Resources
A binary liquid mixture is prepared by dissolving acetone, , into chloroform, . (a) Identify the primary intermolecular force present within pure liquid acetone and within pure liquid chloroform. (b) Identify the new, specific intermolecular interaction that forms between an acetone molecule and a chloroform molecule in the mixture, and classify whether the mixture exhibits positive or negative deviations from Raoult's law.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) In pure liquid acetone: dipole-dipole interactions (and London dispersion forces); in pure liquid chloroform: dipole-dipole interactions (and London dispersion forces). (b) Between acetone and chloroform: hydrogen bonding (formed between the strongly polarized proton of , activated by three electron-withdrawing chlorine atoms, and the basic oxygen lone pairs of acetone); this produces stronger adhesive than cohesive forces, resulting in negative deviations from Raoult's law.
Steps
Part (a): Intermolecular Forces in Pure Acetone and Pure Chloroform
-
Pure Liquid Acetone, :
- Molecular polarity: Acetone contains a carbonyl group () with a significant dipole moment due to the large electronegativity difference between oxygen and carbon. The molecule has no atom covalently bonded to , , or , so it cannot form hydrogen bonds with other acetone molecules.
- Intermolecular forces: The primary intermolecular interaction between acetone molecules is dipole-dipole attraction (supported by underlying London dispersion forces).
-
Pure Liquid Chloroform, :
- Molecular polarity: Chloroform has a tetrahedral geometry with three highly electronegative chlorine atoms and one hydrogen atom bound to carbon. The individual bond dipoles do not cancel, giving the molecule a permanent net dipole moment.
- Intermolecular forces: Because the hydrogen atom is bonded to carbon rather than nitrogen, oxygen, or fluorine, pure chloroform cannot donate a classical hydrogen bond to another chloroform molecule. The primary intermolecular force in pure chloroform is therefore dipole-dipole attraction (along with significant London dispersion forces from the large, polarizable chlorine atoms).
Part (b): Interaction in the Mixture and Raoult's Law Deviation
-
Formation of Hydrogen Bonding Between Unlike Molecules:
- The three strongly electronegative chlorine atoms in exert an additive electron-withdrawing inductive effect on the central carbon atom.
- This withdraws electron density away from the bond, rendering the hydrogen atom unusually electron-deficient with a prominent partial positive charge ().
- The carbonyl oxygen atom of acetone has two non-bonding lone pairs and a partial negative charge (), acting as an effective hydrogen-bond acceptor.
- When mixed, a hydrogen bond () forms between the chloroform hydrogen and the acetone oxygen.
-
Deviation from Raoult's Law:
- Relative interaction strength: The new adhesive hydrogen-bonding interactions between acetone and chloroform () are substantially stronger than the cohesive dipole-dipole interactions in pure acetone () or pure chloroform ().
- Thermodynamic consequence: Because the molecules attract each other more strongly in the mixture than in their pure states, fewer molecules escape into the gas phase.
- Consequently, the measured vapor pressure of the solution is lower than that predicted by Raoult's law, meaning the mixture exhibits a negative deviation from Raoult's law (accompanied by an exothermic enthalpy of mixing, ).
Common Pitfall: A standard hydrogen bond typically requires a hydrogen atom attached directly to , , or . Students often overlook that a bond can act as a viable hydrogen-bond donor when the carbon is activated by multiple strongly electron-withdrawing substituents, as seen in chloroform.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses stronger intermolecular interactions with higher vapor pressure, leading them to conclude that the mixture exhibits positive deviations from Raoult's law.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Acetone has a permanent dipole from , so pure acetone has dipole-dipole attractions. Chloroform has a permanent dipole from bonds, so pure chloroform has dipole-dipole attractions.
- Step 2
Acetone oxygen interacts with the chloroform hydrogen via hydrogen bonding. Hydrogen bonding is stronger than pure dipole-dipole attractions.
- Step 3
Stronger intermolecular attractions lead to positive deviations from Raoult's law.
CorrectStronger intermolecular attractions hold molecules in the liquid phase more tightly, reducing vapor pressure and resulting in negative deviations from Raoult's law.
You reversed the relationship between intermolecular attraction strength and Raoult's law deviations. Stronger attractions between unlike molecules () make it harder for molecules to vaporize, which lowers the vapor pressure below ideal behavior and causes a negative deviation.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified dipole-dipole attractions as the primary intermolecular force in both pure acetone and pure chloroform.
