Resources

A student analyzes the ionic radius of sulfur (S2−S^{2-}, Z=16Z = 16) and potassium (K+K^+, Z=19Z = 19) alongside their respective first ionization energies in neutral form (IE1(S)=999.6 kJ/molIE_1(\text{S}) = 999.6\text{ kJ/mol}, IE1(K)=418.8 kJ/molIE_1(\text{K}) = 418.8\text{ kJ/mol}). Both ions are isoelectronic with argon (1818 electrons). (a) Identify which ion has the larger ionic radius and explain why using ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}. (b) Explain why potassium has a substantially lower neutral IE1IE_1 than sulfur despite its higher nuclear charge (Z=19Z = 19 vs. Z=16Z = 16).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Larger ionic radius: S2−\text{S}^{2-}, because it has fewer protons (Z=16Z = 16 vs. Z=19Z = 19) attracting the identical 1818-electron cloud, resulting in a lower ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} and greater orbital expansion; (b) Potassium's single valence electron occupies the higher principal shell (n=4n = 4, 4s14s^1) which is much farther from the nucleus and heavily shielded by 1818 core electrons, whereas sulfur's valence electrons occupy the lower n=3n = 3 shell (3s23p43s^2 3p^4).

Steps

Part (a): Comparing the Ionic Radii of SX2−\ce{S^2-} and KX+\ce{K+}

  1. Determine the Electron Configurations and Nuclear Charges:

    • Both sulfide (SX2−\ce{S^2-}) and potassium (KX+\ce{K+}) are isoelectronic with argon (Ar\ce{Ar}), containing 1818 electrons in the configuration: 1s22s22p63s23p61s^2 2s^2 2p^6 3s^2 3p^6
    • Sulfide has an atomic number of Z=16Z = 16 (1616 protons in the nucleus).
    • Potassium has an atomic number of Z=19Z = 19 (1919 protons in the nucleus).
  2. Evaluate the Effective Nuclear Charge (ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}):

    • Effective nuclear charge represents the net positive charge experienced by valence electrons after accounting for shielding from other electrons: Zeff≈Z−SZ_{\text{eff}} \approx Z - S
    • Because both ions share identical 1818-electron configurations, the electron shielding (SS) is virtually identical.
    • With 33 additional protons, KX+\ce{K+} exerts a significantly higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} on its electron cloud than SX2−\ce{S^2-}: Zeff(KX+)>Zeff(SX2−)Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{K+}) > Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{S^2-})
  3. Relate ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} to Ionic Radius:

    • The stronger electrostatic attraction in KX+\ce{K+} pulls the electron cloud tighter toward the nucleus, shrinking the ionic size.
    • Conversely, the lower ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} in SX2−\ce{S^2-} results in a weaker hold on the 1818 electrons, allowing mutual electron-electron repulsions to expand the electron cloud.
    • Therefore, SX2−\ce{S^2-} has the larger ionic radius.

Part (b): Explaining the Lower Ionization Energy (IE1IE_1) of Potassium

  1. Compare Ground-State Electron Configurations of Neutral Atoms:

    • Sulfur (S\ce{S}, Z=16Z = 16): [Ne] 3s23p4[\ce{Ne}]\, 3s^2 3p^4
    • Potassium (K\ce{K}, Z=19Z = 19): [Ar] 4s1[\ce{Ar}]\, 4s^1
  2. Analyze Principal Shell Level (nn) and Distance:

    • The outermost electron of potassium occupies the n=4n = 4 principal energy level (4s4s), whereas the outermost electrons of sulfur occupy the n=3n = 3 level (3p3p).
    • As the principal quantum number nn increases, the valence orbital is located at a much greater average distance from the nucleus. Electrostatic attraction decreases significantly with increasing distance (F∝1r2F \propto \frac{1}{r^2}).
  3. Analyze Core Shielding:

    • Potassium's lone 4s4s valence electron is shielded by a dense inner core of 1818 electrons ([Ar][\ce{Ar}] core). Thus, its valence electron experiences an effective nuclear charge of roughly: Zeff(K)≈19−18=+1Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{K}) \approx 19 - 18 = +1
    • Sulfur's n=3n = 3 valence electrons are shielded by only 1010 core electrons ([Ne][\ce{Ne}] core), yielding a much higher effective nuclear charge: Zeff(S)≈16−10=+6Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{S}) \approx 16 - 10 = +6
  4. Conclusion:

    • Despite potassium having a larger atomic number (Z=19Z = 19 vs. Z=16Z = 16), the combined effect of a higher principal energy shell (n=4n = 4) and heavy core shielding means potassium's outermost electron is much more loosely held. Consequently, neutral potassium requires substantially less energy to remove its first electron (IE1=418.8 kJ/molIE_1 = 418.8\text{ kJ/mol}) than sulfur (IE1=999.6 kJ/molIE_1 = 999.6\text{ kJ/mol}).

Common Pitfall: Do not assume a higher nuclear charge (ZZ) automatically guarantees a higher first ionization energy. The trend of increasing IE1IE_1 with ZZ holds reliably across a single period where nn is constant; moving down into a new period increases nn and adds a whole inner shell of shielding, which overrides the increase in nuclear charge.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student mistakenly assumes that a higher nuclear charge attracts more electrons to make the ion larger, concluding K⁺ has a larger radius.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Both ions have 1818 electrons. K+\text{K}^+ has Z=19Z = 19 and S2−\text{S}^{2-} has Z=16Z = 16. Higher ZZ means higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}.

  2. Step 2

    so K+\text{K}^+ has a larger nuclear pull and therefore holds a larger electron cloud. K+\text{K}^+ has the larger ionic radius.

    Correct

    A higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} pulls the identical 1818-electron cloud more tightly toward the nucleus, shrinking K+\text{K}^+. With lower ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}, S2−\text{S}^{2-} holds its electrons more loosely, allowing electron repulsions to expand the cloud. Therefore, S2−\text{S}^{2-} has the larger ionic radius.

    A stronger inward nuclear pull compresses the electron cloud rather than expanding it. Because K+\text{K}^+ draws its 1818 electrons closer, it is smaller; S2−\text{S}^{2-} has the weaker pull, giving it the larger radius.

  3. Step 3

    Neutral K\text{K} has electron configuration [Ar] 4s1[\text{Ar}]\,4s^1 and neutral S\text{S} has [Ne] 3s23p4[\text{Ne}]\,3s^2 3p^4. The valence electron of K\text{K} is in the n=4n = 4 shell, which is farther from the nucleus than the n=3n = 3 shell of S\text{S}. Greater distance and shielding reduce the nuclear hold on the 4s4s electron, giving K\text{K} a lower IE1IE_1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that both S2−\text{S}^{2-} and K+\text{K}^+ are isoelectronic with 1818 electrons.

You correctly concluded that K+\text{K}^+ has a higher ZZ and therefore a higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} than S2−\text{S}^{2-}.

You thoroughly explained why neutral potassium has a lower first ionization energy than sulfur by citing principal shell distance (n=4n=4 vs. n=3n=3) and core electron shielding.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Zeff-to-Radius Relationship

You equated a larger electrostatic pull with a larger electron cloud, instead of realizing that attraction pulls electrons inward.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You misunderstood how electrostatic attraction dictates ionic volume for isoelectronic species: an increased net positive pull draws the same number of electrons closer to the nucleus, compressing rather than expanding the orbital cloud.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isoelectronic Radius vs. Nuclear Charge
  • For isoelectronic species with identical electron counts and shielding, ionic radius is inversely related to atomic number: Radius∝1Z\text{Radius} \propto \frac{1}{Z}.

  • Whenever comparing ions with the same number of electrons, assign the smaller radius to the species with the higher ZZ because its greater positive charge pulls the electron cloud inward.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the nuclear charge of the two 1818-electron species: Z(K+)=19Z(\text{K}^+) = 19 and Z(S2−)=16Z(\text{S}^{2-}) = 16.

