3-3 completely from the radicand: −3x+12=−3(x−4)-3x + 12 = -3(x - 4), so p(x)=−3(x−4)p(x) = \sqrt{-3(x - 4)}.

  2. Read the horizontal shift from standard form f(B(x−h))f(B(x - h)): here h=4h = 4, which indicates a shift 44 units to the right.

  3. Find the domain by setting the radicand non-negative: −3(x−4)≥0  ⟹  x−4≤0  ⟹  x≤4-3(x - 4) \ge 0 \implies x - 4 \le 0 \implies x \le 4, yielding the interval (−∞,4](-\infty, 4].

Final answer

Factored form: p(x)=−3(x−4)p(x) = \sqrt{-3(x - 4)}; horizontal translation: 44 units to the right; domain: (−∞,4](-\infty, 4].

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice factoring negative coefficients from binomial expressions such as −2x+10-2x + 10 and −5x+15-5x + 15.

  • Double-check your factored forms by expanding mentally before moving on to transformations.

  • Highlight or circle inequality signs whenever multiplying or dividing by negative numbers to ensure you reverse them.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student identifies the magnitude of the shift as 4 by dividing 12 by 3, but forgets to reverse the inequality when dividing by a negative number in the domain.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Factor −3-3 from −3x+12-3x + 12: p(x)=−3(x−4)p(x) = \sqrt{-3(x - 4)}

  2. Step 2

    Since it is (x−4)(x - 4), shift 44 units to the right

  3. Step 3

    −3x+12≥0  ⟹  −3x≥−12  ⟹  x≥4-3x + 12 \ge 0 \implies -3x \ge -12 \implies x \ge 4

    Correct

    −3x+12≥0  ⟹  −3x≥−12  ⟹  x≤4-3x + 12 \ge 0 \implies -3x \ge -12 \implies x \le 4

    When dividing both sides of an inequality by a negative number (here, dividing by −3-3), the direction of the inequality sign must flip from ≥\ge to ≤\le.

  4. Step 4

    Domain: [4,∞)[4, \infty)](streamdown:incomplete-link)

    Correct

    Domain: (−∞,4](-\infty, 4]

    This interval notation follows directly from the unreversed inequality x≥4x \ge 4 in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly factored −3-3 out of −3x+12-3x + 12 to place the function into standard transformation form f(B(x−h))f(B(x - h)).

You correctly determined that (x−4)(x - 4) indicates a shift of 44 units to the right rather than 1212 units to the left.

You correctly set the radicand −3x+12≥0-3x + 12 \ge 0 as the starting condition for finding the domain.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inequality Sign Direction

You forgot to flip the ≥\ge symbol to ≤\le when dividing both sides by −3-3.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the rule that multiplying or dividing an inequality by a negative number reverses the inequality relation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dividing by a Negative
  • If a≥ba \ge b and c<0c < 0, then ac≤bc\frac{a}{c} \le \frac{b}{c}.

  • Whenever you divide or multiply an inequality by a negative coefficient, immediately reverse the inequality symbol.

Domain Test Point
  • Points in the domain must keep the radicand non-negative.

  • Pick a test value such as x=5x = 5 from your proposed interval: −3(5)+12=−3\sqrt{-3(5) + 12} = \sqrt{-3}, which is undefined, showing x≥4x \ge 4 cannot be correct.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Divide both sides by −3-3 and reverse the inequality sign: x≤4x \le 4.

  2. Write the solution set in interval notation: (−∞,4](-\infty, 4].

Final answer

Factored form: p(x)=−3(x−4)p(x) = \sqrt{-3(x - 4)}; horizontal translation: 44 units to the right; domain: (−∞,4](-\infty, 4]

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice solving one-variable linear inequalities involving negative coefficients.

  • Always test a quick sample point inside your final domain interval to verify that the expression remains real.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student factors -3 incorrectly as -3(x + 4) due to a sign error when dividing positive 12 by negative 3, resulting in a shift of 4 units to the left.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    −3x+12=−3(x+4)  ⟹  p(x)=−3(x+4)-3x + 12 = -3(x + 4) \implies p(x) = \sqrt{-3(x + 4)}

    Correct

    −3x+12=−3(x−4)  ⟹  p(x)=−3(x−4)-3x + 12 = -3(x - 4) \implies p(x) = \sqrt{-3(x - 4)}

    When you factored out −3-3, you divided +12+12 by −3-3 and wrote +4+4 instead of −4-4.

