Resources

An environmental scientist models the concentration C(x)C(x) (in mg/L\text{mg/L}) of a biodegradable solute at equidistant downstream stations x=0,1,2,3 kmx = 0, 1, 2, 3\text{ km} from an industrial effluent pipe. Prior empirical verification confirms that the data structure follows a quadratic relationship C(x)=ax2+bx+cC(x) = ax^2 + bx + c. Downstream station sampling yields the values C(1)=43 mg/LC(1) = 43\text{ mg/L}, C(2)=34 mg/LC(2) = 34\text{ mg/L}, and C(3)=21 mg/LC(3) = 21\text{ mg/L}. Reverse-engineer the initial discharge concentration C(0)=cC(0) = c at the source pipe and write the completed quadratic model.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Initial concentration: C(0)=48 mg/LC(0) = 48\text{ mg/L}; Model equation: C(x)=−2x2−3x+48C(x) = -2x^2 - 3x + 48

Steps

To determine the parameters of the quadratic model C(x)=ax2+bx+cC(x) = ax^2 + bx + c, we use the given sampling values at the downstream stations:

  1. Set up the system of linear equations: Substitute the given data points into the quadratic function C(x)=ax2+bx+cC(x) = ax^2 + bx + c:

    • For x=1x = 1: a(1)2+b(1)+c=43  ⟹  a+b+c=43(Equation 1)a(1)^2 + b(1) + c = 43 \implies a + b + c = 43 \quad \text{(Equation 1)}
    • For x=2x = 2: a(2)2+b(2)+c=34  ⟹  4a+2b+c=34(Equation 2)a(2)^2 + b(2) + c = 34 \implies 4a + 2b + c = 34 \quad \text{(Equation 2)}
    • For x=3x = 3: a(3)2+b(3)+c=21  ⟹  9a+3b+c=21(Equation 3)a(3)^2 + b(3) + c = 21 \implies 9a + 3b + c = 21 \quad \text{(Equation 3)}
  2. Eliminate cc by taking consecutive differences: Subtract Equation 1 from Equation 2: (4a+2b+c)−(a+b+c)=34−43(4a + 2b + c) - (a + b + c) = 34 - 43 3a+b=−9(Equation 4)3a + b = -9 \quad \text{(Equation 4)}

    Subtract Equation 2 from Equation 3: (9a+3b+c)−(4a+2b+c)=21−34(9a + 3b + c) - (4a + 2b + c) = 21 - 34 5a+b=−13(Equation 5)5a + b = -13 \quad \text{(Equation 5)}

  3. Solve for aa and bb: Subtract Equation 4 from Equation 5 to eliminate bb: (5a+b)−(3a+b)=−13−(−9)(5a + b) - (3a + b) = -13 - (-9) 2a=−4  ⟹  a=−22a = -4 \implies a = -2

    Substitute a=−2a = -2 back into Equation 4: 3(−2)+b=−93(-2) + b = -9 −6+b=−9  ⟹  b=−3-6 + b = -9 \implies b = -3

  4. Determine the initial concentration c=C(0)c = C(0): Substitute a=−2a = -2 and b=−3b = -3 into Equation 1: (−2)+(−3)+c=43(-2) + (-3) + c = 43 −5+c=43  ⟹  c=48-5 + c = 43 \implies c = 48

    Since x=0x = 0 represents the effluent pipe location, the initial discharge concentration is: C(0)=c=48 mg/LC(0) = c = 48\text{ mg/L}

  5. State the completed model: Substituting a=−2a = -2, b=−3b = -3, and c=48c = 48 into C(x)=ax2+bx+cC(x) = ax^2 + bx + c gives: C(x)=−2x2−3x+48C(x) = -2x^2 - 3x + 48

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to square x when evaluating C(2) and C(3), setting up a linear system instead of a quadratic one.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    C(1)=a+b+c=43  ⟹  C(2)=2a+2b+c=34  ⟹  C(3)=3a+3b+c=21C(1) = a+b+c = 43 \implies C(2) = 2a+2b+c = 34 \implies C(3) = 3a+3b+c = 21

    Correct

    a+b+c=43a+b+c = 43, 4a+2b+c=344a+2b+c = 34, and 9a+3b+c=219a+3b+c = 21

    You substituted xx into the linear term correctly, but you did not square xx in the ax2ax^2 term. For x=2x=2, a(2)2=4aa(2)^2 = 4a, and for x=3x=3, a(3)2=9aa(3)^2 = 9a.

