Resources

A student models predator-prey dynamics between snowshoe hares (HH) and Canada lynx (LL) using the classical Lotka-Volterra equations: dHdt=αH−βHL\frac{dH}{dt} = \alpha H - \beta H L and dLdt=δHL−γL\frac{dL}{dt} = \delta H L - \gamma L, with parameters α=0.50\alpha = 0.50, β=0.020\beta = 0.020, γ=0.40\gamma = 0.40, and δ=0.0050\delta = 0.0050. A wildlife manager proposes continuously harvesting hares at a fixed proportional rate h=0.10 year−1h = 0.10\text{ year}^{-1} by modifying the prey equation to dHdt=(α−h)H−βHL\frac{dH}{dt} = (\alpha - h)H - \beta H L, assuming this will primarily reduce the average hare population. (a) State two primary ecological assumptions of the unharvested Lotka-Volterra model. (b) Counter-intuitively, calculate the non-zero equilibrium population coordinates (H∗,L∗)(H^*, L^*) before and after implementing the hare harvest hh. (c) Explain the Volterra Principle limitation illustrated by this outcome.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Assumptions: Prey population growth is limited solely by predation (no prey carrying capacity); the predator is an obligate specialist consuming exclusively this prey; predation encounters occur purely at random (law of mass action); environmental conditions remain constant. (b) Pre-harvest equilibrium: H∗=γδ=0.400.0050=80.0 haresH^* = \frac{\gamma}{\delta} = \frac{0.40}{0.0050} = 80.0\text{ hares}, L∗=αβ=0.500.020=25.0 lynxL^* = \frac{\alpha}{\beta} = \frac{0.50}{0.020} = 25.0\text{ lynx}. Post-harvest equilibrium: Hnew∗=γδ=80.0 haresH^*_{\text{new}} = \frac{\gamma}{\delta} = 80.0\text{ hares}, Lnew∗=α−hβ=0.50−0.100.020=20.0 lynxL^*_{\text{new}} = \frac{\alpha - h}{\beta} = \frac{0.50 - 0.10}{0.020} = 20.0\text{ lynx}. (c) The Volterra Principle reveals that moderate indiscriminate harvesting of prey leaves the mean prey equilibrium population entirely unchanged while systematically reducing the predator equilibrium population, directly countering common intuition.

Steps

01

Pre-Harvest Equilibrium

Part (a): Ecological Assumptions of the Unharvested Lotka-Volterra Model

The classical Lotka-Volterra equations are based on several idealized simplifying assumptions:

  1. Unconstrained Prey Growth in the Absence of Predators: In the absence of lynx (L=0L = 0), the snowshoe hare population grows exponentially (dHdt=αH\frac{dH}{dt} = \alpha H). This assumes an infinite food supply, no intraspecific competition, and no environmental carrying capacity.
  2. Specialist Predator Diet: The lynx is an obligate specialist relying entirely on snowshoe hares as its food source. In the absence of hares (H=0H = 0), the lynx population decays exponentially at rate γ\gamma (dLdt=−γL\frac{dL}{dt} = -\gamma L).
  3. Mass-Action Predation: The rate of predation (βHL\beta H L) is directly proportional to the product of both populations, assuming individuals move completely at random in a homogeneous environment with no predator satiation (a linear Type I functional response).
  4. Constant Environment: Environmental conditions such as climate, terrain, and disease remain constant over time, fixing the interaction rates (α,β,γ,δ\alpha, \beta, \gamma, \delta). (Stating any two of these assumptions fully addresses the question).

Part (b): Calculating the Non-Zero Equilibrium Populations

An equilibrium (H∗,L∗)(H^*, L^*) occurs where the rates of change for both populations are simultaneously zero: dHdt=0anddLdt=0\frac{dH}{dt} = 0 \quad \text{and} \quad \frac{dL}{dt} = 0

Using the original system: dHdt=H(α−βL)=0\frac{dH}{dt} = H(\alpha - \beta L) = 0 dLdt=L(δH−γ)=0\frac{dL}{dt} = L(\delta H - \gamma) = 0

For a non-zero, coexisting equilibrium (H∗>0H^* > 0 and L∗>0L^* > 0):

  • From δH−γ=0\delta H - \gamma = 0: H∗=γδ=0.400.0050=80.0 haresH^* = \frac{\gamma}{\delta} = \frac{0.40}{0.0050} = 80.0\text{ hares}
  • From α−βL=0\alpha - \beta L = 0: L∗=αβ=0.500.020=25.0 lynxL^* = \frac{\alpha}{\beta} = \frac{0.50}{0.020} = 25.0\text{ lynx}

Thus, the pre-harvest equilibrium is (H∗,L∗)=(80.0,25.0)(H^*, L^*) = (80.0, 25.0).

