Resources

A physics student uses the logarithmic potential energy model U(x)=−kln⁡(x0−xd)U(x) = -k \ln\left(\frac{x_0 - x}{d}\right) to describe a particle confined to a 1D force field, where k=12 Jk = 12\text{ J}, x0=2 mx_0 = 2\text{ m}, and d=1 md = 1\text{ m}. The student proposes two candidate equilibrium positions where the potential energy is hypothesized to satisfy U(x)=0 JU(x) = 0\text{ J}: (a) x=1 mx = 1\text{ m} and (b) x=3 mx = 3\text{ m}. Test whether each candidate position satisfies the equation U(x)=0U(x) = 0, explicitly addressing negative coordinate arguments and domain constraints of the logarithm.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) x=1 mx = 1\text{ m} satisfies the equation because U(1)=−12ln⁡(2−11)=−12ln⁡(1)=0 JU(1) = -12 \ln\left(\frac{2 - 1}{1}\right) = -12 \ln(1) = 0\text{ J}; (b) x=3 mx = 3\text{ m} does not satisfy the equation because the argument of the logarithm becomes 2−31=−1<0\frac{2 - 3}{1} = -1 < 0, which is undefined on the real domain.

Steps

01

State the Model and Domain Constraint

To determine whether a candidate position satisfies the equation U(x)=0 JU(x) = 0\text{ J}, substitute the position into the potential energy model and verify that the expression is well-defined and evaluates to zero.

Substitute the given parameters k=12 Jk = 12\text{ J}, x0=2 mx_0 = 2\text{ m}, and d=1 md = 1\text{ m} into the model: U(x)=−12ln⁡(2−x1)=−12ln⁡(2−x)U(x) = -12\ln\left(\frac{2 - x}{1}\right) = -12\ln(2 - x)

In real-valued mathematical modeling, the natural logarithm ln⁡(z)\ln(z) is defined only for strictly positive arguments: z>0  ⟹  2−x>0  ⟹  x<2z > 0 \implies 2 - x > 0 \implies x < 2

Any value x≥2x \ge 2 falls outside the domain of the physical model.


02

Test Candidate (a): x=1 mx = 1\text{ m}

  1. Check the domain: 2−(1)1=1>0\frac{2 - (1)}{1} = 1 > 0 Because the argument is strictly positive, x=1 mx = 1\text{ m} lies in the domain.
  2. Evaluate U(1)U(1): U(1)=−12ln⁡(1)=−12⋅0=0 JU(1) = -12\ln(1) = -12 \cdot 0 = 0\text{ J}

Therefore, x=1 mx = 1\text{ m} satisfies the equation U(x)=0U(x) = 0.


03

Test Candidate (b): x=3 mx = 3\text{ m}

  1. Check the argument of the logarithm: 2−(3)1=−11=−1\frac{2 - (3)}{1} = \frac{-1}{1} = -1
  2. Evaluate the domain constraint: Since −1≤0-1 \le 0, the expression ln⁡(−1)\ln(-1) is undefined in the real number system.

Therefore, x=3 mx = 3\text{ m} does not satisfy the equation because the function is undefined at this point.


Common Pitfall

A common algebraic error is formally setting −12ln⁡(2−x)=0-12\ln(2-x) = 0, dividing by −12-12 to get ln⁡(2−x)=0\ln(2-x) = 0, exponentiating to get 2−x=12-x = 1 (which gives x=1x = 1), but then confusing coordinate signs or squaring terms (such as solving (2−x)2=1  ⟹  x=1(2-x)^2 = 1 \implies x = 1 or x=3x = 3). Always verify candidate solutions directly in the original logarithmic function to ensure the argument is strictly positive.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student improperly applies an absolute value to the argument of the logarithm, causing the negative argument at x = 3 m to become ln(1) = 0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    2−11=1>0  ⟹  −12ln⁡(1)=0 J  ⟹  x=1 m satisfies U(x)=0\frac{2 - 1}{1} = 1 > 0 \implies -12\ln(1) = 0\text{ J} \implies x = 1\text{ m}\text{ satisfies } U(x) = 0

  2. Step 2

    2−31=−1  ⟹  Taking the magnitude inside the log gives ln⁡∣−1∣=ln⁡(1)=0\frac{2 - 3}{1} = -1 \implies \text{Taking the magnitude inside the log gives } \ln|-1| = \ln(1) = 0

    Correct

    2−31=−1≤0  ⟹  ln⁡(−1) is undefined in the real domain\frac{2 - 3}{1} = -1 \le 0 \implies \ln(-1)\text{ is undefined in the real domain}

    The defined model uses standard parentheses ln⁡(x0−xd)\ln\left(\frac{x_0 - x}{d}\right), not absolute values ln⁡∣z∣\ln|z|. In real-variable models, you cannot introduce absolute value bars to force a negative argument to be positive.

