Resources
Students frequently confuse the oxyacids of chlorine with binary acids and with each other. Distinguish between the following three chlorine-containing compounds by providing their precise chemical formulas: (a) hydrochloric acid, (b) chloric acid, and (c) chlorous acid. Explain how the naming prefixes ('hydro-') and suffixes ('-ic' vs. '-ous') dictate the presence or absence and number of oxygen atoms.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Hydrochloric acid: (binary acid, no oxygen); (b) Chloric acid: (derived from chlorate ion ); (c) Chlorous acid: (derived from chlorite ion , containing one fewer oxygen than chloric acid)
Steps
Identifying Binary Acids vs. Oxyacids
Acid nomenclature distinguishes compounds that contain only hydrogen and one other element (binary acids) from compounds that contain hydrogen, oxygen, and another element (oxyacids):
-
Binary Acids (prefix hydro- + suffix -ic):
- When an acid name starts with the prefix hydro- and ends with the suffix -ic acid, it indicates a binary acid containing hydrogen and a nonmetal, with no oxygen atoms.
- For chlorine, the base element is chlorine (). Combining hydrogen () and chloride () yields hydrochloric acid, which has the formula .
-
Oxyacids (no hydro- prefix):
- The absence of the hydro- prefix signifies an oxyacid—a compound composed of hydrogen combined with an oxygen-containing polyatomic anion.
- The suffix depends on the specific polyatomic ion:
- Anion ending in -ate acid ending in -ic acid
- Anion ending in -ite acid ending in -ous acid
Determining the Formulas for the Chlorine Oxyacids
-
Chloric Acid:
- The suffix -ic (without hydro-) shows that it originates from the polyatomic ion ending in -ate, which is the chlorate ion, .
- Neutralizing the charge with one hydrogen ion () gives the formula:
-
Chlorous Acid:
- The suffix -ous indicates that it originates from the polyatomic ion ending in -ite, which has one fewer oxygen atom than the -ate ion: the chlorite ion, .
- Neutralizing the charge with one hydrogen ion () gives the formula:
Summary of Naming Rules and Formulas
- (a) Hydrochloric acid: (binary acid, contains no oxygen atoms due to the hydro-...-ic format).
- (b) Chloric acid: (oxyacid derived from the chlorate ion, ).
- (c) Chlorous acid: (oxyacid derived from the chlorite ion, , having one fewer oxygen atom than chloric acid).
Common Pitfall: Never confuse hydrochloric acid () with chloric acid (). The presence of the prefix hydro- exclusively denotes the absence of oxygen in the acid.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the prefix 'hydro-' with containing oxygen or water, incorrectly assigning oxygen to hydrochloric acid and treating chloric acid as the binary acid.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You wrote (hypochlorous acid) for hydrochloric acid. The prefix 'hydro-' with the suffix '-ic' designates a binary acid containing only hydrogen and chlorine, without any oxygen atoms.
- Step 2Correct
You wrote for chloric acid. Because chloric acid lacks the prefix 'hydro-', it is an oxyacid derived from the chlorate ion (), giving the formula .
- Step 3
- Step 4
d) The prefix 'hydro-' indicates oxygen is present with hydrogen, while '-ic' alone without 'hydro-' means no oxygen.
CorrectThe prefix 'hydro-' with suffix '-ic' indicates a binary acid containing no oxygen atoms. The absence of 'hydro-' indicates an oxyacid containing oxygen.
You inverted the meaning of the prefix: 'hydro-' specifically indicates a binary acid containing no oxygen, whereas oxyacids omit the 'hydro-' prefix entirely.
- Step 5
e) The suffix '-ous' indicates fewer oxygen atoms than '-ic'.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the chemical formula of chlorous acid as .
You correctly understood the relative oxygen count between the '-ic' and '-ous' suffixes.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeSwapping the meanings of the prefix 'hydro-' and the suffix '-ic' regarding whether oxygen is present.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou interpreted the prefix 'hydro-' as implying oxygen or hydration, whereas in IUPAC acid nomenclature, 'hydro-' exclusively designates binary acids that contain no oxygen.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Binary Acid Rule
Prefix 'hydro-' + nonmetal root + '-ic acid' = binary acid (contains NO oxygen).
Whenever you see 'hydro-...-ic', immediately write hydrogen paired only with the nonmetal (e.g., ).
- Oxyacid Rule
Oxyacids never use the prefix 'hydro-'; their suffix is determined by the polyatomic ion ('-ate' becomes '-ic acid', '-ite' becomes '-ous acid').
If the acid name lacks 'hydro-', look up the corresponding polyatomic oxyanion to find the oxygen count.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the acid type: 'hydrochloric acid' has the prefix 'hydro-', indicating a binary acid of hydrogen and chlorine with no oxygen .
Identify 'chloric acid': lacking 'hydro-', it is an oxyacid derived from chlorate () .
Identify 'chlorous acid': the suffix '-ous' indicates the chlorite ion (), which has one fewer oxygen atom than chlorate .
(a) Hydrochloric acid: ; (b) Chloric acid: ; (c) Chlorous acid:
02 The student reverses the oxygen-count convention of the suffixes, believing '-ous' has more oxygens than '-ic'.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
⟹ The prefix 'hydro-' with '-ic' indicates a binary acid with no oxygen.
- Step 2
(b) , (c) ⟹ The suffix '-ous' indicates more oxygen atoms, while '-ic' indicates fewer oxygen atoms in the oxyacid series.
