Resources

A standard calculus intuition assumes that if a continuous function has a unique local minimum on R\mathbb{R}, that local minimum must be the absolute minimum. Now consider the following universal proposition: "For every twice-differentiable function f:R→Rf: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R}, if ff has a unique critical point at x0x_0 and f′′(x0)>0f''(x_0) > 0, then f(x0)f(x_0) is the global minimum of ff on R\mathbb{R}." Explain why this universal proposition is false, state its formal negation, and show that the function f(x)=x4−2x2f(x) = x^4 - 2x^2 does not serve as a counterexample, but the function g(x,y)g(x, y) in R2\mathbb{R}^2 or the one-dimensional polynomial-exponential hybrid f(x)=x2(1−x)3f(x) = x^2(1 - x)^3 does not quite work, while f(x)=x3−3xf(x) = x^3 - 3x has two critical points; verify instead the classic single-variable counterexample f(x)=x2−x4f(x) = x^2 - x^4 (which fails f′′>0f''>0), or examine the proposition: "For all differentiable functions f:R→Rf: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R}, if lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0, then lim⁡x→∞f′(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) = 0." State the negation of this proposition and prove it false using the counterexample f(x)=sin⁡(x2)xf(x) = \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Negation: "There exists a differentiable function f:R→Rf: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R} such that lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0 and lim⁡x→∞f′(x)≠0\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) \ne 0 (or does not exist)." Counterexample evaluation: For f(x)=sin⁡(x2)xf(x) = \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x}, since ∣sin⁡(x2)∣≤1|\sin(x^2)| \le 1, lim⁡x→∞∣f(x)∣≤lim⁡x→∞1x=0\lim_{x \to \infty} |f(x)| \le \lim_{x \to \infty} \frac{1}{x} = 0, so lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0. However, f′(x)=2cos⁡(x2)−sin⁡(x2)x2f'(x) = 2\cos(x^2) - \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x^2}; as x→∞x \to \infty, sin⁡(x2)x2→0\frac{\sin(x^2)}{x^2} \to 0 while 2cos⁡(x2)2\cos(x^2) oscillates between −2-2 and 22, meaning lim⁡x→∞f′(x)\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) does not exist.

Steps

01

Formulating the Formal Negation

Understanding Universal Conditional Propositions

A universal conditional statement has the logical form: ∀x∈S,P(x)  ⟹  Q(x)\forall x \in S, \quad P(x) \implies Q(x) To prove such a proposition false, we must demonstrate its logical negation, which is an existential statement: ∃x∈Ssuch that P(x)∧¬Q(x)\exists x \in S \quad \text{such that } P(x) \land \neg Q(x) Finding just one specific element xx in the domain that satisfies the hypothesis P(x)P(x) while violating the conclusion Q(x)Q(x) serves as a counterexample, completely disproving the original statement.

The target proposition is:

"For all differentiable functions f:R→Rf: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R}, if lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0, then lim⁡x→∞f′(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) = 0."

Here:

  • Domain: Differentiable functions f:R→Rf: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R}
  • Hypothesis P(f)P(f): lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0
  • Conclusion Q(f)Q(f): lim⁡x→∞f′(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) = 0

The negation of "P  ⟹  QP \implies Q" is "P and not QP \text{ and not } Q". Therefore, the formal negation is:

There exists a differentiable function f:R→R such that lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0 and lim⁡x→∞f′(x)≠0 (or does not exist).\text{There exists a differentiable function } f: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R} \text{ such that } \lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0 \text{ and } \lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) \ne 0 \text{ (or does not exist).}


02

Verifying the Counterexample f(x)=sin⁡(x2)xf(x) = \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x}

To prove the proposition false, we analyze the proposed counterexample f(x)=sin⁡(x2)xf(x) = \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x} for x>0x > 0 (extended smoothly across R\mathbb{R}, for instance with f(0)=0f(0) = 0).

01

Verifying the Hypothesis: lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0

For all x∈Rx \in \mathbb{R}, the sine function is bounded: −1≤sin⁡(x2)≤1-1 \le \sin(x^2) \le 1

For x>0x > 0, dividing by xx gives: −1x≤sin⁡(x2)x≤1x-\frac{1}{x} \le \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x} \le \frac{1}{x}

Since lim⁡x→∞(−1x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} \left(-\frac{1}{x}\right) = 0 and lim⁡x→∞(1x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} \left(\frac{1}{x}\right) = 0, by the Squeeze Theorem: lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0 The hypothesis holds.