  3. Step 3

    U(3)=−12(0)=0 J  ⟹  x=3 m satisfies U(x)=0U(3) = -12(0) = 0\text{ J} \implies x = 3\text{ m}\text{ satisfies } U(x) = 0

    Correct

    x=3 m does not satisfy U(x)=0 because U(3) is undefinedx = 3\text{ m}\text{ does not satisfy } U(x) = 0\text{ because } U(3)\text{ is undefined}

    Because the logarithm is undefined at x=3 mx = 3\text{ m}, the potential energy function has no real value there, so the equation is not satisfied.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the model parameters and tested whether the argument of the logarithm was positive for x=1 mx = 1\text{ m}.

You correctly recognized that ln⁡(1)=0\ln(1) = 0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Improper Absolute Value Insertion in Logarithmic Domain

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the argument of the logarithm as a magnitude or distance that can be made positive with absolute value bars, rather than strictly enforcing the real domain constraint arg⁡(ln⁡)>0\arg(\ln) > 0 dictated by the model formula.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Respect the Given Function's Formula
  • Only functions explicitly defined with absolute values, such as ln⁡∣z∣\ln|z|, accept negative arguments; ln⁡(z)\ln(z) requires z>0z > 0.

  • Do not add absolute value bars unless they are given in the problem statement.

Check the Real Domain First
  • For a real function f(x)f(x) to satisfy f(x)=cf(x) = c, xx must first lie in the domain of ff.

  • If evaluating an input results in a non-positive logarithmic argument, immediately conclude that the function is undefined and the equation is not satisfied.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate the argument of the logarithm at x=3 mx = 3\text{ m}: 2−31=−1\frac{2 - 3}{1} = -1.

  2. Check the real logarithmic domain condition: ln⁡(z)\ln(z) requires z>0z > 0.

  3. Observe that −1≤0-1 \le 0, which means ln⁡(−1)\ln(-1) is undefined on the real numbers.

  4. Conclude that U(3)U(3) does not exist as a real potential energy value.

Final answer

(a) x=1 mx = 1\text{ m} satisfies the equation because U(1)=0 JU(1) = 0\text{ J}; (b) x=3 mx = 3\text{ m} does not satisfy the equation because U(3)U(3) is undefined.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the strict domain requirements of real-valued functions, especially ln⁡(z)\ln(z) where z>0z > 0.

  • Practice identifying candidate solutions that are extraneous due to domain restrictions without altering algebraic operators.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student reverses the order of terms in the numerator as (x - x₀)/d, evaluating the argument at x = 3 m as positive 1 and incorrectly concluding it satisfies the equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    1−21=−1  ⟹  ln⁡(−1) is undefined  ⟹  x=1 m is outside the domain and does not satisfy U(x)=0\frac{1 - 2}{1} = -1 \implies \ln(-1) \text{ is undefined} \implies x = 1\text{ m is outside the domain and does not satisfy } U(x) = 0

    Correct

    x0−xd=2−11=1>0  ⟹  U(1)=−12ln⁡(1)=0 J  ⟹  x=1 m satisfies U(x)=0\frac{x_0 - x}{d} = \frac{2 - 1}{1} = 1 > 0 \implies U(1) = -12\ln(1) = 0\text{ J} \implies x = 1\text{ m satisfies } U(x) = 0

    You correctly noted that ln⁡(−1)\ln(-1) is undefined on the real numbers, but the model specifies the numerator as x0−xx_0 - x, not x−x0x - x_0. For x=1 mx = 1\text{ m}, the argument is 2−11=1\frac{2 - 1}{1} = 1, which is valid and gives U(1)=0 JU(1) = 0\text{ J}.

  2. Step 2

    3−21=1>0  ⟹  U(3)=−12ln⁡(1)=0 J  ⟹  x=3 m satisfies U(x)=0\frac{3 - 2}{1} = 1 > 0 \implies U(3) = -12\ln(1) = 0\text{ J} \implies x = 3\text{ m satisfies } U(x) = 0

    Correct

    x0−xd=2−31=−1<0  ⟹  ln⁡(−1) is undefined  ⟹  x=3 m does not satisfy U(x)=0\frac{x_0 - x}{d} = \frac{2 - 3}{1} = -1 < 0 \implies \ln(-1) \text{ is undefined} \implies x = 3\text{ m does not satisfy } U(x) = 0

    Because you evaluated x−x0d=3−21=1\frac{x - x_0}{d} = \frac{3 - 2}{1} = 1 rather than x0−xd=2−31=−1\frac{x_0 - x}{d} = \frac{2 - 3}{1} = -1, you obtained a positive argument where the true model is undefined.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the real natural logarithm is undefined for non-positive arguments.