  2. Step 2

    Because of \text{Because of }(x + 4), shift \text{, shift }4 units to the left\text{ units to the left}

    Correct

    Shift 4 units to the right\text{Shift }4\text{ units to the right}

    Your interpretation followed your factored form (x+4)(x + 4), but the correct factored form (x−4)(x - 4) corresponds to a shift of 44 units to the right.

  3. Step 3

    -3(x + 4) ≥\ge 0   ⟹  \implies x + 4 ≤\le 0   ⟹  \implies x ≤\le -4   ⟹  \implies Domain: \text{Domain: } (-∞\infty, -4]

    Correct

    -3(x - 4) ≥\ge 0   ⟹  \implies x - 4 ≤\le 0   ⟹  \implies x ≤\le 4   ⟹  \implies Domain: \text{Domain: } (-∞\infty, 4]

    You correctly flipped the inequality sign when dividing by −3-3, but the earlier sign error carried over into the domain boundary.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly realized that you must factor out the coefficient of xx before reading the horizontal translation.

You correctly identified that the base radical function requires the radicand to be non-negative to find the domain.

You correctly reversed the inequality direction when dividing by a negative number.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in factoring

You divided positive 1212 by negative 33 and wrote +4+4 instead of −4-4.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked distributing or factoring a negative sign across both terms when factoring a negative greatest common factor.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Factoring negative coefficients
  • When factoring a negative number out of an expression, reverse the signs of all terms: −ax+b=−a(x−ba)-ax + b = -a\left(x - \frac{b}{a}\right).

  • Always mentally redistribute your factored form (for instance, check if −3⋅(−4)=+12-3 \cdot (-4) = +12) before continuing.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Factor −3-3 out of −3x+12-3x + 12: −3x+12=−3(x−4)-3x + 12 = -3(x - 4), so p(x)=−3(x−4)p(x) = \sqrt{-3(x - 4)}.

  2. Identify the horizontal shift from (x−4)(x - 4): the graph shifts 44 units to the right.

  3. Solve −3(x−4)≥0-3(x - 4) \ge 0: dividing by −3-3 gives x−4≤0x - 4 \le 0, so x≤4x \le 4.

Final answer

Factored form is p(x)=−3(x−4)p(x) = \sqrt{-3(x - 4)}; the true horizontal translation is 44 units to the right; the domain of p(x)p(x) is (−∞,4](-\infty, 4].

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice factoring negative common factors from linear binomials and checking each term by redistribution.

  • Review reading horizontal shifts from standard transformation form f(B(x−h))f(B(x - h)), where (x−h)(x - h) with positive hh means a shift to the right.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Rewrite g(x)=−2x+10g(x) = \sqrt{-2x + 10} in standard factored form g(x)=B(x−h)g(x) = \sqrt{B(x - h)}, state the horizontal translation of the graph relative to y=xy = \sqrt{x}, and find its domain.

Answer

Factored form: g(x)=−2(x−5)g(x) = \sqrt{-2(x - 5)}. Horizontal translation: 55 units to the right. Domain: (−∞,5](-\infty, 5] (from −2x+10≥0  ⟹  −2x≥−10  ⟹  x≤5-2x + 10 \ge 0 \implies -2x \ge -10 \implies x \le 5).

02

A student states that h(x)=−4x−12h(x) = \sqrt{-4x - 12} has been shifted 1212 units to the left. Correct the student's statement by finding the true shift and the domain of h(x)h(x).

Answer

Factoring gives h(x)=−4(x+3)h(x) = \sqrt{-4(x + 3)}. The true horizontal shift is 33 units to the left (h=−3h = -3). The domain is (−∞,−3](-\infty, -3] since −4(x+3)≥0  ⟹  x+3≤0  ⟹  x≤−3-4(x + 3) \ge 0 \implies x + 3 \le 0 \implies x \le -3.

03

Given the function k(x)=6−2x+3k(x) = \sqrt{6 - 2x} + 3, list all transformations applied to the parent function f(x)=xf(x) = \sqrt{x} in correct order, and state both the domain and range of k(x)k(x).

Answer

In factored form, k(x)=−2(x−3)+3k(x) = \sqrt{-2(x - 3)} + 3. Transformations: horizontal translation 33 units right, reflection across the yy-axis, horizontal compression by a factor of 12\frac{1}{2}, and vertical translation 33 units up. Domain: (−∞,3](-\infty, 3]. Range: [3,∞)[3, \infty).](streamdown:incomplete-link)

Loading workspace…