02

Post-Harvest Equilibrium

With the proportional harvesting rate h=0.10 year−1h = 0.10\text{ year}^{-1} applied to hares, the prey rate equation becomes: dHdt=H((α−h)−βL)=0\frac{dH}{dt} = H\big((\alpha - h) - \beta L\big) = 0 while the predator equation remains unchanged: dLdt=L(δH−γ)=0\frac{dL}{dt} = L(\delta H - \gamma) = 0

Solving for non-zero coordinates:

  • From the predator equation: Hnew∗=γδ=0.400.0050=80.0 haresH^*_{\text{new}} = \frac{\gamma}{\delta} = \frac{0.40}{0.0050} = 80.0\text{ hares}
  • From the modified prey equation: Lnew∗=α−hβ=0.50−0.100.020=0.400.020=20.0 lynxL^*_{\text{new}} = \frac{\alpha - h}{\beta} = \frac{0.50 - 0.10}{0.020} = \frac{0.40}{0.020} = 20.0\text{ lynx}

Thus, the post-harvest equilibrium is (Hnew∗,Lnew∗)=(80.0,20.0)(H^*_{\text{new}}, L^*_{\text{new}}) = (80.0, 20.0).


Part (c): The Volterra Principle and Modeling Limitation

  • The Volterra Principle: In a coupled predator-prey system, a perturbation that symmetrically decreases the net reproduction rate of the prey (or an external factor that removes prey proportionally) shifts the internal balance such that the predator's equilibrium level drops, while the prey's equilibrium level remains unchanged. Because the equilibrium (H∗,L∗)(H^*, L^*) represents the time-average center of the cyclic orbits, continuous harvesting of the prey reduces the average predator population (25.0→20.025.0 \to 20.0) while leaving the average prey population unaffected (80.080.0).
  • Model Limitation & Pitfall: Intuition often suggests that removing prey will directly lower prey abundance. However, in this coupled linear model, prey numbers are strictly regulated by predator efficiency and mortality (γ/δ\gamma / \delta). Harvesting hares reduces the food surplus that sustains the lynx population, causing fewer lynx to survive until predation pressure relaxes enough to leave the prey at its original baseline. Relying on simple single-species intuition ignores this trophic feedback.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misassigns which equation determines which equilibrium coordinate, solving dH/dt = 0 for H* and dL/dt = 0 for L*.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Prey has unlimited resources and grows exponentially without predators. Predators rely solely on hares for food.

  2. Step 2

    dHdt=H(α−βL)=0  ⟹  H∗=αβ\frac{dH}{dt} = H(\alpha - \beta L) = 0 \implies H^* = \frac{\alpha}{\beta} and dLdt=L(δH−γ)=0  ⟹  L∗=δγ\frac{dL}{dt} = L(\delta H - \gamma) = 0 \implies L^* = \frac{\delta}{\gamma} ⟹\Longrightarrow Before harvest: (H∗,L∗)=(25,0.0125)(H^*, L^*) = (25, 0.0125); After harvest: (Hnew∗,Lnew∗)=(20,0.0125)(H^*_{\text{new}}, L^*_{\text{new}}) = (20, 0.0125)

    Correct

    For H∗>0H^* > 0 and L∗>0L^* > 0, α−βL=0  ⟹  L∗=αβ=25.0\alpha - \beta L = 0 \implies L^* = \frac{\alpha}{\beta} = 25.0 and δH−γ=0  ⟹  H∗=γδ=80.0\delta H - \gamma = 0 \implies H^* = \frac{\gamma}{\delta} = 80.0. After harvest: Lnew∗=α−hβ=0.400.020=20.0L^*_{\text{new}} = \frac{\alpha - h}{\beta} = \frac{0.40}{0.020} = 20.0 and Hnew∗=γδ=80.0H^*_{\text{new}} = \frac{\gamma}{\delta} = 80.0.

