Resources

A chemistry student prepares 500 mL500\text{ mL} of a 0.28 M0.28\text{ M} hydrochloric acid (HCl\text{HCl}) solution by combining a stock solution of known concentration C1=0.50 MC_1 = 0.50\text{ M} with a more dilute stock solution of unknown concentration C2C_2. The student used exactly 300 mL300\text{ mL} of the 0.50 M0.50\text{ M} solution and 200 mL200\text{ mL} of the dilute solution. Write the system of linear equations modeling the total solution volume and total molar amount of solute, and solve backwards for the unknown initial stock concentration C2C_2 in mol/L\text{mol/L}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Let V1V_1 and V2V_2 denote the volumes in liters of the two solutions, and let C2C_2 denote the unknown molarity of the second solution. The system of equations is: {V1+V2=0.5000.50V1+C2V2=0.28(0.500)\begin{cases} V_1 + V_2 = 0.500 \\ 0.50V_1 + C_2 V_2 = 0.28(0.500) \end{cases}. Substituting V1=0.300 LV_1 = 0.300\text{ L} and V2=0.200 LV_2 = 0.200\text{ L} yields 0.150+0.200C2=0.1400.150 + 0.200C_2 = 0.140, which gives C2=−0.05 MC_2 = -0.05\text{ M} (physically unfeasible for these parameters; mathematically, setting the target concentration to 0.38 M0.38\text{ M} gives {V1+V2=0.5000.50V1+C2V2=0.38(0.500)\begin{cases} V_1 + V_2 = 0.500 \\ 0.50V_1 + C_2 V_2 = 0.38(0.500) \end{cases}, yielding 0.150+0.200C2=0.1900.150 + 0.200C_2 = 0.190, so C2=0.20 MC_2 = 0.20\text{ M}). Thus, with target molarity 0.38 M0.38\text{ M}, C2=0.20 MC_2 = 0.20\text{ M}.

Steps

01

Identify the variables and units

Convert all volumes from milliliters (mL\text{mL}) to liters (L\text{L}):

  • Volume of solution 1: V1=300 mL=0.300 LV_1 = 300\text{ mL} = 0.300\text{ L}
  • Volume of solution 2: V2=200 mL=0.200 LV_2 = 200\text{ mL} = 0.200\text{ L}
  • Total volume: Vtotal=500 mL=0.500 LV_{\text{total}} = 500\text{ mL} = 0.500\text{ L}

Let:

  • C1=0.50 MC_1 = 0.50\text{ M} be the molarity of solution 1.
  • C2C_2 be the unknown molarity of solution 2 in mol/L\text{mol/L}.
  • CfinalC_{\text{final}} be the molarity of the final mixed solution.

02

Formulate the system of equations

A mixture problem of this type relies on two conservation principles:

  1. Conservation of total volume: V1+V2=0.500V_1 + V_2 = 0.500
  2. Conservation of solute (moles of HCl\ce{HCl}): Moles from Solution 1+Moles from Solution 2=Total Moles\text{Moles from Solution 1} + \text{Moles from Solution 2} = \text{Total Moles} C1V1+C2V2=CfinalVtotalC_1 V_1 + C_2 V_2 = C_{\text{final}} V_{\text{total}} 0.50V1+C2V2=0.28(0.500)0.50 V_1 + C_2 V_2 = 0.28(0.500)

Expressed as a system: {V1+V2=0.500,0.50V1+C2V2=0.28(0.500)\lbrace V_1 + V_2 = 0.500,\quad 0.50 V_1 + C_2 V_2 = 0.28(0.500)


03

Solve for the unknown concentration C2C_2

Substitute the known volumes V1=0.300 LV_1 = 0.300\text{ L} and V2=0.200 LV_2 = 0.200\text{ L} into the solute equation: 0.50(0.300)+C2(0.200)=0.28(0.500)0.50(0.300) + C_2(0.200) = 0.28(0.500) 0.150+0.200C2=0.1400.150 + 0.200 C_2 = 0.140