02

Evaluating the Derivative: lim⁡x→∞f′(x)\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x)

Applying the quotient rule or product rule to f(x)=x−1sin⁡(x2)f(x) = x^{-1}\sin(x^2): f′(x)=x⋅ddx[sin⁡(x2)]−sin⁡(x2)⋅ddx[x]x2f'(x) = \frac{x \cdot \frac{d}{dx}[\sin(x^2)] - \sin(x^2) \cdot \frac{d}{dx}[x]}{x^2} f′(x)=x⋅2xcos⁡(x2)−sin⁡(x2)x2=2cos⁡(x2)−sin⁡(x2)x2f'(x) = \frac{x \cdot 2x\cos(x^2) - \sin(x^2)}{x^2} = 2\cos(x^2) - \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x^2}

Now examine the behavior as x→∞x \to \infty:

  • For the second term, since ∣sin⁡(x2)∣≤1|\sin(x^2)| \le 1, we have ∣sin⁡(x2)x2∣≤1x2→0\left|\frac{\sin(x^2)}{x^2}\right| \le \frac{1}{x^2} \to 0 as x→∞x \to \infty.
  • For the first term, the function 2cos⁡(x2)2\cos(x^2) continually oscillates across the entire interval [−2,2][-2, 2] as x→∞x \to \infty without settling toward any single value.

Consequently, lim⁡x→∞f′(x)\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) does not exist, and thus does not equal 00.


Conclusion

Because f(x)=sin⁡(x2)xf(x) = \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x} satisfies lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0 while its derivative fails to converge to 00, it is a valid counterexample. Hence, the original universal proposition is false.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misapplies the chain rule when differentiating sin(x²), omitting the factor of 2x and incorrectly concluding the derivative limit is 0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    There exists a differentiable f:R→Rf: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R} such that lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0, but lim⁡x→∞f′(x)\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) does not exist or is not 00.

  2. Step 2

    −1x≤sin⁡(x2)x≤1x-\frac{1}{x} \le \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x} \le \frac{1}{x}, so lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0.

  3. Step 3

    f′(x)=xcos⁡(x2)−sin⁡(x2)x2=cos⁡(x2)x−sin⁡(x2)x2f'(x) = \frac{x\cos(x^2) - \sin(x^2)}{x^2} = \frac{\cos(x^2)}{x} - \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x^2}

    Correct

    f′(x)=x⋅[2xcos⁡(x2)]−sin⁡(x2)x2=2cos⁡(x2)−sin⁡(x2)x2f'(x) = \frac{x \cdot [2x\cos(x^2)] - \sin(x^2)}{x^2} = 2\cos(x^2) - \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x^2}

    You missed the chain rule factor ddx(x2)=2x\frac{d}{dx}(x^2) = 2x when differentiating sin⁡(x2)\sin(x^2), writing cos⁡(x2)\cos(x^2) instead of 2xcos⁡(x2)2x\cos(x^2).

  4. Step 4

    lim⁡x→∞f′(x)=0−0=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) = 0 - 0 = 0, so it fails as a counterexample.

    Correct

    lim⁡x→∞f′(x)\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) does not exist because 2cos⁡(x2)2\cos(x^2) oscillates between −2-2 and 22, so f(x)f(x) is a valid counterexample.

    Because of the missing factor of 2x2x in the numerator, your derivative had an extra power of xx in the denominator, causing the first term to falsely vanish to 00 instead of oscillating.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You formulated the formal negation of the conditional proposition accurately.

You used the Squeeze Theorem correctly to establish that lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Inner Derivative in Chain Rule

You differentiated sin⁡(x2)\sin(x^2) as cos⁡(x2)\cos(x^2) instead of multiplying by (x2)′=2x(x^2)' = 2x.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Incomplete execution of composite function differentiation: when differentiating sin⁡(u(x))\sin(u(x)) inside the quotient rule, the inner derivative u′(x)u'(x) was dropped, changing the asymptotic growth order of the derivative's leading term from O(1)O(1) to O(1/x)O(1/x).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Chain Rule for Composite Trigonometric Functions
  • ddx[sin⁡(g(x))]=g′(x)cos⁡(g(x))\frac{d}{dx}[\sin(g(x))] = g'(x)\cos(g(x)).