    You assumed that the prey differential equation dHdt=0\frac{dH}{dt} = 0 determines H∗H^* and the predator equation dLdt=0\frac{dL}{dt} = 0 determines L∗L^*. In a coupled system with non-zero populations, setting α−βL=0\alpha - \beta L = 0 fixes the predator abundance L∗=αβL^* = \frac{\alpha}{\beta}, while setting δH−γ=0\delta H - \gamma = 0 fixes the prey abundance H∗=γδH^* = \frac{\gamma}{\delta}.

  3. Step 3

    Harvesting directly decreases the prey equilibrium from 25 to 20 while leaving predators unchanged at 0.0125.

    Correct

    Moderate harvesting of prey leaves the equilibrium prey population unchanged (H∗=80.0H^* = 80.0) and strictly reduces the predator equilibrium population (L∗L^* drops from 25.025.0 to 20.020.0), showing that coupled trophic feedback counteracts intuitive single-species expectations.

    Your reasoning followed logically from your inverted equilibrium values from part (b), but because the coordinates were swapped, you reached the opposite of the Volterra Principle's core conclusion.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You clearly articulated valid biological assumptions regarding prey exponential growth and predator dietary specialization.

You correctly set the time derivatives to zero and factored out the non-zero population terms.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Variable-Nullcline Misassignment

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated each species' time derivative with that species' own equilibrium variable rather than looking at which variable actually appears inside the non-trivial nullcline factor.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Cross-Coupled Nullclines
  • In the Lotka-Volterra model, the prey growth rate is zero when the predator population balances prey birth (α−βL=0  ⟹  L∗=αβ\alpha - \beta L = 0 \implies L^* = \frac{\alpha}{\beta}), not prey.

  • Inspect the algebraic factor inside the parentheses; solve for the variable present in that specific factor.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set dLdt=L(δH−γ)=0\frac{dL}{dt} = L(\delta H - \gamma) = 0. For L∗>0L^* > 0, solve δH−γ=0\delta H - \gamma = 0 to get H∗=γδ=0.400.0050=80.0H^* = \frac{\gamma}{\delta} = \frac{0.40}{0.0050} = 80.0.

  2. Set dHdt=H(α−h−βL)=0\frac{dH}{dt} = H(\alpha - h - \beta L) = 0. For H∗>0H^* > 0, solve (α−h)−βL=0(\alpha - h) - \beta L = 0 to get Lnew∗=0.50−0.100.020=20.0L^*_{\text{new}} = \frac{0.50 - 0.10}{0.020} = 20.0.

  3. Compare equilibria: the prey equilibrium is unchanged at 80.080.0, while the predator equilibrium falls from 25.025.0 to 20.020.0.

Final answer

(a) Assumptions: exponential prey growth without predation; specialist predator diet. (b) Pre-harvest: (H∗,L∗)=(80.0,25.0)(H^*, L^*) = (80.0, 25.0); Post-harvest: (Hnew∗,Lnew∗)=(80.0,20.0)(H^*_{\text{new}}, L^*_{\text{new}}) = (80.0, 20.0). (c) The Volterra Principle demonstrates that harvesting prey selectively depresses predator equilibrium numbers while leaving prey equilibrium abundance completely unchanged.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice isolating non-trivial nullclines by explicitly writing out which variable is contained in each factor.

  • Verify your equilibrium results by checking units: γδ\frac{\gamma}{\delta} carries units of prey, while αβ\frac{\alpha}{\beta} carries units of predators.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student applies the harvest rate h as a reduction to the predator death parameter γ instead of the prey birth parameter α.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Prey population has unlimited food supply. ⟹\Longrightarrow Predator mortality rate is constant in the absence of prey.

