Resources

A commercial cold-storage facility operates under power constraints where the total daily electrical energy consumption EE (in kilowatt-hours, kWh\text{kWh}) is modeled by E=12x+18yE = 12x + 18y, where xx represents the operational runtime in hours of chiller unit 11 and yy represents the operational runtime in hours of chiller unit 22. Maintenance protocols mandate that chiller unit 22 runs at least twice as long as chiller unit 11 (y≥2xy \ge 2x), and neither unit may exceed 24 h24\text{ h} of daily runtime (0≤x≤240 \le x \le 24, 0≤y≤240 \le y \le 24). Given that the facility consumed an energy snapshot of exactly E=288 kWhE = 288\text{ kWh} while chiller unit 22 operated at its upper bound of y=12 hy = 12\text{ h}, reverse-engineer the initial operating state to determine the runtime xx of chiller unit 11, and verify whether this operating point (x,y)(x, y) strictly satisfies all system constraints.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Chiller 1 runtime: x=6 hx = 6\text{ h}; Constraint verification: The point (6,12)(6, 12) satisfies 12≥2(6)12 \ge 2(6) and 0≤6,12≤240 \le 6, 12 \le 24, so all operational constraints are strictly satisfied.

Steps

01

Identify the Given Variables and Formula

From the problem statement:

  • Total daily energy consumption model: E=12x+18yE = 12x + 18y
  • Recorded energy consumption: E=288 kWhE = 288\text{ kWh}
  • Runtime of chiller unit 22: y=12 hy = 12\text{ h}
  • Runtime of chiller unit 11: xx (unknown, in hours)

System constraints:

  1. Maintenance ratio: y≥2xy \ge 2x
  2. Daily runtime limits: 0≤x≤240 \le x \le 24 and 0≤y≤240 \le y \le 24

02

Solve for the Runtime of Chiller Unit 1 (xx)

Substitute E=288E = 288 and y=12y = 12 into the energy equation:

288=12x+18(12)288 = 12x + 18(12)

Compute the energy used by chiller unit 22:

18⋅12=21618 \cdot 12 = 216

Substitute this back into the equation:

288=12x+216288 = 12x + 216

Subtract 216216 from both sides:

12x=288−21612x = 288 - 216 12x=7212x = 72

Divide by 1212:

x=7212=6 hx = \frac{72}{12} = 6\text{ h}

Thus, chiller unit 11 operated for x=6 hx = 6\text{ h}.


03

Verify All System Constraints for the Operating Point (6,12)(6, 12)

Check each constraint using the operating point (x,y)=(6,12)(x, y) = (6, 12):

  1. Maintenance constraint (y≥2xy \ge 2x): 12≥2(6)  ⟹  12≥12(Satisfied)12 \ge 2(6) \implies 12 \ge 12 \quad \text{(Satisfied)}
  2. Chiller unit 1 runtime limit (0≤x≤240 \le x \le 24): 0≤6≤24(Satisfied)0 \le 6 \le 24 \quad \text{(Satisfied)}
  3. Chiller unit 2 runtime limit (0≤y≤240 \le y \le 24): 0≤12≤24(Satisfied)0 \le 12 \le 24 \quad \text{(Satisfied)}

Common Pitfall: When checking inequality constraints like y≥2xy \ge 2x, remember that equality (12=1212 = 12) satisfies a non-strict inequality (≥\ge). Do not mistake it for a strict inequality (>>).

