Resources

In a college chemistry lab titration experiment, the electrical conductivity CC (in μS/cm\mu\text{S/cm}) of an acid solution is monitored graphically as a function of the volume VV (in mL\text{mL}) of added standard NaOH\text{NaOH} titrant. Before the equivalence point, the conductivity decreases linearly along the line C1(V)=−18.5V+555.0C_1(V) = -18.5V + 555.0. After the equivalence point, excess titrant causes conductivity to increase linearly along the line C2(V)=24.0V−490.0C_2(V) = 24.0V - 490.0. Determine the equivalence point volume VeqV_{\text{eq}} and the minimum conductivity CminC_{\text{min}} at the graphical intersection of these two linear response curves.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Veq=24.6 mLV_{\text{eq}} = 24.6\text{ mL}, Cmin=100 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = 100\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

Steps

01

Set the two linear equations equal to each other

To find the equivalence point volume VeqV_{\text{eq}} and the minimum conductivity CminC_{\text{min}}, determine the intersection point (V,C)(V, C) where the two linear functions are equal: C1(V)=C2(V)C_1(V) = C_2(V)

Substitute the given equations into the equality:

−18.5V+555.0=24.0V−490.0-18.5V + 555.0 = 24.0V - 490.0

02

Solve for the volume VV

Group the variable terms on one side and the constant terms on the other:

555.0+490.0=24.0V+18.5V555.0 + 490.0 = 24.0V + 18.5V

1045.0=42.5V1045.0 = 42.5V

Divide both sides by 42.542.5:

V=1045.042.5≈24.588 mLV = \frac{1045.0}{42.5} \approx 24.588\text{ mL}

Rounding to one decimal place gives:

Veq≈24.6 mLV_{\text{eq}} \approx 24.6\text{ mL}

03

Calculate the conductivity CminC_{\text{min}}

Substitute the volume into either linear equation to find the corresponding conductivity value.

Using C1(V)C_1(V):

C1(24.588)=−18.5(24.588)+555.0≈100.1 μS/cmC_1(24.588) = -18.5(24.588) + 555.0 \approx 100.1\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

Using C2(V)C_2(V):

C2(24.588)=24.0(24.588)−490.0≈100.1 μS/cmC_2(24.588) = 24.0(24.588) - 490.0 \approx 100.1\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

Rounding to the nearest whole number gives:

Cmin=100 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = 100\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

(Note: Always retain unrounded values during intermediate calculation steps to avoid discrepancies between the two linear branches at the intersection point.)

Educational illustration for this question

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student subtracts instead of adds 490.0 when rearranging terms across the equals sign, obtaining 42.5V = 65.0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    -18.5V + 555.0 = 24.0V - 490.0

  2. Step 2

    42.5V = 555.0 - 490.0   ⟹  \implies 42.5V = 65.0

    Correct

    42.5V = 555.0 + 490.0   ⟹  \implies 42.5V = 1045.0

    When moving −490.0-490.0 to the other side of the equation, you must apply the inverse operation and add 490.0490.0 to both sides. Subtracting it instead produced 65.065.0 rather than 1045.01045.0.

  3. Step 3

    Veq=65.0/42.5≈1.53 mLV_{\text{eq}} = 65.0 / 42.5 \approx 1.53\text{ mL}

    Correct

    Veq=1045.0/42.5≈24.6 mLV_{\text{eq}} = 1045.0 / 42.5 \approx 24.6\text{ mL}

    Your division step followed logically from your prior line, but the numerical result was affected by the earlier transposition error.

  4. Step 4

    Cmin=−18.5(1.53)+555.0≈526.7 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = -18.5(1.53) + 555.0 \approx 526.7\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

    Correct

    Cmin=−18.5(24.588)+555.0≈100 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = -18.5(24.588) + 555.0 \approx 100\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

    You substituted your calculated volume into the conductivity function correctly, but the resulting value reflects the incorrect volume from step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the equivalence point occurs at the intersection where C1(V)=C2(V)C_1(V) = C_2(V).