  2. Step 2

    dHdt=0  ⟹  L∗=αβ\frac{dH}{dt} = 0 \implies L^* = \frac{\alpha}{\beta} and dLdt=0  ⟹  H∗=γδ  ⟹  H∗=0.400.0050=80,  L∗=0.500.020=25  ⟹  (H∗,L∗)=(80,25)\frac{dL}{dt} = 0 \implies H^* = \frac{\gamma}{\delta} \implies H^* = \frac{0.40}{0.0050} = 80,\; L^* = \frac{0.50}{0.020} = 25 \implies (H^*, L^*) = (80, 25)

  3. Step 3

    modify predator rate to γ−h=0.30  ⟹  H∗=0.300.0050=60,  L∗=0.500.020=25  ⟹  (H∗,L∗)=(60,25)\gamma - h = 0.30 \implies H^* = \frac{0.30}{0.0050} = 60,\; L^* = \frac{0.50}{0.020} = 25 \implies (H^*, L^*) = (60, 25)

    Correct

    dHdt=H((α−h)−βL)=0  ⟹  Lnew∗=α−hβ=0.50−0.100.020=20.0\frac{dH}{dt} = H((\alpha - h) - \beta L) = 0 \implies L^*_{\text{new}} = \frac{\alpha - h}{\beta} = \frac{0.50 - 0.10}{0.020} = 20.0, and dLdt=L(δH−γ)=0  ⟹  Hnew∗=γδ=80.0  ⟹  (Hnew∗,Lnew∗)=(80.0,20.0)\frac{dL}{dt} = L(\delta H - \gamma) = 0 \implies H^*_{\text{new}} = \frac{\gamma}{\delta} = 80.0 \implies (H^*_{\text{new}}, L^*_{\text{new}}) = (80.0, 20.0)

    You subtracted the hare harvesting rate hh from the lynx mortality parameter γ\gamma instead of modifying the hare growth rate α\alpha. Since hares are the prey, harvesting hares alters the prey equation to (α−h)H−βHL=0(\alpha - h)H - \beta HL = 0, which determines L∗L^*, while the predator equation remains unchanged and keeps H∗=γδ=80H^* = \frac{\gamma}{\delta} = 80.

  4. Step 4

    Harvesting hares causes the equilibrium hare population to decrease from 80 to 60 while lynx remain constant at 25.

    Correct

    The Volterra Principle states that continuously harvesting the prey species reduces the equilibrium predator population (L∗:25.0→20.0L^*: 25.0 \to 20.0) while leaving the equilibrium prey population unchanged (H∗=80.0H^* = 80.0).

    Because of the parameter misplacement in the previous step, your conclusion reflected your calculated values instead of the true Volterra Principle.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You stated two valid ecological assumptions underlying the classical Lotka-Volterra model.

You correctly derived the algebraic expressions for the nullclines and equilibrium coordinates.

You calculated the pre-harvest equilibrium (H∗,L∗)=(80,25)(H^*, L^*) = (80, 25) with complete numerical accuracy.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Parameter Association Misplacement

You knew to subtract the harvest rate h=0.10h = 0.10, but you subtracted it from the predator death rate γ\gamma rather than the prey birth rate α\alpha.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In Lotka-Volterra systems, an equilibrium coordinate for one species is determined by the parameters of the other species' rate equation (the prey nullcline dHdt=0\frac{dH}{dt} = 0 determines L∗=αβL^* = \frac{\alpha}{\beta}, and the predator nullcline dLdt=0\frac{dL}{dt} = 0 determines H∗=γδH^* = \frac{\gamma}{\delta}). Conflating which biological parameter belongs to which differential equation led to modifying γ\gamma instead of α\alpha.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match Perturbations to the Correct Equation
  • Harvesting or treating a specific species always modifies the differential equation for that species: hare harvesting alters dHdt\frac{dH}{dt}, not dLdt\frac{dL}{dt}.

  • Write out the full modified equation explicitly: dHdt=(α−h)H−βHL\frac{dH}{dt} = (\alpha - h)H - \beta H L before solving for nullclines.

Cross-Coupled Equilibrium Coordinates
  • In standard Lotka-Volterra equations, setting dHdt=0\frac{dH}{dt} = 0 yields the predator equilibrium L∗=net prey growthβL^* = \frac{\text{net prey growth}}{\beta}, whereas setting dLdt=0\frac{dL}{dt} = 0 yields the prey equilibrium H∗=γδH^* = \frac{\gamma}{\delta}.

