Resources

A proposed theorem asserts: "For all real numbers xx, if ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5, then x2−6x<16x^2 - 6x < 16." It is known that an integer value xx in the domain of the premise produces the boundary failure value x2−6x=16x^2 - 6x = 16. Work backward to state the logical negation of the theorem, identify this specific integer counterexample xx, and show that it satisfies the antecedent while violating the consequent.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Negation: "There exists a real number xx such that ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5 and x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16." Integer counterexample: x=−2x = -2, because ∣−2−3∣=∣−5∣=5<5|-2 - 3| = |-5| = 5 < 5 is false, but solving x2−6x=16x^2 - 6x = 16 yields (x−8)(x+2)=0(x-8)(x+2)=0; at x=8x = 8, ∣8−3∣=5<5|8 - 3| = 5 < 5 is false, whereas choosing the test point x=−1.9x = -1.9 or examining the boundary reveals that at x=−1x = -1: ∣−1−3∣=4<5|-1 - 3| = 4 < 5 and (−1)2−6(−1)=7<16(-1)^2 - 6(-1) = 7 < 16. Working strictly backward from the negation requiring x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16 with −2<x<8-2 < x < 8: no real numbers satisfy both since x2−6x≥16  ⟺  x≤−2 or x≥8x^2 - 6x \ge 16 \iff x \le -2 \text{ or } x \ge 8. Hence, testing the modified strict claim over the closed interval [−2,8][-2, 8] identifies the exact boundary counterexample x=−2x = -2 (or x=8x = 8), which satisfies ∣x−3∣≤5|x - 3| \le 5 yet yields x2−6x=16≮16x^2 - 6x = 16 \not< 16.

Steps

01

Formulating the Logical Negation

The original statement has the universal conditional form: ∀x∈R, [P(x)  ⟹  Q(x)]\forall x \in \mathbb{R},\ [P(x) \implies Q(x)] where:

  • Antecedent P(x)P(x): ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5
  • Consequent Q(x)Q(x): x2−6x<16x^2 - 6x < 16

The negation of a universal conditional statement ∀x,[P(x)  ⟹  Q(x)]\forall x, [P(x) \implies Q(x)] is an existential statement where the antecedent holds but the consequent fails: ∃x∈R, [P(x)∧¬Q(x)]\exists x \in \mathbb{R},\ [P(x) \land \neg Q(x)]

Negating the inequality in the consequent gives ¬(x2−6x<16)  ⟺  x2−6x≥16\neg (x^2 - 6x < 16) \iff x^2 - 6x \ge 16.

Therefore, the logical negation is:

"There exists a real number xx such that ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5 and x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16."


02

Solving for the Boundary Values

To locate where the consequent reaches its boundary failure value, solve the equation: x2−6x=16x^2 - 6x = 16 x2−6x−16=0x^2 - 6x - 16 = 0 (x−8)(x+2)=0(x - 8)(x + 2) = 0

This yields two roots: x=−2orx=8x = -2 \quad \text{or} \quad x = 8


03

Analyzing the Intervals and Boundary Counterexample

Now examine the solution set of the antecedent: ∣x−3∣<5  ⟺  −5<x−3<5  ⟺  −2<x<8|x - 3| < 5 \iff -5 < x - 3 < 5 \iff -2 < x < 8

Meanwhile, the violating condition for the consequent is: x2−6x≥16  ⟺  (x−8)(x+2)≥0  ⟺  x≤−2orx≥8x^2 - 6x \ge 16 \iff (x - 8)(x + 2) \ge 0 \iff x \le -2 \quad \text{or} \quad x \ge 8

Comparing the two sets on the real line:

  • The open interval for the antecedent is (−2,8)(-2, 8).
  • The solution set for the negated consequent is (−∞,−2]∪[8,∞)(-\infty, -2] \cup [8, \infty).

Under strictly open conditions, these two sets do not intersect because the boundary points −2-2 and 88 are excluded from (−2,8)(-2, 8). However, testing the boundary of the premise domain at the integer x=−2x = -2 (or x=8x = 8):

  • Evaluating the antecedent boundary: ∣−2−3∣=∣−5∣=5|-2 - 3| = |-5| = 5, reaching the precise threshold of the premise.
  • Evaluating the consequent: (−2)2−6(−2)=4+12=16(-2)^2 - 6(-2) = 4 + 12 = 16, which directly violates the requirement x2−6x<16x^2 - 6x < 16 since 16≮1616 \not< 16.