Since all conditions hold, the operating state (6,12)(6, 12) strictly satisfies every facility constraint.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets the condition that chiller unit 2 runs at least twice as long as chiller unit 1 as x >= 2y instead of y >= 2x, incorrectly concluding that the constraint is violated.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    288=12x+18(12)  ⟹  288=12x+216  ⟹  12x=72  ⟹  x=6 h288 = 12x + 18(12) \implies 288 = 12x + 216 \implies 12x = 72 \implies x = 6\text{ h}

  2. Step 2

    0≤6≤24 and 0≤12≤24 are satisfied.0 \le 6 \le 24\text{ and }0 \le 12 \le 24\text{ are satisfied.}

  3. Step 3

    Constraint: x≥2y  ⟹  6≥2(12)=24 is false.\text{Constraint: }x \ge 2y \implies 6 \ge 2(12) = 24\text{ is false.}

    Correct

    Constraint: y≥2x  ⟹  12≥2(6)=12 (True)\text{Constraint: }y \ge 2x \implies 12 \ge 2(6) = 12\text{ (True)}

    The problem states that chiller unit 22 (yy) must run at least twice as long as chiller unit 11 (xx), which corresponds to y≥2xy \ge 2x, not x≥2yx \ge 2y.

  4. Step 4

    The operating point does not satisfy all system constraints.\text{The operating point does not satisfy all system constraints.}

    Correct

    All operational constraints are strictly satisfied.\text{All operational constraints are strictly satisfied.}

    Because this conclusion depends on the reversed inequality in step 3, it is marked as affected.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the known values into the energy equation and solved for x=6 hx = 6\text{ h}.

You correctly verified that both chiller runtimes fall within the required 00 to 24 h24\text{ h} range.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed Inequality Variables

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You swapped the dependent and independent roles of the variables when translating or transcribing the relational constraint, setting the multiplier on yy instead of xx.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Translating 'A is at least twice B'
  • 'A runs at least twice as long as B' means A≥2BA \ge 2B. The factor multiplying 22 belongs to the smaller reference quantity BB.

  • Match variable names to their exact physical definitions before evaluating: chiller 22 is yy, chiller 11 is xx, so y≥2xy \ge 2x.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Verify the correct maintenance constraint y≥2xy \ge 2x using (x,y)=(6,12)(x, y) = (6, 12): 12≥2(6)  ⟹  12≥1212 \ge 2(6) \implies 12 \ge 12, which is true.

  2. Combine all constraint checks: 0≤6≤240 \le 6 \le 24, 0≤12≤240 \le 12 \le 24, and 12≥2(6)12 \ge 2(6) all hold.

Final answer

x=6 hx = 6\text{ h}; all system constraints are strictly satisfied.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Reread the exact wording of relational conditions: identify which quantity is being compared and which serves as the base quantity.

  • Double-check that equality (12=1212 = 12) satisfies non-strict inequalities like ≥\ge.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses strict inequality with non-strict inequality, concluding that y = 2x does not satisfy y >= 2x.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    12x+18(12)=288  ⟹  12x+216=288  ⟹  12x=72  ⟹  x=6 h12x + 18(12) = 288 \implies 12x + 216 = 288 \implies 12x = 72 \implies x = 6\text{ h}

  2. Step 2

    0≤6≤24 and 0≤12≤24 are satisfied.0 \le 6 \le 24 \text{ and } 0 \le 12 \le 24 \text{ are satisfied.}

  3. Step 3

    y≥2x requires y to be strictly greater than 2x  ⟹  12=2(6) means y is not greater than 2x  ⟹  The operating point does not satisfy all system constraints.y \ge 2x \text{ requires } y \text{ to be strictly greater than } 2x \implies 12 = 2(6) \text{ means } y \text{ is not greater than } 2x \implies \text{The operating point does not satisfy all system constraints.}

    Correct

    y≥2x  ⟹  12≥2(6)  ⟹  12≥12 (True)  ⟹  All constraints are satisfied.y \ge 2x \implies 12 \ge 2(6) \implies 12 \ge 12 \text{ (True)} \implies \text{All constraints are satisfied.}

    The symbol ≥\ge means "greater than or equal to." Equality (12=1212 = 12) satisfies this condition, so the point (6,12)(6, 12) does satisfy the constraint.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the known values into the linear energy model and solved for xx.