You accurately recognized that ln⁡(1)=0\ln(1) = 0 leads to a potential energy of 0 J0\text{ J}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Subtrahend-Minuend Reversal in Algebraic Substitution

You evaluated the numerator as x−x0x - x_0 rather than matching the given formula x0−xx_0 - x.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You swapped the variable and reference point positions during substitution, confusing a displacement vector form Δx=x−x0\Delta x = x - x_0 with the model's defined argument x0−xx_0 - x.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Template Matching
  • In non-commutative operations like subtraction (a−b≠b−aa - b \ne b - a), substitution must strictly preserve the position of each term.

  • Write the formula with empty parentheses for the variable first, such as x0−( ⋅ )d\frac{x_0 - (\,\cdot\,)}{d}, before inserting the test value.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the potential energy formula with the given parameters: U(x)=−12ln⁡(2−x1)U(x) = -12\ln\left(\frac{2 - x}{1}\right).

  2. Test candidate (a) x=1 mx = 1\text{ m}: evaluate the argument 2−11=1\frac{2 - 1}{1} = 1. Since 1>01 > 0, U(1)=−12ln⁡(1)=0 JU(1) = -12\ln(1) = 0\text{ J}, so x=1 mx = 1\text{ m} satisfies the equation.

  3. Test candidate (b) x=3 mx = 3\text{ m}: evaluate the argument 2−31=−1\frac{2 - 3}{1} = -1. Since −1≤0-1 \le 0, ln⁡(−1)\ln(-1) is undefined on R\mathbb{R}, so x=3 mx = 3\text{ m} does not satisfy the equation.

Final answer

(a) x=1 mx = 1\text{ m} satisfies U(x)=0 JU(x) = 0\text{ J}; (b) x=3 mx = 3\text{ m} does not satisfy U(x)=0 JU(x) = 0\text{ J} because the logarithmic argument is negative.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the exact placement of constants and variables in a formula before calculating differences.

  • Always state the explicit domain constraint (e.g., x0−x>0  ⟹  x<x0x_0 - x > 0 \implies x < x_0) before plugging in candidate coordinates.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A model is given by V(x)=−5ln⁡(4−x)V(x) = -5\ln(4 - x). Test whether x=3x = 3 and x=5x = 5 satisfy V(x)=0V(x) = 0.

Answer

x=3x = 3 satisfies the equation because V(3)=−5ln⁡(4−3)=−5ln⁡(1)=0V(3) = -5\ln(4 - 3) = -5\ln(1) = 0. In contrast, x=5x = 5 gives an argument of 4−5=−1≤04 - 5 = -1 \le 0, so ln⁡(−1)\ln(-1) is undefined and x=5x = 5 does not satisfy the equation.

02

Determine all real equilibrium points satisfying F(x)=0F(x) = 0 for the force field model F(x)=ln⁡(9−x25)F(x) = \ln\left(\frac{9 - x^2}{5}\right). Explicitly state the domain constraint.

Answer

Domain: 9−x2>0  ⟹  x2<9  ⟹  −3<x<39 - x^2 > 0 \implies x^2 < 9 \implies -3 < x < 3. Setting F(x)=0  ⟹  9−x25=1  ⟹  9−x2=5  ⟹  x2=4  ⟹  x=±2F(x) = 0 \implies \frac{9 - x^2}{5} = 1 \implies 9 - x^2 = 5 \implies x^2 = 4 \implies x = \pm 2. Both values lie within (−3,3)(-3, 3), so the equilibrium points are x=2x = 2 and x=−2x = -2.

03

A student solves ln⁡(x−2)+ln⁡(x−4)=ln⁡(3)\ln(x - 2) + \ln(x - 4) = \ln(3) and arrives at the quadratic equation (x−2)(x−4)=3  ⟹  x2−6x+5=0(x - 2)(x - 4) = 3 \implies x^2 - 6x + 5 = 0, yielding candidate values x=1x = 1 and x=5x = 5. Test whether both candidates satisfy the original equation.

Answer

The original equation requires x−2>0x - 2 > 0 and x−4>0x - 4 > 0, so x>4x > 4. For x=1x = 1, the terms ln⁡(−1)\ln(-1) and ln⁡(−3)\ln(-3) are both undefined, so x=1x = 1 is an extraneous solution that does not satisfy the equation. For x=5x = 5, ln⁡(3)+ln⁡(1)=ln⁡(3)+0=ln⁡(3)\ln(3) + \ln(1) = \ln(3) + 0 = \ln(3), so only x=5x = 5 satisfies the equation.

Loading workspace…