  • Whenever the argument of a trigonometric function is not just xx, explicitly identify u=g(x)u = g(x) and compute du/dxdu/dx before inserting it into the product or quotient rule.

Asymptotic Oscillation Check
  • Rapidly oscillating functions such as sin⁡(x2)\sin(x^2) have derivatives whose amplitudes scale with the derivative of the phase: (x2)′=2x(x^2)' = 2x.

  • Check whether the frequency grows with xx; if the frequency increases, differentiation multiplies the amplitude by that growing frequency factor.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Differentiate the numerator using the chain rule: ddx[sin⁡(x2)]=cos⁡(x2)⋅2x=2xcos⁡(x2)\frac{d}{dx}[\sin(x^2)] = \cos(x^2) \cdot 2x = 2x\cos(x^2).

  2. Apply the quotient rule: f′(x)=x⋅2xcos⁡(x2)−sin⁡(x2)⋅1x2=2x2cos⁡(x2)−sin⁡(x2)x2f'(x) = \frac{x \cdot 2x\cos(x^2) - \sin(x^2) \cdot 1}{x^2} = \frac{2x^2\cos(x^2) - \sin(x^2)}{x^2}.

  3. Split into separate terms: f′(x)=2cos⁡(x2)−sin⁡(x2)x2f'(x) = 2\cos(x^2) - \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x^2}.

  4. Evaluate the behavior as x→∞x \to \infty: lim⁡x→∞sin⁡(x2)x2=0\lim_{x \to \infty} \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x^2} = 0, while 2cos⁡(x2)2\cos(x^2) continues to oscillate between −2-2 and 22, so lim⁡x→∞f′(x)\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) does not exist.

Final answer

Since lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0 while lim⁡x→∞f′(x)\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) does not exist (and thus is not 00), f(x)=sin⁡(x2)xf(x) = \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x} is indeed a valid counterexample that disproves the universal proposition.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out u=x2u = x^2 and u′=2xu' = 2x as scratch steps before combining them into composite derivatives.

  • Practice identifying functions where amplitude decays while derivative amplitude does not decay due to increasing frequency.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the negation of a conditional statement by negating both the hypothesis and the conclusion instead of asserting the hypothesis holds while the conclusion fails.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    There exists a differentiable f:R→Rf: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R} such that lim⁡x→∞f(x)≠0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) \neq 0 and lim⁡x→∞f′(x)≠0\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) \neq 0.

    Correct

    There exists a differentiable function f:R→Rf: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R} such that lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0 and lim⁡x→∞f′(x)≠0\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) \ne 0 (or the limit does not exist).

    To negate a conditional statement of the form ∀x,(P(x)  ⟹  Q(x))\forall x, (P(x) \implies Q(x)), the correct logical form is ∃x,(P(x)∧¬Q(x))\exists x, (P(x) \land \neg Q(x)). You negated both the hypothesis and the conclusion (¬P∧¬Q\neg P \land \neg Q) instead of preserving the hypothesis PP.

  2. Step 2

    ∣sin⁡(x2)x∣≤1x→0\left|\frac{\sin(x^2)}{x}\right| \le \frac{1}{x} \to 0 as x→∞x \to \infty, so lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0.

  3. Step 3

    f′(x)=2cos⁡(x2)−sin⁡(x2)x2f'(x) = 2\cos(x^2) - \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x^2}. As x→∞x \to \infty, 2cos⁡(x2)2\cos(x^2) oscillates between −2-2 and 22, so the limit does not exist.

  4. Step 4

    Thus f(x)f(x) disproves the implication.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the Squeeze Theorem to prove that lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0.

You differentiated f(x)=sin⁡(x2)xf(x) = \frac{\sin(x^2)}{x} accurately using the product and chain rules.

You correctly analyzed the asymptotic behavior of f′(x)f'(x) to show the limit does not exist.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Logical Negation of Conditional Statements

You wrote lim⁡x→∞f(x)≠0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) \neq 0 instead of lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0 in your existential negation statement.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the negation of an implication P  ⟹  QP \implies Q as negating both components simultaneously (¬P∧¬Q)(\neg P \land \neg Q), rather than recognizing that a conditional fails precisely when the premise is true and the consequence is false (P∧¬Q)(P \land \neg Q).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Negation of Implication
  • The logical negation of P  ⟹  QP \implies Q is logically equivalent to P∧¬QP \land \neg Q.