You recognized that a hydrogen bond forms between the carbonyl oxygen of acetone and the polarized hydrogen of chloroform.
You correctly determined that the new adhesive interactions are stronger than the original cohesive interactions.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou associated 'stronger' interactions directly with a 'positive' deviation rather than connecting stronger attraction to lower vapor pressure.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating interaction strength with the direction of deviation from Raoult's law: deviation sign refers to vapor pressure relative to ideal prediction ( is negative), not to whether attraction increased.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Linking Intermolecular Forces to Escaping Tendency
Stronger adhesive intermolecular attractions () hold molecules more tightly in the liquid phase, decreasing their tendency to vaporize.
When unlike attractions are stronger than like attractions, deduce that the equilibrium vapor pressure will drop below ideal Raoult's law predictions.
- Assigning Raoult's Law Deviation Sign
A deviation is named by the observed total vapor pressure relative to Raoult's law: lower vapor pressure () is a negative deviation; higher vapor pressure () is a positive deviation.
Always verify: stronger attraction lower vapor pressure negative deviation.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationStronger adhesive hydrogen bonds hold acetone and chloroform molecules more tightly in the liquid mixture than their pure components hold themselves.
Because fewer molecules escape into the vapor phase, the equilibrium vapor pressure is lower than predicted by Raoult's law ().
A vapor pressure lower than predicted corresponds to a negative deviation from Raoult's law.
The mixture exhibits negative deviations from Raoult's law.
02 The student believes hydrogen bonding requires hydrogen to be bonded directly to N, O, or F in both isolated molecules, failing to recognize C-H---O hydrogen bonding in this activated mixture and incorrectly classifying the interaction as ordinary dipole-dipole forces.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
a) Pure acetone has dipole-dipole forces. ⟹ b) Pure chloroform has dipole-dipole forces.
- Step 2
c) Neither molecule has H directly bonded to N, O, or F, so no hydrogen bonds can form. ⟹ d) The new interaction between acetone and chloroform is dipole-dipole interaction.
CorrectHydrogen bonding (specifically a interaction between the activated chloroform proton and the carbonyl oxygen lone pairs).
You applied the standard guideline that hydrogen bonding requires bonded to , , or . However, the three highly electronegative chlorine atoms in exert an additive inductive effect that leaves the carbon-bound proton strongly electron-deficient (), allowing it to form a non-classical hydrogen bond with the lone pairs on acetone's carbonyl oxygen.
- Step 3
e) Since the interactions are similar to pure components, the mixture exhibits ideal behavior with slight positive deviations from Raoult's law.
CorrectNegative deviations from Raoult's law.
Because your classification of the interaction in the mixture was based on ordinary dipole-dipole forces, you deduced similar interaction strengths. In reality, the newly formed hydrogen bond is stronger than the dipole-dipole attractions within the pure liquids (), which lowers the vapor pressure and causes a negative deviation from Raoult's law.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that both pure liquid acetone and pure liquid chloroform are governed primarily by dipole-dipole forces.
You remembered the foundational rule that standard hydrogen bonding requires an electronegative partner.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the donor rule as an absolute requirement, overlooking that carbon can serve as a viable hydrogen-bond donor when bound to multiple strongly electron-withdrawing groups (such as three chlorine atoms).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check for Activated C-H Donors
A group can act as an effective hydrogen-bond donor if the carbon atom is bonded to multiple strongly electronegative, electron-withdrawing substituents (like or ).
Whenever you encounter polyhalogenated species like haloforms () mixed with Lewis bases (carbonyls, ethers, amines), look for non-classical or hydrogen bonding.
- Adhesive vs. Cohesive Forces and Raoult's Law
If unlike interactions () are stronger than like interactions ( and ), vapor pressure decreases relative to ideal behavior.
Classify the deviation from Raoult's law as negative when mixing introduces new, stronger attractions such as hydrogen bonds.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate the inductive effect of the three chlorine atoms in : they pull electron density away from carbon, making the hydrogen significantly .
Identify the interaction: the hydrogen on forms a hydrogen bond with the lone pairs on the carbonyl oxygen of .
Compare force strengths: the adhesive hydrogen bond () is stronger than the cohesive dipole-dipole attractions ( and ).