  • Always verify which equation provided which coordinate: changing a prey parameter shifts the predator equilibrium level, not the prey equilibrium level.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the modified prey equation to zero: dHdt=H((α−h)−βL)=0\frac{dH}{dt} = H((\alpha - h) - \beta L) = 0. For H>0H > 0, (α−h)−βL=0  ⟹  Lnew∗=α−hβ(\alpha - h) - \beta L = 0 \implies L^*_{\text{new}} = \frac{\alpha - h}{\beta}.

  2. Substitute the given parameters: Lnew∗=0.50−0.100.020=0.400.020=20.0 lynxL^*_{\text{new}} = \frac{0.50 - 0.10}{0.020} = \frac{0.40}{0.020} = 20.0\text{ lynx}.

  3. Set the unchanged predator equation to zero: dLdt=L(δH−γ)=0  ⟹  Hnew∗=γδ=0.400.0050=80.0 hares\frac{dL}{dt} = L(\delta H - \gamma) = 0 \implies H^*_{\text{new}} = \frac{\gamma}{\delta} = \frac{0.40}{0.0050} = 80.0\text{ hares}.

  4. State the conclusion: Harvesting hares leaves the equilibrium hare population unchanged at 80.080.0 while reducing the lynx population from 25.025.0 to 20.020.0, illustrating the counter-intuitive Volterra Principle.

Final answer

(Hnew∗,Lnew∗)=(80.0,20.0)(H^*_{\text{new}}, L^*_{\text{new}}) = (80.0, 20.0), demonstrating that harvesting prey exclusively reduces the predator equilibrium while leaving the prey equilibrium unchanged.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice deriving nullclines directly from modified equations rather than memorizing equilibrium formulas.

  • Review the Volterra Principle to understand why trophic feedback shifts equilibrium abundance onto the predator when prey growth is altered.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A predator-prey system follows dNdt=N(0.6−0.03P)\frac{dN}{dt} = N(0.6 - 0.03P) and dPdt=P(0.01N−0.2)\frac{dP}{dt} = P(0.01N - 0.2). Find the non-zero equilibrium point (N∗,P∗)(N^*, P^*).

Answer

(N∗,P∗)=(20,20)(N^*, P^*) = (20, 20). From dPdt=0\frac{dP}{dt} = 0, 0.01N−0.2=0  ⟹  N∗=200.01N - 0.2 = 0 \implies N^* = 20. From dNdt=0\frac{dN}{dt} = 0, 0.6−0.03P=0  ⟹  P∗=200.6 - 0.03P = 0 \implies P^* = 20.

02

In the system dHdt=H(r−aP)\frac{dH}{dt} = H(r - aP) and dPdt=P(bH−m)\frac{dP}{dt} = P(bH - m), suppose a disease increases the predator death rate mm by 25%25\%. Describe the quantitative effect on both equilibrium populations H∗H^* and P∗P^*.

Answer

H∗H^* increases by 25%25\% and P∗P^* remains unchanged. Since H∗=mbH^* = \frac{m}{b}, an increase in mm directly raises the prey equilibrium to 1.25mb\frac{1.25m}{b}. Since P∗=raP^* = \frac{r}{a} depends only on prey parameters, the predator equilibrium is unaffected.

03

Consider a harvested predator-prey model where both species are harvested proportionally at rate EE: dHdt=H(α−E−βL)\frac{dH}{dt} = H(\alpha - E - \beta L) and dLdt=L(δH−(γ+E))\frac{dL}{dt} = L(\delta H - (\gamma + E)). Show which species equilibrium increases and which decreases under harvesting.

Answer

Prey equilibrium increases; predator equilibrium decreases. The new equilibria are H∗=γ+Eδ>γδH^* = \frac{\gamma + E}{\delta} > \frac{\gamma}{\delta} (increased prey) and L∗=α−Eβ<αβL^* = \frac{\alpha - E}{\beta} < \frac{\alpha}{\beta} (decreased predator), which is the classic Volterra Principle under general harvesting.

Loading workspace…