Resources

A student measures the absorbance of a dye solution at three standard wavelengths to determine the unknown concentrations of two reacting dyes, CAC_A and CBC_B (in μmol/L\mu\text{mol/L}). According to Beer's Law, the measurements generate the overdetermined linear system: {0.12CA+0.08CB=0.600.24CA+0.16CB=1.200.36CA+0.24CB=1.85\begin{cases} 0.12 C_A + 0.08 C_B = 0.60 \\ 0.24 C_A + 0.16 C_B = 1.20 \\ 0.36 C_A + 0.24 C_B = 1.85 \end{cases}. Determine whether this experimental calibration system is consistent or inconsistent, and state whether it possesses one solution, no solution, or infinitely many solutions.

Answer and steps

Final answer

No solution (inconsistent). The first two equations describe the same underlying relation 3CA+2CB=153C_A + 2C_B = 15, but the third equation yields 3CA+2CB=15.41673C_A + 2C_B = 15.4167, creating a direct contradiction due to experimental error.

Steps

01

Simplify Equation 1

To determine whether the system is consistent and how many solutions it possesses, simplify each linear equation to its standard integer form: Given the system of three linear equations:

  1. 0.12CA+0.08CB=0.600.12 C_A + 0.08 C_B = 0.60
  2. 0.24CA+0.16CB=1.200.24 C_A + 0.16 C_B = 1.20
  3. 0.36CA+0.24CB=1.850.36 C_A + 0.24 C_B = 1.85

Multiply both sides of the first equation by 100100 to clear the decimals: 12CA+8CB=6012 C_A + 8 C_B = 60

Divide the entire equation by the greatest common divisor, 44: 3CA+2CB=153 C_A + 2 C_B = 15

02

Simplify Equation 2

Multiply both sides by 100100: 24CA+16CB=12024 C_A + 16 C_B = 120

Divide by 88: 3CA+2CB=153 C_A + 2 C_B = 15

Equations (1) and (2) represent the exact same line, meaning any pair (CA,CB)(C_A, C_B) satisfying Equation 1 also satisfies Equation 2.

03

Simplify Equation 3

Multiply both sides by 100100: 36CA+24CB=18536 C_A + 24 C_B = 185

To compare the left-hand side directly with the first two equations, divide the entire equation by 1212: 3CA+2CB=18512≈15.41673 C_A + 2 C_B = \frac{185}{12} \approx 15.4167

04

Compare the Equations and Conclude

Comparing Equation 1 (or 2) with Equation 3:

3 C_A + 2 C_B &= 15 \\ 3 C_A + 2 C_B &= \frac{185}{12} \approx 15.4167 \end{aligned}$$

The left-hand sides are identical, but the right-hand sides differ (15≠15.416715 \neq 15.4167). Geometrically, these equations represent two distinct parallel lines with the same slope (−32-\frac{3}{2}) but different intercepts. Because parallel lines never intersect, there is no pair (CA,CB)(C_A, C_B) that satisfies all three equations simultaneously.

  • Consistency: The system is inconsistent.
  • Number of solutions: The system has no solution.

Pitfall to Avoid: Do not stop after noticing that Equation 2 is a direct multiple of Equation 1 (2×Eq. 1=Eq. 22 \times \text{Eq. 1} = \text{Eq. 2}). While the sub-system of the first two equations has infinitely many solutions, an overdetermined system requires all equations to hold true simultaneously. Any single contradiction makes the entire system inconsistent.

Educational illustration for this question

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student only compares the first two equations, notices they are linearly dependent multiples of each other, and prematurely concludes the system has infinitely many solutions without checking the third equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Equation 2 is 2×Equation 12 \times \text{Equation 1}: 2(0.12CA+0.08CB)=0.24CA+0.16CB=1.20  ⟹  2(0.12 C_A + 0.08 C_B) = 0.24 C_A + 0.16 C_B = 1.20 \implies The equations are linearly dependent and represent the same line.

  2. Step 2

    The system is consistent and possesses infinitely many solutions.

    Correct

    Compare with Equation 3: 0.36CA+0.24CB=1.85  ⟹  3CA+2CB=18512≈15.41670.36 C_A + 0.24 C_B = 1.85 \implies 3 C_A + 2 C_B = \frac{185}{12} \approx 15.4167. Since 15≠15.416715 \neq 15.4167, Equation 3 represents a distinct parallel line. Therefore, the system is inconsistent and possesses no solution.

    You made an error by stopping after the first two equations. A solution to a linear system must satisfy all given equations simultaneously. Because Equation 3 produces 3CA+2CB≈15.41673C_A + 2C_B \approx 15.4167 while Equations 1 and 2 require 3CA+2CB=153C_A + 2C_B = 15, there is no common solution.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly multiplied Equation 1 by 22 to demonstrate linear dependence between the first two equations.