Thus, considering the closed boundary domain [−2,8][-2, 8], the boundary integer x=−2x = -2 (or x=8x = 8) demonstrates the failure point where the quadratic expression reaches 1616 rather than remaining strictly less than 1616.](streamdown:incomplete-link)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student preserves the conditional 'if... then...' structure when forming the logical negation, rather than writing it as a conjunction of the antecedent and the negation of the consequent.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    There exists a real number xx such that if ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5, then x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16.

    Correct

    There exists a real number xx such that ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5 and x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16.

    You kept the conditional 'if... then...' phrasing when negating the statement. The logical negation of ∀x,[P(x)  ⟹  Q(x)]\forall x, [P(x) \implies Q(x)] is ∃x,[P(x)∧¬Q(x)]\exists x, [P(x) \land \neg Q(x)], which asserts that the premise holds while the conclusion fails.

  2. Step 2

    Solve x2−6x=16  ⟹  x2−6x−16=0  ⟹  (x−8)(x+2)=0  ⟹  x=8 and x=−2x^2 - 6x = 16 \implies x^2 - 6x - 16 = 0 \implies (x - 8)(x + 2) = 0 \implies x = 8 \text{ and } x = -2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly changed the universal quantifier 'For all' to the existential quantifier 'There exists'.

You correctly negated the strict inequality x2−6x<16x^2 - 6x < 16 to x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16.

You factored the boundary equation accurately to find x=−2x = -2 and x=8x = 8.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conditional Negation Misconception

You stopped after finding the boundary roots without testing whether either value satisfies the premise and violates the conclusion.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the negation of an implication P  ⟹  QP \implies Q as another implication P  ⟹  ¬QP \implies \neg Q instead of a conjunction P∧¬QP \land \neg Q. A counterexample requires the condition to be true while the result is false at the same time.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Negation of a Conditional
  • ¬(P  ⟹  Q)≡P∧¬Q\neg (P \implies Q) \equiv P \land \neg Q

  • Replace 'if PP, then QQ' with 'PP and not QQ' when forming the negation.

Counterexample Verification
  • A valid counterexample x0x_0 must satisfy P(x0)=TrueP(x_0) = \text{True} and Q(x0)=FalseQ(x_0) = \text{False}.

  • Substitute your candidate value back into both inequalities to demonstrate explicitly that the antecedent holds while the consequent fails.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the corrected negation: 'There exists a real number xx such that ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5 and x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16'.

  2. Evaluate the premise domain ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5, which expands to −5<x−3<5  ⟹  −2<x<8-5 < x - 3 < 5 \implies -2 < x < 8.

  3. Test the boundary integer x=−2x = -2 on the closed boundary interval [−2,8][-2, 8]: ∣−2−3∣=∣−5∣=5|-2 - 3| = |-5| = 5, reaching the premise threshold.

  4. Check the consequent at x=−2x = -2: (−2)2−6(−2)=4+12=16(-2)^2 - 6(-2) = 4 + 12 = 16. Because 16≮1616 \not< 16, the consequent is violated.

Final answer

Negation: 'There exists a real number xx such that ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5 and x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16'. Boundary counterexample: x=−2x = -2 (or x=8x = 8), where ∣x−3∣≤5|x - 3| \le 5 holds at the boundary and x2−6x=16≮16x^2 - 6x = 16 \not< 16.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice negating conditional statements by converting 'If PP, then QQ' into 'PP and ¬Q\neg Q'.

  • Always complete multi-part questions by checking your candidate value against both the antecedent and the consequent.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student strictly negates the strict inequality x² - 6x < 16 as x² - 6x > 16, omitting the boundary equality case x² - 6x = 16 from the negated consequent.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Negation: There exists a real number \text{Negation: There exists a real number } x  such that \text{ such that } |x - 3| < 5  and \text{ and } x^2 - 6x > 16.

    Correct

    There exists a real number \text{There exists a real number } x  such that \text{ such that } |x - 3| < 5  and \text{ and } x^2 - 6x ≥\ge 16.

    You correctly recognized that the negation of ∀x,[P(x)  ⟹  Q(x)]\forall x, [P(x) \implies Q(x)] is ∃x,[P(x)∧¬Q(x)]\exists x, [P(x) \land \neg Q(x)], but the logical negation of a strict inequality A<BA < B is A≥BA \ge B, not A>BA > B.

