Resources
Consider the perturbed linear system , where and are real parameters. Analyze the number of solutions to the system when as a function of , and determine the limiting behavior of the unique solution as when .
Answer and steps
Final answer
When : infinitely many solutions if , and no solution if . For and , the unique solution is , which is constant and thus has the limit as .
Steps
To analyze the perturbed linear system, we write the two equations:
Part 1: Number of Solutions when
Substitute into Equation (2):
Multiplying Equation (1) by gives:
Subtracting this from Equation (2) eliminates both variables on the left-hand side:
- Case 1 (): The equation simplifies to , which is always true. Both equations represent the same line, resulting in infinitely many solutions.
- Case 2 (): The equation states , which is a contradiction. The two lines are parallel and distinct, resulting in no solution.
Part 2: Limiting Behavior when as
Now consider and . Subtract from Equation (2):
Since , we can divide both sides by :
Substitute back into Equation (1) to find :
For any , the unique solution to the system is constant:
Because the coordinates do not vary with , the limit as is:
(Note: Although the unperturbed system with has infinitely many solutions along the line , tying the perturbations together by selects the specific single point lying on that line, since .)
Typical errors
01 The student forgets to multiply the right-hand side of the first equation when eliminating variables, resulting in an incorrect consistency condition on δ.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
0 = (10 + ) - 5 = 5 +
Correct(10 + ) - 2(5) = = 0
When subtracting times the first equation from the second equation, the right-hand side must be . You subtracted instead of .
- Step 2
If 5 + = 0, or = -5, there are infinitely many solutions. If -5, there is no solution.
CorrectIf = 0, there are infinitely many solutions; if 0, there is no solution.
Your classification logic was mathematically sound, but because of the arithmetic slip in Step 1, your condition evaluated to rather than .
- Step 3
y = 10 + 3 - 10 = 3 y() = 3 x() = 5 - 2(3) = -1 $\lim_{ 0}$ (x(\epsilon), y(\epsilon)) = (-1, 3)_
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly substituted into the original system.
You correctly recognized that a consistent identity yields infinitely many solutions while a contradiction yields no solution.
You executed the elimination, substitution, and limiting process in Part 2 completely and accurately.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeWhen computing in Part 1, you multiplied the left-hand side of by but subtracted the unmultiplied right-hand side constant .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisIncomplete scaling during mental linear combinations: the multiplier factor was applied to the variable terms on the left side but missed on the constant term on the right side.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Scale the Entire Equation
Multiplying an equation by a scalar requires scaling every single term: .
Always write down the fully scaled auxiliary equation before subtracting it from the other equation.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite .
Subtract from Equation (2): .
If , the equation reduces to , giving infinitely many solutions.
If , the equation states , giving no solution.
When : infinitely many solutions if , and no solution if 0. As with , .
02 The student assumes that because ε → 0 makes the coefficient matrix singular, the solution must blow up to infinity instead of solving for the unique solution prior to taking the limit.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
When , the system is and Subtracting gives Infinitely many solutions if , no solution if .
- Step 2
The determinant of the system matrix is . As , , so the matrix becomes non-invertible.
- Step 3
Since the determinant in the denominator approaches , the coordinates blow up. The limit does not exist.
CorrectFor and , elimination gives , and substituting into the first equation gives . Because the unique solution is constant at for every , the limit is .
A vanishing determinant means the denominator approaches zero in Cramer's rule, but the numerator can also approach zero. Here, the numerator is , creating an indeterminate form that remains completely finite.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly analyzed the system when , identifying infinitely many solutions when and no solution when .
You correctly calculated the determinant of the coefficient matrix as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeAssuming that a denominator tending to zero guarantees that the solution coordinates diverge to infinity.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated as sufficient proof of divergence. In perturbed linear systems where the right-hand vector is also perturbed, Cramer's numerators often vanish at the exact same rate as the determinant, resulting in a finite limit.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Solve Algebraically Before Taking Limits
Never evaluate the limit of individual matrix components in isolation; solve for explicitly before taking .
Use row elimination or Cramer's rule with preserved as an algebraic variable, simplify common factors of , and only then take the limit.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSubtract from , which gives , simplifying to .
Because , divide both sides by to find .
Substitute into to obtain .
Observe that is constant for all .
Lock it in
When performing elimination by subtracting times Equation 1 from Equation 2, how must the constant term of Equation 1 be handled?
The constant term of Equation 1 must also be multiplied by : .
Similar question
Determine the values of for which the system has infinitely many solutions, no solution, or a unique solution.
Answer
Infinitely many solutions if ; no solution if ; never has a unique solution. Key steps: Multiply the first equation by to obtain . Subtracting gives . Thus gives (infinitely many), and gives a contradiction (no solution).
Consider the system . Find the unique solution when , and find .
Answer
for all , and the limit is . Key steps: Subtract from the second equation: . For , . Then . The limit as is .
Consider the system . Find the condition on for the system to be consistent when . Then, if for a constant , determine the value of such that the limiting solution as lies on the line .
Answer
Consistent when if and only if . The required constant is . Key steps: For , subtract : , so consistency requires . For and , subtracting gives . To lie on , we must have .