Resources
A common mistake when writing the ground-state electron configuration of the iron(II) cation, (), is to apply the Aufbau filling sequence directly to a system with electrons, yielding . (a) Write the correct ground-state condensed electron configuration of . (b) Identify the specific convention/energy rule violated by the incorrect configuration. (c) Determine the correct number of unpaired electrons in versus the number predicted by the erroneous configuration.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Correct configuration of : ; (b) In transition metal ionization, electrons with the highest principal quantum number (, from ) are removed before electrons; (c) Correct has unpaired electrons; the erroneous configuration also predicts unpaired electrons, but incorrectly places electrons in the higher-energy orbital rather than pairing one in .
Steps
Determine the Ground-State Configuration of (Part a)
- Write the ground-state electron configuration of the neutral iron atom (, ):
- To form the divalent cation , remove two electrons. In transition metals, electrons are always removed first from the subshell with the highest principal quantum number ().
- Because for the subshell and for the subshell, the two electrons are removed from the orbital rather than the orbitals:
Identify the Violated Principle (Part b)
- The error: Treating as an arbitrary -electron system and applying the Aufbau filling sequence directly gives .
- The rule violated: The transition metal ionization rule (removal order). Once the subshell begins filling, the nuclear charge stabilizes the orbitals below the orbital in energy. Therefore, upon ionization, electrons with the highest principal quantum number (, from ) are removed before electrons (). Aufbau filling applies to constructing neutral atoms, not to removing electrons during transition metal cation formation.
Compare Unpaired Electrons (Part c)
Apply Hund's rule and the Pauli exclusion principle to both configurations:
-
Correct configuration ():
- The five degenerate orbitals are populated by electrons.
- Following Hund's rule, each of the five orbitals receives one electron before any orbital receives a second: \uparrow\downarrow & \uparrow & \uparrow & \uparrow & \uparrow \end{array}$$
- There is paired orbital and unpaired electrons.
-
Erroneous configuration ():
- The single orbital holds paired electrons: .
- The four electrons occupy four separate orbitals: \uparrow & \uparrow & \uparrow & \uparrow & \underline{\phantom{\uparrow}} \end{array}$$
- This arrangement also predicts unpaired electrons.
- Comparison: Both configurations coincidentally predict unpaired electrons; however, the incorrect model erroneously places two electrons into the higher-energy subshell instead of pairing them in the lower-energy subshell.
Typical errors
01 The student removes one electron from 4s and one from 3d instead of removing both from 4s, leading to an incorrect configuration and unpaired electron count.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You removed one electron from and one from . When forming transition metal cations, both valence electrons from the outermost shell (, the subshell) must be removed before removing any electrons, giving .
- Step 2
- Step 3
[],4s^1 3d^5: 1 4s 5 3d 6 [],4s^2 3d^4: 4 3d.
CorrectCorrect () has unpaired electrons; erroneous also predicts unpaired electrons.
You correctly counted unpaired electrons for the hypothetical configuration. However, because you carried forward your incorrect cation configuration from part (a), you calculated unpaired electrons instead of the true value of unpaired electrons for ground-state ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly stated that electrons must be removed before electrons upon ionization.
You correctly determined that the erroneous configuration contains unpaired electrons using Hund's rule.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou understood the verbal rule that electrons leave first, but you split the two removals between and (likely influenced by the stability of a half-filled subshell) instead of emptying the entire subshell before touching the subshell.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- First-in, First-out for 4s
For neutral atoms, fills before , but upon ionization, electrons are removed first because they possess a higher principal quantum number ().
Empty the orbital entirely ( electrons) before removing any electrons from the orbitals.
- Orbital Box Diagramming for d-electrons
Distribute electrons into five degenerate orbitals singly with parallel spins before pairing.
Place electrons across five orbitals: paired orbital and singly occupied orbitals ( unpaired electrons).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the neutral iron configuration: .
Form the divalent cation by removing two electrons from the highest principal energy level (), which empties the orbital completely: .
Draw the five degenerate orbital boxes for electrons: Hund's rule gives , yielding unpaired electrons.
(a) ; (b) In transition metal ionization, electrons with the highest principal quantum number (, from ) are removed before electrons; (c) Correct has unpaired electrons; the erroneous configuration also predicts unpaired electrons.
02 The student mistakenly pairs electrons in the 3d subshell rather than applying Hund's rule, calculating an incorrect number of unpaired electrons.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
By Hund's rule, electrons occupy degenerate orbitals singly with parallel spins before pairing. For electrons across five orbitals, orbital has a pair and the remaining orbitals each have unpaired electron.
- Step 4Correct
In , the subshell holds paired electrons, while the four electrons occupy four separate orbitals singly, resulting in unpaired electrons.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly derived the electron configuration of by removing the electrons first.
You stated the correct transition metal ionization principle governing electron removal order.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou paired electrons into the fewest possible orbitals instead of following Hund's rule, which requires placing one electron with parallel spin into each degenerate orbital of a subshell before pairing begins.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Hund's Rule for Degenerate Orbitals
Every orbital in a degenerate subshell is singly occupied with parallel spins before any orbital is doubly occupied.
Draw all five boxes for the subshell. Place one spin-up arrow in each box from left to right, and only start pairing with spin-down arrows once each box has one electron.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDistribute the electrons of () across the five degenerate orbitals: place electron in each of the orbitals, then pair the electron in the first orbital.
Count the single electrons: paired orbital and singly occupied orbitals yield unpaired electrons.
Distribute the four electrons of : the orbital contains paired electrons, and four of the five orbitals hold electron each, also giving unpaired electrons.
Correct has unpaired electrons; the erroneous configuration also predicts unpaired electrons.
Lock it in
Which electrons are removed first when a neutral first-row transition metal forms a positive cation?
Electrons from the subshell (highest principal quantum number ) are always removed before any electrons.
Similar question
Write the ground-state condensed electron configuration of the cobalt(II) ion, (), and state its number of unpaired electrons.
Answer
Configuration: . Unpaired electrons: . Key steps: Neutral is . Ionization removes both electrons to yield . Distributing electrons across five orbitals gives two paired orbitals and three singly occupied orbitals.
A student writes the electron configuration for the titanium(II) ion, (), as . Explain why this is incorrect, provide the correct configuration, and indicate whether the ion is diamagnetic or paramagnetic.
Answer
Incorrect because is formed by removing the two valence electrons from neutral (), not the electrons. Correct configuration: . The ion is paramagnetic because it has unpaired electrons in the subshell.
Compare the ground-state electron configurations and the number of unpaired electrons of () and (). Are these ions isoelectronic?
Answer
Both ions are isoelectronic with configuration . Both have unpaired electrons. Key steps: Neutral () loses two electrons to become . Neutral () loses two electrons and one electron to become . Five electrons singly occupy the five degenerate orbitals.