Resources

Consider the perturbed linear system {x+2y=52x+(4+ϵ)y=10+δ\begin{cases} x + 2y = 5 \\ 2x + (4 + \epsilon)y = 10 + \delta \end{cases}, where ϵ\epsilon and δ\delta are real parameters. Analyze the number of solutions to the system when ϵ=0\epsilon = 0 as a function of δ\delta, and determine the limiting behavior of the unique solution (x(ϵ),y(ϵ))(x(\epsilon), y(\epsilon)) as ϵ→0\epsilon \to 0 when δ=3ϵ\delta = 3\epsilon.

Answer and steps

Final answer

When ϵ=0\epsilon = 0: infinitely many solutions if δ=0\delta = 0, and no solution if δ≠0\delta \neq 0. For ϵ≠0\epsilon \neq 0 and δ=3ϵ\delta = 3\epsilon, the unique solution is (x,y)=(−1,3)(x, y) = (-1, 3), which is constant and thus has the limit (−1,3)(-1, 3) as ϵ→0\epsilon \to 0.

Steps

To analyze the perturbed linear system, we write the two equations: Equation (1): x+2y=5\text{Equation (1): } x + 2y = 5 Equation (2): 2x+(4+ϵ)y=10+δ\text{Equation (2): } 2x + (4 + \epsilon)y = 10 + \delta

Part 1: Number of Solutions when ϵ=0\epsilon = 0

Substitute ϵ=0\epsilon = 0 into Equation (2): 2x+4y=10+δ2x + 4y = 10 + \delta

Multiplying Equation (1) by 22 gives: 2(x+2y)=2(5)  ⟹  2x+4y=102(x + 2y) = 2(5) \implies 2x + 4y = 10

Subtracting this from Equation (2) eliminates both variables on the left-hand side: (2x+4y)−(2x+4y)=(10+δ)−10(2x + 4y) - (2x + 4y) = (10 + \delta) - 10 0=δ0 = \delta

  • Case 1 (δ=0\delta = 0): The equation simplifies to 0=00 = 0, which is always true. Both equations represent the same line, resulting in infinitely many solutions.
  • Case 2 (δ≠0\delta \neq 0): The equation states 0=δ≠00 = \delta \neq 0, which is a contradiction. The two lines are parallel and distinct, resulting in no solution.

Part 2: Limiting Behavior when δ=3ϵ\delta = 3\epsilon as ϵ→0\epsilon \to 0

Now consider ϵ≠0\epsilon \neq 0 and δ=3ϵ\delta = 3\epsilon. Subtract 2×Equation (1)2 \times \text{Equation (1)} from Equation (2): [2x+(4+ϵ)y]−2(x+2y)=(10+3ϵ)−2(5)[2x + (4 + \epsilon)y] - 2(x + 2y) = (10 + 3\epsilon) - 2(5) ϵy=3ϵ\epsilon y = 3\epsilon

Since ϵ≠0\epsilon \neq 0, we can divide both sides by ϵ\epsilon: y=3y = 3

Substitute y=3y = 3 back into Equation (1) to find xx: x+2(3)=5x + 2(3) = 5 x+6=5  ⟹  x=−1x + 6 = 5 \implies x = -1

For any ϵ≠0\epsilon \neq 0, the unique solution to the system is constant: (x(ϵ),y(ϵ))=(−1,3)(x(\epsilon), y(\epsilon)) = (-1, 3)

Because the coordinates do not vary with ϵ\epsilon, the limit as ϵ→0\epsilon \to 0 is: lim⁡ϵ→0(x(ϵ),y(ϵ))=(−1,3)\lim_{\epsilon \to 0} (x(\epsilon), y(\epsilon)) = (-1, 3)

(Note: Although the unperturbed system with δ=0\delta = 0 has infinitely many solutions along the line x+2y=5x + 2y = 5, tying the perturbations together by δ=3ϵ\delta = 3\epsilon selects the specific single point (−1,3)(-1, 3) lying on that line, since (−1)+2(3)=5(-1) + 2(3) = 5.)

Educational illustration for this question

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to multiply the right-hand side of the first equation when eliminating variables, resulting in an incorrect consistency condition on δ.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    0 = (10 + δ\delta) - 5 = 5 + δ\delta

    Correct

    (10 + δ\delta) - 2(5) = δ\delta = 0

    When subtracting 22 times the first equation from the second equation, the right-hand side must be (10+δ)−2(5)=δ(10 + \delta) - 2(5) = \delta. You subtracted 55 instead of 2×5=102 \times 5 = 10.

  2. Step 2

    If 5 + δ\delta = 0, or δ\delta = -5, there are infinitely many solutions. If δ\delta ≠\neq -5, there is no solution.

    Correct

    If δ\delta = 0, there are infinitely many solutions; if δ\delta ≠\neq 0, there is no solution.

