Resources

Consider the function g(x)=x2−9x−3g(x) = \frac{x^2 - 9}{x - 3}. A student claims that g(x)g(x) is identical to the linear function h(x)=x+3h(x) = x + 3 over all real numbers. Formally resolve this claim by stating the natural domain of g(x)g(x) in set-builder notation, the domain of h(x)h(x) in interval notation, and evaluating lim⁡x→3g(x)\lim_{x \to 3} g(x) alongside the value g(3)g(3) using proper mathematical symbols.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Claim is false: Domain(g)={x∈R∣x≠3}\text{Domain}(g) = \{x \in \mathbb{R} \mid x \neq 3\}, while Domain(h)=(−∞,∞)\text{Domain}(h) = (-\infty, \infty); lim⁡x→3g(x)=6\lim_{x \to 3} g(x) = 6, but g(3)g(3) is undefined

Steps

01

Determine the natural domain of g(x)g(x)

To determine whether two functions are identical, they must share the exact same domain and produce the same output for every input in that domain.

The function is given by: g(x)=x2−9x−3g(x) = \frac{x^2 - 9}{x - 3}

A rational expression is defined only when its denominator is non-zero. Setting the denominator equal to zero gives: x−3=0  ⟹  x=3x - 3 = 0 \implies x = 3

Because division by zero is undefined, x=3x = 3 must be excluded from the domain. Expressed in set-builder notation, the natural domain of gg is: Domain(g)={x∈R∣x≠3}\text{Domain}(g) = \{x \in \mathbb{R} \mid x \neq 3\}

02

Determine the domain of h(x)h(x)

The function h(x)=x+3h(x) = x + 3 is a standard linear polynomial. Polynomials are defined for all real numbers without restriction. Expressed in interval notation, the domain of hh is: Domain(h)=(−∞,∞)\text{Domain}(h) = (-\infty, \infty)

Because Domain(g)≠Domain(h)\text{Domain}(g) \neq \text{Domain}(h), the two functions are not identical over all real numbers.

03

Evaluate the function value g(3)g(3) and the limit lim⁡x→3g(x)\lim_{x \to 3} g(x)

  • Function Value g(3)g(3): Substituting x=3x = 3 directly into g(x)g(x) yields: g(3)=32−93−3=00g(3) = \frac{3^2 - 9}{3 - 3} = \frac{0}{0} Division by zero is mathematically undefined, so: g(3) is undefinedg(3) \text{ is undefined}
  • Limit as x→3x \to 3: The limit describes the behavior of g(x)g(x) as xx gets arbitrarily close to 33, without ever actually equaling 33. For all x≠3x \neq 3, we can factor the numerator and simplify: g(x)=(x−3)(x+3)x−3=x+3(for x≠3)g(x) = \frac{(x - 3)(x + 3)}{x - 3} = x + 3 \quad (\text{for } x \neq 3)

    Evaluating the limit: lim⁡x→3g(x)=lim⁡x→3(x+3)=3+3=6\lim_{x \to 3} g(x) = \lim_{x \to 3} (x + 3) = 3 + 3 = 6

Common Pitfall

A common mistake is canceling (x−3)(x - 3) from the numerator and denominator before finding the domain. Algebraic simplification is only valid on the domain where the canceled factor is non-zero (x≠3x \neq 3). Simplifying does not eliminate the hole in the graph of g(x)g(x) at (3,6)(3, 6).

Conclusion

The student's claim is false. While g(x)=h(x)g(x) = h(x) for all x≠3x \neq 3, they have different domains:

  • Domain(g)={x∈R∣x≠3}\text{Domain}(g) = \{x \in \mathbb{R} \mid x \neq 3\}
  • Domain(h)=(−∞,∞)\text{Domain}(h) = (-\infty, \infty)
  • lim⁡x→3g(x)=6\lim_{x \to 3} g(x) = 6, whereas g(3)g(3) is undefined (creating a removable discontinuity, or "hole", at (3,6)(3, 6) on the graph of gg).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student conflates algebraic simplification with functional equivalence and believes that g(3) equals 6 by directly evaluating the simplified form.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    The claim is true because g(x)g(x) simplifies to x+3x+3, so they are the same function.