  2. Step 2

    (2a+2b+c)−(a+b+c)=a+b=−9  ⟹  (3a+3b+c)−(2a+2b+c)=a+b=−13(2a+2b+c) - (a+b+c) = a+b = -9 \implies (3a+3b+c) - (2a+2b+c) = a+b = -13

    Correct

    (4a+2b+c)−(a+b+c)  ⟹  3a+b=−9(4a+2b+c) - (a+b+c) \implies 3a+b = -9 and (9a+3b+c)−(4a+2b+c)  ⟹  5a+b=−13(9a+3b+c) - (4a+2b+c) \implies 5a+b = -13

    Your algebraic subtraction was internally consistent with your equations from Step 1, but the missing squared coefficients produced the contradiction a+b=−9a+b = -9 and a+b=−13a+b = -13.

  3. Step 3

    Average difference \text{Average difference } a+b = -11   ⟹  \implies a = -5.5  and \text{ and } b = -5.5

    Correct

    (5a+b)−(3a+b)=−13−(−9)  ⟹  2a=−4  ⟹  a=−2(5a+b) - (3a+b) = -13 - (-9) \implies 2a = -4 \implies a = -2, and 3(−2)+b=−9  ⟹  b=−33(-2)+b = -9 \implies b = -3

    Because of the earlier substitution error, you averaged the contradictory results and split aa and bb arbitrarily instead of solving a linear system in aa and bb.

  4. Step 4

    c=43−(a+b)=43−(−11)=54 mg/L  ⟹  C(x)=−5.5x2−5.5x+54c = 43 - (a+b) = 43 - (-11) = 54\text{ mg/L} \implies C(x) = -5.5x^2 - 5.5x + 54

    Correct

    c=43−(−2)−(−3)=48 mg/L  ⟹  C(x)=−2x2−3x+48c = 43 - (-2) - (-3) = 48\text{ mg/L} \implies C(x) = -2x^2 - 3x + 48

    Carrying through the incorrect coefficients produced an incorrect initial discharge concentration and model equation.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted x=1x=1 into the quadratic model to write a+b+c=43a+b+c = 43.

You used consecutive differences effectively as a strategy to eliminate the constant term cc.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Exponent Evaluation in Polynomial Substitution

You treated ax2ax^2 as axax, omitting the exponent 22 when evaluating at x=2x=2 and x=3x=3.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated a linear model structure with a quadratic model structure during point evaluation, writing a⋅xa \cdot x rather than a⋅x2a \cdot x^2 for the leading term.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate Exponents First
  • In f(x)=ax2+bx+cf(x) = ax^2 + bx + c, always compute x2x^2 before multiplying by aa: (2)2=4(2)^2 = 4 and (3)2=9(3)^2 = 9.

  • Write out the substitution explicitly with parentheses around each input, such as a(2)2+b(2)+ca(2)^2 + b(2) + c, before simplifying.

Sanity Check for Inconsistent Systems
  • If consecutive differences produce contradictory statements like a+b=−9a+b=-9 and a+b=−13a+b=-13, an earlier coefficient was set up incorrectly.

  • Never average contradictory equations; retrace the setup of the initial system.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute x=1,2,3x=1, 2, 3 with exponents evaluated: a(1)2+b(1)+c=43  ⟹  a+b+c=43a(1)^2 + b(1) + c = 43 \implies a+b+c = 43, a(2)2+b(2)+c=34  ⟹  4a+2b+c=34a(2)^2 + b(2) + c = 34 \implies 4a+2b+c = 34, and a(3)2+b(3)+c=21  ⟹  9a+3b+c=21a(3)^2 + b(3) + c = 21 \implies 9a+3b+c = 21.

  2. Subtract consecutive equations to eliminate cc: (4a+2b+c)−(a+b+c)  ⟹  3a+b=−9(4a+2b+c) - (a+b+c) \implies 3a+b = -9, and (9a+3b+c)−(4a+2b+c)  ⟹  5a+b=−13(9a+3b+c) - (4a+2b+c) \implies 5a+b = -13.

  3. Subtract the two first-difference equations to eliminate bb: (5a+b)−(3a+b)=−13−(−9)  ⟹  2a=−4  ⟹  a=−2(5a+b) - (3a+b) = -13 - (-9) \implies 2a = -4 \implies a = -2.