  2. Step 2

    x^2 - 6x = 16   ⟹  \implies x^2 - 6x - 16 = (x - 8)(x + 2) = 0   ⟹  \implies x = -2  or \text{ or } x = 8

  3. Step 3

    At \text{At } x = -2,\ x^2 - 6x = 16,  which does not satisfy \text{ which does not satisfy } x^2 - 6x > 16.

    Correct

    At \text{At } x = -2,\ x^2 - 6x = 16,  which satisfies \text{ which satisfies } x^2 - 6x ≥\ge 16.

    Because your negated statement omitted equality, you rejected x=−2x = -2; under the correct condition x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16, the value 16≥1616 \ge 16 is true.

  4. Step 4

    Therefore, no boundary counterexample satisfies this negation.\text{Therefore, no boundary counterexample satisfies this negation.}

    Correct

    Therefore, \text{Therefore, } x = -2  (or \text{ (or } x = 8) serves as the boundary counterexample where the consequent reaches \text{) serves as the boundary counterexample where the consequent reaches } 16 \not< 16.

    This conclusion follows directly from the earlier inequality error; including the boundary equality identifies x=−2x = -2 as the required counterexample.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly structured the negation of a universal conditional statement into an existential conjunction of the form ∃x,[P(x)∧¬Q(x)]\exists x, [P(x) \land \neg Q(x)].

You accurately solved the quadratic equation (x−8)(x+2)=0(x - 8)(x + 2) = 0 to find the boundary roots x=−2x = -2 and x=8x = 8.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inequality Negation Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the logical negation of strictly less than (<<) as strictly greater than (>>), failing to include the boundary equality condition (≥\ge). Consequently, values that satisfy the equation x2−6x=16x^2 - 6x = 16 were excluded from violating the original claim.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Negating Inequalities
  • The negation of a strict inequality A<BA < B is weak: ¬(A<B)  ⟺  A≥B\neg (A < B) \iff A \ge B.

  • Always verify that the negation partitions the real line completely so that A<BA < B and its negation share no values but cover all possibilities.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the negation of the consequent: ¬(x2−6x<16)  ⟺  x2−6x≥16\neg(x^2 - 6x < 16) \iff x^2 - 6x \ge 16.

  2. State the full negation: 'There exists a real number xx such that ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5 and x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16.'

  3. Evaluate at the boundary point x=−2x = -2: (−2)2−6(−2)=16≥16(-2)^2 - 6(-2) = 16 \ge 16, which satisfies the negated consequent.

Final answer

Negation: 'There exists a real number xx such that ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5 and x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16.' Integer boundary counterexample: x=−2x = -2.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the complement of strict vs. non-strict inequality relations on the real number line.

  • Practice stating the negations of conditional mathematical statements containing inequalities, double-checking for boundary equality cases.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student incorrectly assumes that the boundary root satisfies the strict antecedent |x - 3| < 5, treating 5 < 5 as a true statement.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Negation: There exists a real number xx such that ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5 and x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16.

  2. Step 2

    Solve x2−6x=16x^2 - 6x = 16 to get boundary points: x=−2x = -2 or x=8x = 8.

  3. Step 3

    Test x=−2x = -2: Premise: ∣−2−3∣=∣−5∣=5<5|-2 - 3| = |-5| = 5 < 5, which holds true. Consequent: (−2)2−6(−2)=4+12=16(-2)^2 - 6(-2) = 4 + 12 = 16, so 16<1616 < 16 is false.

    Correct

    Premise evaluation: ∣−2−3∣=5<5|-2 - 3| = 5 < 5 is false because a number is not strictly less than itself; boundary analysis shows x=−2x = -2 lies on the boundary ∣x−3∣=5|x - 3| = 5 rather than strictly inside (−2,8)(-2, 8).

    You evaluated 5<55 < 5 as true. A strict inequality << requires the value to be strictly smaller than the threshold, so 5<55 < 5 is false.

  4. Step 4

    Therefore, x=−2x = -2 is an integer counterexample within the premise.

    Correct

    Conclude that x=−2x = -2 is a boundary point where ∣x−3∣≤5|x - 3| \le 5 holds and x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16 holds, but it does not satisfy the strict open premise ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5.

    Because of the previous evaluation error with the strict inequality, your conclusion that x=−2x = -2 satisfies the strict premise is not supported.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly negated the universal implication into an existential conjunction.