    Correct

    The claim is false because g(x)g(x) and h(x)h(x) do not have the same domain.

    Two functions are identical if and only if they have the same domain and assign the same output to every element in that domain. Because 3∉Domain(g)3 \notin \text{Domain}(g) but 3∈Domain(h)3 \in \text{Domain}(h), they are not identical over all real numbers.

  2. Step 2

    {x∈R∣x≠3}\{x \in \mathbb{R} \mid x \neq 3\}

  3. Step 3

    (−∞,∞)(-\infty, \infty)

  4. Step 4

    lim⁡x→3g(x)=lim⁡x→3(x+3)=3+3=6\lim_{x \to 3} g(x) = \lim_{x \to 3} (x+3) = 3+3 = 6

  5. Step 5

    g(3)=(3+3)=6g(3) = (3+3) = 6

    Correct

    g(3)g(3) is undefined

    Function values must be evaluated using the original formula g(x)=x2−9x−3g(x) = \frac{x^2 - 9}{x - 3}. Substituting x=3x = 3 gives 00\frac{0}{0}, which is undefined. Algebraic simplification is only valid on the domain x≠3x \neq 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the natural domain of g(x)g(x) in proper set-builder notation.

You correctly stated the domain of the linear polynomial h(x)h(x) in interval notation.

You evaluated the limit of g(x)g(x) as x→3x \to 3 accurately by canceling the common factor.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating algebraic simplification with functional equivalence

Evaluating g(3)g(3) using the canceled expression x+3x + 3 instead of the original formula.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated algebraic cancellation as an unconditional replacement rather than recognizing that simplification is valid only on the intersection of the domains (x≠3x \neq 3). Consequently, you assumed that simplifying away a denominator removes the domain restriction from the original function.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate at a Point Using the Original Definition
  • Always plug the input into the original, unsimplified rule of the function when checking whether a point is in the domain.

  • Substitute x=3x = 3 into x2−9x−3\frac{x^2 - 9}{x - 3} to verify that division by zero occurs, making g(3)g(3) undefined.

Definition of Equal Functions
  • Two functions ff and gg are equal (f=gf = g) if and only if Domain(f)=Domain(g)\text{Domain}(f) = \text{Domain}(g) and f(x)=g(x)f(x) = g(x) for all xx in that domain.

  • Compare the domains before concluding equivalence: since Domain(g)≠Domain(h)\text{Domain}(g) \neq \text{Domain}(h), the functions cannot be identical.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. To find g(3)g(3), substitute x=3x = 3 directly into the original definition: g(3)=32−93−3=00g(3) = \frac{3^2 - 9}{3 - 3} = \frac{0}{0}.

  2. Division by zero is undefined, so g(3)g(3) is undefined.

  3. Because Domain(g)={x∈R∣x≠3}≠(−∞,∞)=Domain(h)\text{Domain}(g) = \{x \in \mathbb{R} \mid x \neq 3\} \neq (-\infty, \infty) = \text{Domain}(h), the two functions do not have the same domain.

  4. Therefore, the claim that g(x)g(x) is identical to h(x)h(x) over all real numbers is false.

Final answer

Claim is false: Domain(g)={x∈R∣x≠3}\text{Domain}(g) = \{x \in \mathbb{R} \mid x \neq 3\}, while Domain(h)=(−∞,∞)\text{Domain}(h) = (-\infty, \infty); lim⁡x→3g(x)=6\lim_{x \to 3} g(x) = 6, but g(3)g(3) is undefined

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the formal definition of function equality to reinforce that matching formulas after algebraic reduction does not guarantee equal domains.