Determine thermodynamic behavior: stronger attractions retain molecules in the liquid phase more effectively, lowering total vapor pressure below ideal predictions.
(a) In pure acetone: dipole-dipole forces (and London dispersion forces); in pure chloroform: dipole-dipole forces (and London dispersion forces). (b) Interaction between acetone and chloroform: hydrogen bonding; deviation from Raoult's law: negative deviation.
03 The student incorrectly assumes pure acetone molecules can hydrogen bond with one another because acetone contains oxygen and hydrogen atoms.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Acetone contains oxygen and hydrogen, so pure acetone has hydrogen bonding.
CorrectIn pure liquid acetone, the primary intermolecular force is dipole-dipole attraction (along with London dispersion forces).
For a pure substance to exhibit hydrogen bonding, a hydrogen atom must be directly bonded to a highly electronegative atom (, , or ). In acetone, , all hydrogen atoms are covalently bonded to carbon atoms (), not to oxygen. Acetone can act as a hydrogen-bond acceptor via its carbonyl oxygen, but it cannot act as a hydrogen-bond donor to another acetone molecule.
- Step 2
Pure chloroform has dipole-dipole attractions.
- Step 3
Acetone and chloroform form hydrogen bonds between the oxygen and chloroform .
- Step 4
Negative deviations from Raoult's law.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified dipole-dipole attractions as the primary force in pure chloroform.
You recognized the specific hydrogen-bonding interaction between the carbonyl oxygen of acetone and the activated hydrogen of chloroform.
You correctly concluded that the mixture exhibits negative deviations from Raoult's law.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeAssuming that having both and anywhere in a molecular formula permits hydrogen bonding between identical molecules.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked the structural connectivity requirement for hydrogen bonding in pure liquids: a hydrogen atom must be covalently attached directly to , , or to create the large partial positive charge necessary to donate a hydrogen bond.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Verify H-Bond Donor Connectivity
A molecule can only donate a conventional hydrogen bond if it contains a hydrogen atom directly bonded to , , or (i.e., an , , or bond).
Draw or inspect the Lewis structure before assigning hydrogen bonding to ensure that the hydrogen atom is attached to , , or , rather than to carbon.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationInspect the Lewis structure of acetone: .
Observe that the six hydrogen atoms are all bonded to carbon atoms in methyl groups, while the oxygen atom is doubly bonded to the central carbonyl carbon.
Because there are no bonds, acetone has no hydrogen-bond donor group.
Conclude that between pure acetone molecules, the permanent dipole of the bond produces dipole-dipole attractions as the primary intermolecular force.
(a) Pure acetone: dipole-dipole interactions; pure chloroform: dipole-dipole interactions. (b) Mixture: hydrogen bonding; negative deviations from Raoult's law.
Lock it in
How does the strength of intermolecular forces in a liquid relate to its equilibrium vapor pressure?
Stronger intermolecular forces hold molecules in the liquid more tightly, lowering escaping tendency and decreasing equilibrium vapor pressure.
Similar question
A liquid mixture of ethanol () and cyclohexane () is prepared. Explain whether this mixture exhibits positive or negative deviations from Raoult's law based on intermolecular forces.
Answer
Positive deviation. Pure ethanol has strong hydrogen bonding, while cyclohexane is nonpolar. Mixing disrupts the strong ethanol-ethanol hydrogen-bonding network without forming comparable adhesive interactions, weakening overall attractions, increasing escaping tendency, and raising vapor pressure above Raoult's law predictions.
In an equimolar mixture of liquid A and liquid B, the total vapor pressure is measured to be . If the pure vapor pressures are and , classify the deviation from Raoult's law and compare the strength of interactions to and interactions.
Answer
Ideal vapor pressure is . Because , the solution exhibits a negative deviation from Raoult's law. This implies adhesive interactions are stronger on average than cohesive and interactions.
Pyridine () and formic acid () are mixed. Identify the primary adhesive interaction between them, determine the sign of , and state whether the mixture has a higher or lower boiling point than predicted for an ideal solution.
Answer
A strong hydrogen bond (or partial proton transfer / acid-base interaction) forms between the acidic proton of and the basic nitrogen lone pair of pyridine. Because adhesive forces are stronger than cohesive forces, mixing is exothermic (), causing a negative deviation from Raoult's law (lower vapor pressure) and therefore a higher boiling point (maximum-boiling azeotrope behavior) than ideal.