Subtract 0.1500.150 from both sides: 0.200C2=0.140−0.1500.200 C_2 = 0.140 - 0.150 0.200C2=−0.0100.200 C_2 = -0.010 C2=−0.0100.200=−0.05 MC_2 = \frac{-0.010}{0.200} = -0.05\text{ M}

Physical Pitfall & Correction: A negative concentration is physically impossible because the initial 300 mL300\text{ mL} of 0.50 M0.50\text{ M} solution alone provides 0.150 mol0.150\text{ mol} of HCl\ce{HCl}, which already exceeds the 0.140 mol0.140\text{ mol} expected in a 0.28 M0.28\text{ M} mixture.

Correcting the target concentration to 0.38 M0.38\text{ M} resolves this inconsistency: {V1+V2=0.500,0.50V1+C2V2=0.38(0.500)\lbrace V_1 + V_2 = 0.500,\quad 0.50 V_1 + C_2 V_2 = 0.38(0.500)

Evaluating with Cfinal=0.38 MC_{\text{final}} = 0.38\text{ M}: 0.50(0.300)+C2(0.200)=0.38(0.500)0.50(0.300) + C_2(0.200) = 0.38(0.500) 0.150+0.200C2=0.1900.150 + 0.200 C_2 = 0.190 0.200C2=0.0400.200 C_2 = 0.040 C2=0.0400.200=0.20 MC_2 = \frac{0.040}{0.200} = 0.20\text{ M}

Thus, with the corrected target concentration of 0.38 M0.38\text{ M}, the unknown initial stock concentration is C2=0.20 MC_2 = 0.20\text{ M}.

Educational illustration for this question

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student swaps the volumes used for each solution, assigning 200 mL to the 0.50 M stock solution and 300 mL to the unknown dilute solution.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    V1+V2=0.500 LV_1 + V_2 = 0.500\text{ L} and 0.50V1+C2V2=0.28(0.500)0.50V_1 + C_2V_2 = 0.28(0.500)

  2. Step 2

    Substitute V1=0.200 LV_1 = 0.200\text{ L} and V2=0.300 LV_2 = 0.300\text{ L}: 0.50(0.200)+C2(0.300)=0.1400.50(0.200) + C_2(0.300) = 0.140

    Correct

    Substitute V1=0.300 LV_1 = 0.300\text{ L} and V2=0.200 LV_2 = 0.200\text{ L}: 0.50(0.300)+C2(0.200)=0.1400.50(0.300) + C_2(0.200) = 0.140

    You reversed the volumes of the two solutions. The problem states that 300 mL300\text{ mL} (0.300 L0.300\text{ L}) of the 0.50 M0.50\text{ M} stock solution was used, meaning V1=0.300 LV_1 = 0.300\text{ L}, and 200 mL200\text{ mL} (0.200 L0.200\text{ L}) of the dilute solution was used, meaning V2=0.200 LV_2 = 0.200\text{ L}.

  3. Step 3

    0.100+0.300C2=0.140  ⟹  0.300C2=0.040  ⟹  C2=0.040/0.300=0.133 M0.100 + 0.300C_2 = 0.140 \implies 0.300C_2 = 0.040 \implies C_2 = 0.040/0.300 = 0.133\text{ M}

    Correct

    0.150+0.200C2=0.140  ⟹  0.200C2=−0.010  ⟹  C2=−0.05 M0.150 + 0.200C_2 = 0.140 \implies 0.200C_2 = -0.010 \implies C_2 = -0.05\text{ M}

    Your algebraic solving steps were mechanically correct for your equation, but the numerical result was affected by the swapped volume values.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You translated the problem context into an accurate system of linear equations.

You converted all given volume values from milliliters to liters consistently.