  4. Back-substitute a=−2a=-2 into 3a+b=−93a+b = -9: 3(−2)+b=−9  ⟹  −6+b=−9  ⟹  b=−33(-2) + b = -9 \implies -6 + b = -9 \implies b = -3.

  5. Back-substitute a=−2a=-2 and b=−3b=-3 into a+b+c=43a+b+c = 43: (−2)+(−3)+c=43  ⟹  c=48(-2) + (-3) + c = 43 \implies c = 48.

Final answer

Initial concentration: C(0)=48 mg/LC(0) = 48\text{ mg/L}; Model equation: C(x)=−2x2−3x+48C(x) = -2x^2 - 3x + 48

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice setting up quadratic systems with explicit parentheses: write a(k)2+b(k)+ca(k)^2 + b(k) + c before simplifying coefficients.

  • Check that the second difference of equidistant points in a quadratic sequence is constant (2a2a).

  • Review how to identify whether an algebraic contradiction signals a setup error rather than a data discrepancy.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student subtracts the equations in the wrong order or drops the negative sign during difference calculation, obtaining positive values for the rates of change.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    a+b+c=43a + b + c = 43 4a+2b+c=344a + 2b + c = 34 9a+3b+c=219a + 3b + c = 21

  2. Step 2

    3a+b=43−34=9  ⟹  5a+b=34−21=13  ⟹  2a=13−9=4  ⟹  a=23a + b = 43 - 34 = 9 \implies 5a + b = 34 - 21 = 13 \implies 2a = 13 - 9 = 4 \implies a = 2

    Correct

    3a+b=34−43=−9  ⟹  5a+b=21−34=−13  ⟹  2a=−13−(−9)=−4  ⟹  a=−23a + b = 34 - 43 = -9 \implies 5a + b = 21 - 34 = -13 \implies 2a = -13 - (-9) = -4 \implies a = -2

    On the left side, you computed Equation 2−Equation 1\text{Equation 2} - \text{Equation 1} to get (4a−a)+(2b−b)=3a+b(4a - a) + (2b - b) = 3a + b, but on the right side you computed Equation 1−Equation 2\text{Equation 1} - \text{Equation 2} (43−34=943 - 34 = 9). Because the concentration is decreasing downstream, the differences must be negative: 34−43=−934 - 43 = -9 and 21−34=−1321 - 34 = -13.

  3. Step 3

    3(2)+b=9  ⟹  b=3  ⟹  2+3+c=43  ⟹  c=38 mg/L3(2) + b = 9 \implies b = 3 \implies 2 + 3 + c = 43 \implies c = 38\text{ mg/L}

    Correct

    3(−2)+b=−9  ⟹  b=−3  ⟹  (−2)+(−3)+c=43  ⟹  c=48 mg/L3(-2) + b = -9 \implies b = -3 \implies (-2) + (-3) + c = 43 \implies c = 48\text{ mg/L}

    Your substitution method was algebraically sound, but the values were distorted by the sign error in aa.

  4. Step 4

    C(x)=2x2+3x+38C(x) = 2x^2 + 3x + 38

    Correct

    C(x)=−2x2−3x+48C(x) = -2x^2 - 3x + 48

    This final model follows logically from your previous values, but it reflects an increasing concentration rather than the true decreasing decay curve.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You translated the discrete downstream sampling stations into a correct system of three linear equations.

You used an efficient successive-difference elimination strategy to eliminate the constant parameter cc.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error from inconsistent subtraction order

You reversed the order of terms on the right-hand side of the subtraction (43−3443 - 34 instead of 34−4334 - 43), creating positive values for a decreasing sequence.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Inconsistent application of equation subtraction across the equals sign. When eliminating a variable by subtracting Equation AA from Equation BB, both sides must strictly follow LHSB−LHSA=RHSB−RHSA\text{LHS}_B - \text{LHS}_A = \text{RHS}_B - \text{RHS}_A.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Maintain Subtraction Direction
  • If you compute LHS2−LHS1\text{LHS}_2 - \text{LHS}_1 on the left, you must compute RHS2−RHS1\text{RHS}_2 - \text{RHS}_1 on the right.

  • Write out the subtraction explicitly in parentheses: (4a+2b+c)−(a+b+c)=34−43(4a + 2b + c) - (a + b + c) = 34 - 43.