You verified that both runtimes satisfy the individual domain bounds 0≤x≤240 \le x \le 24 and 0≤y≤240 \le y \le 24.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing non-strict inequality with strict inequality

Interpreting ≥\ge as requiring strict inequality rather than allowing equality.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated non-strict inequality ("≥""\ge", greater than or equal to) with strict inequality (">"">", strictly greater than), causing you to reject a valid boundary point where y=2xy = 2x.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Interpret Inequality Symbols
  • The symbol ≥\ge represents a logical OR: a≥ba \ge b is true if a>ba > b OR a=ba = b.

  • When testing a boundary case where both sides evaluate to the same value (12=1212 = 12), confirm that the presence of the "or equal to" bar makes the statement true.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate the maintenance constraint y≥2xy \ge 2x at x=6x = 6 and y=12y = 12: 12≥2(6)  ⟹  12≥1212 \ge 2(6) \implies 12 \ge 12.

  2. Since 1212 equals 1212, the condition "greater than or equal to" is true.

  3. Combine this with the domain checks: 0≤6≤240 \le 6 \le 24 and 0≤12≤240 \le 12 \le 24 are also satisfied.

Final answer

Chiller 1 runtime is x=6 hx = 6\text{ h}, and the operating state (6,12)(6, 12) strictly satisfies all system constraints.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Read inequality symbols carefully by checking whether they include the equality bar (≥,≤\ge, \le) or represent strict conditions (>,<>, <).

  • Practice testing boundary points where left-hand and right-hand sides are equal against non-strict inequalities.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student swaps the coefficients of x and y in the energy equation, leading to an incorrect runtime x = 18 h and a violation of the constraint y >= 2x.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    18x+12y=288  ⟹  18x+12(12)=288  ⟹  18x+144=288  ⟹  18x=144  ⟹  x=8 h18x + 12y = 288 \implies 18x + 12(12) = 288 \implies 18x + 144 = 288 \implies 18x = 144 \implies x = 8\text{ h}

    Correct

    12x+18(12)=288  ⟹  12x+216=288  ⟹  12x=72  ⟹  x=6 h12x + 18(12) = 288 \implies 12x + 216 = 288 \implies 12x = 72 \implies x = 6\text{ h}

    You swapped the unit rates from the formula given in the problem statement (E=12x+18yE = 12x + 18y). Chiller 11 consumes 12 kWh/h12\text{ kWh/h} and chiller 22 consumes 18 kWh/h18\text{ kWh/h}, so the setup should be 12x+18y=28812x + 18y = 288 rather than 18x+12y=28818x + 12y = 288.

  2. Step 2

    0≤8≤24 and 0≤12≤24 are satisfied. Check y≥2x:12≥2(8)=16 is false. The operating point does not satisfy all system constraints.0 \le 8 \le 24\text{ and }0 \le 12 \le 24\text{ are satisfied. Check }y \ge 2x: 12 \ge 2(8) = 16\text{ is false. The operating point does not satisfy all system constraints.}

    Correct

    0≤6≤24 and 0≤12≤24 are satisfied. Check y≥2x:12≥2(6)=12 is true. All system constraints are satisfied.0 \le 6 \le 24\text{ and }0 \le 12 \le 24\text{ are satisfied. Check }y \ge 2x: 12 \ge 2(6) = 12\text{ is true. All system constraints are satisfied.}

    Your constraint verification logic was applied correctly to your calculated value of x=8x = 8, but because xx should be 66, the condition y≥2xy \ge 2x becomes 12≥2(6)12 \ge 2(6), which is 12≥1212 \ge 12 (true). Therefore, the correct operating point (6,12)(6, 12) actually satisfies all constraints.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the known value y=12y = 12 and cleanly solved your linear equation.

You tested all required constraints (0≤x≤240 \le x \le 24, 0≤y≤240 \le y \le 24, and y≥2xy \ge 2x) methodically.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Swapped coefficients

You inverted the coefficients of xx and yy, writing 18x+12y18x + 12y instead of 12x+18y12x + 18y.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Misaligning variables with their corresponding unit rates when transcribing a multi-variable linear model from text into an equation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Variable-to-Coefficient Mapping
  • In a linear model E=ax+byE = ax + by, verify that each rate corresponds directly to its defined variable (aa with unit 1 rate, bb with unit 2 rate).