    Your classification logic was mathematically sound, but because of the arithmetic slip in Step 1, your condition evaluated to δ=−5\delta = -5 rather than δ=0\delta = 0.

  3. Step 3

    ϵ\epsilon y = 10 + 3ϵ\epsilon - 10 = 3ϵ\epsilon   ⟹  \implies y(ϵ\epsilon) = 3   ⟹  \implies x(ϵ\epsilon) = 5 - 2(3) = -1   ⟹  \implies $\lim_{ϵ\epsilon →\to 0}$ (x(\epsilon), y(\epsilon)) = (-1, 3)_

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted ϵ=0\epsilon = 0 into the original system.

You correctly recognized that a consistent identity yields infinitely many solutions while a contradiction yields no solution.

You executed the elimination, substitution, and limiting process in Part 2 completely and accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unbalanced equation scaling during elimination

When computing E2−2E1E_2 - 2E_1 in Part 1, you multiplied the left-hand side of E1E_1 by 22 but subtracted the unmultiplied right-hand side constant 55.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Incomplete scaling during mental linear combinations: the multiplier factor was applied to the variable terms on the left side but missed on the constant term on the right side.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Scale the Entire Equation
  • Multiplying an equation ax+by=ca x + b y = c by a scalar kk requires scaling every single term: k(ax+by)=kck(a x + b y) = k c.

  • Always write down the fully scaled auxiliary equation before subtracting it from the other equation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write 2×(x+2y=5)  ⟹  2x+4y=102 \times (x + 2y = 5) \implies 2x + 4y = 10.

  2. Subtract from Equation (2): (2x+4y)−(2x+4y)=(10+δ)−10  ⟹  0=δ(2x + 4y) - (2x + 4y) = (10 + \delta) - 10 \implies 0 = \delta.

  3. If δ=0\delta = 0, the equation reduces to 0=00 = 0, giving infinitely many solutions.

  4. If δ≠0\delta \neq 0, the equation states 0=δ≠00 = \delta \neq 0, giving no solution.

Final answer

When ϵ=0\epsilon = 0: infinitely many solutions if δ=0\delta = 0, and no solution if δ\delta ≠\neq 0. As ϵ→0\epsilon \to 0 with δ=3ϵ\delta = 3\epsilon, lim⁡ϵ→0(x(ϵ),y(ϵ))=(−1,3)\lim_{\epsilon \to 0} (x(\epsilon), y(\epsilon)) = (-1, 3).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the multiplied equation explicitly above or below the target equation before subtracting.

  • Check that the unperturbed system (ϵ=0,δ=0)(\epsilon = 0, \delta = 0) has both equations identical up to a scalar factor.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes that because ε → 0 makes the coefficient matrix singular, the solution must blow up to infinity instead of solving for the unique solution prior to taking the limit.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    When ϵ=0\epsilon = 0, the system is 2x+4y=102x + 4y = 10 and 2x+4y=10+δ2x + 4y = 10 + \delta ⟹\Longrightarrow Subtracting gives 0=δ0 = \delta ⟹\Longrightarrow Infinitely many solutions if δ=0\delta = 0, no solution if δ≠0\delta \neq 0.

  2. Step 2

    The determinant of the system matrix is 1(4+ϵ)−2(2)=ϵ1(4 + \epsilon) - 2(2) = \epsilon. As ϵ→0\epsilon \to 0, det⁡(A)→0\det(A) \to 0, so the matrix becomes non-invertible.

  3. Step 3

    Since the determinant in the denominator approaches 00, the coordinates blow up. The limit does not exist.

    Correct

    For ϵ≠0\epsilon \neq 0 and δ=3ϵ\delta = 3\epsilon, elimination gives ϵy=3ϵ  ⟹  y=3\epsilon y = 3\epsilon \implies y = 3, and substituting into the first equation gives x=−1x = -1. Because the unique solution is constant at (−1,3)(-1, 3) for every ϵ≠0\epsilon \neq 0, the limit is (−1,3)(-1, 3).

    A vanishing determinant means the denominator approaches zero in Cramer's rule, but the numerator can also approach zero. Here, the numerator is 3ϵ3\epsilon, creating an indeterminate form 3ϵϵ=3\frac{3\epsilon}{\epsilon} = 3 that remains completely finite.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly analyzed the system when ϵ=0\epsilon = 0, identifying infinitely many solutions when δ=0\delta = 0 and no solution when δ≠0\delta \neq 0.

You correctly calculated the determinant of the 2×22 \times 2 coefficient matrix as det⁡(A)=ϵ\det(A) = \epsilon.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Premature Limit on Indeterminate Form

Assuming that a denominator tending to zero guarantees that the solution coordinates diverge to infinity.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated det⁡(A)→0\det(A) \to 0 as sufficient proof of divergence. In perturbed linear systems where the right-hand vector is also perturbed, Cramer's numerators often vanish at the exact same rate as the determinant, resulting in a finite limit.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Solve Algebraically Before Taking Limits
  • Never evaluate the limit of individual matrix components in isolation; solve for (x(ϵ),y(ϵ))(x(\epsilon), y(\epsilon)) explicitly before taking ϵ→0\epsilon \to 0.