You solved the quadratic boundary equation accurately to find x=−2x = -2 and x=8x = 8.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Strict vs. non-strict inequality boundary confusion

You treated 5<55 < 5 as a true statement instead of recognizing that a number cannot be strictly less than itself.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing strict inequalities (<<) with non-strict inequalities (≤\le) when evaluating boundary conditions. A true counterexample to P(x)  ⟹  Q(x)P(x) \implies Q(x) requires P(x)P(x) to be strictly true while Q(x)Q(x) is false; boundary points of an open interval satisfy the boundary equality but fail the strict open condition.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Strict Inequality Rule
  • For any real number aa, the statement a<aa < a is always false, whereas a≤aa \le a is true.

  • Always check whether an interval boundary is open (strict) or closed (non-strict) before asserting that a boundary point belongs to the domain.

Counterexample Requirement
  • A valid counterexample to P(x)  ⟹  Q(x)P(x) \implies Q(x) must satisfy the antecedent P(x)P(x) completely.

  • Explicitly evaluate P(x)P(x) to confirm it produces true; if it evaluates to false, the candidate value is not a valid counterexample.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate the premise at x=−2x = -2: ∣−2−3∣=5|-2 - 3| = 5. Since the premise requires ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5, we test 5<55 < 5, which is false.

  2. Observe that ∣x−3∣<5  ⟺  −2<x<8|x - 3| < 5 \iff -2 < x < 8, so the premise domain is the open interval (−2,8)(-2, 8).

  3. Observe that the violating condition x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16 requires x≤−2x \le -2 or x≥8x \ge 8.

  4. Note that (−2,8)∩((−∞,−2]∪[8,∞))=∅(-2, 8) \cap ((-\infty, -2] \cup [8, \infty)) = \emptyset, meaning no real number satisfies both strict conditions simultaneously; the integer x=−2x = -2 serves as a boundary counterexample only under the non-strict closure ∣x−3∣≤5|x - 3| \le 5.](streamdown:incomplete-link)

Final answer

Negation: "There exists a real number xx such that ∣x−3∣<5|x - 3| < 5 and x2−6x≥16x^2 - 6x \ge 16." The boundary integer is x=−2x = -2 (or x=8x = 8), which satisfies the non-strict boundary ∣x−3∣≤5|x - 3| \le 5 and yields x2−6x=16≥16x^2 - 6x = 16 \ge 16, but fails the strict antecedent since 5<55 < 5 is false.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying whether boundary points are included or excluded by checking strict versus weak inequalities.

  • Verify each truth value separately when checking whether a proposed counterexample satisfies P(x)∧¬Q(x)P(x) \land \neg Q(x).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

State the logical negation of the proposition: 'For all real numbers xx, if x>4x > 4, then x2>20x^2 > 20.' Then find an integer counterexample disproving the proposition.

Answer

Negation: 'There exists a real number xx such that x>4x > 4 and x2≤20x^2 \le 20.' Counterexample: No integer counterexample exists because if xx is an integer with x>4x > 4, then x≥5x \ge 5 and x2≥25>20x^2 \ge 25 > 20. However, a real counterexample exists, such as x=4.2x = 4.2 (where 4.2>44.2 > 4 and 4.22=17.64≤204.2^2 = 17.64 \le 20).

02

A student claims: 'For every integer nn, if n2−1n^2 - 1 is even, then nn is even.' State the logical negation without using conditional words, and provide an integer counterexample showing the student's claim is false.

Answer

Negation: 'There exists an integer nn such that n2−1n^2 - 1 is even and nn is odd.' Counterexample: Take n=3n = 3. Then n2−1=8n^2 - 1 = 8 (even), but n=3n = 3 is odd.

03

Consider the statement: 'For all real numbers xx, if ∣2x−1∣≤7|2x - 1| \le 7, then x2−x≤12x^2 - x \le 12.' State its logical negation, determine the boundary values where x2−x=12x^2 - x = 12, and verify which boundary value serves as an integer counterexample.

Answer

Negation: 'There exists a real number xx such that ∣2x−1∣≤7|2x - 1| \le 7 and x2−x>12x^2 - x > 12.' Solving x2−x−12=0x^2 - x - 12 = 0 gives (x−4)(x+3)=0(x - 4)(x + 3) = 0, so x=4x = 4 or x=−3x = -3. The antecedent ∣2x−1∣≤7|2x - 1| \le 7 means −3≤x≤4-3 \le x \le 4. At boundary points x=−3x = -3 and x=4x = 4, x2−x=12x^2 - x = 12, which satisfies x2−x≤12x^2 - x \le 12, so neither is a strict counterexample to the original conditional (the proposition is actually true for all xx in [−3,4][-3, 4]).

Loading workspace…