  2. Recognize that identical electron counts mean identical shielding (SS), so Zeff≈Z−SZ_{\text{eff}} \approx Z - S is higher for K+\text{K}^+ (+1+1) than for S2−\text{S}^{2-} (−2-2 net pull relative to valence).

  3. Apply Coulomb's law: stronger attraction pulls the n=3n = 3 valence electrons closer to the nucleus, contracting the K+\text{K}^+ ion.

  4. Conclude that the ion with fewer protons and weaker inward attraction, S2−\text{S}^{2-}, has the larger ionic radius.

Final answer

(a) S2−\text{S}^{2-} has the larger ionic radius because its lower nuclear charge (Z=16Z = 16 vs. Z=19Z = 19) exerts a weaker ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} on the 1818 electrons, allowing the electron cloud to expand; (b) Potassium's valence electron occupies the n=4n = 4 shell, which is farther from the nucleus and more heavily shielded by inner electrons than sulfur's n=3n = 3 valence electrons.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice comparing radii across isoelectronic series (such as O2−\text{O}^{2-}, F−\text{F}^-, Na+\text{Na}^+, Mg2+\text{Mg}^{2+}) by ordering them strictly by decreasing atomic number ZZ.

  • Keep a mental image of Coulombic attraction: stronger positive charge acts like a tighter cinch on a drawstring, shrinking the boundary of the electron cloud.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses neutral atom ionization energy with ionic ionization or thinks K has lower IE₁ because it has fewer valence electrons to hold onto.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Both ions have 1818 electrons. S2−\text{S}^{2-} has 1616 protons and K+\text{K}^+ has 1919 protons. With fewer protons, S2−\text{S}^{2-} has a lower ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}, so its electron cloud is pulled less tightly. S2−\text{S}^{2-} has the larger ionic radius.

  2. Step 2

    Neutral K\text{K} has 11 valence electron while neutral S\text{S} has 66 valence electrons. Potassium wants to lose 11 electron to achieve an octet, whereas sulfur wants to gain electrons. Because K\text{K} only has 11 valence electron, it takes less energy to pull it away than the 66 valence electrons of S\text{S}. K\text{K} has a lower IE1IE_1 because removing an electron from an almost empty shell is easier than from a nearly full shell.

    Correct

    Potassium's valence electron occupies a higher principal energy level (n=4n = 4, 4s14s^1) and is shielded by 1818 core electrons (Zeff≈+1Z_{\text{eff}} \approx +1), placing it much farther from the nucleus. Sulfur's valence electrons occupy the n=3n = 3 shell (3s23p43s^2 3p^4) and are shielded by only 1010 core electrons (Zeff≈+6Z_{\text{eff}} \approx +6), holding them much more tightly.

    Ionization energy is determined by Coulombic attraction (F∝q1q2r2F \propto \frac{q_1 q_2}{r^2}), not by an atom's desire to complete an octet or the number of valence electrons in a shell. Potassium has a lower IE1IE_1 because its valence electron is in the n=4n = 4 shell, which is located at a much greater distance from the nucleus and experiences substantial shielding from an [extAr][ ext{Ar}] core.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that S2−\text{S}^{2-} and K+\text{K}^+ are isoelectronic with 1818 electrons.

You applied effective nuclear charge (ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}) accurately to determine the relative size of isoelectronic ions.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Octet Teleology over Coulombic Principles

No calculation slip was made; the issue stems from conceptual justification.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You explained ionization energy using anthropomorphic octet-rule reasoning ('wants to lose an electron') instead of Coulombic attraction governed by the principal energy level (nn), average electron-nucleus distance (rr), and core electron shielding.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Coulomb's Law over Octet Desires
  • Ionization energy is the energy required to overcome electrostatic attraction: F∝Zeffr2F \propto \frac{Z_{\text{eff}}}{r^2}. Atoms do not possess intent to complete an octet.

  • Always frame ionization energy comparisons in terms of nuclear charge, principal shell (nn), distance from the nucleus, and inner-shell shielding.