Physical Reality Check
  • Downstream solute concentration decreases over distance (43→34→2143 \to 34 \to 21), which requires negative first differences.

  • Check that the sign of ΔC=C(x+1)−C(x)\Delta C = C(x+1) - C(x) matches the trend of the data before solving for aa.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Subtract Equation 1 from Equation 2: (4a+2b+c)−(a+b+c)=34−43  ⟹  3a+b=−9(4a + 2b + c) - (a + b + c) = 34 - 43 \implies 3a + b = -9

  2. Subtract Equation 2 from Equation 3: (9a+3b+c)−(4a+2b+c)=21−34  ⟹  5a+b=−13(9a + 3b + c) - (4a + 2b + c) = 21 - 34 \implies 5a + b = -13

  3. Subtract the two simplified equations: (5a+b)−(3a+b)=−13−(−9)  ⟹  2a=−4  ⟹  a=−2(5a + b) - (3a + b) = -13 - (-9) \implies 2a = -4 \implies a = -2

  4. Substitute a=−2a = -2 into 3a+b=−93a + b = -9: 3(−2)+b=−9  ⟹  −6+b=−9  ⟹  b=−33(-2) + b = -9 \implies -6 + b = -9 \implies b = -3

  5. Substitute a=−2a = -2 and b=−3b = -3 into a+b+c=43a + b + c = 43: −2−3+c=43  ⟹  c=48-2 - 3 + c = 43 \implies c = 48

Final answer

Initial concentration: C(0)=48 mg/LC(0) = 48\text{ mg/L}; Model equation: C(x)=−2x2−3x+48C(x) = -2x^2 - 3x + 48

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice subtracting systems of equations with negative outcomes to build consistent left-to-right subtraction habits.

  • Perform a quick mental test by plugging x=2x = 2 into your final equation to see if it reproduces C(2)=34C(2) = 34.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student incorrectly assumes equal first differences and models the data as a linear function rather than a quadratic function.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Slope between x=1 and x=2:  m=34−43=−9  ⟹  Slope between x=2 and x=3:  m=21−34=−13\text{Slope between } x=1 \text{ and } x=2:\; m = 34 - 43 = -9 \implies \text{Slope between } x=2 \text{ and } x=3:\; m = 21 - 34 = -13

  2. Step 2

    Average slope m=−9+−132=−11\text{Average slope } m = \frac{-9 + -13}{2} = -11

    Correct

    Δ2C=ΔC2−ΔC1=−13−(−9)=−4  ⟹  2a=−4  ⟹  a=−2\Delta^2 C = \Delta C_2 - \Delta C_1 = -13 - (-9) = -4 \implies 2a = -4 \implies a = -2

    The problem specifies a quadratic model C(x)=ax2+bx+cC(x) = ax^2 + bx + c. Because the first differences are unequal (−9-9 and −13-13), the rate of change is not constant, so averaging them into a single linear slope mm ignores the quadratic structure. In a quadratic sequence with unit spacing, the constant second difference equals 2a2a.

  3. Step 3

    C(0)=C(1)−m=43−(−11)=54 mg/LC(0) = C(1) - m = 43 - (-11) = 54\text{ mg/L}

    Correct

    C(0)=c=48 mg/LC(0) = c = 48\text{ mg/L}

    This step relied on your linear assumption with slope m=−11m = -11. Setting up the quadratic equations from C(1)=43C(1)=43, C(2)=34C(2)=34, and C(3)=21C(3)=21 yields c=48 mg/Lc = 48\text{ mg/L}.

  4. Step 4

    C(x)=−11x+54C(x) = -11x + 54

    Correct

    C(x)=−2x2−3x+48C(x) = -2x^2 - 3x + 48

    This equation follows from the linear extrapolation rather than the required quadratic model.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the differences in concentration between adjacent downstream sampling stations.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Linearization of quadratic data

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that unequal first differences can be averaged into an effective constant slope, fitting a linear function instead of setting up a three-parameter quadratic system C(x)=ax2+bx+cC(x) = ax^2 + bx + c or using constant second differences.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Model Identification from Differences
  • For data sampled at equal intervals, constant first differences imply a linear function, while constant second differences imply a quadratic function (2a=Δ2y2a = \Delta^2 y).

  • Inspect the first differences: if they change, do not average them to force a linear model; check the second differences or set up a system of polynomial equations.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the second difference: Δ2C=−13−(−9)=−4\Delta^2 C = -13 - (-9) = -4.