You combined the variable terms 24.0V+18.5V=42.5V24.0V + 18.5V = 42.5V correctly.

You used the correct substitution method into the linear response function to calculate CminC_{\text{min}}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error during equation transposition

You copied the minus sign from −490.0-490.0 onto the left side as subtraction instead of adding 490.0490.0 to both sides.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Inverting the sign of a term when transposing across the equals sign was skipped, treating −b-b as subtracting bb from the opposite side rather than adding it.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Balance with inverse operations
  • To eliminate a subtracted term −k-k from one side of an equation, you must add +k+k to both sides.

  • Always write the explicit inverse operation: −490.0  ⟹  +490.0-490.0 \implies +490.0 on the opposite side.

Check reasonableness with a quick graph sketch
  • The intersection must lie between the intercepts: C1(V)=0C_1(V) = 0 at V=30V = 30, and C2(V)=0C_2(V) = 0 at V≈20.4V \approx 20.4.

  • Notice that V=1.53 mLV = 1.53\text{ mL} is far too close to V=0V = 0 and gives a conductivity near the initial starting value rather than a minimum.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Add 18.5V18.5V and add 490.0490.0 to both sides: 555.0+490.0=24.0V+18.5V555.0 + 490.0 = 24.0V + 18.5V.

  2. Simplify both sides: 1045.0=42.5V1045.0 = 42.5V.

  3. Divide by 42.542.5: V=1045.042.5≈24.588 mL≈24.6 mLV = \frac{1045.0}{42.5} \approx 24.588\text{ mL} \approx 24.6\text{ mL}.

  4. Substitute V≈24.588V \approx 24.588 into C1(V)C_1(V): Cmin=−18.5(24.588)+555.0≈100.1 μS/cm≈100 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = -18.5(24.588) + 555.0 \approx 100.1\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm} \approx 100\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}.

Final answer

Veq=24.6 mLV_{\text{eq}} = 24.6\text{ mL}, Cmin=100 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = 100\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice moving negative constants across linear equations using explicit addition steps on both sides.

  • Verify your intersection point by plugging the solution back into both original equations to see if they yield the same value.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student subtracts 18.5V from 24.0V instead of adding it, incorrectly finding 5.5V = 1045.0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    -18.5V + 555.0 = 24.0V - 490.0

  2. Step 2

    24.0V - 18.5V = 555.0 + 490.0   ⟹  \implies 5.5V = 1045.0

    Correct

    24.0V + 18.5V = 555.0 + 490.0   ⟹  \implies 42.5V = 1045.0

    When transposing −18.5V-18.5V from the left side of the equation to the right side, you must add 18.5V18.5V to both sides, which yields 24.0V+18.5V=42.5V24.0V + 18.5V = 42.5V rather than 24.0V−18.5V=5.5V24.0V - 18.5V = 5.5V.

  3. Step 3

    Veq=1045.0/5.5=190.0 mLV_{\text{eq}} = 1045.0 / 5.5 = 190.0\text{ mL}

    Correct

    Veq=1045.042.5≈24.6 mLV_{\text{eq}} = \frac{1045.0}{42.5} \approx 24.6\text{ mL}

    Your division step was computed correctly based on your previous line, but the value is affected by the earlier transposition error.

  4. Step 4

    Cmin=24.0(190.0)−490.0=4070.0 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = 24.0(190.0) - 490.0 = 4070.0\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

    Correct

    Cmin=24.0(24.588)−490.0≈100 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = 24.0(24.588) - 490.0 \approx 100\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

    You substituted your volume into C2(V)C_2(V) correctly, but because VeqV_{\text{eq}} was incorrect, the resulting conductivity value is also affected.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that the equivalence point corresponds to the graphical intersection where C1(V)=C2(V)C_1(V) = C_2(V).

You correctly isolated the constant terms on one side by adding 490.0490.0 to 555.0555.0.

