Resources
A student seeks to disprove the claim: "For all positive integers , is a prime number." Rather than just testing consecutive integers from , find the smallest positive integer that serves as a counterexample, and determine the exact composite value and prime factorization of at this critical value.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Smallest positive integer counterexample: ; resulting value: , which is composite with prime factorization .
Steps
Analyze the algebraic structure of the expression
To disprove a universal statement of the form "For all positive integers , is true," it is sufficient to find a single positive integer where the statement fails (a counterexample).
Consider the polynomial:
We can factor the first two terms:
For to be composite, it must share a common factor with , or more generally, factor into integers greater than .
Notice that if the term is a multiple of , then the entire expression will be divisible by .
Identify candidate values for
Because is prime, for the product to be divisible by , either:
- is a multiple of , which gives the smallest positive integer .
- is a multiple of , which gives .
Since , is the smallest candidate suggested by this algebraic structure.
Evaluate and factor at
Substitute into the expression:
Using our grouped form :
Factor out the common factor :
Calculating the numerical value:
Since has factors other than and itself (specifically, ), it is composite.
Confirm that is the smallest positive integer counterexample
Euler's polynomial produces prime numbers for every integer from up to . A common pitfall is assuming that the first counterexample must occur at because the constant term is . However, because the linear and quadratic terms can be factored as , setting the factor equal to yields the smaller counterexample .
- Smallest positive integer counterexample:
- Resulting value:
- Prime factorization:
Typical errors
01 The student tests n = 41 because 41 directly divides the constant term, overlooking the smaller solution n = 40 where n + 1 = 41.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
is divisible by when is a multiple of Smallest positive integer is
Correctis divisible by when , so either or . The smallest positive integer is .
You correctly realized that making the expression a multiple of produces a composite number. However, because , the factor of can come from either or . Setting yields , which is smaller than .
- Step 2Correct
Your arithmetic and prime factorization for were carried out accurately, but this step was affected by using instead of the minimal counterexample .
- Step 3
Smallest counterexample , composite value , prime factorization
CorrectSmallest counterexample , composite value , prime factorization
This conclusion follows directly from the earlier choice of . The minimal counterexample is .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that forcing the polynomial to be divisible by its constant term guarantees a composite value.
You accurately calculated the value and prime factorization for .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou chose directly from the constant term without checking if the neighboring factor could equal .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisWhen looking for divisibility of by a prime , writing the quadratic as shows that . By Euclid's lemma for primes, this requires or , which gives the smaller positive solution .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Factor the non-constant part
In expressions of the form , write before testing divisibility.
Always check both factors: test and (i.e., ) to find the minimal positive integer.
- Verify minimality
A counterexample must be the smallest positive integer satisfying the condition.
Compare all candidate integer solutions before concluding which value is minimal.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFactor the expression: .
Set the product to be a multiple of : since is prime, either or .
Find the smallest positive integer from these cases: or . Since , choose .
Evaluate at : .
Smallest positive integer counterexample: ; composite value: ; prime factorization:
02 The student finds n = 40 and factors the algebraic expression as 41², but miscalculates the arithmetic value of 41².
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
You made an arithmetic multiplication error: , not .
- Step 4Correct
Smallest counterexample , composite value , prime factorization
Your counterexample and prime factorization are correct, but the final composite value is affected by the arithmetic error in the previous step.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou cleverly factored the polynomial as rather than brute-forcing values of .
You correctly observed that choosing gives the minimal positive counterexample .
You accurately identified the prime factorization of the resulting composite number as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou calculated as instead of , likely by computing and adding instead of computing .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou made a mental arithmetic slip during multi-digit multiplication or binomial expansion of .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Binomial expansion for mental squaring
Break into to prevent off-by-tens multiplication slips.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate using the binomial formula: .
Compute the terms: .
Smallest positive integer counterexample: ; resulting composite value: ; prime factorization: .
Lock it in
Why is often a smaller counterexample than for polynomials of the form ?
Because . When , the factor equals , making the entire expression a multiple of .
Similar question
Find the smallest positive integer that serves as a counterexample to the claim that is always prime, and write the resulting value as a product of primes.
Answer
. Rewriting gives . Setting yields . The value is .
Consider the polynomial . Find the smallest positive integer for which is a multiple of , and determine its prime factorization at that value.
Answer
. Grouping the terms gives . For , either (smallest positive is ) or (smallest positive is ). At , .
A student claims that for all positive integers , is prime. Find the smallest positive integer that disproves this claim, and state the value of along with its prime factorization.
Answer
. Factoring the first two terms gives . For , either or . The smaller integer strictly greater than is . The value is .