Resources

An economist measures the consumer demand curve for a specialized software subscription as p(x)=120−0.05xp(x) = 120 - 0.05x, where pp is the monthly subscription price in dollars and xx is the total number of active subscribers. Total revenue is R(x)=x⋅p(x)=120x−0.05x2R(x) = x \cdot p(x) = 120x - 0.05x^2. (a) Find the subscriber count xx that maximizes total revenue, and determine the corresponding subscription price pp. (b) A sales director assumes that to maximize overall revenue, the company should set the price as high as possible. Explain using the real economic situation why this intuition is incorrect.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Maximum revenue occurs at x=1,200x = 1{,}200 subscribers, corresponding to a subscription price of p(1,200)=$60p(1{,}200) = \text{\char36}60; (b) Intuition fails because total revenue depends simultaneously on price and sales volume (R=p⋅xR = p \cdot x); setting an excessively high price sharply diminishes consumer demand, causing the loss of paying subscribers to outweigh the higher per-unit price and reducing overall company revenue toward zero as price approaches $120\text{\char36}120.

Steps

Part (a): Finding the Revenue-Maximizing Subscriber Count and Price

Step 1: Identify the revenue function and its mathematical type

Total monthly revenue R(x)R(x) is the product of the number of subscribers xx and the price per subscription p(x)p(x): R(x)=x⋅p(x)=x(120−0.05x)=−0.05x2+120xR(x) = x \cdot p(x) = x(120 - 0.05x) = -0.05x^2 + 120x

This is a quadratic function of the standard form R(x)=ax2+bx+cR(x) = ax^2 + bx + c, where:

  • a=−0.05a = -0.05
  • b=120b = 120
  • c=0c = 0

Because a<0a < 0, the parabola opens downward, meaning its vertex corresponds to the unique global maximum of the function.

Step 2: Find the vertex to maximize revenue

The xx-coordinate of the vertex of a parabola is given by the formula: x=−b2ax = -\frac{b}{2a}

Substitute the values of aa and bb: x=−1202(−0.05)=1200.10=1,200x = -\frac{120}{2(-0.05)} = \frac{120}{0.10} = 1{,}200

Thus, total revenue is maximized when there are 1,2001{,}200 active subscribers.

Step 3: Calculate the optimal monthly subscription price

Substitute x=1,200x = 1{,}200 into the demand equation p(x)p(x): p(1,200)=120−0.05(1,200)=120−60=60p(1{,}200) = 120 - 0.05(1{,}200) = 120 - 60 = 60

The subscription price that yields maximum revenue is $60\text{\char36}60 per month.


Part (b): Explaining Why Setting the Highest Possible Price Fails

Step 1: Deconstruct the components of total revenue

Total revenue depends on two linked variables: Total Revenue=Price per Subscription (p)×Number of Subscribers (x)\text{Total Revenue} = \text{Price per Subscription } (p) \times \text{Number of Subscribers } (x)

Step 2: Connect the price increase to consumer behavior

According to the demand equation p(x)=120−0.05xp(x) = 120 - 0.05x, price and subscriber count have an inverse relationship:

  • If the company raises the price toward its theoretical maximum of $120\text{\char36}120, subscriber demand drops sharply toward zero (x→0x \to 0).
  • At p=$120p = \text{\char36}120, x=0x = 0, producing a total revenue of $0\text{\char36}0.

Step 3: Interpret the trade-off in the real situation

The sales director's intuition focuses only on the per-unit price while ignoring the volume effect. Beyond the optimal price point of $60\text{\char36}60, any gain made by charging remaining customers more is completely outweighed by the loss of paying subscribers who cancel or decline to join. Maximizing revenue requires balancing price and customer volume rather than maximizing price alone.