Period Changes vs. Across-Period Trends
  • Moving to a new period adds an entire principal shell (nn increases), which dramatically increases the average distance (rr) and core shielding.

  • When comparing elements across different periods, identify the principal quantum number (nn) of the valence shell first before comparing nuclear charges.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the principal quantum levels (nn): potassium's outermost electron is in n=4n = 4, whereas sulfur's outermost electrons are in n=3n = 3.

  2. Account for distance and shielding: the 4s4s electron in potassium is farther from the nucleus and shielded by 1818 core electrons ([Ar][\text{Ar}] core), leaving Zeff≈19−18=+1Z_{\text{eff}} \approx 19 - 18 = +1.

  3. Compare with sulfur: sulfur's 3p3p electrons are shielded by only 1010 core electrons ([Ne][\text{Ne}] core), giving Zeff≈16−10=+6Z_{\text{eff}} \approx 16 - 10 = +6, held much closer and more strongly by Coulombic attraction (F∝Zeffr2F \propto \frac{Z_{\text{eff}}}{r^2}).

Final answer

Potassium has a lower IE1IE_1 because its valence electron occupies the higher principal shell (n=4n = 4), which lies at a significantly greater average distance from the nucleus and experiences heavy shielding from 1818 core electrons.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Coulomb's Law as the physical foundation for atomic properties instead of relying on octet stability.

  • Practice explaining periodic trends using the three-pillar checklist: nuclear charge (ZZ), inner core shielding (SS), and principal energy level (nn).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Rank the following isoelectronic species in order of increasing ionic radius: Mg2+\text{Mg}^{2+} (Z=12Z = 12), O2−\text{O}^{2-} (Z=8Z = 8), and F−\text{F}^- (Z=9Z = 9). Explain briefly using ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}.

Answer

Mg2+<F−<O2−\text{Mg}^{2+} < \text{F}^- < \text{O}^{2-}. All three species have 1010 electrons (1s22s22p61s^2 2s^2 2p^6). With the greatest nuclear charge (Z=12Z = 12), Mg2+\text{Mg}^{2+} exerts the highest ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} and pulls its electrons closest, while O2−\text{O}^{2-} (Z=8Z = 8) has the lowest ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}, allowing the cloud to expand the most.

02

The ionic radii of P3−\text{P}^{3-}, S2−\text{S}^{2-}, and Cl−\text{Cl}^- are 212 pm212\text{ pm}, 184 pm184\text{ pm}, and 181 pm181\text{ pm} respectively. Justify this trend using nuclear charge and electron shielding.

Answer

All three anions are isoelectronic with argon (1818 electrons), so inner-shell shielding (SS) is constant. As atomic number increases from phosphorus (Z=15Z = 15) to sulfur (Z=16Z = 16) to chlorine (Z=17Z = 17), ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} increases. The progressively stronger electrostatic attraction pulls the valence shell tighter, decreasing the ionic radius from 212 pm212\text{ pm} down to 181 pm181\text{ pm}.

03

Consider neutral sodium (Na\text{Na}, Z=11Z = 11, IE1=496 kJ/molIE_1 = 496\text{ kJ/mol}) and neutral neon (Ne\text{Ne}, Z=10Z = 10, IE1=2081 kJ/molIE_1 = 2081\text{ kJ/mol}). Despite sodium having a higher atomic number, its IE1IE_1 is less than a quarter of neon's. Explain this difference using shell level (nn) and ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}.

Answer

Neon has the valence configuration 2s22p62s^2 2p^6 (n=2n = 2) with 22 core electrons, giving Zeff≈10−2=+8Z_{\text{eff}} \approx 10 - 2 = +8. Sodium has the configuration [Ne] 3s1[\text{Ne}]\,3s^1, placing its valence electron in the higher n=3n = 3 shell. This 3s3s electron is farther from the nucleus and shielded by 1010 core electrons (Zeff≈11−10=+1Z_{\text{eff}} \approx 11 - 10 = +1). The combination of greater distance and drastically lower ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} makes sodium's valence electron far easier to remove.

Loading workspace…