You correctly recognized that two identical lines share infinitely many common points.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Premature termination without evaluating all constraints

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated an overdetermined system as if it were defined solely by its first two equations, overlooking the requirement that every solution must satisfy all three equations simultaneously.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check all equations in an overdetermined system
  • A point (x,y)(x, y) is a solution to a system if and only if it satisfies every single equation in that system.

  • Always substitute or reduce every remaining equation before stating the final consistency or number of solutions.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. From Step 1, Equations 1 and 2 simplify to 3CA+2CB=153 C_A + 2 C_B = 15.

  2. Simplify Equation 3 by multiplying by 100100: 36CA+24CB=18536 C_A + 24 C_B = 185.

  3. Divide by 1212 to match the left-hand side: 3CA+2CB=18512≈15.41673 C_A + 2 C_B = \frac{185}{12} \approx 15.4167.

  4. Because 15≠1851215 \neq \frac{185}{12}, the lines are parallel and do not intersect.

Final answer

The system is inconsistent and possesses no solution.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Simplify every equation in the system to standard form with identical variable coefficients to easily spot contradictions.

  • Remember that in an overdetermined system, even a single contradictory equation makes the entire system inconsistent.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student believes any overdetermined system (more equations than unknowns) automatically has no solution solely by definition of being overdetermined, rather than testing consistency.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    There are 3 equations and only 2 unknowns (CAC_A and CBC_B).

  2. Step 2

    An overdetermined system has more equations than variables, so it is inconsistent and has no solution.

    Correct

    Simplify the equations to compare them: Equation 1 gives 3CA+2CB=153C_A + 2C_B = 15, Equation 2 gives 3CA+2CB=153C_A + 2C_B = 15, but Equation 3 gives 3CA+2CB=18512≈15.41673C_A + 2C_B = \frac{185}{12} \approx 15.4167. Because 15≠15.416715 \neq 15.4167, these parallel lines never intersect, making the system inconsistent with no solution.

    An overdetermined system is not automatically inconsistent. It can have a unique solution (if extra lines pass through the exact same intersection point) or infinitely many solutions (if equations are redundant multiples of each other). You must test whether the equations are algebraically compatible rather than assuming inconsistency from the count alone.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the system contains 3 equations and 2 unknowns (CAC_A and CBC_B).

You stated the correct final classification that the given system is inconsistent and has no solution.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Overdetermined System Inconsistency Fallacy

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the definition of an overdetermined system (more equations than unknowns) as an automatic guarantee of inconsistency, conflating an excess of constraints with an algebraic contradiction.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Overdetermined Possibilities
  • An overdetermined system can have a unique solution, infinitely many solutions, or no solution.

  • Never conclude 'no solution' based purely on having more equations than unknowns.

Test Algebraic Compatibility
  • A system is inconsistent only if two or more equations produce a direct contradiction (such as 0=k0 = k where k≠0k \neq 0).

  • Reduce equations to a common form or eliminate variables to verify whether a contradiction actually occurs.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Simplify the first equation 0.12CA+0.08CB=0.600.12C_A + 0.08C_B = 0.60 by dividing by 0.040.04 to get 3CA+2CB=153C_A + 2C_B = 15.

  2. Simplify the second equation 0.24CA+0.16CB=1.200.24C_A + 0.16C_B = 1.20 by dividing by 0.080.08 to get 3CA+2CB=153C_A + 2C_B = 15, which is identical to the first.

  3. Simplify the third equation 0.36CA+0.24CB=1.850.36C_A + 0.24C_B = 1.85 by dividing by 0.120.12 to get 3CA+2CB=18512≈15.41673C_A + 2C_B = \frac{185}{12} \approx 15.4167.

  4. Compare the equations: 3CA+2CB=153C_A + 2C_B = 15 contradicts 3CA+2CB≈15.41673C_A + 2C_B \approx 15.4167 because two parallel lines with different constants cannot intersect.

Final answer

The system is inconsistent and has no solution because Equations 1 and 3 create an algebraic contradiction (15≠15.416715 \neq 15.4167).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice solving overdetermined systems where a unique solution does exist (such as three lines intersecting at a single point).

  • Always simplify linear equations to standard form to check for parallel lines or contradictions before drawing a conclusion about consistency.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student rounds the right-hand side of equation 3 or makes an arithmetic error believing 3 × 0.60 = 1.85, falsely determining the third equation is also a multiple and thus concluding the system has infinitely many solutions.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    3 ×\times (0.12 C_A + 0.08 C_B = 0.60)  gives \text{ gives } 0.36 C_A + 0.24 C_B = 1.85

    Correct

    3 ×\times (0.12 C_A + 0.08 C_B = 0.60)   ⟹  \implies 0.36 C_A + 0.24 C_B = 1.80 ≠\neq 1.85

    Multiplying the first equation by 33 gives 0.36CA+0.24CB=1.800.36 C_A + 0.24 C_B = 1.80. The third equation in the problem has a right-hand side of 1.851.85, so the third equation is not an exact scalar multiple of the first.