You knew to evaluate the conductivity by substituting your calculated volume into the linear function.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Transposition Sign Error

You copied the minus sign from −18.5V-18.5V as a subtraction on the right-hand side instead of applying the inverse operation of addition.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Inverting operations across an equality: when moving a negative term −bV-bV to the other side of an equation, the balance rule requires adding +bV+bV to both sides.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Use Explicit Balance Operations
  • To eliminate a negative term −ax-ax from one side of an equation, add +ax+ax to both sides: −ax+c=dx  ⟹  c=dx+ax-ax + c = dx \implies c = dx + ax.

  • Write +18.5V+18.5V under both sides before simplifying to ensure the sign changes properly.

Dual-Branch Intersection Check
  • At an intersection point, substituting VV into both original equations must yield the exact same value: C1(V)=C2(V)C_1(V) = C_2(V).

  • Substitute your answer into both functions. Here, C1(190.0)=−2960C_1(190.0) = -2960 while C2(190.0)=4070C_2(190.0) = 4070, which immediately flags a calculation error.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. 555.0+490.0=24.0V+18.5V555.0 + 490.0 = 24.0V + 18.5V

  2. 1045.0=42.5V1045.0 = 42.5V

  3. Veq=1045.042.5≈24.588 mL≈24.6 mLV_{\text{eq}} = \frac{1045.0}{42.5} \approx 24.588\text{ mL} \approx 24.6\text{ mL}

  4. Cmin=−18.5(24.588)+555.0≈100.1≈100 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = -18.5(24.588) + 555.0 \approx 100.1 \approx 100\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

Final answer

Veq=24.6 mLV_{\text{eq}} = 24.6\text{ mL}, Cmin=100 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = 100\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice solving linear equations with negative coefficients on the left-hand side by explicitly writing the addition step on both sides.

  • Always substitute your calculated coordinate back into both original equations to verify that both sides produce matching values before finalizing your answer.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets the minimum conductivity as the x-intercept of the first line where conductivity reaches zero, solving C_1(V) = 0 instead of finding the intersection of both lines.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    −18.5V+555.0=0  ⟹  18.5V=555.0  ⟹  Veq=555.0/18.5=30.0 mL-18.5V + 555.0 = 0 \implies 18.5V = 555.0 \implies V_{\text{eq}} = 555.0 / 18.5 = 30.0\text{ mL}

    Correct

    −18.5V+555.0=24.0V−490.0  ⟹  42.5V=1045.0  ⟹  Veq≈24.6 mL-18.5V + 555.0 = 24.0V - 490.0 \implies 42.5V = 1045.0 \implies V_{\text{eq}} \approx 24.6\text{ mL}

    You set the pre-equivalence line equal to zero instead of setting the two response lines equal to each other. The equivalence point occurs at the intersection of the two linear curves C1(V)=C2(V)C_1(V) = C_2(V), where conductivity reaches its minimum non-zero value.

  2. Step 2

    Cmin=0 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = 0\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

    Correct

    Cmin=−18.5(24.588)+555.0≈100 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = -18.5(24.588) + 555.0 \approx 100\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

    Because you assumed conductivity drops completely to zero at the equivalence point, your minimum conductivity was stated as 0 μS/cm0\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm} rather than the actual value at the intersection.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You solved the linear equation that you set up algebraically without calculation errors.

You labeled your answers clearly with the proper physical units for volume and conductivity.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equating to Zero Instead of System Intersection

You treated the minimum point as an axis intercept (C=0C = 0) rather than finding where the decreasing and increasing branches intersect.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that the minimum conductivity in a titration must reach zero, which led you to find the VV-intercept of C1(V)C_1(V) rather than solving the system of equations formed by both curves C1(V)=C2(V)C_1(V) = C_2(V). In real experimental systems, background ions keep conductivity above zero at the intersection.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Intersection vs. Axis Intercept
  • When a curve transitions from one linear rate to another at a minimum or peak, that point is the graphical intersection of both equations (y1=y2y_1 = y_2), not necessarily where y=0y = 0.