Correct(b) Chloric acid: ; (c) Chlorous acid: . In oxyacids, '-ic' corresponds to the '-ate' polyatomic anion (which has more oxygen atoms, such as chlorate ), while '-ous' corresponds to the '-ite' anion (which has one fewer oxygen atom, such as chlorite ).
You reversed the suffix rule for oxyacids. The suffix '-ic' indicates the standard reference oxyacid with more oxygen atoms (derived from chlorate, ), whereas '-ous' indicates one fewer oxygen atom (derived from chlorite, ).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that the 'hydro-' prefix denotes a binary acid with no oxygen.
You correctly determined that hydrochloric acid has the chemical formula .
You correctly realized that chloric acid and chlorous acid differ by exactly one oxygen atom.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou inverted the meaning of the oxyacid suffixes '-ic' and '-ous', associating '-ous' with a greater number of oxygen atoms and '-ic' with a lesser number, rather than linking '-ic' to '-ate' (higher oxidation state / more oxygens) and '-ous' to '-ite' (lower oxidation state / fewer oxygens).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Connecting Anion Suffixes to Acid Suffixes
Anions ending in '-ate' form oxyacids ending in '-ic acid'; anions ending in '-ite' form oxyacids ending in '-ous acid'.
Use the mnemonic 'I ate something icky; a bite was delicious' to remember that '-ate' maps to '-ic' and '-ite' maps to '-ous'.
- Oxygen Count in '-ic' vs. '-ous' Acids
Within the same oxyacid series, the '-ic' acid always has one more oxygen atom than the '-ous' acid.
Identify the base '-ate' ion first (e.g., chlorate is chloric acid ), then subtract one oxygen for '-ous' (chlorite is chlorous acid ).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the polyatomic ions associated with chlorine oxyacids: chlorate is and chlorite is .
Apply the acid naming transformation: '-ate' '-ic acid' and '-ite' '-ous acid'.
Match chlorate () with chloric acid to obtain .
Match chlorite () with chlorous acid to obtain .
(a) Hydrochloric acid: ; (b) Chloric acid: ; (c) Chlorous acid:
03 The student misidentifies chloric acid as hypochlorous acid (HClO) by treating the base '-ic' acid as having only one oxygen atom.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
(a) ⟹ The 'hydro-' prefix indicates no oxygen in the acid.
- Step 2
(b) ⟹ The '-ic' acid has one oxygen atom...
Correct(derived from chlorate, )
You wrote for chloric acid, which is actually hypochlorous acid. The base "-ic" oxyacid of chlorine corresponds to the chlorate ion (), giving .
- Step 3
(c) ⟹ ...and '-ous' adds another oxygen atom.
Correct(derived from chlorite, , containing one fewer oxygen than chloric acid)
Although you wrote the correct formula for chlorous acid, your underlying rule was inverted: an "-ous" acid has one fewer oxygen atom than the "-ic" acid ( vs. ), not one more.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the prefix "hydro-" signifies a binary acid containing no oxygen atoms.
You correctly provided the formula for hydrochloric acid.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that the base "-ic" oxyacid contains only one oxygen atom and that the suffix "-ous" indicates the addition of an oxygen atom, rather than recognizing that "-ic" corresponds to the standard "-ate" polyatomic ion () and "-ous" represents one fewer oxygen atom ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Polyatomic Ion Foundation
Oxyacid names derive from polyatomic ions: "-ate" ions form "-ic" acids, while "-ite" ions form "-ous" acids.
Identify the reference "-ate" ion first (e.g., chlorate is , so chloric acid is ).
- Comparing Oxygen Count in Oxyacids
The "-ous" suffix indicates one fewer oxygen atom than the "-ic" acid, not an additional oxygen.
Subtract one oxygen atom from the "-ic" formula to find the "-ous" formula: .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the base chlorate polyatomic ion: .
Combine with to write chloric acid: .
Apply the "-ous" rule: remove one oxygen atom from chloric acid () to form chlorous acid, which is derived from chlorite (): .
(a) Hydrochloric acid: ; (b) Chloric acid: ; (c) Chlorous acid:
Lock it in
What does the prefix 'hydro-' followed by the suffix '-ic acid' indicate about an acid's composition?
It indicates a binary acid containing only hydrogen and a nonmetal, with NO oxygen atoms (e.g., hydrochloric acid is ).
Similar question
Provide the chemical formulas for (a) hydrobromic acid and (b) bromic acid, and identify which one contains oxygen.
Answer
(a) Hydrobromic acid is (contains no oxygen). (b) Bromic acid is (derived from bromate, , contains oxygen).
Given that sulfate is , sulfite is , and sulfide is , write the names and formulas for the acids formed by combining each with hydrogen ions.
Answer
- : Hydrosulfuric acid (binary acid from sulfide, prefix 'hydro-' and suffix '-ic').
- : Sulfuric acid (oxyacid from sulfate, suffix '-ic', no 'hydro-').
- : Sulfurous acid (oxyacid from sulfite, suffix '-ous', no 'hydro-').
An acid is named 'iodous acid'. (a) Does it contain the prefix 'hydro-'? (b) What polyatomic ion is it derived from? (c) What is its chemical formula?
Answer
(a) No, oxyacids do not contain the prefix 'hydro-'. (b) It is derived from the iodite ion (), because the '-ous' acid suffix corresponds to the '-ite' anion suffix. (c) Combining with gives the formula .