You correctly manipulated the linear equation to isolate the unknown variable C2C_2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Variable-value mismatch

You accidentally swapped the volume assigned to the 0.50 M0.50\text{ M} solution (V1V_1) with the volume assigned to the unknown dilute solution (V2V_2).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You matched numerical quantities to variable names without explicitly linking each variable definition to its specific solute component.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Label with descriptive subscripts
  • Always annotate each volume variable with its corresponding concentration or label before plugging numbers into an equation.

  • Write V0.50=0.300 LV_{0.50} = 0.300\text{ L} and Vdilute=0.200 LV_{\text{dilute}} = 0.200\text{ L} so the quantities cannot be inadvertently transposed.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. 0.50(0.300)+C2(0.200)=0.28(0.500)0.50(0.300) + C_2(0.200) = 0.28(0.500)

  2. 0.150+0.200C2=0.1400.150 + 0.200C_2 = 0.140

  3. 0.200C2=0.140−0.150=−0.0100.200C_2 = 0.140 - 0.150 = -0.010

  4. C2=−0.0100.200=−0.05 MC_2 = \frac{-0.010}{0.200} = -0.05\text{ M} (Note: If the target concentration is corrected to 0.38 M0.38\text{ M} to yield a physically realistic non-negative concentration, 0.150+0.200C2=0.190  ⟹  C2=0.20 M0.150 + 0.200C_2 = 0.190 \implies C_2 = 0.20\text{ M}).

Final answer

C2=−0.05 MC_2 = -0.05\text{ M} (or 0.20 M0.20\text{ M} with corrected target concentration 0.38 M0.38\text{ M})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out explicit variable definitions such as V1=volume of 0.50 M solutionV_1 = \text{volume of } 0.50\text{ M solution} before substituting.

  • Double-check that coefficients and volume values match their respective chemical solution before performing arithmetic.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly assumes concentrations are additive and solves C1 + C2 = C_final without accounting for solution volumes.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Volume equation: V1+V2=500\text{Volume equation: } V_1 + V_2 = 500

  2. Step 2

    Concentration equation: C1+C2=Cfinal  ⟹  0.50+C2=0.28\text{Concentration equation: } C_1 + C_2 = C_{\text{final}} \implies 0.50 + C_2 = 0.28

    Correct

    C1V1+C2V2=CfinalVtotal  ⟹  0.50(0.300)+C2(0.200)=0.28(0.500)C_1 V_1 + C_2 V_2 = C_{\text{final}} V_{\text{total}} \implies 0.50(0.300) + C_2(0.200) = 0.28(0.500)

    Molar concentration is an intensive property and cannot be added directly. You need an equation that conserves the total moles of solute, which is calculated as concentration×volume\text{concentration} \times \text{volume}.

  3. Step 3

    C2=0.28−0.50=−0.22 MC_2 = 0.28 - 0.50 = -0.22\text{ M}

    Correct

    0.150+0.200C2=0.140  ⟹  C2=−0.05 M0.150 + 0.200 C_2 = 0.140 \implies C_2 = -0.05\text{ M} (or C2=0.20 MC_2 = 0.20\text{ M} if the target concentration is corrected to 0.38 M0.38\text{ M})

    Your algebra followed from your additive concentration equation, but the underlying equation was incorrect.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up the linear relation for total solution volume.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Additive Intensive Property Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that mixing two solutions means their concentrations add together directly (C1+C2=CfinalC_1 + C_2 = C_{\text{final}}), confusing concentration (an intensive property) with the extensive quantity of solute (moles = C×VC \times V).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Conservation of Solute
  • In a solution mixture, total solute is conserved: n1+n2=ntotaln_1 + n_2 = n_{\text{total}}, which means C1V1+C2V2=CfinalVtotalC_1 V_1 + C_2 V_2 = C_{\text{final}} V_{\text{total}}.

  • Always multiply each concentration by its corresponding volume before adding.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert volumes to liters: V1=0.300 LV_1 = 0.300\text{ L}, V2=0.200 LV_2 = 0.200\text{ L}, Vtotal=0.500 LV_{\text{total}} = 0.500\text{ L}.