Common Pitfall: Confusing unit price (or profit margin per unit) with total revenue. A high unit price yields high revenue per customer, but if customer count collapses, overall incoming cash flow drops.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student maximizes the demand price function p(x) instead of the total revenue function R(x) when finding the optimal subscriber count.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    p(x)=120−0.05x  ⟹  p′(x)=−0.05  ⟹  Set p(x)=0:120−0.05x=0  ⟹  x=2400,p=0p(x) = 120 - 0.05x \implies p'(x) = -0.05 \implies \text{Set } p(x) = 0: 120 - 0.05x = 0 \implies x = 2400, p = 0

    Correct

    R′(x)=120−0.10x=0  ⟹  x=1,200  ⟹  p(1,200)=120−0.05(1,200)=$60R'(x) = 120 - 0.10x = 0 \implies x = 1{,}200 \implies p(1{,}200) = 120 - 0.05(1{,}200) = \text{\char36}60

    You tried to optimize the price function p(x)p(x) by setting p(x)=0p(x) = 0, which actually finds where price and revenue drop to zero. To maximize total revenue, you need to find the vertex or critical point of the revenue function R(x)=120x−0.05x2R(x) = 120x - 0.05x^2.

  2. Step 2

    Raising price reduces the number of subscribers xx. If price is too high, very few people subscribe so total revenue decreases.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that demand and subscriber count decrease as the subscription price increases.

You clearly explained why total revenue drops when price is set too high.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Objective function mismatch

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the demand price equation p(x)p(x) as the objective to analyze instead of optimizing the total revenue model R(x)=x⋅p(x)R(x) = x \cdot p(x).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the target objective function
  • Optimization requires maximizing or minimizing the specific quantity requested (here, total revenue R(x)R(x)), not an intermediate input like unit price p(x)p(x).

  • Locate or build the total revenue function R(x)=120x−0.05x2R(x) = 120x - 0.05x^2 before differentiating or finding the vertex.

Find the vertex of a quadratic revenue function
  • For a downward-opening parabola R(x)=ax2+bxR(x) = ax^2 + bx, the maximum occurs at x=−b2ax = -\frac{b}{2a} or where R′(x)=0R'(x) = 0.

  • Set R′(x)=120−0.10x=0R'(x) = 120 - 0.10x = 0 to find the optimal quantity x=1,200x = 1{,}200, then evaluate p(1,200)p(1{,}200).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the total revenue function: R(x)=x⋅p(x)=120x−0.05x2R(x) = x \cdot p(x) = 120x - 0.05x^2.

  2. Find the critical value by differentiating and setting the derivative to zero: R′(x)=120−0.10x=0R'(x) = 120 - 0.10x = 0, giving x=1,200x = 1{,}200.

  3. Substitute x=1,200x = 1{,}200 back into the demand price function: p(1,200)=120−0.05(1,200)=$60p(1{,}200) = 120 - 0.05(1{,}200) = \text{\char36}60.

Final answer

(a) x=1,200x = 1{,}200 subscribers, p=$60p = \text{\char36}60; (b) Raising the price too high drives subscriber count toward zero, reducing total revenue.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before setting up derivatives or solving for zeros, write down explicitly which quantity you are trying to maximize (total revenue vs. price).

  • Practice distinguishing between finding the horizontal intercept of a curve (p(x)=0p(x) = 0) and finding the peak of a curve (R′(x)=0R'(x) = 0).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student differentiates -0.05x² incorrectly as -0.05x instead of -0.10x, leading to an incorrect subscriber count and price.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    R′(x)=120−0.05xR'(x) = 120 - 0.05x

    Correct

    R′(x)=120−2(0.05)x=120−0.10xR'(x) = 120 - 2(0.05)x = 120 - 0.10x

    You differentiated the quadratic term −0.05x2-0.05x^2 as −0.05x-0.05x instead of multiplying the coefficient by the exponent 22, which yields −0.10x-0.10x.

  2. Step 2

    120−0.05x=0  ⟹  0.05x=120  ⟹  x=2400120 - 0.05x = 0 \implies 0.05x = 120 \implies x = 2400

    Correct

    120−0.10x=0  ⟹  0.10x=120  ⟹  x=1,200120 - 0.10x = 0 \implies 0.10x = 120 \implies x = 1{,}200

    Your algebraic solving technique was correct, but the result was doubled due to the missing factor of 22 from the derivative in Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    p=120−0.05(2400)=0p = 120 - 0.05(2400) = 0

    Correct

    p=120−0.05(1,200)=120−60=60p = 120 - 0.05(1{,}200) = 120 - 60 = 60

    You correctly substituted your subscriber count into the demand function, but substituting the affected value x=2400x = 2400 resulted in a price of $0\text{\char36}0.