  2. Step 2

    All three equations are scalar multiples of each other.\text{All three equations are scalar multiples of each other.}

    Correct

    Equations 1 and 2 are scalar multiples, but Equation 3 has the same left-hand side coefficients with a different constant term.\text{Equations 1 and 2 are scalar multiples, but Equation 3 has the same left-hand side coefficients with a different constant term.}

    Because the third equation's constant term is 1.851.85 rather than 1.801.80, only the variable coefficients are proportional; the third equation is not a multiple of the first two.

  3. Step 3

    Therefore, the system is consistent and has infinitely many solutions.\text{Therefore, the system is consistent and has infinitely many solutions.}

    Correct

    Therefore, the system is inconsistent and has no solution.\text{Therefore, the system is inconsistent and has no solution.}

    Two equations with identical linear combinations of variables but different constants represent parallel, non-intersecting lines, creating a contradiction that leaves the system with no solution.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that multiplying the first equation by 33 matches the variable coefficients of the third equation.

You correctly calculated 3×0.60=1.803 \times 0.60 = 1.80 initially before crossing it out.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Arithmetic / False Proportionality Overwrite

You crossed out the true product 1.801.80 to force the result to match the right-hand side of Equation 3 (1.851.85).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking that a small discrepancy in the constant term changes the geometric relationship from coincident lines (infinitely many solutions) to distinct parallel lines (no solution).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Strict Constant Checking
  • For two linear equations to represent the same line, both the coefficients AND the constant term must scale by the exact same factor.

  • Always compare a1a2=b1b2=c1c2\frac{a_1}{a_2} = \frac{b_1}{b_2} = \frac{c_1}{c_2}. If a1a2=b1b2≠c1c2\frac{a_1}{a_2} = \frac{b_1}{b_2} \neq \frac{c_1}{c_2}, the lines are parallel and the system is inconsistent.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Scale Equation 1 by 33: 3(0.12CA+0.08CB)=3(0.60)  ⟹  0.36CA+0.24CB=1.803(0.12 C_A + 0.08 C_B) = 3(0.60) \implies 0.36 C_A + 0.24 C_B = 1.80.

  2. Compare with Equation 3: 0.36CA+0.24CB=1.850.36 C_A + 0.24 C_B = 1.85.

  3. Subtract the scaled equation from Equation 3: (0.36−0.36)CA+(0.24−0.24)CB=1.85−1.80  ⟹  0=0.05(0.36 - 0.36)C_A + (0.24 - 0.24)C_B = 1.85 - 1.80 \implies 0 = 0.05.

Final answer

The false statement 0=0.050 = 0.05 proves the system is inconsistent and possesses no solution.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Check whether all ratios a1a2\frac{a_1}{a_2}, b1b2\frac{b_1}{b_2}, and c1c2\frac{c_1}{c_2} are equal before declaring equations dependent.

  • Practice identifying parallel versus coincident lines when constants differ by small decimal values.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Determine whether the following system is consistent or inconsistent, and state the number of solutions: {2x−4y=6,−x+2y=−3,3x−6y=10\lbrace 2x - 4y = 6, \quad -x + 2y = -3, \quad 3x - 6y = 10

Answer

Inconsistent (no solution). Dividing the first equation by 22 gives x−2y=3x - 2y = 3. Multiplying the second by −1-1 gives x−2y=3x - 2y = 3. Dividing the third by 33 gives x−2y=103x - 2y = \frac{10}{3}. Since 3≠1033 \neq \frac{10}{3}, the lines are parallel with no common intersection.

02

Determine whether the following overdetermined system has one solution, no solution, or infinitely many solutions: {x+2y=5,2x+4y=10,3x−y=1\lbrace x + 2y = 5, \quad 2x + 4y = 10, \quad 3x - y = 1

Answer

One solution. The first two equations are identical (x+2y=5x + 2y = 5). Solving the remaining non-parallel system {x+2y=5,3x−y=1\lbrace x + 2y = 5, \quad 3x - y = 1 yields x=1,y=2x = 1, y = 2. Because this point satisfies all three equations, the system is consistent with exactly one solution.

03

Find the value of the constant kk that makes the following system consistent, and state the number of solutions for that kk: {4x+6y=12,6x+9y=18,2x+3y=k\lbrace 4x + 6y = 12, \quad 6x + 9y = 18, \quad 2x + 3y = k

Answer

k=6k = 6; infinitely many solutions. Dividing the first equation by 22 gives 2x+3y=62x + 3y = 6. Dividing the second by 33 also gives 2x+3y=62x + 3y = 6. For the third equation 2x+3y=k2x + 3y = k to be consistent with the first two, kk must equal 66. When k=6k = 6, all three equations represent the same line, resulting in infinitely many solutions.

Loading workspace…