  • Practice identifying removable discontinuities (holes) on rational function graphs versus values of simplified linear functions.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the value of a function at a point with the two-sided limit, concluding that the limit does not exist because g(3) is undefined.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    {x∈R∣x≠3}\{x \in \mathbb{R} \mid x \neq 3\}

  2. Step 2

    (−∞,∞)(-\infty, \infty)

  3. Step 3

    g(3) is undefinedg(3) \text{ is undefined}

  4. Step 4

    lim⁡x→3g(x) does not exist because g(3) is undefined.\lim_{x \to 3} g(x) \text{ does not exist because } g(3) \text{ is undefined.}

    Correct

    lim⁡x→3g(x)=lim⁡x→3(x−3)(x+3)x−3=lim⁡x→3(x+3)=6\lim_{x \to 3} g(x) = \lim_{x \to 3} \frac{(x - 3)(x + 3)}{x - 3} = \lim_{x \to 3} (x + 3) = 6

    A two-sided limit lim⁡x→cg(x)\lim_{x \to c} g(x) describes the output values as xx gets arbitrarily close to cc, without ever requiring g(c)g(c) to be defined. Factoring the numerator gives (x−3)(x+3)x−3=x+3\frac{(x - 3)(x + 3)}{x - 3} = x + 3 for all x≠3x \neq 3, which approaches 66 as x→3x \to 3.

  5. Step 5

    The claim is false because g(x) has a hole at x=3 and their domains are different.\text{The claim is false because } g(x) \text{ has a hole at } x=3 \text{ and their domains are different.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately identified and formatted the domains of both functions using set-builder and interval notation.

You correctly identified that g(3)g(3) is undefined due to division by zero.

You correctly concluded that the functions are not identical because their domains differ.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing function value with limit value

No, this is a conceptual misunderstanding of the definition of a limit at a point of removable discontinuity.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that a limit cannot exist at an input where the function itself is undefined, conflating the local behavior around a point with the function's evaluation at that point.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Independence of Limits from Function Values
  • The statement lim⁡x→cf(x)=L\lim_{x \to c} f(x) = L depends only on the behavior of f(x)f(x) for values of xx near cc, never on f(c)f(c) itself.

  • When evaluating a limit where direct substitution yields 00\frac{0}{0}, factor and cancel common non-zero terms rather than concluding that the limit does not exist.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Factor the numerator of g(x)g(x): x2−9=(x−3)(x+3)x^2 - 9 = (x - 3)(x + 3).

  2. Simplify the rational expression for x≠3x \neq 3: g(x)=(x−3)(x+3)x−3=x+3g(x) = \frac{(x - 3)(x + 3)}{x - 3} = x + 3.

  3. Evaluate the limit by direct substitution into the simplified form: lim⁡x→3(x+3)=3+3=6\lim_{x \to 3} (x + 3) = 3 + 3 = 6.

Final answer

Claim is false: Domain(g)={x∈R∣x≠3}\text{Domain}(g) = \{x \in \mathbb{R} \mid x \neq 3\}, while Domain(h)=(−∞,∞)\text{Domain}(h) = (-\infty, \infty); lim⁡x→3g(x)=6\lim_{x \to 3} g(x) = 6, but g(3)g(3) is undefined

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the formal definition of a two-sided limit and how it differs from function evaluation.

  • Practice computing limits of rational functions that have removable discontinuities (holes).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student evaluates the limit using direct substitution without canceling the indeterminate factor, incorrectly concluding that the limit equals 0 because 0/0 is treated as zero.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    The claim is false because g(x)g(x) is not defined at x=3x = 3 while h(x)h(x) is defined everywhere. {x∈R∣x≠3}(−∞,∞)\{x \in \mathbb{R} \mid x \neq 3\} \quad (-\infty, \infty)

  2. Step 2

    lim⁡x→3g(x)=32−93−3=00=0\lim_{x \to 3} g(x) = \frac{3^2 - 9}{3 - 3} = \frac{0}{0} = 0

    Correct

    lim⁡x→3g(x)=lim⁡x→3(x−3)(x+3)x−3=lim⁡x→3(x+3)=3+3=6\lim_{x \to 3} g(x) = \lim_{x \to 3} \frac{(x - 3)(x + 3)}{x - 3} = \lim_{x \to 3} (x + 3) = 3 + 3 = 6

    Direct substitution yields the indeterminate form 00\frac{0}{0}, which does not equal 00. Because a limit examines values of xx close to 33 but not equal to 33, you must factor the numerator as (x−3)(x+3)(x - 3)(x + 3) and cancel the common factor (x−3)(x - 3) before evaluating.

  3. Step 3

    g(3) is undefinedg(3) \text{ is undefined}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly resolved the claim by explaining that the two functions have different domains.

You accurately expressed the domain of g(x)g(x) in set-builder notation and the domain of h(x)h(x) in interval notation.