  4. Step 4

    Setting the price as high as possible causes quantity demanded to drop. When the price is too high, subscriber loss reduces total revenue.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that maximizing revenue involves finding the critical point where R′(x)=0R'(x) = 0.

You solved linear equations accurately and substituted your critical value back into the demand function.

You accurately explained the inverse relationship between price and subscriber demand in the real-world context.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Power rule coefficient omission

You forgot to multiply the coefficient by the exponent 22 when taking the derivative of 0.05x20.05x^2.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the multiplier step of the power rule ddx[axn]=n⋅axn−1\frac{d}{dx}[a x^n] = n \cdot a x^{n-1}, treating x2x^2 as if its derivative were simply xx rather than 2x2x.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Applying the Power Rule with Coefficients
  • For any term axna x^n, the derivative is ddx(axn)=a⋅nxn−1\frac{d}{dx}(a x^n) = a \cdot n x^{n-1}.

  • Always bring the exponent down as a multiplier before reducing the power: ddx(−0.05x2)=−0.05⋅2x=−0.10x\frac{d}{dx}(-0.05x^2) = -0.05 \cdot 2x = -0.10x.

Sanity Checking Economic Outputs
  • An optimal selling price of $0\text{\char36}0 implies giving the product away for free, which yields zero total revenue.

  • If your optimal price calculates to 00 or a negative number for a positive demand function, stop and check your derivative or algebra.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the first derivative of R(x)=120x−0.05x2R(x) = 120x - 0.05x^2 correctly: R′(x)=120−2(0.05)x=120−0.10xR'(x) = 120 - 2(0.05)x = 120 - 0.10x.

  2. Set the derivative equal to zero: 120−0.10x=0  ⟹  0.10x=120  ⟹  x=1,200120 - 0.10x = 0 \implies 0.10x = 120 \implies x = 1{,}200.

  3. Substitute x=1,200x = 1{,}200 into the price function: p=120−0.05(1,200)=120−60=60p = 120 - 0.05(1{,}200) = 120 - 60 = 60.

Final answer

(a) x=1,200x = 1{,}200 subscribers, p=$60p = \text{\char36}60; (b) Intuition fails because total revenue depends on both price and volume (R=p⋅xR = p \cdot x); setting the price too high eliminates subscribers (x→0x \to 0), driving total revenue toward zero.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that you multiply the coefficient by the exponent whenever differentiating polynomial terms like ax2a x^2.

  • Perform a quick reality check on your final answers: a revenue-maximizing price should not equal zero when demand exists.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student agrees with the sales director in part (b), mistakenly assuming higher prices always increase total revenue regardless of subscriber dropoff.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    R(x)=120x−0.05x2  ⟹  R′(x)=120−0.10x=0  ⟹  0.10x=120  ⟹  x=1200R(x) = 120x - 0.05x^2 \implies R'(x) = 120 - 0.10x = 0 \implies 0.10x = 120 \implies x = 1200

  2. Step 2

    p=120−0.05(1200)=60p = 120 - 0.05(1200) = 60

  3. Step 3

    The intuition is actually correct because charging the highest possible price brings in maximum cash per customer. More revenue is always collected when prices are higher.

    Correct

    The intuition is incorrect because total revenue is R=p⋅xR = p \cdot x. Setting the price as high as possible (up to $120\text{\char36}120) causes subscriber count to drop toward zero (x→0x \to 0). The volume loss outweighs the price gain, reducing total revenue back to $0\text{\char36}0.

    You evaluated revenue solely on a per-customer basis rather than looking at total company revenue. In real markets, raising price reduces quantity demanded; if the price is pushed to its maximum of $120\text{\char36}120, demand drops to zero subscribers, producing $0\text{\char36}0 in total revenue.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly derived the first-order condition for maximizing the revenue function.

You accurately calculated the optimal subscriber count of 1,2001{,}200.