  • Use row elimination or Cramer's rule with ϵ\epsilon preserved as an algebraic variable, simplify common factors of ϵ\epsilon, and only then take the limit.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Subtract 2×(x+2y=5)2 \times (x + 2y = 5) from 2x+(4+ϵ)y=10+3ϵ2x + (4 + \epsilon)y = 10 + 3\epsilon, which gives [2x+(4+ϵ)y]−(2x+4y)=(10+3ϵ)−10[2x + (4+\epsilon)y] - (2x + 4y) = (10 + 3\epsilon) - 10, simplifying to ϵy=3ϵ\epsilon y = 3\epsilon.

  2. Because ϵ≠0\epsilon \neq 0, divide both sides by ϵ\epsilon to find y=3y = 3.

  3. Substitute y=3y = 3 into x+2y=5x + 2y = 5 to obtain x=5−2(3)=−1x = 5 - 2(3) = -1.

  4. Observe that (x(ϵ),y(ϵ))=(−1,3)(x(\epsilon), y(\epsilon)) = (-1, 3) is constant for all ϵ≠0\epsilon \neq 0.

Final answer

lim⁡ϵ→0(x(ϵ),y(ϵ))=(−1,3)\lim_{\epsilon \to 0} (x(\epsilon), y(\epsilon)) = (-1, 3)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Carry out elimination symbolically to see whether factors of ϵ\epsilon cancel before drawing conclusions about limits.

  • Remember that in Cramer's rule, det⁡(Ai)det⁡(A)\frac{\det(A_i)}{\det(A)} can yield a 00\frac{0}{0} indeterminate form that converges to a finite point.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Determine the values of kk for which the system {2x−3y=7,4x−6y=14+k\lbrace 2x - 3y = 7,\quad 4x - 6y = 14 + k has infinitely many solutions, no solution, or a unique solution.

Answer

Infinitely many solutions if k=0k = 0; no solution if k≠0k \neq 0; never has a unique solution. Key steps: Multiply the first equation by 22 to obtain 4x−6y=144x - 6y = 14. Subtracting gives 0=(14+k)−14=k0 = (14 + k) - 14 = k. Thus k=0k = 0 gives 0=00 = 0 (infinitely many), and k≠0k \neq 0 gives a contradiction (no solution).

02

Consider the system {x−y=2,3x−(3−ϵ)y=6+2ϵ\lbrace x - y = 2,\quad 3x - (3 - \epsilon)y = 6 + 2\epsilon. Find the unique solution (x(ϵ),y(ϵ))(x(\epsilon), y(\epsilon)) when ϵ≠0\epsilon \neq 0, and find lim⁡ϵ→0(x(ϵ),y(ϵ))\lim_{\epsilon \to 0} (x(\epsilon), y(\epsilon)).

Answer

(x(ϵ),y(ϵ))=(4,2)(x(\epsilon), y(\epsilon)) = (4, 2) for all ϵ≠0\epsilon \neq 0, and the limit is (4,2)(4, 2). Key steps: Subtract 3×(x−y=2)3 \times (x - y = 2) from the second equation: ϵy=(6+2ϵ)−3(2)=2ϵ\epsilon y = (6 + 2\epsilon) - 3(2) = 2\epsilon. For ϵ≠0\epsilon \neq 0, y=2y = 2. Then x=2+y=4x = 2 + y = 4. The limit as ϵ→0\epsilon \to 0 is (4,2)(4, 2).

03

Consider the system {x+3y=4,2x+(6+ϵ)y=8+δ\lbrace x + 3y = 4,\quad 2x + (6 + \epsilon)y = 8 + \delta. Find the condition on δ\delta for the system to be consistent when ϵ=0\epsilon = 0. Then, if δ=cϵ\delta = c\epsilon for a constant cc, determine the value of cc such that the limiting solution as ϵ→0\epsilon \to 0 lies on the line y=2y = 2.

Answer

Consistent when ϵ=0\epsilon = 0 if and only if δ=0\delta = 0. The required constant is c=2c = 2. Key steps: For ϵ=0\epsilon = 0, subtract 2×E12 \times E_1: 0=(8+δ)−2(4)=δ0 = (8 + \delta) - 2(4) = \delta, so consistency requires δ=0\delta = 0. For ϵ≠0\epsilon \neq 0 and δ=cϵ\delta = c\epsilon, subtracting 2×E12 \times E_1 gives ϵy=(8+cϵ)−8=cϵ  ⟹  y=c\epsilon y = (8 + c\epsilon) - 8 = c\epsilon \implies y = c. To lie on y=2y = 2, we must have c=2c = 2.

Loading workspace…