  2. Write the solute conservation equation: 0.50(0.300)+C2(0.200)=0.28(0.500)0.50(0.300) + C_2(0.200) = 0.28(0.500).

  3. Simplify the products: 0.150+0.200C2=0.1400.150 + 0.200 C_2 = 0.140.

  4. Isolate C2C_2: 0.200C2=0.140−0.150=−0.0100.200 C_2 = 0.140 - 0.150 = -0.010, giving C2=−0.05 MC_2 = -0.05\text{ M} (or C2=0.20 MC_2 = 0.20\text{ M} with corrected target 0.38 M0.38\text{ M}).

Final answer

C2=−0.05 MC_2 = -0.05\text{ M} (or 0.20 M0.20\text{ M} with target 0.38 M0.38\text{ M})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the difference between intensive properties (like concentration and temperature) and extensive properties (like moles, mass, and volume).

  • When setting up mixture word problems, always write one equation for the total bulk amount (volume or mass) and a second equation for the weighted amount of pure component or solute.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student mixes units by keeping volumes in milliliters on the left-hand side of the solute equation while converting to liters on the right-hand side.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    V1+V2=500 mLV_1 + V_2 = 500\text{ mL}

  2. Step 2

    0.50(300)+C2(200)=0.28(0.500)  ⟹  150+200C2=0.1400.50(300) + C_2(200) = 0.28(0.500) \implies 150 + 200 C_2 = 0.140

    Correct

    0.50(0.300)+C2(0.200)=0.28(0.500)  ⟹  0.150+0.200C2=0.1400.50(0.300) + C_2(0.200) = 0.28(0.500) \implies 0.150 + 0.200 C_2 = 0.140

    You substituted volumes in milliliters (300 mL300\text{ mL} and 200 mL200\text{ mL}) on the left-hand side, which yields millimoles of solute, but you converted the volume to liters (0.500 L0.500\text{ L}) on the right-hand side, which yields moles of solute. Both sides must use the same volume units.

  3. Step 3

    200C2=0.140−150  ⟹  200C2=−149.86  ⟹  C2=−149.86/200=−0.7493 M200 C_2 = 0.140 - 150 \implies 200 C_2 = -149.86 \implies C_2 = -149.86 / 200 = -0.7493\text{ M}

    Correct

    0.200C2=0.140−0.150  ⟹  0.200C2=−0.010  ⟹  C2=−0.05 M0.200 C_2 = 0.140 - 0.150 \implies 0.200 C_2 = -0.010 \implies C_2 = -0.05\text{ M}

    Your algebraic rearrangement and division were executed correctly, but the result is distorted by the unit mismatch in Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly wrote the linear relationship representing the total volume of the mixture.

You accurately identified the structure of the solute equation C1V1+C2V2=CfinalVtotalC_1 V_1 + C_2 V_2 = C_{\text{final}} V_{\text{total}}.

You correctly carried out the algebraic steps to isolate the variable C2C_2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inconsistent Units in Solute Equation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You did not enforce consistent volume units across both sides of the solute conservation equation, mixing milliliters (yielding millimoles) on the left side with liters (yielding moles) on the right side.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimensional and Unit Consistency
  • Before multiplying molarity (mol/L\text{mol/L}) by volume, ensure all volume terms share the same unit: either all in liters (L\text{L}) to give moles (mol\text{mol}), or all in milliliters (mL\text{mL}) to give millimoles (mmol\text{mmol}).

  • Convert all given volumes to liters (300 mL=0.300 L300\text{ mL} = 0.300\text{ L}, 200 mL=0.200 L200\text{ mL} = 0.200\text{ L}, 500 mL=0.500 L500\text{ mL} = 0.500\text{ L}) before substituting them into the mixture formula.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert all volumes consistently to liters: V1=0.300 LV_1 = 0.300\text{ L}, V2=0.200 LV_2 = 0.200\text{ L}, Vtotal=0.500 LV_{\text{total}} = 0.500\text{ L}.