You correctly determined the corresponding optimal subscription price of $60\text{\char36}60.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing unit price with total revenue in demand modeling

You assumed that maximizing unit price automatically maximizes total company revenue.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked the trade-off in the formula Revenue=Price×Quantity\text{Revenue} = \text{Price} \times \text{Quantity}. Because quantity demanded decreases as price increases, charging the highest possible price drastically reduces the customer base, causing total revenue to decline past the optimal price point.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Revenue Decomposition
  • Total Revenue=p(x)⋅x\text{Total Revenue} = p(x) \cdot x, which depends on both unit price and sales volume simultaneously.

  • Check how an increase in price affects the number of active buyers before drawing conclusions about overall cash inflow.

Demand Boundary Check
  • At the price intercept (p=$120p = \text{\char36}120), active demand reaches zero (x=0x = 0), so R=120⋅0=$0R = 120 \cdot 0 = \text{\char36}0.

  • Test the extreme value of your assumption to verify whether setting the maximum price actually yields maximum total revenue.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express total revenue as the product of price and quantity: Revenue=p⋅x\text{Revenue} = p \cdot x.

  2. Analyze the demand relationship p(x)=120−0.05xp(x) = 120 - 0.05x: raising pp toward $120\text{\char36}120 causes xx to decrease toward 00.

  3. Evaluate total revenue at the extreme price: if p=$120p = \text{\char36}120, then x=0x = 0 subscribers, giving R=$0R = \text{\char36}0.

  4. Conclude why the intuition fails: beyond the optimal price of $60\text{\char36}60, the lost volume of paying subscribers hurts total incoming cash more than the higher per-person rate helps.

Final answer

The intuition is incorrect because total revenue is the product of price and subscriber count (R=p⋅xR = p \cdot x). As the price approaches its maximum of $120\text{\char36}120, customer demand drops toward zero, driving total revenue down to $0\text{\char36}0.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice sketching the inverted-U curve of total revenue alongside the downward-sloping demand curve to visualize the price-volume trade-off.

  • Whenever interpreting economic optimization results, test the extreme boundary points (e.g., p=0p = 0 and p=pmax⁡p = p_{\max}) to verify whether your verbal reasoning matches the mathematics.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A gym membership demand curve is p(x)=100−0.1xp(x) = 100 - 0.1x, where xx is the number of members and pp is the monthly fee in dollars. Find the number of members xx that maximizes monthly revenue, and find the corresponding monthly fee.

Answer

x=500x = 500 members and p=$50p = \text{\char36}50. Revenue is R(x)=100x−0.1x2R(x) = 100x - 0.1x^2. Setting R′(x)=100−0.2x=0R'(x) = 100 - 0.2x = 0 yields x=500x = 500. Then p(500)=100−0.1(500)=50p(500) = 100 - 0.1(500) = 50.

02

An online streaming service models total revenue as R(x)=150x−0.02x2R(x) = 150x - 0.02x^2, where xx is the subscriber count. A manager suggests setting the price such that x=5,000x = 5{,}000. Determine whether this subscriber count achieves maximum revenue, and calculate the maximum revenue possible.

Answer

No, x=5,000x = 5{,}000 does not maximize revenue; maximum revenue occurs at x=3,750x = 3{,}750 with R(3,750)=$281,250R(3{,}750) = \text{\char36}281{,}250. Setting R′(x)=150−0.04x=0R'(x) = 150 - 0.04x = 0 gives x=3,750x = 3{,}750. At x=5,000x = 5{,}000, revenue is R(5,000)=$250,000R(5{,}000) = \text{\char36}250{,}000, which is less than the peak.

03

A firm has linear demand p(x)=a−bxp(x) = a - bx with a,b>0a, b > 0. Show in general that total revenue is maximized at a price equal to exactly half of the vertical intercept aa, and interpret what happens to total revenue if the price is set to p=ap = a.

Answer

Optimal price is p=a2p = \frac{a}{2}; at p=ap = a, revenue is $0\text{\char36}0. Total revenue is R(x)=ax−bx2R(x) = ax - bx^2. Maximizing gives R′(x)=a−2bx=0  ⟹  x∗=a2bR'(x) = a - 2bx = 0 \implies x^* = \frac{a}{2b}. Substituting into demand gives p(x∗)=a−b(a2b)=a2p(x^*) = a - b\left(\frac{a}{2b}\right) = \frac{a}{2}. If p=ap = a, quantity demanded drops to x=0x = 0, yielding zero total revenue.

Loading workspace…