  • Always set the two branch equations equal to each other (C1(V)=C2(V)C_1(V) = C_2(V)) rather than setting either equation to zero.

Evaluate the Dependent Variable
  • The minimum value of a two-piece linear curve is the yy-value at the intersection xx-coordinate.

  • Substitute the calculated intersection coordinate back into either original function to determine the actual minimum output value.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set C1(V)=C2(V)C_1(V) = C_2(V): −18.5V+555.0=24.0V−490.0-18.5V + 555.0 = 24.0V - 490.0.

  2. Collect like terms: 42.5V=1045.042.5V = 1045.0, which yields Veq≈24.588 mL≈24.6 mLV_{\text{eq}} \approx 24.588\text{ mL} \approx 24.6\text{ mL}.

  3. Substitute VeqV_{\text{eq}} into C1(V)C_1(V): Cmin=−18.5(24.588)+555.0≈100.1 μS/cm≈100 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = -18.5(24.588) + 555.0 \approx 100.1\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm} \approx 100\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}.

Final answer

Veq=24.6 mLV_{\text{eq}} = 24.6\text{ mL}, Cmin=100 μS/cmC_{\text{min}} = 100\text{ }\mu\text{S/cm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the practice problems below on finding the intersection point of two linear models.

  • Remember to check whether a minimum value is explicitly constrained to zero before setting an expression to zero.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two temperature probes record linear readings during a reaction: T1(t)=−3.5t+84.0T_1(t) = -3.5t + 84.0 and T2(t)=4.5t−28.0T_2(t) = 4.5t - 28.0, where tt is in minutes. Find the time tt and temperature TT where both probes read the same value.

Answer

t=14.0 mint = 14.0\text{ min}, T=35.0∘CT = 35.0^\circ\text{C}. Equate −3.5t+84.0=4.5t−28.0-3.5t + 84.0 = 4.5t - 28.0. Add 28.028.0 and 3.5t3.5t to both sides: 84.0+28.0=4.5t+3.5t  ⟹  112.0=8.0t  ⟹  t=14.084.0 + 28.0 = 4.5t + 3.5t \implies 112.0 = 8.0t \implies t = 14.0. Substitute into T1(14.0)=−3.5(14)+84=35.0T_1(14.0) = -3.5(14) + 84 = 35.0.

02

A buffer solution's pH during two phases of titration follows y1=−0.45x+9.20y_1 = -0.45x + 9.20 and y2=0.80x−3.30y_2 = 0.80x - 3.30, where xx is titrant volume in mL\text{mL}. Find the intersection point (x,y)(x, y) rounded to two decimal places.

Answer

x=10.00 mLx = 10.00\text{ mL}, y=4.70y = 4.70. Set −0.45x+9.20=0.80x−3.30-0.45x + 9.20 = 0.80x - 3.30. Add 3.303.30 and 0.45x0.45x to both sides: 9.20+3.30=0.80x+0.45x  ⟹  12.50=1.25x  ⟹  x=10.009.20 + 3.30 = 0.80x + 0.45x \implies 12.50 = 1.25x \implies x = 10.00. Substitute to find y=−0.45(10)+9.20=4.70y = -0.45(10) + 9.20 = 4.70.

03

Two cost models for equipment maintenance are given by CA(m)=−12.5m+680.0C_A(m) = -12.5m + 680.0 and CB(m)=17.5m−250.0C_B(m) = 17.5m - 250.0, where mm is operating months. A student writes 30.0m=680.0−250.0=430.030.0m = 680.0 - 250.0 = 430.0. Identify the student's algebraic mistake, correct the equation, and find the break-even month mm.

Answer

Mistake: The student subtracted 250.0250.0 instead of adding it when transposing across the equals sign. Correct equation: 17.5m+12.5m=680.0+250.0  ⟹  30.0m=930.017.5m + 12.5m = 680.0 + 250.0 \implies 30.0m = 930.0. Solving gives m=31 monthsm = 31\text{ months}.

Loading workspace…