You correctly identified that the function value g(3)g(3) is undefined due to division by zero.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Indeterminate Form Misconception

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating the indeterminate expression 00\frac{0}{0} as equal to 00 rather than recognizing it as a signal that algebraic simplification (factoring and canceling the zero factor) is required to evaluate the limit.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Recognizing Indeterminate Forms
  • Obtaining 00\frac{0}{0} from direct substitution means the limit cannot be determined immediately; it indicates a shared factor of (x−c)(x - c) in the numerator and denominator.

  • Whenever direct substitution yields 00\frac{0}{0}, stop and factor the expression to cancel the factor causing division by zero before evaluating the limit.

Distinguishing Limits from Function Values
  • A function value g(c)g(c) depends strictly on direct evaluation in the original formula, while lim⁡x→cg(x)\lim_{x \to c} g(x) depends only on values near cc where x≠cx \neq c.

  • Use factoring and algebraic cancellation for the limit, but retain the original unsimplified denominator to evaluate function values and domain restrictions.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Factor the numerator using the difference of squares: x2−9=(x−3)(x+3)x^2 - 9 = (x - 3)(x + 3).

  2. Cancel the common factor (x−3)(x - 3), which is valid for all x≠3x \neq 3: lim⁡x→3(x−3)(x+3)x−3=lim⁡x→3(x+3)\lim_{x \to 3} \frac{(x - 3)(x + 3)}{x - 3} = \lim_{x \to 3} (x + 3).

  3. Evaluate the simplified limit by direct substitution: 3+3=63 + 3 = 6.

Final answer

Claim is false: Domain(g)={x∈R∣x≠3}\text{Domain}(g) = \{x \in \mathbb{R} \mid x \neq 3\}, while Domain(h)=(−∞,∞)\text{Domain}(h) = (-\infty, \infty); lim⁡x→3g(x)=6\lim_{x \to 3} g(x) = 6, but g(3)g(3) is undefined

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between undefined values (such as k0\frac{k}{0} with k≠0k \neq 0) and indeterminate forms (such as 00\frac{0}{0}).

  • Practice factoring rational functions before computing limits where direct substitution yields 00\frac{0}{0}.

  • Sketch rational functions with removable discontinuities to visually reinforce why the limit exists at a hole even when the point itself is undefined.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Consider f(x)=x2−4x+2f(x) = \frac{x^2 - 4}{x + 2} and k(x)=x−2k(x) = x - 2. Are ff and kk identical functions over R\mathbb{R}? State their natural domains to justify your answer.

Answer

No, they are not identical. Domain(f)={x∈R∣x≠−2}\text{Domain}(f) = \{x \in \mathbb{R} \mid x \neq -2\}, while Domain(k)=(−∞,∞)\text{Domain}(k) = (-\infty, \infty). Because their domains are different, f≠kf \neq k.

02

Let r(x)=x(x−5)x−5r(x) = \frac{x(x - 5)}{x - 5}. Evaluate r(5)r(5) and lim⁡x→5r(x)\lim_{x \to 5} r(x) using appropriate mathematical statements.

Answer

r(5)r(5) is undefined (substituting x=5x=5 gives division by zero, 00\frac{0}{0}). lim⁡x→5r(x)=lim⁡x→5x=5\lim_{x \to 5} r(x) = \lim_{x \to 5} x = 5.

03

Define p(x)=x3−xx−1p(x) = \frac{x^3 - x}{x - 1} and q(x)=x2+xq(x) = x^2 + x. Find the set of all real numbers xx where p(x)=q(x)p(x) = q(x), and state whether pp and qq are equal as functions.

Answer

Factoring gives p(x)=x(x−1)(x+1)x−1=x(x+1)=x2+xp(x) = \frac{x(x-1)(x+1)}{x-1} = x(x+1) = x^2 + x for x≠1x \neq 1. Thus, p(x)=q(x)p(x) = q(x) on {x∈R∣x≠1}\{x \in \mathbb{R} \mid x \neq 1\}. They are not equal as functions because 1∈Domain(q)1 \in \text{Domain}(q) but 1∉Domain(p)1 \notin \text{Domain}(p).

Loading workspace…