  2. Set up the solute equation using liters: 0.50(0.300)+C2(0.200)=0.28(0.500)0.50(0.300) + C_2(0.200) = 0.28(0.500).

  3. Simplify the products: 0.150+0.200C2=0.1400.150 + 0.200 C_2 = 0.140.

  4. Subtract 0.1500.150 from both sides: 0.200C2=−0.0100.200 C_2 = -0.010.

  5. Divide by 0.2000.200: C2=−0.0100.200=−0.05 MC_2 = \frac{-0.010}{0.200} = -0.05\text{ M}.

Final answer

C2=−0.05 MC_2 = -0.05\text{ M} (or C2=0.20 MC_2 = 0.20\text{ M} if using the physically feasible target of 0.38 M0.38\text{ M})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write explicit units next to your numbers in the first setup step to verify dimensional consistency.

  • Check that the left-hand side and right-hand side have the exact same unit dimension before simplifying.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A student mixes 400 mL400\text{ mL} of a 1.50 M1.50\text{ M} sodium hydroxide solution with 100 mL100\text{ mL} of an unknown sodium hydroxide solution to produce 500 mL500\text{ mL} of a 1.30 M1.30\text{ M} solution. Write the solute conservation equation and solve for the unknown concentration C2C_2.

Answer

Equation: 1.50(0.400)+C2(0.100)=1.30(0.500)1.50(0.400) + C_2(0.100) = 1.30(0.500). Simplifying: 0.600+0.100C2=0.650  ⟹  0.100C2=0.050  ⟹  C2=0.50 M0.600 + 0.100C_2 = 0.650 \implies 0.100C_2 = 0.050 \implies C_2 = 0.50\text{ M}.

02

A lab technician combines V1 LV_1\text{ L} of a 0.80 M0.80\text{ M} saline solution and V2 LV_2\text{ L} of a 0.20 M0.20\text{ M} saline solution to obtain 2.0 L2.0\text{ L} of a 0.35 M0.35\text{ M} solution. Set up the system of linear equations for volume and solute, and solve for both V1V_1 and V2V_2.

Answer

System: {V1+V2=2.00.80V1+0.20V2=0.35(2.0)=0.70\begin{cases} V_1 + V_2 = 2.0 \\ 0.80V_1 + 0.20V_2 = 0.35(2.0) = 0.70 \end{cases}. From equation 1, V2=2.0−V1V_2 = 2.0 - V_1. Substituting: 0.80V1+0.20(2.0−V1)=0.70  ⟹  0.60V1+0.40=0.70  ⟹  0.60V1=0.30  ⟹  V1=0.50 L0.80V_1 + 0.20(2.0 - V_1) = 0.70 \implies 0.60V_1 + 0.40 = 0.70 \implies 0.60V_1 = 0.30 \implies V_1 = 0.50\text{ L} and V2=1.50 LV_2 = 1.50\text{ L}.

03

An environmental engineer mixes two contaminated wastewater streams. Stream A has a toxin concentration of 45 mg/L45\text{ mg/L} and Stream B has 15 mg/L15\text{ mg/L}. The combined discharge must be 1200 L1200\text{ L} at an average concentration of 25 mg/L25\text{ mg/L}. Determine the volume required from each stream and write the modeling system of equations.

Answer

System: {VA+VB=120045VA+15VB=25(1200)=30000\begin{cases} V_A + V_B = 1200 \\ 45V_A + 15V_B = 25(1200) = 30000 \end{cases}. Substituting VB=1200−VAV_B = 1200 - V_A: 45VA+15(1200−VA)=30000  ⟹  30VA+18000=30000  ⟹  30VA=12000  ⟹  VA=400 L45V_A + 15(1200 - V_A) = 30000 \implies 30V_A + 18000 = 30000 \implies 30V_A = 12000 \implies V_A = 400\text{ L}, so VB=800 LV_B = 800\text{ L}.

Loading workspace…