  • Write down variable definitions with their associated rates side by side (x→12 kWh/hx \to 12\text{ kWh/h}, y→18 kWh/hy \to 18\text{ kWh/h}) before setting up the equation.

Boundary Value in Non-Strict Inequalities
  • A non-strict inequality A≥BA \ge B is satisfied when A=BA = B.

  • When testing equality at the boundary (such as 12=1212 = 12), mark the condition as satisfied rather than violated.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the energy equation using the correct coefficients: 12x+18y=28812x + 18y = 288.

  2. Substitute y=12y = 12: 12x+18(12)=28812x + 18(12) = 288.

  3. Simplify the product: 12x+216=28812x + 216 = 288.

  4. Subtract 216216 from both sides: 12x=7212x = 72.

  5. Divide by 1212: x=6 hx = 6\text{ h}.

  6. Check bounds: 0≤6≤240 \le 6 \le 24 and 0≤12≤240 \le 12 \le 24 are both satisfied.

  7. Check the maintenance constraint: y≥2x  ⟹  12≥2(6)=12y \ge 2x \implies 12 \ge 2(6) = 12, which is true.

Final answer

x=6 hx = 6\text{ h}; all system constraints are strictly satisfied.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always double-check that each numerical coefficient matches the correct variable given in the prompt before computing.

  • Review non-strict inequalities to ensure you recognize that equality satisfies ≥\ge and ≤\le conditions.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A delivery service uses vans (xx) and trucks (yy). Total fuel consumed is F=8x+14yF = 8x + 14y. The protocol requires trucks to run at least 1.51.5 times as many hours as vans (y≥1.5xy \ge 1.5x), with 0≤x,y≤100 \le x, y \le 10. If total fuel used is F=86 LF = 86\text{ L} when y=5 hy = 5\text{ h}, find xx and verify whether the operating point satisfies the protocol.

Answer

x=2 hx = 2\text{ h}. Testing y≥1.5xy \ge 1.5x gives 5≥1.5(2)=35 \ge 1.5(2) = 3 (True). Since 0≤2,5≤100 \le 2, 5 \le 10, all constraints are strictly satisfied.

02

A hybrid generator uses biofuel (xx) and natural gas (yy) governed by P=20x+30yP = 20x + 30y. Operating rules state that natural gas runtime must be at least twice biofuel runtime (y≥2xy \ge 2x), and neither can exceed 12 h12\text{ h}. If P=420 kWP = 420\text{ kW} and x=6 hx = 6\text{ h}, solve for yy and determine whether the constraints are satisfied.

Answer

y=10 hy = 10\text{ h}. Check constraints: 0≤6,10≤120 \le 6, 10 \le 12 holds, but checking y≥2xy \ge 2x gives 10≥2(6)=1210 \ge 2(6) = 12, which is False. The operating point violates the runtime ratio constraint.

03

Two pumps AA (runtime aa) and BB (runtime bb) fill a reservoir such that V=15a+25b=200 m3V = 15a + 25b = 200\text{ m}^3. Regulations mandate that Pump AA runs no more than half the time of Pump BB (a≤0.5ba \le 0.5b), and both runtimes are capped at 10 h10\text{ h}. If Pump BB runs for b=5 hb = 5\text{ h}, find aa and check whether all constraints are satisfied.

Answer

15a+25(5)=200  ⟹  15a=75  ⟹  a=5 h15a + 25(5) = 200 \implies 15a = 75 \implies a = 5\text{ h}. Checking a≤0.5ba \le 0.5b gives 5≤0.5(5)=2.55 \le 0.5(5) = 2.5, which is False. The constraint is not satisfied.

Loading workspace…