  2. Set 2a=−42a = -4, giving a=−2a = -2.

  3. Use the first difference formula ΔC(1)=3a+b=−9\Delta C(1) = 3a + b = -9 with a=−2a = -2: 3(−2)+b=−9  ⟹  b=−33(-2) + b = -9 \implies b = -3.

  4. Solve for cc using C(1)=a+b+c=43C(1) = a + b + c = 43: (−2)+(−3)+c=43  ⟹  c=48(-2) + (-3) + c = 43 \implies c = 48.

  5. Write the completed quadratic function: C(x)=−2x2−3x+48C(x) = -2x^2 - 3x + 48.

Final answer

Initial concentration: C(0)=48 mg/LC(0) = 48\text{ mg/L}; Model equation: C(x)=−2x2−3x+48C(x) = -2x^2 - 3x + 48

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the relationship between polynomial degree and finite differences on equally spaced data.

  • Practice setting up a 3×33 \times 3 linear system by substituting known coordinates into y=ax2+bx+cy = ax^2 + bx + c.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A projectile's height follows h(t)=at2+bt+ch(t) = at^2 + bt + c. Given h(1)=25 mh(1) = 25\text{ m}, h(2)=40 mh(2) = 40\text{ m}, and h(3)=45 mh(3) = 45\text{ m}, set up the 3×33 \times 3 system of linear equations in aa, bb, and cc, then solve for aa, bb, and cc.

Answer

System: a+b+c=25a + b + c = 25, 4a+2b+c=404a + 2b + c = 40, 9a+3b+c=459a + 3b + c = 45. First differences: 3a+b=153a + b = 15 and 5a+b=55a + b = 5. Second difference: 2a=−10  ⟹  a=−52a = -10 \implies a = -5. Then b=15−3(−5)=30b = 15 - 3(-5) = 30, and c=25−(−5)−30=0c = 25 - (-5) - 30 = 0. Result: a=−5,b=30,c=0a = -5, b = 30, c = 0.

02

A thermal sensor measures temperature T(x)=ax2+bx+cT(x) = ax^2 + bx + c along a rod at x=1,2,3 cmx = 1, 2, 3\text{ cm} yielding T(1)=18∘CT(1) = 18^\circ\text{C}, T(2)=28∘CT(2) = 28^\circ\text{C}, and T(3)=42∘CT(3) = 42^\circ\text{C}. Determine the base temperature T(0)=cT(0) = c and write the temperature function.

Answer

System: a+b+c=18a + b + c = 18, 4a+2b+c=284a + 2b + c = 28, 9a+3b+c=429a + 3b + c = 42. First differences: 3a+b=103a + b = 10, 5a+b=145a + b = 14. Subtracting gives 2a=4  ⟹  a=22a = 4 \implies a = 2. Then b=10−3(2)=4b = 10 - 3(2) = 4, and c=18−2−4=12∘Cc = 18 - 2 - 4 = 12^\circ\text{C}. Result: T(0)=12∘CT(0) = 12^\circ\text{C} and T(x)=2x2+4x+12T(x) = 2x^2 + 4x + 12.

03

A chemical reaction yield is given by Y(t)=at2+bt+cY(t) = at^2 + bt + c. Measurements at t=2,3,4 hourst = 2, 3, 4\text{ hours} are Y(2)=36Y(2) = 36, Y(3)=47Y(3) = 47, and Y(4)=54Y(4) = 54. Reverse-engineer Y(0)=cY(0) = c and write the complete model.

Answer

System: 4a+2b+c=364a + 2b + c = 36, 9a+3b+c=479a + 3b + c = 47, 16a+4b+c=5416a + 4b + c = 54. First differences: 5a+b=115a + b = 11, 7a+b=77a + b = 7. Second difference: 2a=−4  ⟹  a=−22a = -4 \implies a = -2. Then b=11−5(−2)=21b = 11 - 5(-2) = 21. From the first equation: 4(−2)+2(21)+c=36  ⟹  −8+42+c=36  ⟹  c=24(-2) + 2(21) + c = 36 \implies -8 + 42 + c = 36 \implies c = 2. Result: Y(0)=2Y(0) = 2 and Y(t)=−2t2+21t+2Y(t) = -2t^2 + 21t + 2.

Loading workspace…