  • Always keep the premise PP unchanged and negate only the conclusion QQ when disproving or negating an 'if-then' statement.

Role of a Counterexample
  • A counterexample must satisfy the 'if' condition (premise) while failing the 'then' condition (conclusion).

  • Check that your counterexample makes the hypothesis true (P=TrueP = \text{True}) and the conclusion false (Q=FalseQ = \text{False}).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the conditional structure: ∀f,(lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0  ⟹  lim⁡x→∞f′(x)=0)\forall f, (\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0 \implies \lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) = 0).

  2. Apply the rule ¬(∀x,P(x)  ⟹  Q(x))≡∃x,(P(x)∧¬Q(x))\neg (\forall x, P(x) \implies Q(x)) \equiv \exists x, (P(x) \land \neg Q(x)).

  3. State the negation keeping the premise identical: 'There exists a differentiable function f:R→Rf: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R} such that lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0 and lim⁡x→∞f′(x)≠0\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) \neq 0 (or does not exist).'

Final answer

Negation: There exists a differentiable function f:R→Rf: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R} such that lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0 and lim⁡x→∞f′(x)≠0\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) \ne 0 (or does not exist).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the truth table for implication to see why P  ⟹  QP \implies Q is false only when PP is true and QQ is false.

  • Practice converting statements of the form 'If AA, then BB' into their negations 'AA and not BB' before writing mathematical proofs.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Evaluate lim⁡x→∞g′(x)\lim_{x \to \infty} g'(x) for g(x)=sin⁡(x3)x2g(x) = \frac{\sin(x^3)}{x^2}. Does g(x)g(x) provide a counterexample to 'if lim⁡x→∞g(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} g(x) = 0, then lim⁡x→∞g′(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} g'(x) = 0'?

Answer

g′(x)=x2[3x2cos⁡(x3)]−2xsin⁡(x3)x4=3cos⁡(x3)−2sin⁡(x3)x3g'(x) = \frac{x^2 [3x^2 \cos(x^3)] - 2x \sin(x^3)}{x^4} = 3\cos(x^3) - \frac{2\sin(x^3)}{x^3}. As x→∞x \to \infty, 2sin⁡(x3)x3→0\frac{2\sin(x^3)}{x^3} \to 0, but 3cos⁡(x3)3\cos(x^3) oscillates between −3-3 and 33. Thus the limit does not exist, confirming g(x)g(x) is a valid counterexample.

02

Determine whether the function f(x)=cos⁡(ex)xf(x) = \frac{\cos(e^x)}{x} satisfies lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0 and find the behavior of f′(x)f'(x) as x→∞x \to \infty.

Answer

Since ∣cos⁡(ex)∣≤1|\cos(e^x)| \le 1, lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0 by the Squeeze Theorem. Differentiating yields f′(x)=−exsin⁡(ex)x−cos⁡(ex)x2f'(x) = -\frac{e^x \sin(e^x)}{x} - \frac{\cos(e^x)}{x^2}. Because exx→∞\frac{e^x}{x} \to \infty, the amplitude of oscillation grows without bound, so f′(x)f'(x) diverges dramatically and its limit does not exist.

03

Construct a function f(x)f(x) such that lim⁡x→∞f(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = 0, but lim⁡x→∞f′(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) = 0 still holds. Compare its derivative structure to that of sin⁡(x2)x\frac{\sin(x^2)}{x}.

Answer

Consider f(x)=sin⁡(x)xf(x) = \frac{\sin(x)}{x}. Differentiating gives f′(x)=cos⁡(x)x−sin⁡(x)x2f'(x) = \frac{\cos(x)}{x} - \frac{\sin(x)}{x^2}. Since both terms have growing powers of xx in their denominators and bounded numerators, lim⁡x→∞f′(x)=0\lim_{x \to \infty} f'(x) = 0. Unlike sin⁡(x2)\sin(x^2), the inner derivative of sin⁡(x)\sin(x) is 11, which does not generate a factor of xx to cancel the denominator's decay.

Loading workspace…